Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
Spectre8 · 09/11/2022 21:49

So if you had a sick child who couldn't get to hospital in time because of protests and died or have life changing consequences are you okay with that? Just asking out of curiosity? Are you ok about missing your parents funeral?

Why are you out demonstrating and throwing shit over embassies of those countries who are the biggest polluters in the world and show no sign of stopping?

I'm not saying we in the uk sit back and do nothing but christ if other countries just carry on and have a bigger impact it does feel pointless.

TheSomersetGimp · 09/11/2022 21:36

Burningsky · 09/11/2022 21:18

Thanks, I’m going to stay a fuckwit activist though! I guess you’ll just have to stay pissed off. Believe me the people I’ve met by doing it are so are lovely, I can never imagine them talking about other people like you do. Anyone reading this join us if you want to be with the lovers not the haters like this poster!

You'll probably end up in prison at some point then. If someone doesn't flatten you to the tarmac with their motor that is. Enjoy.

Burningsky · 09/11/2022 21:18

fernfen · 09/11/2022 13:16

If you really care and want to be involved and not become a fuckwit activist, there is plenty you can do and If you care enough become involved in the real movement not those bloody awful eco-warrior idiots.

Let me tell you what I did. In my early 50`s I quit my cushy office job, and went back to univerity as a very mature student. I studied hard with mydyslexia, and got my BSc in environmetal science, I then went on to get my masters and now work in the environment industry activly making a diffrence, this is where I met my DH who is a scientist (not saying more as to out us both).

We both work on major projects and do make a diffence and this is why it pissed me off so much when I see childish silly little eco warriors doing their shit. There nothing more than vocal pathetic troublemakers who are in it for their own ego.

If you want to make a diffrence, learn the science get invoved in a productive way or get involved at a local level with politics. That is how change is made, eco warriors are nobodys and I can promise you they have ZERO influence over what we do. If you want change you have to step up and become a valued member not a spoilt brat.

Thanks, I’m going to stay a fuckwit activist though! I guess you’ll just have to stay pissed off. Believe me the people I’ve met by doing it are so are lovely, I can never imagine them talking about other people like you do. Anyone reading this join us if you want to be with the lovers not the haters like this poster!

UnstableCarHouse · 09/11/2022 20:34

I broadly agree with the aims of the protests but not the means. It’s not the way to win round the public or influence politicians. There was a guy on radio yesterday who missed his father’s funeral because of it, and sounded heartbroken. I get there’s a much bigger picture, but I’m not sure I could live with myself if I’d deliberately caused something like that to happen.

Federal · 09/11/2022 20:15

So OP, have you left your child and stuck yourself to a gantry yet???

CMZ2018 · 09/11/2022 19:29

medicellen · 09/11/2022 19:15

One final attempt to contextualise this discussion. Having taken part in (legal) protests with Extinction Rebellion, I posed a theoretical question about taking part in a future protest action with the risk of arrest.

I have no problem with people disagreeing about the idea of non-violent direct action – that’s the whole point of having a discussion on social media. For those of you who expressed your views in a reasonable way, I thank-you and have taken on board your comments.

However, there are a series of responses to thinking about a possible future action, that I think are unjustified. NVDA takes many forms and does not necessarily mean blocking roads. To recap:

@Prinnny You stopped a man trying to get to the hospital to see his dying mother. To be honest you’re lucky it happened down south as northerners would have dragged yous all out the way and hoyed you in the Tyne

@Alexandernevermind Pooring poo over a Captain Tom memorial didn't do you any favours, nor did trying to destroy a Van Gogh, and what was custard pieing King Charles's wax work all about, he's long been a environmental advocate?

@CourtneeLuv Most people think you are behaving like cunts.

@Theluggage15 The middle class handwringing over this issue is pathetic. If the U.K. disappeared tomorrow it would make absolutely no difference to the climate. But yeah stop people getting to work, delay ambulances while you fuck about and piss people off.

@Biker47 Blocking me getting to work or where I need to be isn't going to get me on your side, I'd just think you're a cunt. Same goes if you throw some soup over a painting, grade A cunt.

@fernfen XR and Just stop oil are pathetic always have been and always will, spoilt little brats desperately looking for attention and achieving nothing.

@CMZ2018 I hope you get an absolute leathering off the public then locked up.

@TheSomersetGimp Fucking twats the lot of them

😂😂😂

medicellen · 09/11/2022 19:15

One final attempt to contextualise this discussion. Having taken part in (legal) protests with Extinction Rebellion, I posed a theoretical question about taking part in a future protest action with the risk of arrest.

I have no problem with people disagreeing about the idea of non-violent direct action – that’s the whole point of having a discussion on social media. For those of you who expressed your views in a reasonable way, I thank-you and have taken on board your comments.

However, there are a series of responses to thinking about a possible future action, that I think are unjustified. NVDA takes many forms and does not necessarily mean blocking roads. To recap:

@Prinnny You stopped a man trying to get to the hospital to see his dying mother. To be honest you’re lucky it happened down south as northerners would have dragged yous all out the way and hoyed you in the Tyne

@Alexandernevermind Pooring poo over a Captain Tom memorial didn't do you any favours, nor did trying to destroy a Van Gogh, and what was custard pieing King Charles's wax work all about, he's long been a environmental advocate?

@CourtneeLuv Most people think you are behaving like cunts.

@Theluggage15 The middle class handwringing over this issue is pathetic. If the U.K. disappeared tomorrow it would make absolutely no difference to the climate. But yeah stop people getting to work, delay ambulances while you fuck about and piss people off.

@Biker47 Blocking me getting to work or where I need to be isn't going to get me on your side, I'd just think you're a cunt. Same goes if you throw some soup over a painting, grade A cunt.

@fernfen XR and Just stop oil are pathetic always have been and always will, spoilt little brats desperately looking for attention and achieving nothing.

@CMZ2018 I hope you get an absolute leathering off the public then locked up.

@TheSomersetGimp Fucking twats the lot of them

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2022 14:18

Shouting into the wind vs doing the hard work are very different things

banning all domestic flights under a certain length as someone posted has been done in France is a good example. It’s a simple concept. It is probably an effective idea. But someone has to sit down and make sure that it will actually help the environment.

  1. start by making a list of every domestic flight path that is now banned
  2. investigate existing alternative transportation paths
  3. collect data on historical usage of both flights and the alternative paths
  4. gather historical economic data that may impact trends in the data from step 3
  5. develop a statistical model that predicts shifts in transportation behavior choice.
  6. collect engineering data that provides estimates of the environmental impact of the shifts estimated in step 5 and compare to simply allowing flights to continue
Popgoestheweaselagain · 09/11/2022 13:30

fernfen · 09/11/2022 09:55

Climate nutters Various people have concluded that the public are I am somehow a cheerleader`s for climate change road blocks on the M25 and care nothing for anyone involved. It seems as though making assumptions to fit their your own prejudices somehow justifies venting their your fury on anyone who dares question them contradict you.

There changed your own statment works both ways 🙄.

Wish I could like this. I no longer believe the OP is a scientist. Her engagement in the discussion has been unimpressive.

something2say · 09/11/2022 13:30

Wow!!

Well, no one can deny that you are indeed walking your talk, and I applaud you and take off my hat.

But I dislike the way you speak about people who campaign. Maybe even for multiple ideas / constant campaigns. I do live in Glastonbury after all.

Carry on doing your thing, but two fingers to the way you speak about other people who are actually on your team.

fernfen · 09/11/2022 13:16

If you really care and want to be involved and not become a fuckwit activist, there is plenty you can do and If you care enough become involved in the real movement not those bloody awful eco-warrior idiots.

Let me tell you what I did. In my early 50`s I quit my cushy office job, and went back to univerity as a very mature student. I studied hard with mydyslexia, and got my BSc in environmetal science, I then went on to get my masters and now work in the environment industry activly making a diffrence, this is where I met my DH who is a scientist (not saying more as to out us both).

We both work on major projects and do make a diffence and this is why it pissed me off so much when I see childish silly little eco warriors doing their shit. There nothing more than vocal pathetic troublemakers who are in it for their own ego.

If you want to make a diffrence, learn the science get invoved in a productive way or get involved at a local level with politics. That is how change is made, eco warriors are nobodys and I can promise you they have ZERO influence over what we do. If you want change you have to step up and become a valued member not a spoilt brat.

something2say · 09/11/2022 12:32

The thing is tho...

How, genuinely, are we going to turn this juggernaut around??

Gluing oneself to things is not the point. The only point is, what exactly are we going to do? Politicians care only for business and profit. We are all going down if we blindly carry on like this.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 12:30

What @TimBoothseyes said. In spades.

TimBoothseyes · 09/11/2022 12:29

Various people have concluded that I am somehow a cheerleader for road blocks on the M25 and care nothing for anyone involved.

You don't care about people who can't go to work, may be attending chemo sessions which failure to get to could cause no end of complications. You don't care about pregnant women needing to go to a scan to find out if the baby they are carrying is still alive. You don't care about relatives trying to get to the funeral of a loved one but can't because idiots gluing themselves to the roads prevent them from doing so. But the most ironic thing is you don't care about climate change scientists not being able to get to their place of work because they are being obstructed from doing so.

It's absolutely clear that you care nothing for anyone involved if you are willing to be a part of the virtue signalling tossers who actively promote such behaviour. So well done you and when someone inevitably dies as a direct result of actions taken by you and others like you I doubt anyone one of you will care.

CatJumperTwat · 09/11/2022 12:17

Only ignorant Daily Mail readers don't believe in Nostradamus! Apparently.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 12:05

Nothing says 'we take science seriously' quite like talking about bloody fortune tellers.

😅

A 16th century man whose 'predictions' are so gnomic and obscure that they can be used to predict pretty much anything the reader wants.

RedToothBrush · 09/11/2022 11:55

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 09/11/2022 04:01

France have banned short under 2.5 flights in France. We need more action. The world is dying as predicted by Nostradamus.

When someone starts using Nostr-fucking-damus as a reason why we should support JSO and XR, the shark has been leapt and all sense of sanity and wisdom lost.

Nothing says 'we take science seriously' quite like talking about bloody fortune tellers.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 11:53

Vitrioil should be vitriol, of course. Talk about a Freudian slip.

TheSomersetGimp · 09/11/2022 11:52

🎯🤣

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 09/11/2022 11:51

Thus far, the vitriol here on mumsnet matches the very best on the Daily Mail forums. I anticipated it and therefore can take it, but its been an interesting experience in how people choose to direct their hatred

Translation - 'Oh bugger, I just got my arse comprehensively handed to me over 23 pages, didn't expect that, better reverse out and start whining about 'vitrioil' and 'hatred.''

CMZ2018 · 09/11/2022 11:27

Meseekslookatme · 09/11/2022 10:57

Most people I know are unsympathetic to the protestors.
Most people I know would like to do their bit.
Most people I know are alo struggling.

cool. I agree.

TheSomersetGimp · 09/11/2022 11:14

There is a breathtaking ignorance. From activists who decide they have the right to bring the road network to a standstill. And accusing people who need to work /are being prevented from doing so as ignorant daily mail readers. It makes you look like a twat with no understanding of the real world. Your actions achieving nothing. Apart from the increasing likelihood of an angry motorist driving their car straight over you. Do you think people would feel sorry for you? Or just think you deserve it?

GloomyDarkness · 09/11/2022 11:09

Most people I know are unsympathetic to the protestors.
Most people I know would like to do their bit.
Most people I know are also struggling.

They don't want to hear this - they keep refuting that people are aware.

I think they are confusing "raising awareness" with actually doing something which as many poster have pointed out is hard and frustrating and involves much less drama.

These threads have changed my mind in one way- I think police and courts need to start being very harsh with these people because they clearly won't listen and stop with out that.

VegMam · 09/11/2022 11:05

This post is bleak reading, spot the daily mail readers: the angry rude ones calling others clueless and in the same breath showing their own ignorance.

As I’ve said before on posts like this, don’t take the word of ransoms on MN, check what the experts are saying. Here’s a NASA a scientist.

I’ve also attached a screenshot by a tweet from the secretary general of the UN.

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?
ElmoNeedsThePotty · 09/11/2022 11:02

Musti · 09/11/2022 10:53

No art was damaged. It was behind glass.

Weird how people are indignant about stuff that wasn’t damaged instead of all the stuff that is being irreplaceably damaged around the world.

I know very well it was behind glass, but how long do you think it will be before this is stepped up?

They are getting absolutely nowhere at the moment, in fact the exact opposite, so more drastic action will be needed surely, as that poor policeman found out to his cost this morning

Swipe left for the next trending thread