Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
LemonAndLimeTree · 11/11/2022 14:08

I’ve always been intrigued why so many climate protestors have such enormous carbon footprints. I’ve seen a few examples like this protestor who has done far more international travel than me or, to be frank, most people I know.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11416705/Indigo-Rumbelow-Globe-trotting-farmers-daughter-lectures-public-saving-planet.html

Any thoughts @medicellen ?

DdraigGoch · 11/11/2022 14:01

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2022 14:18

Shouting into the wind vs doing the hard work are very different things

banning all domestic flights under a certain length as someone posted has been done in France is a good example. It’s a simple concept. It is probably an effective idea. But someone has to sit down and make sure that it will actually help the environment.

  1. start by making a list of every domestic flight path that is now banned
  2. investigate existing alternative transportation paths
  3. collect data on historical usage of both flights and the alternative paths
  4. gather historical economic data that may impact trends in the data from step 3
  5. develop a statistical model that predicts shifts in transportation behavior choice.
  6. collect engineering data that provides estimates of the environmental impact of the shifts estimated in step 5 and compare to simply allowing flights to continue

The French legislation is pretty limited in scope anyway. It doesn't apply to short haul international flights, no matter what rail alternatives exist, and I don't believe that it applies to connecting flights either. The original plan was to ban flights where a rail alternative of less than 4hrs existed, but this got watered down to 2.5hrs.

The current thing preventing modal shift from air to rail is a lack of capacity. Eurotunnel, LGV Nord and (when it was eventually built) HS1 decimated the air travel market between London and Paris/Brussels. HS2 will achieve the same between London and Manchester/Edinburgh/Glasgow. This is one of the big infrastructure projects that climate campaigners should be supporting rather than sitting in shanty towns to "save" an "ancient" alder tree that far from being 400 years old only has an expected lifespan of 60. hs2.green/

I'd look at an outright ban on flights where rail alternatives of less than 4hrs exist, no matter what borders are crossed or if it's a connecting flight. That would mean no flights from London to Paris/Brussels/Manchester from day one. Amsterdam is only 4hr8 from St Pancras so if the dwell time in Brussels could be reduced then it would come under the threshold. On completion of HS2 London to Edinburgh/Glasgow would easily be short enough, plus (if we're counting connecting services) Birmingham/Manchester to Paris/Brussels. Manchester to Southampton is 4h15 currently, but a link between HS2 at Birmingham Interchange with the existing line to Reading could knock 30m or more from that.

What to do in the meantime before these infrastructure projects are complete? Time to start rationing flights. Much fairer than taxes (which would be pocket money to the wealthiest but exclude the poor from that one once-in-a-lifetime flight). You get one short-haul flight per year, for long-haul flights you will have to save up. If you need more (perhaps you need to fly for work) then you/your employer will have to buy a non-flier's allocation. I wonder what reserve price I could set for mine...

TheSomersetGimp · 11/11/2022 13:29

Yes without a doubt they would be forced to close. Which would be even worse for actual people.

And if what is required is for people to take individual responsibility, then behaviour like stopping people getting to work isn't going to gain much sympathy for the cause.

The planet won't die. People might. Im not sure I really care that much anymore anyway.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/11/2022 13:26

I didn't realise climate change was the fault of village halls. Why aren't protestors targeting them? are they afraid of the militant WI brigade?

Meseekslookatme · 11/11/2022 13:23

Just look at your dismissive village hall commetn. There's something like 10,000 village halls in England alone, and based on average consumption data they contribute around 57000 tonnes of CO2e a year, just from energy use. Putting insulation into every single one would not only help the climate but would reduce demand for energy and running costs for those halls.

Realistically what will happen is that they will be forced to close with no replacement due to lack of funding.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/11/2022 13:16

Tigofigo · 10/11/2022 14:09

I'm assuming this post is a pisstake and some kind of parody, but assuming it's not for a second... No. It's big business and govt that can and must make the biggest changes here. Putting fucking insulation into the village hall will not move the needle but thanks for the laugh.

Nothing on it's own will "move the needle". Sustained collective action is required from all sections of society, not just the bits that mean you don't have to change. Simply passing the buck to those we see as "bigger" than us will not help the situation.

Tbh big businesses aren't really that much of an issue, they're taking things far more seriously than governments and the public.

The money people at the very top are taking climate change very seriously and have started taking net zero / sustainability into their lending decisions. The Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero, for example, has around $140 trillion under their members control, none of which will be mobilised to companies that can't evidence they are working towards a net zero goal. The net zero asset managers initiative has a further $66 trillion under their control and there are several other initiatives in place with the same goal.

Most large corporations are doing far more to reduce the emissions of their operations than any government or public population. Something like over 4000 large companies are either committed to or have verified science-based targets, which align with the Paris agreement's 1.5 degree scenario. No country can claim the same.

Trying to pass the buck to businesses doesn't wash now. Similarly, governments can take action but are limited in what they can do by the public, and will only implement measures that they are sure won't cost them an election, or inspire a revolution for those countries who do not follow a democratic process.

So really the onus is now on the people to make an effort to change and every little action that "won't move the needle" on it's own will add up if enough people participate.

Just look at your dismissive village hall commetn. There's something like 10,000 village halls in England alone, and based on average consumption data they contribute around 57000 tonnes of CO2e a year, just from energy use. Putting insulation into every single one would not only help the climate but would reduce demand for energy and running costs for those halls.

So while you might laugh at these little actions they do add up and they also provide more than "just" environmental benefits.

TheSomersetGimp · 11/11/2022 13:03

medicellen · 11/11/2022 11:04

@CatJumperTwat Maybe if I were a sadist. The attention isnt exactly pleasant, but sometimes I think it migh be worth getting out of the cosy tofu-eating, arm-pit-hair plaiting, woke, narcissist, middle-class activist bubble?

What a strange thing to say. I would think, without a doubt, that the majority of the protesters fit that profile rather than the average MNer. But that advice could certainly be directed to the protester twats.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/11/2022 12:50

The attention isnt exactly pleasant

That genuinely surprises me, considering the pumped up smirks on the faces of many who get carted away from "demonstrations". Of course I realise these don't represent them all, but the obvious drive to have a mindless, "look at meeee" moment to post on SM doesn't exactly help their cause

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/11/2022 12:31

The attention isnt exactly pleasant, but sometimes I think it migh be worth getting out of the cosy tofu-eating, arm-pit-hair plaiting, woke, narcissist, middle-class activist bubble?

Slightly confused now. Is this the bubble you're in or the one you think we haterzzzz are in? because I sure as hell don't recognise myself in that description.

medicellen · 11/11/2022 11:29

@BloodAndFire - correct. The one you said

OP posts:
CatJumperTwat · 11/11/2022 11:24

medicellen · 11/11/2022 11:04

@CatJumperTwat Maybe if I were a sadist. The attention isnt exactly pleasant, but sometimes I think it migh be worth getting out of the cosy tofu-eating, arm-pit-hair plaiting, woke, narcissist, middle-class activist bubble?

By taking part in stupid stunts besides other narcissistic middle-class "activists"?

BloodAndFire · 11/11/2022 11:20

medicellen · 11/11/2022 11:04

@CatJumperTwat Maybe if I were a sadist. The attention isnt exactly pleasant, but sometimes I think it migh be worth getting out of the cosy tofu-eating, arm-pit-hair plaiting, woke, narcissist, middle-class activist bubble?

Did you mean masochist? That didn't really work, did it?

medicellen · 11/11/2022 11:04

@CatJumperTwat Maybe if I were a sadist. The attention isnt exactly pleasant, but sometimes I think it migh be worth getting out of the cosy tofu-eating, arm-pit-hair plaiting, woke, narcissist, middle-class activist bubble?

OP posts:
CatJumperTwat · 11/11/2022 10:39

medicellen · 10/11/2022 17:53

@Puzzledandpissedoff as per post above I have said that I don't have any issue with disagreement, but have cited some examples of comments directed at me personally for a theoretical action that has not actually taken place. Those example seem fairly "hatey" in my eyes. Most of the other comments, no problem and fair

You've spent more time in this thread copy and pasting "hatey" comments than suggesting how the climate crisis could actually be fixed. You're an attention seeker, not an activist.

Daftasabroom · 11/11/2022 08:40

Tigofigo · 10/11/2022 14:09

I'm assuming this post is a pisstake and some kind of parody, but assuming it's not for a second... No. It's big business and govt that can and must make the biggest changes here. Putting fucking insulation into the village hall will not move the needle but thanks for the laugh.

99% of the people on this thread are doing fuck all about climate change, whether they anti or pro JSO (and no a bamboo toothbrush isn't going to have an impact). But hey guess what there are over 150,000 sports clubs in the UK, 10s of thousands of primary schools, 10s of thousands of Scout halls etc etc. Whether you're climbing a gantry or not blaming government and big businesses is just lazy.

WaveyHair · 10/11/2022 21:50

I don't understand why you think Uk fossil fuels are high up on the list of polluters. It is not. Even if the UK agree to the demands it won't actually make much difference.

You would be better off glueing yourself to the Brazilian embassy to protest at the rate they are destroying the rainforest. Or China for their part in it. Or the American embassy as they are one of the worst polluters & have essentially denied it is happening (a country where a surprisingly large majority of the population think the planet is flat).

Heatherjayne1972 · 10/11/2022 20:54

This is my opinion only
politicians. Don’t care - if they did why are they flying to Egypt on private planes?

ceo of international corporations don’t care - they ( personally) have the money and connections to get underground or wherever it is to escape.
big business is all about the money

these are the people who can and should make a difference ( they’re about 40 years too late I reckon- I suspect it’s all too late now anyway)

stopping traffic on the m25 / gluing yourself to a train/ being a general nuisance etc does nothing but put the public / media firmly against you

but you do what you think is right

BloodAndFire · 10/11/2022 20:46

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2022 19:15

Why do YOU get to decide whether that ambulance gets through or not?

Think about the power trip for a moment ... for some activists who've spent so long telling us just how soon we'll all be dead there may be a perverse satisfaction in actually seeing it happen, even if a little early

Then of course there's a good chance they'd be arrested and get to smirk at the news cameras, while crying a version of "This will be ALL of us if you don't listen NOW!!"

There is absolutely, definitely a power trip element in it. Have you seen the clip of the c**t who climbed on top of a tube at 6am at Canning Town tube station? absolutely revelling in his power to stop a load of predominantly Black, working class workers from getting to their jobs. He got what he was coming to him, but was let off relatively lightly. Sooner or later, they will fuck over the wrong people at the wrong time.

TheSomersetGimp · 10/11/2022 19:17

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2022 19:15

Why do YOU get to decide whether that ambulance gets through or not?

Think about the power trip for a moment ... for some activists who've spent so long telling us just how soon we'll all be dead there may be a perverse satisfaction in actually seeing it happen, even if a little early

Then of course there's a good chance they'd be arrested and get to smirk at the news cameras, while crying a version of "This will be ALL of us if you don't listen NOW!!"

I guess I might find a perverse satisfaction if one of them fell off a gantry. As long as no innocent people were injured as a result of this 🤷‍♀️

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2022 19:15

Why do YOU get to decide whether that ambulance gets through or not?

Think about the power trip for a moment ... for some activists who've spent so long telling us just how soon we'll all be dead there may be a perverse satisfaction in actually seeing it happen, even if a little early

Then of course there's a good chance they'd be arrested and get to smirk at the news cameras, while crying a version of "This will be ALL of us if you don't listen NOW!!"

onlythreenow · 10/11/2022 19:04

The op hasn't achieved anything. Although it has been helpful to clarify that the majority of people think that demonstrators who block roads are not achieving much, their message is lost, and that the people carrying out these protests are a self absorbed bunch of twats.

And yet the OP still believes they are in the right, and if the planet suddenly magically heals it will be because of them! You sound rather naive and immature OP, but you go ahead and do whatever you like. Then you can come back and tell us how well it went.

TheSomersetGimp · 10/11/2022 18:54

Why do YOU get to decide whether that ambulance gets through or not?

One day they'll stop the wrong person trying to get their loved one through to emergency care. I hope when it happens, someone uploads it so I get to watch when it happens.

Sausagenbacon · 10/11/2022 18:19

no, I do think it's us. Busy busy busy, consuming all day long.

Meseekslookatme · 10/11/2022 17:53

Another point to the ridiculous protests, Is that if laws are passed to stop the petulant little twats from getting off easily, it will affect protestors that genuinely might be doing something useful.

medicellen · 10/11/2022 17:53

@Puzzledandpissedoff as per post above I have said that I don't have any issue with disagreement, but have cited some examples of comments directed at me personally for a theoretical action that has not actually taken place. Those example seem fairly "hatey" in my eyes. Most of the other comments, no problem and fair

OP posts: