Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
user1484264563 · 08/11/2022 19:51

Where did you get that figure from? It seems extraordinarily implausible. Previous Oxfam reports have placed around 15% on the heads of the richest 1% and even that is based on very broad assumptions (their words not mine).

Runmybathforme · 08/11/2022 19:50

When are you going to realise that the protests alienate the public, and that having a miles of stranded cars running their engines just causes more pollution ? I was caught up in the M25 mess yesterday, and I'm still fuming. I feel nothing but fury towards the protesters. How is that helpful ? Heard a guy on the news who was travelling to his Father's funeral, he had to go home so missed it. Not to mention the total waste of police resources.

Popgoestheweaselagain · 08/11/2022 19:46

medicellen · 08/11/2022 14:13

@Popgoestheweaselagain

  1. 75% YABU.
  2. Unfounded along the lines of "you are all middle-class twats", founded - there is likely to be a negative impact on some people
  3. Its not feasible to outline all of the possible NVDA activities - they range from blocking roads, to throwing soup, to breaking windows of big polluters. to spray painting Tufton street. By definition any NVDA will cause disruption to someone, somewhere

So your plan is to smash windows, throw soup at paintings and carry on blocking the roads. OK. I thought you were a scientist so would have something interesting to say, but I'm just bored of this thread now ...

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 19:42

@RedToothBrush

Which renewables? Where?
Offshore, floating offshore more again.

Ultimately PtL
What scale do we need to upscale what we have?

Wind energy is planned to grow by 500% within a decade
Do we have enough people to install enough renewable generators?
Training and education is one of the top priorities of the sector.

Is it cost effective - will it help people have lower bills?
Renewables are now cheaper than fossil fuels over their lifecycle - yes it will help lower bills

How is the investiment in infrustructure being funded? Is it public / privately owned?
The technology is funded largely by collaborative research and development, i.e. joint government commercial partnerships the organisation reseponsible for this in the UK is Innovate UK there grants funding site is here. There are also levelling up funds and build back better.

What issues are there will renewables in terms of meeting demand at peak times - if there is no wind or solar for example?
Energy storage, I wish I'd thought of this I hope it makes them very rich! And maybe Small Modular Nuclear.

Is our battery tech sufficient at present? If its not do we need to invest to improve this?
There are new technologies being developed all the time and old technologies being reengineered - sorry I couldn't find a good link

You need a credible plan for replacement not just demanding like petulant toddlers who just ignore the practical boring stuff of 'how'.

As per my previous post, I do not support JSO:

No one has offered a viable alternative strategy to try and mitigate the climate emergency.

Simply put we need to stop burning fossil fuels, in that context JSO are correct but sustainability also has social and economic pillars. Bearing this in mind I suggest to you that we need to reduce our reliance on gulf and Russian oil and the conflicts and inequalities those states perpetuate. So we need to create an energy buffer, which reluctantly can only only come from fossil fuels while we also massively increase our renewable energy supply. Net zero by 2050 is doable but we need to be pragmatic and realistic in our journey.

(And no-one will need to stop flying).

SundownOnTheStair · 08/11/2022 19:03

fernfen · 08/11/2022 18:54

That's the thing though isn't it, if they all claim to be experts in this field. Them why have they not written up their own action plan and white paper, that all other scientists in the actual field of work can peer review and get behind and offer their solutions to the world.

The big fat answer is they can't , there a set of obnoxious fools who would rather spend their time pissing off hard working people with their childish antics than coming up with some coherent scientific research, they can get others to agree upon. There full of hot air and just quote random bollocks, and spout well known facts to the public as though they are some sort of meshhias.

They just want to protest cause disruption while others do the hard work and research.

Was Greta Thunberg a scientist when she started this at 13?

No, of course she wasn't and yet by some sleight of hand, everyone from the Pope downwards was kissing her arse.

The movement has no credibility for me and when Nostradamus like-they come out with predictions that the world will burn in 2040, I just think oh do fuck off!

Off you fuck to protest in China? No? Well shut up then.

Fred Flintstone may be lovely but I don't want to emulate him. Zero Emissions my arse.

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 18:55

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 17:45

Its aims are woolly at best

Judging by the latter part of this thread (haven'tt read all of it) the message is either Ban It or Tax It.

I think a slogan of "Ban it or Tax it" is probably better than anything written on their website.

fernfen · 08/11/2022 18:54

User2145738790 · 08/11/2022 18:41

They all pretend to be scientists.

That's the thing though isn't it, if they all claim to be experts in this field. Them why have they not written up their own action plan and white paper, that all other scientists in the actual field of work can peer review and get behind and offer their solutions to the world.

The big fat answer is they can't , there a set of obnoxious fools who would rather spend their time pissing off hard working people with their childish antics than coming up with some coherent scientific research, they can get others to agree upon. There full of hot air and just quote random bollocks, and spout well known facts to the public as though they are some sort of meshhias.

They just want to protest cause disruption while others do the hard work and research.

User2145738790 · 08/11/2022 18:41

sst1234 · 08/11/2022 17:51

You are a scientist and you think that a nonsense protest in the UK will have any impact on your cause? Your powers of reasoning aren’t very strong, are they?

They all pretend to be scientists.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 18:38

Those who think a bit of disruption on the M25 is the end of the world need to open their eyes to the actual end of the world.

That's the point though. Most of us don't think that a bit of disruption on the M25, or a bit of spilt milk or soup on a painting are the end of the world. They are minor annoyances that are somehow being allowed to distract from the very real issues that actually matter. I don't want the media to keep endlessly focusing on the pointless antics of a bunch of self-promoting eco-warriors when they should be focusing on the suffering that is actually being caused by climate change right now. XR and their colleagues have become the story but they are not the solution.

flingingmelon · 08/11/2022 18:37

I'm starting to think that the Canadian 2021 tactic of freezing truckers bank accounts is reasonable in the case of environmentalists who are actively preventing people earning money / picking up their dependents / getting medical treatment.

I get that you are worried, but aren't you more use in your lab working out how to fix this stuff?

I know there's no magic wand and that in many cases the best we can hope for is a least worst option, but preventing people from living their lives is not going to help you gain support.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 18:35

Go and find an activist to talk to and check out their lifestyle. You will find them trying to live more sustainably and involved in nature restoration projects but they know that is not enough

I don't need to "find" an activist since I already know too many, and with a few notable exceptions they all live in ways which utterly negate the message they pretend to support

Luckily it's very easy to smoke them out - just wait until the chatter turns to the latest bit of tech they've simply got to have, ask them if it wouldn't be better to keep their present stuff a bit longer and wait for the gormless stare

User2145738790 · 08/11/2022 18:34

The majority don't give a shit and will roll their eyes at you but you crack on...

Southwig22 · 08/11/2022 18:33

Thanks for all you're doing.

The world is insane, I'm so tired of hearing espoused support for new policies and climate commitments, but no action.

Those who think a bit of disruption on the M25 is the end of the world need to open their eyes to the actual end of the world.

healthadvice123 · 08/11/2022 18:30

I think you don't have the public onside so are doing little for the cause
Plus mother nature always wins
The average person is trying the best within their means
I mean we can't all go and buy an electric car ( i have reservations that is actually better anyway personally- due to batterY life and how they are mined and how we have to produce electric)
More campaigning for ways the public can help and change is better, but even if we did everything right in the uk , us alone cannot change the world
Plus how many if these supporters have travelled by car , have more electric gadgets than needed so maybe don't practice what they preach

TooHotToRamble · 08/11/2022 18:17

I think preventing people from getting to work, school and medical appointments is going to turn off the public. Think about the single parent on minimum wage that doesn't get paid if they don't make it in to work, trying to survive during a cost of living crisis.

Protest but direct it in the right way. Make life difficult for the politicians and worst companies. Not the ordinary working person. Tbh you've turned me off, I'd be dragging you off the road in you got in my way!, and I am very worried about climate change. You've got no hope with people who are on the fence.

You need to get the people behind you and the campaign or you are just going to be branded as a difficult subversive minority. And the tories will bring in laws that make protesting even more difficult than it is already (with the backing of the pissed off public) which will be a huge backward step and issue for democracy.

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 18:17

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 18:07

Environmentalism isn’t a purity test

Could have fooled me.

especially when we know how insignificant individual lifestyle choices are against the weight and impacts of the fossil fuel industry

Ah right, so all the recycling and driving an electric car and biking rather than driving is pointless as it makes no difference

We still have to live in the world as it is right now while campaigning for change in the future

Except those people swanning around in their private jets are the ones telling the plebs not to fly and what cars they should be driving and how many children to have and not to eat meat, eat plant derived food. If it's OK for the likes of Musk and Bezos to fly in a private jet because 'that's the world as it is right now' then it's OK for the likes of me, right?

I think this post sums it up for me well.

The lack of ability to form a cohesive argument that isn't full of so many holes its laughable.

And they wonder why the organisation isn't taken seriously and people don't think its credible.

Do better rather than doing vanity pr stunts.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 18:17

And again, to add. I think some voices of protest have been incredibly compelling and they have undoubtedly helped to spark public debate and raise awareness.

I have seen no evidence to date that the XR/JSO antisocial behaviour style protests have had that effect. The article that you linked to did not offer any such evidence. From my own observations, I believe that protests of that nature actually have the opposite effect.

I don't disagree in the slightest that urgent climate action is needed. I just don't agree that the XR approach is the way to make this happen. You clearly disagree, which is fine. Hopefully, we'll get there sooner rather than later, whether it is in spite of the protests or because of them. Personally, I think they do more damage to the cause than good.

BloodAndFire · 08/11/2022 18:14

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 18:11

I have already suggested what I think is a "better" explanation.

You seem to be of the view that the abundant and growing body of real-world evidence of the negative impacts of climate change is insufficient to persuade the general public that climate change is a real problem that needs to be tackled.

At the same time, I presume that you would argue that the XR protestors have themselves been motivated to protest by that very same body of real-world evidence? Or do you believe that they have different motives for protesting that have nothing to do with the actual impact of climate change?

If XR et al are motivated to protest by the evidence of climate change that's out there, why would you assume that the general public are somehow less capable of accessing or interpreting that evidence and drawing their own conclusions? Why would you assume that random protests such as spilling milk or throwing soup at paintings would help to illuminate that evidence and make it more meaningful to people?

It's almost as if you think that the arguments for climate action don't quite stack up by themselves, so we need some extremist antisocial protestors to make people care enough to want something to be done. That's a very curious way of undermining your own argument.

XR, like JSO, are funded (to the tune of millions of pounds) by Getty, among others. Funny that you see it as a spontaneous, individual act.

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 18:14

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 17:59

Renewable energy.

Yes and...

...how are we going to achieve enough to replace fossil fuels?

Which renewables? Where?

What scale do we need to upscale what we have?

Do we have enough people to install enough renewable generators?

Is it cost effective - will it help people have lower bills?

How is the investiment in infrustructure being funded? Is it public / privately owned?

What issues are there will renewables in terms of meeting demand at peak times - if there is no wind or solar for example?

Is our battery tech sufficient at present? If its not do we need to invest to improve this?

You need a credible plan for replacement not just demanding like petulant toddlers who just ignore the practical boring stuff of 'how'.

A thirteen word statement which only gives half the issue and then has absoluetely no substance what so ever is very basic level primary school level politics. Indeed many year 6s probably would give JSO a run for their money on coming up with something with any level of cohesiveness.

It is nothing more that social media wah wah wailing.

Its not proper activism.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 18:11

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 17:59

They say ‘may’ because as you said it’s a correlation, it would be very difficult if not impossible to have absolutely conclusive evidence in this situation. Most evidence isn’t conclusive, but supportive. Given the spikes in awareness tie closely with the protests I think they are very likely to have been caused by them. Or do you have a better explanation? It might not compare different types of civil disobedience, but it shows (if you accept my claim above) that civil disobedience, including the XR shutting down of London, effectively increases public awareness.

‘Of course, with this brief analysis (Figure 1), we show only correlations. Nevertheless, the data suggest that global movements of civil disobedience focussed on climate change, as well as traditional scientific reports, may play an important role in increasing public awareness and engagement with issues of climate change.’

I have already suggested what I think is a "better" explanation.

You seem to be of the view that the abundant and growing body of real-world evidence of the negative impacts of climate change is insufficient to persuade the general public that climate change is a real problem that needs to be tackled.

At the same time, I presume that you would argue that the XR protestors have themselves been motivated to protest by that very same body of real-world evidence? Or do you believe that they have different motives for protesting that have nothing to do with the actual impact of climate change?

If XR et al are motivated to protest by the evidence of climate change that's out there, why would you assume that the general public are somehow less capable of accessing or interpreting that evidence and drawing their own conclusions? Why would you assume that random protests such as spilling milk or throwing soup at paintings would help to illuminate that evidence and make it more meaningful to people?

It's almost as if you think that the arguments for climate action don't quite stack up by themselves, so we need some extremist antisocial protestors to make people care enough to want something to be done. That's a very curious way of undermining your own argument.

BloodAndFire · 08/11/2022 18:11

The current issue of Private Eye is extremely interesting on JSO and XR. JSO are funded by the Getty heiress via the Climate Emergency Fund (CEF). So far in 2022:
In 2022 so far, we have made $4.5 million in grants to 43 brave, ultra-ambitious groups.
www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/29/just-stop-oils-protests-funded-by-us-philanthropists

The groups funded by CEF predominantly consist of evangelical Christians, e.g. Evangelical Environmental Network, American Conservation Coalition and Conservation Hawks.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 18:07

Environmentalism isn’t a purity test

Could have fooled me.

especially when we know how insignificant individual lifestyle choices are against the weight and impacts of the fossil fuel industry

Ah right, so all the recycling and driving an electric car and biking rather than driving is pointless as it makes no difference

We still have to live in the world as it is right now while campaigning for change in the future

Except those people swanning around in their private jets are the ones telling the plebs not to fly and what cars they should be driving and how many children to have and not to eat meat, eat plant derived food. If it's OK for the likes of Musk and Bezos to fly in a private jet because 'that's the world as it is right now' then it's OK for the likes of me, right?

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 17:59

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 17:39

Thanks, I've had a look. From my reading, the authors didn't actually point to any solid evidence that the protests carried out by XR have actually contributed to a change in public awareness, merely that they "may be important" in contributing to a rise in public awareness. They acknowledge that they have presented evidence of correlation rather than causation. They also don't appear to have offered any significant analysis of the impact of different types of activism, e.g. school strikes vs antisocial behaviour, and whether some approaches are more effective in raising awareness than others.

Again, I am struggling to understand why you think some of the silly antics of XR would be so much more likely to attract public interest and awareness than news about the impact of climate change on real people's lives. If the facts alone are not enough, why is emptying a carton of milk on the floor in waitrose going to persuade people?

They say ‘may’ because as you said it’s a correlation, it would be very difficult if not impossible to have absolutely conclusive evidence in this situation. Most evidence isn’t conclusive, but supportive. Given the spikes in awareness tie closely with the protests I think they are very likely to have been caused by them. Or do you have a better explanation? It might not compare different types of civil disobedience, but it shows (if you accept my claim above) that civil disobedience, including the XR shutting down of London, effectively increases public awareness.

‘Of course, with this brief analysis (Figure 1), we show only correlations. Nevertheless, the data suggest that global movements of civil disobedience focussed on climate change, as well as traditional scientific reports, may play an important role in increasing public awareness and engagement with issues of climate change.’

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 17:59

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 17:56

No that's half a plan

It doesn't explain how and what you replace it with.

As we saw with Brexit, it's a rather fundamental point....

Renewable energy.

time4anothername · 08/11/2022 17:58

seems to me that the end results of these protests are so counter productive I sometimes ask myself if they are being funded by some of the players who profit from oil in order to make the average person anti the anti-oil agenda. Same with insulate Britain, amazing how something so useful and necessary for all of us to save money and help the climate - insulation - was become a dirty word.

As some others have pointed out, it's the small, daily boring approach that will have results. Climate change might be unprovable but getting covered in shite when you go swimming, getting lung conditions from pollution, having a massive bill because all the heat escapes from your attic etc may get people to "look up".

Still all feels like moving chairs on the Titanic though. The Russian war on Ukraine is currently ipolluting some of the most fertile land in Europe so that it may not be usable again in our lifetimes, has kicked up radioactive dust from Chernobyl and is destroying the quality of rivers running into the Black Sea and the sea itself. Russia has ramped up deforesting the Siberian forests as no one is looking (arguably even more dangerous for the planet than what is happening in the Amazon).

Swipe left for the next trending thread