Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want someone else's unwanted tat?

92 replies

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 09:16

I have a friend who is ruthlessly decluttering her house, one room at a time. I've not seen determination and commitment like it and for that I am in awe. I have told her this and she is fully aware that I desperately need to declutter too, but am putting it off to the new year (again!).

I also admire friend for her green credentials. She rarely throws anything she doesn't want out and will try to re home as much as possible via friends/ freecycle/FB market place etc. So far, so good. However...

I frequently (at least weekly) receive texts asking me if I want x,,y, z. 99% of the time I don't . When I say no, a debate ensues where she tries to convince me I need something and makes me feel guilty if I refuse.
Copy of conversation from the last couple of days 'Hi Rocking, would you like this vase?) (attaches pic) ' thank you that is lovely of you to offer but I have loads of vases already' . 'But this one is really unusual, you're not likely to have one like this' 'I don't but I really don't have room and as you know an also in need of a declutter too' 'lit's such a lovely colour' 'it is but not my colour scheme, it's a definite no'. 'Oh, thought I'd try you first as I was sure you'd like it. I thought it would be perfect for your conservatory, but what do I know Such a shame'

I then didn't respond any further.

I then see the same article offered via a couple of WhatsApp groups we both belong to and as least 3 FB groups As a one off, that wouldn't bother me but with so many different things it's really starting to grate.

The other thing that annoys me: On the rare occasion I say yea, maybe a book I'd be interested in, she puts it in a bag with other stuff I don't want or need so I then need to dispose of the stuff I don't want. One time I was out and she left a box of stuff with a message 'pretty sore you can use this stuff'.

I guess I live closer to her than the tip, plus she won't throw anything out until she's exhausted all avenues, but doesn't take things to charity shops because that is too much effort. So end up taking her unwanted stuff to the charity shop - after I've cleaned it because it's usually a bit grubby and covered in cat hairs.

I can't block her, and don't want to, but this is all making me irrationally annoyed. Any ideas how I deal with it? I have tried the firm 'please don't offer me any more stuff as I really need to cut down myself' but I was still then offered a yoghurt maker.as she was sure I could use it.
I guess it's my issue to deal with that it is annoying me so much, but also the practical inconvenience of then having to clean and dispose of what she doesn't want, and she doesn't live close enough to just drop it back at her house.

Maybe just this rant will help! Thanks if you've read this far

OP posts:
stuntbubbles · 08/11/2022 12:59

TootsAtOwls · 08/11/2022 09:47

Start your own declutter (or at least pretend to) and every time she messages you, say "Oh I'm glad you've texted, you've reminded me I wanted to offer you this!" piece of tat) then press her to take it, using her own lines. She'll soon stop if it ends up annoying HER every time.

Much more fun than just repeating "no thanks".

Ooh, yes. Do this. Start boxing up stuff as well and pack it in with all the unwanted stuff she dropped on your doorstep with a little note: “You accidentally left these! But since I was coming over, I packed a few extra treats for you.”

This would drive me insane, btw. I’m on a ruthless decluttering spree too but everything is getting a new life via eBay, Olio, Freecycle, etc. That way the onus is on other people to say yes to it, rather than me making friends say no to it.

MadelineUsher · 08/11/2022 12:51

My family used to do this, but they also expected me to keep forever the stuff I didn't want and had literally no room for. Every time I saw them, over and over and over: when do you want us to bring the (horrible) round table/set of shelves left by a previous husband/large bulky strange item over? It was like I was a storage unit to them. Nothing I said made any difference.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/11/2022 12:51

Ah! Cross-post @GenerationSuper ! Brew Cake

KettrickenSmiled · 08/11/2022 12:50

BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 11:07

If she's struggled with mess, and this is the first time she's really got rid of stuff it can be hard to shed all those old mindsets and the whole "can't waste this" feeling. Try not to take it personally, it's not about you, it's about her not being able to easily let the stuff go. It probably is irritating, but the decluttering process will presumably end at some point, and in the meantime if you can try and just see it as being her difficulty in letting things go, it might be easier to just say "No thanks" and wait for her to get past it.

But she doesn't get past it - she's a repeat offender.

And SO manipulative!
Copy of conversation from the last couple of days 'Hi Rocking, would you like this vase?) (attaches pic) ' thank you that is lovely of you to offer but I have loads of vases already' . 'But this one is really unusual, you're not likely to have one like this' 'I don't but I really don't have room and as you know an also in need of a declutter too' 'lit's such a lovely colour' 'it is but not my colour scheme, it's a definite no'. 'Oh, thought I'd try you first as I was sure you'd like it. I thought it would be perfect for your conservatory, but what do I know Such a shame'

That final "what do I know Such a shame" is pure passive-aggression.
Stop being her pushover OP. She uses her "easily offended" personality trait to control you.

GenerationSuper · 08/11/2022 12:46

Copy of conversation from the last couple of days 'Hi Rocking, would you like this vase?) (attaches pic) ' thank you that is lovely of you to offer but I have loads of vases already' . 'But this one is really unusual, you're not likely to have one like this' 'I don't but I really don't have room and as you know an also in need of a declutter too' 'lit's such a lovely colour' 'it is but not my colour scheme, it's a definite no'. 'Oh, thought I'd try you first as I was sure you'd like it. I thought it would be perfect for your conservatory, but what do I know Such a shame'

😡I am angry on your behalf, so pushy and passive aggressive. I'd say to her please don't offer anything else, I have no need for stuff. Sounds rather obsessive and unhealthy what she is doing, I'd be worried about her mental health. If she offers again, say, no thanks, if she texts but but but, don't reply.

myusernamewastakenbyme · 08/11/2022 12:41

I had a friend offer me 'free' concert tickets once to a band my then 12 year old dd liked....sounds fab but the gig was in Brixton...I live in Norfolk...it finished late in the evening...meaning me and dd trying to get across London to get the train home . .train tickets were expensive and it just wasn't worth the hassle...she couldn't understand why i said no thanks.

habibihabibi · 08/11/2022 12:36

Tell her to use Freecycle - I emptied an entire 4 bed house in London in 10 days. Even mops, buckets and brooms went.
Everything is something to someone.

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 08/11/2022 12:30

PortalooSunset · 08/11/2022 09:24

Take it all. Store in your garage and then when you declutter dump the whole lot on her doorstep.

GrinGrin

Mirabai · 08/11/2022 12:28

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 11:23

I do try to see things from other people's point of view and if it were a one off /when it was the first time, I would agree with you. However, she tends to have a good clear out, not to be able to resist stuff she sees cheap/free and then has to start all over again with the decluttering.
It's a bit like a yo-yo dieting.

She’s basically a hoarder that’s why she’s having such difficulty letting go of stuff.

You say she doesn’t take stuff to charity shops because “it’s too much effort” but it’s too much effort for you and it’s not your stuff. Be as ruthless as she is.

MadelineUsher · 08/11/2022 12:18

It's so unfair to you. You have to go through the hooha of refusing over and over, agree to one item and get ten others you never wanted or expected, then clean those and then go to the bother of tranporting them to the charity shop she should have taken them to in the first place. Meanwhile, like a dealer, she's potentially getting you hooked on her old crap. I think you need to be really firm.

StickofVeg · 08/11/2022 12:09

"No thanks. By the way X Charity do pickups - link here" Rinse and repeat every time. Failing that mute her for a few weeks.

Q2C4 · 08/11/2022 11:58

@SchoolQuestionnaire why don't you take it to an actual charity shop, rather than the tip?

Thelnebriati · 08/11/2022 11:38

''I don't mind you asking but please take my first 'no' as an answer''.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 11:23

BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 11:07

If she's struggled with mess, and this is the first time she's really got rid of stuff it can be hard to shed all those old mindsets and the whole "can't waste this" feeling. Try not to take it personally, it's not about you, it's about her not being able to easily let the stuff go. It probably is irritating, but the decluttering process will presumably end at some point, and in the meantime if you can try and just see it as being her difficulty in letting things go, it might be easier to just say "No thanks" and wait for her to get past it.

I do try to see things from other people's point of view and if it were a one off /when it was the first time, I would agree with you. However, she tends to have a good clear out, not to be able to resist stuff she sees cheap/free and then has to start all over again with the decluttering.
It's a bit like a yo-yo dieting.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 11:07

If she's struggled with mess, and this is the first time she's really got rid of stuff it can be hard to shed all those old mindsets and the whole "can't waste this" feeling. Try not to take it personally, it's not about you, it's about her not being able to easily let the stuff go. It probably is irritating, but the decluttering process will presumably end at some point, and in the meantime if you can try and just see it as being her difficulty in letting things go, it might be easier to just say "No thanks" and wait for her to get past it.

FictionalCharacter · 08/11/2022 11:03

You'll need to be much more blunt because she's using you to dispose of things for her.
You've been very polite, so she will continue. Stop giving her reasons why you don't want things. It's an opportunity for her to persuade you.
If she dumps things on your doorstep, take them straight back. You're not obliged to take stuff to charity shops for her.
"No Susan, I don't want any of your unwanted items. You really must stop asking".
"Susan, stop bringing things round. You can take them to the charity shop yourself, I don't have time".
"Susan, you have to stop doing this. It's stressing me out. It's great that you're doing all this clearing but you have to dispose of things yourself - don't involve me any more please."

cantba · 08/11/2022 10:59

You need to start taking it back to her. Leave on her doorstep. Will knly take once.

Candymay · 08/11/2022 10:57

A yoghurt maker you say …

luckylavender · 08/11/2022 10:54

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 09:16

I have a friend who is ruthlessly decluttering her house, one room at a time. I've not seen determination and commitment like it and for that I am in awe. I have told her this and she is fully aware that I desperately need to declutter too, but am putting it off to the new year (again!).

I also admire friend for her green credentials. She rarely throws anything she doesn't want out and will try to re home as much as possible via friends/ freecycle/FB market place etc. So far, so good. However...

I frequently (at least weekly) receive texts asking me if I want x,,y, z. 99% of the time I don't . When I say no, a debate ensues where she tries to convince me I need something and makes me feel guilty if I refuse.
Copy of conversation from the last couple of days 'Hi Rocking, would you like this vase?) (attaches pic) ' thank you that is lovely of you to offer but I have loads of vases already' . 'But this one is really unusual, you're not likely to have one like this' 'I don't but I really don't have room and as you know an also in need of a declutter too' 'lit's such a lovely colour' 'it is but not my colour scheme, it's a definite no'. 'Oh, thought I'd try you first as I was sure you'd like it. I thought it would be perfect for your conservatory, but what do I know Such a shame'

I then didn't respond any further.

I then see the same article offered via a couple of WhatsApp groups we both belong to and as least 3 FB groups As a one off, that wouldn't bother me but with so many different things it's really starting to grate.

The other thing that annoys me: On the rare occasion I say yea, maybe a book I'd be interested in, she puts it in a bag with other stuff I don't want or need so I then need to dispose of the stuff I don't want. One time I was out and she left a box of stuff with a message 'pretty sore you can use this stuff'.

I guess I live closer to her than the tip, plus she won't throw anything out until she's exhausted all avenues, but doesn't take things to charity shops because that is too much effort. So end up taking her unwanted stuff to the charity shop - after I've cleaned it because it's usually a bit grubby and covered in cat hairs.

I can't block her, and don't want to, but this is all making me irrationally annoyed. Any ideas how I deal with it? I have tried the firm 'please don't offer me any more stuff as I really need to cut down myself' but I was still then offered a yoghurt maker.as she was sure I could use it.
I guess it's my issue to deal with that it is annoying me so much, but also the practical inconvenience of then having to clean and dispose of what she doesn't want, and she doesn't live close enough to just drop it back at her house.

Maybe just this rant will help! Thanks if you've read this far

Send her a message saying you would like to be as ruthless & efficient as her as she's inspired you. Then tell her to stop offering you anything. Don't pander to her.

MistyRock · 08/11/2022 10:52

User478 · 08/11/2022 09:35

Tell her it doesn't spark joy for you.

Yes. That's a good one.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 08/11/2022 10:51

I'd reply to every offer with "no thanks, but if you want to drop it off I'll take it to the tip for you". If you imply it will all end up in landfill she'll soon stop offering.

I wouldn't, she may take the OP up on the offer!

I think the genius of that Stacey Solomon show is that someone else is dealing with the disposal problem. I could clear half my unwanted clutter if someone else was willing to do the tedious practical getting rid of it bit.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 08/11/2022 10:47

Definitely just reply 'No thanks'.

She doesn't care about annoying you by trying to palm stuff onto you so stop giving a shit about if your curt reply offends her!

Sachertortie · 08/11/2022 10:46

I'd reply to every offer with "no thanks, but if you want to drop it off I'll take it to the tip for you". If you imply it will all end up in landfill she'll soon stop offering.

ParentallyUnprepared · 08/11/2022 10:46

Stop accepting anything. Say no once then stop engaging.

Facecream · 08/11/2022 10:45

As @KettrickenSmiled says, it’s always easy to offend someone who has been pushing your boundaries endlessly..,
I would say “no thank you” the first time if she replied, I’d say “I’ve said no”. Anything after that and I would just not reply to her tat texts at all