Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
Q2C4 · 08/11/2022 11:01

Ah @Dotjones the end justifies the means???
Why are you more concerned with future generations that don't yet exist than humans actually alive today?

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 10:59

I know this @Daftasabroom and that is not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that all energy, no matter how it is generated, will release heat when it is used to carry out work, it's one of the fundamental laws of thermodynamics. You can cover the planet in solar panels and wind turbines if you keep increasing energy use, which is required to support economic growth, eventually you will generate enough heat to heat up the planet beyond the point at which life is possible (you'd run out of everything else, water, food, ... before that though). My point is that indefinite economic growth is not sustainable even with renewable energy sources.

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 10:55

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 10:52

Per capita emissions from India are less than ours. When imported emissions are taken into account so are those of China.

Exactly, it's the population of those countries that is the real problem. No country should be allowed to have a billion people, there needs to be a scheme in place to cut the global population to 2 billion max, that would drastically improve things in relation to climate change.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 10:52

Kabbalah · 08/11/2022 10:43

Are you going to protest in China and India then ?. Thought not.

Per capita emissions from India are less than ours. When imported emissions are taken into account so are those of China.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 10:50

@Igneococcus And I'm sure I don't need to tell you that all energy, no matter if it was generated carbon neutrally or not, will release heat when it is put to work (in the physics sense of the word) and we are not going to invent ourselves out of this inconvenient fact. We can calculate that with much greater certainty than any climate models. I know growth lifts people out of poverty but thermodynamics doesn't care and can't be argued with.

Release of heat from burning fossil fuels is not responsible for any measurable impact on climate change. It is the release of green house gases that is causing climate change. I'm afraid you've got the physics completely wrong here.

Kabbalah · 08/11/2022 10:43

Softplayhooray · 08/11/2022 08:36

I think you are bloody incredible OP and its people like you that change the world. I wish I had your balls and I have nothing but utter respect for you. Civil disobedience is sometimes the only way and even then so many people will just complain as it causes short term inconvenience to them, but long term we are destroying our kids futures if we don't act.

Are you going to protest in China and India then ?. Thought not.

Kendodd · 08/11/2022 10:42

Problem we have I think is that the action we need to take is like dieting. We're all over weight, we know we're over weight and need to do something but we really want that cake, so we eat the cake.

Butchyrestingface · 08/11/2022 10:42

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:46

@ShallowHalWantsAGal - knowing the science, what actions would you advocate to try and mitigate the worst of what is coming?

You could have remained childfree for a start but I suppose that horse has bolted.

Q2C4 · 08/11/2022 10:39

@medicellen the moment you take any action which burns more fossil fuels to clear up/undo, you've lose support.

You're a scientist so why not start working on projects to create clean energy, eg nuclear fusion? If we can get that to work we can get clean energy for the entire globe, just from sea water.

www.gov.uk/government/news/site-of-uks-first-fusion-energy-plant-selected

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 10:35

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:32

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - XR have been holding peoples assemblies for years, but they have no mandate. Only the government can grant that and they have chosen not to

Why should someone unelected represent me?

I don’t want that

carefulcalculator · 08/11/2022 10:33

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:16

@Igneococcus - no one is suggesting immediately stopping oil. The JSO demand is for no NEW licenses and a rapid transition to renewables

This is current Labour policy isn't it? They have shortened timescales on renewables to 2030 which is really not far away.

Would it not therefore be worth your while finding your nearest Labour/Tory marginal seat and campaigning for a change of MP?

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 10:33

@medicellen really? I'm pretty sure I've seen this demand.
I actually think we are having the wrong discussion entirely. We should be talking about growth and the fact that our entire society and economy is structured around constant growth forever, which, throughout all our history, has gone hand in hand with growth in energy demand. And I'm sure I don't need to tell you that all energy, no matter if it was generated carbon neutrally or not, will release heat when it is put to work (in the physics sense of the word) and we are not going to invent ourselves out of this inconvenient fact. We can calculate that with much greater certainty than any climate models. I know growth lifts people out of poverty but thermodynamics doesn't care and can't be argued with. I don't actually have a solution for this but admitting that we can't forever grow on a limited planet which is pretty much a closed system would be a good start, though I admit it's fecking scary.
Here, for anyone who doubts what I say with regard to growth Galactic Scale Energy
Off to my lab now.

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:32

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - XR have been holding peoples assemblies for years, but they have no mandate. Only the government can grant that and they have chosen not to

OP posts:
TheSomersetGimp · 08/11/2022 10:29

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 08/11/2022 10:25

FFS can you read? Seriously, READ that post you just quoted.

Argh, I'm stepping away now, this is doing no good for my blood pressure OR my faith in humanity.

Good. Keep off the road too whilst you're about it.

Hohofortherobbers · 08/11/2022 10:26

gamerchick · 08/11/2022 09:25

Personally the sooner the planet kills us all off the better. Itll survive after we've been removed.

Exactly, mother nature will sort it out. These protests achieve nothing.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 08/11/2022 10:25

TheSomersetGimp · 08/11/2022 10:10

Why don't you do these things instead then, rather than sitting in the middle of a road, disrupting people, many of whom are already doing these things.

FFS can you read? Seriously, READ that post you just quoted.

Argh, I'm stepping away now, this is doing no good for my blood pressure OR my faith in humanity.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 10:24

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 10:06

So why doesn't ER set up those citizens' assemblies to start working on those plans.
The cynic in me thinks they don't do this because it's too hard. It means being popular and persuasive.

The realist in me knows that independent citizens' assemblies are impractical, would carry very little influence unless they reached a critical mass, and would likely end up resembling a collection of Judean People's Fronts in a matter of weeks.

At a very local community level democratic assemblies work. At a national level people prefer being told what to do.

I get what you're saying... that it would be difficult to carry as much weight if the assemblies are independent and not set up by government. But if they managed to get enough experts around the table and put forward some really serious, realistic, thought-through proposals about what needs to happen, I think they might stand a chance.

Protesting is the easy bit. Anyone can glue themselves to a road if they so choose, but it doesn't actually solve the problem. We all know that urgent action needs to be taken, and we don't really need the ER protestors to raise awareness of the issue. The real challenge is what we're actually going to do about it. That's where we need some radical thought. That's where people should be putting their energies. That's where we need people to be making a difference.

Successive governments have demonstrated clearly that they either don't know what to do about climate change, or else they do know what to do but they're not brave enough to do it. Our competitive party political system always gets in the way of long term thinking anyway. Instead of all this silly, futile disruption that ER is causing, which isn't actually achieving anything anyway, what we need is an honest, open, informed and grown-up debate about what actions need to be taken, when they need to be taken, what they will cost, what the implications will be, how the most vulnerable can be protected etc. ER (or whoever) could invite politicians from all parties to participate in the process.

These are going to be tough decisions. We are going to have to change the way we live... we can't just pretend that science will come up for solutions to it all....we haven't got time for that now. Let's have a proper national conversation about this, rather than the divisive protests that aren't really getting us anywhere. Telling your grandchildren that you were out there protesting to protect their future will be very cold comfort if you don't actually manage to achieve anything as a result.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 10:23

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 10:13

@ShallowHalWantsAGal The problem with that argument is most of us here have kids. Do we really not care about their futures?

But, thinking about it logically, (and maybe I'm not emotional enough), how will protesting in a way which I don't think is going to be effective help my children in the future? Also, how long am I expecting them to live for? If we stopped emissions immediately, they may live to see climate change slow down at the end of their lives, but their lives will be affected. That's a done deal!

I'm not unconcerned at all. I am very concerned for their future and I passionately believe we should be aiming for net zero emissions ASAP. But equally I want investment in infrastructure which can help mitigate against the affects of climate change. This takes investment and an educated / skilled workforce, which also takes investment. All of these issues are so enmeshed and it is very complex. Most people 'get' economics and climate change, however, some people think one or the other can be ignored which really isn't true (imo)

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 08/11/2022 10:23

How is causing chaos for the general public going to help? They are the people who genuinely can't financially afford to make the changes you want to happen. You are punishing the wrong people and turning them against your cause.

The focus climate change activists have on the doom and gloom is not something the public is interested in. In my opinion, the way to get through to people is through the financial savings renewables can bring. Also the how renewables will make the UK less reliant on other nations. This is currently, I think, the way the general public thinks with the current energy crisis.

However, let's say the civil disobedience for climate change continues. What will the next step be when that doesn't work?

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/11/2022 10:22

You certainly are not winning support for your cause by these criminal activities.

boringbrain · 08/11/2022 10:22

Protesting on busy routes stopping people going to work, hospital appointments will only piss people off. Your heart is in the right place but the way it's done disrupts ordinary people. When you piss off ordinary people you lose support from the general public and then the press demonises you as if they care about ordinary people, but they use it as an opportunity to deflect it from the actual targets which are politicians and corporations. Please target politicians and corporations and not the general public. The general public are going through a lot anyway because of these politicians and corporations and it will make them even more angry when they become a target.

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 10:21

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:19

@Kendodd - there are plenty of pensioners in XR and JSO. But then people abuse them because they have "used oil all their lives and now want to stop others from doing so"

Fair point

Climate issues have been known for a while and we all inherit the previous generation’s lack of change.

Africa seems an interesting one, I don’t know much yet but the idea that countries that have benefited from gas would stop them now is fraught with potential issues.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 08/11/2022 10:21

@TheSomersetGimp Are you assuming that anyone on this thread who objects to particularly thick posts is glued to an ambulance as we speak? I've never actually engaged in any activism, pointless or otherwise. I'm just easily irritated by stupid people.

Like many others on this thread, I don't believe that disrupting traffic etc will actually achieve anything (and is more likely to be counterproductive). There are better ways to protest - Greta Thunberg, for example. Ultimately, though, I really don't know what it would take to persuade governments around the world to make the kind of changes that are necessary. Maybe there isn't anything.

CatJumperTwat · 08/11/2022 10:20

medicellen · 08/11/2022 09:51

@midgetastic - that information is already in the public domain. No political party is prepared to bring in major change as it will too unpopular. The decision needs to be devolved to a citizens assembly

"Politicians won't make the change because the general public will never vote for it. The solution is for the general public to make the decision!"

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:19

@Kendodd - there are plenty of pensioners in XR and JSO. But then people abuse them because they have "used oil all their lives and now want to stop others from doing so"

OP posts: