Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
Musti · 09/11/2022 03:17

fernfen · 08/11/2022 23:52

We have all the solutions do we 🤣, so what is this mystical chemical you know of that is 100% environmental friendly that can replace oil for all our industrial needs, where is your design for vehicles that can run for more than 300 miles and don't need toxic metal extraction of fossil fuels to produce the components?

I could go on, but as usual you talk bollocks like all the protesting nutters. Or are proclaiming we should all just stop using cars, stop eating meat, stop using anything that damaged the environment is that really your answer, well good luck with selling that to the public. Mean while I'll continue to look for breakthroughs in technology and scenic research for alternative ways to produce cleaner energy.

We do have the solutions. And the solution for transport for example isn’t more efficient private transport but better public transport for example. Affordable trains instead of airplanes for inter city transport for example.

But there isn’t a one fits all solution, it will depend on the country. That’s why XR advocates Citizens Assemblies.

Musti · 09/11/2022 03:14

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2022 00:59

If you really want to be effective, I believe the best approach is becoming a part of the process.

if you have the skills to research practical solutions, start applying for grants and get in the lab.

if you have a good education, a scientific background and a passion for advocacy, look for employment that might allow you to be the person presenting information to political and corporate leaders directly instead of indirectly. Working as an aide to a decision maker gives you the chance to write briefs and present information. Working your way up in a corporation that claims to want to change but isn’t doing enough gives you the chance to push them in the right direction.

not everyone has the privilege for trying to fight for what they believe in by trying to get a seat at or near the table, but many do.

All the knowledge and reports and solutions are available and published ad infinitum. That’s not the issue. The issue is that it isn’t getting out there. The fossil fuel companies are powerful and rich and they quash things down.

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2022 00:59

If you really want to be effective, I believe the best approach is becoming a part of the process.

if you have the skills to research practical solutions, start applying for grants and get in the lab.

if you have a good education, a scientific background and a passion for advocacy, look for employment that might allow you to be the person presenting information to political and corporate leaders directly instead of indirectly. Working as an aide to a decision maker gives you the chance to write briefs and present information. Working your way up in a corporation that claims to want to change but isn’t doing enough gives you the chance to push them in the right direction.

not everyone has the privilege for trying to fight for what they believe in by trying to get a seat at or near the table, but many do.

fernfen · 08/11/2022 23:52

VegMam · 08/11/2022 20:37

The answer is because we have the solutions, we know what we need to do. However, the status quo is working for the rich and powerful and so they’re not willing to implement the necessary changes with sufficient urgency.

We have all the solutions do we 🤣, so what is this mystical chemical you know of that is 100% environmental friendly that can replace oil for all our industrial needs, where is your design for vehicles that can run for more than 300 miles and don't need toxic metal extraction of fossil fuels to produce the components?

I could go on, but as usual you talk bollocks like all the protesting nutters. Or are proclaiming we should all just stop using cars, stop eating meat, stop using anything that damaged the environment is that really your answer, well good luck with selling that to the public. Mean while I'll continue to look for breakthroughs in technology and scenic research for alternative ways to produce cleaner energy.

CatJumperTwat · 08/11/2022 21:44

The answer is because we have the solutions, we know what we need to do

Do you? Then why can't the OP, XR, or the rest of her ilk explain it?

Federal · 08/11/2022 21:37

we are all making fuck all difference with our recycling, using less energy, eating less meat etc. eh @Musti ??

what’s the point then? I’m too busy trying to survive so haven’t got the time to go and ruin some paintings and ignore court orders to block the motorway? You crack on though, love.

Musti · 08/11/2022 21:30

Just skim reading lots of pathetic excuses. At the end of the day, you either delude yourself and end up with a really shitty life or you do something about it.

Musti · 08/11/2022 21:27

Federal · 08/11/2022 21:06

As far as I am concerned theses protesters are a complete pain in the arse and committing vandalism, disrupting people trying to earn a living etc. is dreadful behaviour.

The majority of people I know all recycle, walk more and are doing their bit. We all know we use too much energy and buy too much crap and eating too much meat so we are all cutting down. Why aren’t you in China/Abu Dhabi/outside Kylie Jenner’s house/wherever protesting there?

As if our lives aren’t hard enough as it is at the moment without these protestors stopping people working and getting to hospital etc.

And as for your demands? Well it’s like you’ve just put your fingers in the air and guessed how you’re going to achieve them. You have no viable plan except to make life more difficult for ordinary people.

Good for you, you’re making fuck all difference

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 21:17

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:39

@BerriesOnTop I am not suggesting that we stop buying everything from China, just that we start demanding more sustainable products. I'm sure China will adapt its production to meet a change in demand from those nations that consume most of its products.

China’s top trading partners are the US, Japan, South Korea, Vietnam. I doubt they care or will demand ‘sustainable’ products from China.

Also, as I said, the share of exports to middle- and low-income countries is rising. Don’t think you can just dictate terms to China.

Federal · 08/11/2022 21:06

As far as I am concerned theses protesters are a complete pain in the arse and committing vandalism, disrupting people trying to earn a living etc. is dreadful behaviour.

The majority of people I know all recycle, walk more and are doing their bit. We all know we use too much energy and buy too much crap and eating too much meat so we are all cutting down. Why aren’t you in China/Abu Dhabi/outside Kylie Jenner’s house/wherever protesting there?

As if our lives aren’t hard enough as it is at the moment without these protestors stopping people working and getting to hospital etc.

And as for your demands? Well it’s like you’ve just put your fingers in the air and guessed how you’re going to achieve them. You have no viable plan except to make life more difficult for ordinary people.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 08/11/2022 21:05

Maybe chain yourselves to a tree in one of the many , ever dwindling rainforests in South America that is being cut down to make way for soya bean production.

That way you'll appease the carbon emissions protesters and piss off the vegans too.

A win win !

thehorsehasnowbolted · 08/11/2022 20:57

Was Greta Thunberg a scientist when she started this at 13?
No, of course she wasn't and yet by some sleight of hand, everyone from the Pope downwards was kissing her arse.
The movement has no credibility for me and when Nostradamus like-they come out with predictions that the world will burn in 2040, I just think oh do fuck off!
Off you fuck to protest in China? No? Well shut up then.
Fred Flintstone may be lovely but I don't want to emulate him. Zero Emissions my arse

Spot on. This madness will only result in the decline and impoverishment of the Western world, civilised nations, the destruction of our industries, culture and way of life.

Now who will be benefiting from that?

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:48

@Daftasabroom I am not disagreeing with you, but price is much more persuasive than green credentials to most buyers,

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 20:46

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:11

@Daftasabroom I am not sure what point you are trying to make.

EPDs allow us to make informed choices on the products we purchase, i.e. we can control our own consumption.

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:45

@Moonmelodies ..and how do you think they are funding such projects? Their wealth is, to a large extent created by exporting tat to the west.

Moonmelodies · 08/11/2022 20:39

The Chinese aren't building hundreds of coal-fired power stations to make stuff for westerners, they are building them to charge their electric cars, and to power their enormous infrastructure projects.

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:39

@BerriesOnTop I am not suggesting that we stop buying everything from China, just that we start demanding more sustainable products. I'm sure China will adapt its production to meet a change in demand from those nations that consume most of its products.

VegMam · 08/11/2022 20:37

fernfen · 08/11/2022 18:54

That's the thing though isn't it, if they all claim to be experts in this field. Them why have they not written up their own action plan and white paper, that all other scientists in the actual field of work can peer review and get behind and offer their solutions to the world.

The big fat answer is they can't , there a set of obnoxious fools who would rather spend their time pissing off hard working people with their childish antics than coming up with some coherent scientific research, they can get others to agree upon. There full of hot air and just quote random bollocks, and spout well known facts to the public as though they are some sort of meshhias.

They just want to protest cause disruption while others do the hard work and research.

The answer is because we have the solutions, we know what we need to do. However, the status quo is working for the rich and powerful and so they’re not willing to implement the necessary changes with sufficient urgency.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 20:31

We need to accept that we have no control over places like China, but we can control our own consumption.Production and pollution in China would be reduced or become more sustainable if that is what the rest of the world demanded

The living standards of the average Chinese person improved massively thanks to this; it was the biggest poverty reduction action in history.

And don’t worry, even if ‘the West’ stopped buying Chinese goods (improbable), the Chinese are more than happy to keep providing the middle-income and developing countries with their goods while the West commits civilisational suicide for reasons best known to themselves

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 20:25

Climate change might be unprovable but getting covered in shite when you go swimming, getting lung conditions from pollution, having a massive bill because all the heat escapes from your attic etc may get people to "look up

All these can actually be solved through good regulations on industrial waste, better insulation and using EVs in urban areas.

It has little to do with carbon emissions.

FacebookPhotos · 08/11/2022 20:15

Those who think a bit of disruption on the M25 is the end of the world need to open their eyes to the actual end of the world.

I couldn’t give a stuff what happens on the M25 most of the time, but statements like this piss me off. The world will not actually end. It existed for billions of years before humanity. Our species will either adapt to climate change or die off. But the world will keep turning regardless. Being dismissive of other people’s significant problems (such as getting an ambulance to hospital) while engaging in hyperbole make you look ridiculous.

Personally, I can’t stand XR because they seem like spoilt brat drama queens form my working-class perspective. The second they disrupted a commuter train was the second they lost my support. If they had any sense they’d be encouraging public transport, not stopping it. They may not need to work (class privilege perhaps?) but most people need to keep a roof over their heads. As for throwing away perfectly good food at a time when tens of thousands in the UK are using food banks (and millions world wide are literally starving), that is simply immoral.

And I’ve yet to meet an environmentalist willing to accept nuclear fission as an intermediary energy source while we perfect nuclear fusion. It’s almost as though they think the public will accept a dramatic, sustained drop in standard of living “for the greater good”. Idiots.

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 20:11

@Daftasabroom I am not sure what point you are trying to make.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 20:06

@Unicorn1919 but we can control our own consumption

Environmental product declarations allow us to make informed choices

Google Pixel 7 here
Apple iPhone 14 here

Unicorn1919 · 08/11/2022 19:53

Some PPs have suggested going to protest in China. It is not China’s fault that we buy so much from them. Unfortunately capitalist entrepreneurs the world over will always exploit the demands of the general public. History and the study of economics tells us that the only way to successfully counter demand is to interfere in the market. The problem we are faced with is that our markets are flooded with cheap imported unsustainable products so there is no incentive for businesses or the public to consider the greener options. I do agree that we need more pressure put on Government and I think now is the time to start formulating real solutions.

Prior to the introduction of VAT in 1973, we had Purchase Tax (originally introduced in 1940) charged at 33.3 per cent tax on goods classed as 'luxury' and purposefully designed to discourage waste. Such as shame it was abolished as it is exactly what we need now.

Tax the hell out of super yachts, flashy cars and other unnecessary luxury spending that is polluting the planet. Anything beneficial to the environment, such as installing renewables, bicycles, and locally produced sustainable food and clothing for example should be tax free.

The Government needs to encourage people to make better decisions by making it easier to choose the environmentally sound option because it is cheaper than the wasteful alternative. For the those who don’t care about the environment, they can still buy their wasteful luxuries, but they will pay punitive taxes that can be used to help in other ways – seems very fair to me. We are seeing this already - the price of heating our homes has increased to a point where most people are actively looking for ways to cut consumption. Unfortunately price inflation is hitting the poorest the hardest. Using a tax designed to increase the price of luxury goods the most, should hit the wealthy the hardest.

We need to accept that we have no control over places like China, but we can control our own consumption.Production and pollution in China would be reduced or become more sustainable if that is what the rest of the world demanded.

Jijithecat · 08/11/2022 19:51

I would take much more notice of ER if they took positive action rather than undertaking civil disobedience.
Our local group regularly stand by the roundabout waving their flags with their designer dogs at their feet, fly posting (which then gets ripped down and you just see unsightly remnants) and putting stickers on nature boards obscuring the information about how to care for the local habitat.
If during their protests they had a quiet word with the people sitting in their cars with their engines idling or picked up the litter in the bit where they are protesting I might feel a bit more engaged.
The sentiment that I get from the local branch is that this is so much the fault of the government that they don't even need to try to improve things locally.
And yes I did pick the rubbish up myself.