Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:42

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:37

By how much could it be reversed if we took every single possible measure today and when would that reverse occur?

It can be reversed to the extent that excess CO2 and other greenhouse gases could be removed from the system. Remember that the excess CO2 we're talking about has been locked up in fossil fuels for millions of years as a result of process that themselves occurred over geological timescales.

Stopping emissions stops the atmospheric levels rising. Reversing atmospheric levels requires emissions to maintained below the rate of capture from the atmosphere and storage in biomass, soils, etc.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:41

Nobody can answer that really @glowtorch. Even the top scientists who work in this area cannot agree on what you are asking.

I do disagree with some of the rhetoric which some people spew online. Do this now so we can stop climate change for our children hurray! That isn't possible. We need to prepare for the damage climate change will do. If it's all about "our children", then mitigation is more important (imo) than halting emissions immediately. (But I still think we should be aiming to do that)

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 11:41

@Daftasabroom You could read the blog post I linked to or you could try to understand what I'm actually saying. I'm not saying it's driving climate change now, but that on the long run, if you keep expanding energy consumption it will add to the overall heating of the planet beyond sustainable levels.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:40

Musti · 08/11/2022 11:39

It isn’t just about reversing, it is about stopping it from getting worse and worse.

Does the climate not change anyway naturally?

Musti · 08/11/2022 11:39

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:37

By how much could it be reversed if we took every single possible measure today and when would that reverse occur?

It isn’t just about reversing, it is about stopping it from getting worse and worse.

IncompleteSenten · 08/11/2022 11:39

What form will your protest take?

Specifically I mean. What do you plan to do that may lead to your arrest?

Eg the people who superglued their hands to things, the people who threw soup at a painting.

That level of specific.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:37

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:36

The immediate impact would appear to be negligible.

The medium and long term impact would depend whether the inertia of events in motion is too great to prevent passing irreversible tipping points (see an earlier reply of mine). If irreversible change can be avoided, then anthropogenic climate change can be halted and indeed reversed.

By how much could it be reversed if we took every single possible measure today and when would that reverse occur?

Theluggage15 · 08/11/2022 11:36

Go and protest in China.

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:36

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:29

Is it possible the impact would negligible?

The immediate impact would appear to be negligible.

The medium and long term impact would depend whether the inertia of events in motion is too great to prevent passing irreversible tipping points (see an earlier reply of mine). If irreversible change can be avoided, then anthropogenic climate change can be halted and indeed reversed.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:36

That doesn't mean we can't change anything though. Rewinding, cleaning seas and other bodies of water can make an impact. We can work to mitigate against the worst of climate change in a number of ways, but halting emissions alone won't make a difference for a long time

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:33

Ok, so are you saying that a lot of the work on this has actually been done and that ER have already drawn up detailed, costed policy proposals etc, with full impact assessments, plans on how these policies could be practically implemented, considerations about how to minimise the impact on the most vulnerable etc? And that the main problem is that politicians from all parties are failing to engage with their recommendations?

Giving some credit to ER, People's Assembles should not be about detailed solutions. They should be about demonstrating a commitment and desire to accept solutions in principle. Trying to get consensus on detail is an impossible task (you run headfirst into Parkinson's Law of Triviality).

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:33

Negligible for the immediate future. We won't live to see a halt in climate change based on what we do right now I don't think

[[https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/climate-change-evidence-causes/question-20/][

ChrisS36 · 08/11/2022 11:31

If you have the answers seek election. We are a democracy.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:29

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:28

It's unknown. There are too many variables. If we stopped all (non-respiratory) CO2 emissions today it would take time for the changes already underway to slow and stop.

Taking the chicken out of the oven doesn't stop it cooking immediately.

Is it possible the impact would negligible?

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:28

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:13

If we took all the measures proposed today and kept them up, optimal situation, by how much would we delay disastrous climate change?

It's unknown. There are too many variables. If we stopped all (non-respiratory) CO2 emissions today it would take time for the changes already underway to slow and stop.

Taking the chicken out of the oven doesn't stop it cooking immediately.

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 11:22

There’s a few groups involved - government, business and us

Politicians are elected on a mandate so it’s really us that has to vote and lead it, business reacts to demand. I think as consumers we have more power than we think. But as a pp said a quick glance on here - just on a thread with posters laughing at small houses etc, which model air con? threads picked up during heat waves.

Behaviour change is hard, although not impossible. Usually altered by £ - even small charge for a plastic bag dropped use substantially. People will increasingly be priced out of stuff.

Unfortunately the protests seem to create huge traffic jams and people annoyed more than much else atm

Change imo will happen due to cost

medicellen · 08/11/2022 11:17

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - XR have held exploratory CAs to test the model, but they are aware that they are not necessarily representative of the whole population and therefore any concrete proposals would not be valid. A CA needs time, funding, input of multiple scientific and social experts and government endorsement. An example is the CA held in N Ireland about abortion. CA about climate action is likely to be much more complex

One of the key questions is where funding for carbon cuts will come from - the government will never redistribute large sums from rich to poor unless the population tells them that is what is needed

OP posts:
glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:16

What exact outcome do you want from the protest and how does the protest achieve that outcome?

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:13

If we took all the measures proposed today and kept them up, optimal situation, by how much would we delay disastrous climate change?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 11:12

medicellen · 08/11/2022 10:32

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - XR have been holding peoples assemblies for years, but they have no mandate. Only the government can grant that and they have chosen not to

Ok, so are you saying that a lot of the work on this has actually been done and that ER have already drawn up detailed, costed policy proposals etc, with full impact assessments, plans on how these policies could be practically implemented, considerations about how to minimise the impact on the most vulnerable etc? And that the main problem is that politicians from all parties are failing to engage with their recommendations?

That's great if they have already done this work, but glueing themselves to the roads doesn't seem to be a very effective way of getting their message out there or ensuring that their recommendations are heard.

Could you provide a link to the detailed policy proposals and plans that they are asking politicians to take on board, please? I can see the "bill" that they are proposing which would require the government to come up with a serious plan to tackle climate change, but I can't seem to find any of the serious detailed plans that ER themselves are proposing with regard to what actually needs to be done to tackle the climate emergency. I might be missing it, but if I am, I guess that just highlights the fact that their communications strategy isn't working very effectively.

It always seems to me that there is a lot of handwringing and demanding that the government should do something (which I don't disagree with) but I struggle to find a great deal of detail about what that something should actually look like in real, practical terms. Yes, there are headlines about insulating homes etc, but how do they want that to happen, when, how will it be funded etc? What specific actions do people want the government to take and how do they propose that those actions should be paid for and implemented? I'm not arguing against the fact that action is needed at all. I just want to know more about the detailof what people think that should look like and how we can make it work.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 11:12

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 10:59

I know this @Daftasabroom and that is not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that all energy, no matter how it is generated, will release heat when it is used to carry out work, it's one of the fundamental laws of thermodynamics. You can cover the planet in solar panels and wind turbines if you keep increasing energy use, which is required to support economic growth, eventually you will generate enough heat to heat up the planet beyond the point at which life is possible (you'd run out of everything else, water, food, ... before that though). My point is that indefinite economic growth is not sustainable even with renewable energy sources.

Indefinite economic growth may or may not be sustainable, but the pseudo-physics you're using to justify it is really very wrong. Heat release from work done is absolutely not causing climate change. If you have any evidence, i.e. peer reviewed papers please link to them.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:10

The problem isn't purely population levels anyway. A large family in some developing countries emits less than a single childless person in the western world (statistically speaking) so lifestyle comes in to it too.

Also, more developed and economically stable countries tend to have lower birth rates. In fact there is a direct corellation between high birth rates and poorer living standards. So, economic growth can lead to lower birth rates but as @Igneococcus says, economic growth cannot be sustained forever.

Low birth rates aren't always the best thing for planet but it depends on your perspective. It's a horrible thing to say, but one of the issues with population in western countries is that we have an ageing population (people live a long time and we have a lower birth rate). But that's really reducing people to pounds and pennies which I know is very crass, but this is the way these threads always end up (usually saying people in India must not have babies because poor planet)

biome · 08/11/2022 11:07

NVDA has achieved a lot in the last few years in getting action on climate change and biodiversity loss. There is an evidence base to that. Protest also increases discussions about issues without putting people off those subjects. Those that voted that it is unreasonable: what are you doing? What have you achieved in the last few years to ensure your beloved children inherit a livable planet?

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 11:04

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 10:55

Exactly, it's the population of those countries that is the real problem. No country should be allowed to have a billion people, there needs to be a scheme in place to cut the global population to 2 billion max, that would drastically improve things in relation to climate change.

What a ridiculous statement - the population density of India is about half that of the UK and China is about 1/5.