Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:07

@glowtorch - XR demand of the government are to tell the truth, act now and hold a citizens assembly. The government havent listened via the usual channels (as they didnt about womens votes, civil right and INdian independence). Protest aims to get them to implement

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 12:07

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:02

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - the Brexit decision was influenced by a media and politicians with vested interests who deployed frank lies to the public. I dont think it is because they are incapable of making a sensible decision

Nothing is truly objective but a CA would be considerably better than existing structures (parliament) both in terms of representativeness and coming to the fairest possible decisions.

Clearly this is highly complex but there could be immediate CA votes on issues such as:
Ban all private jets
Limit business travel and holiday travel to x number flights per year
Massive taxes on fossil fuel companies and their finances
Heavy green taxes on those who use a disproportionate amount of resoucres

Why would a member of the CA vote on this for me? How do I elect them

I have an MP who represents my area

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:04

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:02

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - the Brexit decision was influenced by a media and politicians with vested interests who deployed frank lies to the public. I dont think it is because they are incapable of making a sensible decision

Nothing is truly objective but a CA would be considerably better than existing structures (parliament) both in terms of representativeness and coming to the fairest possible decisions.

Clearly this is highly complex but there could be immediate CA votes on issues such as:
Ban all private jets
Limit business travel and holiday travel to x number flights per year
Massive taxes on fossil fuel companies and their finances
Heavy green taxes on those who use a disproportionate amount of resoucres

Ban all private jets
Limit business travel and holiday travel to x number flights per year
Massive taxes on fossil fuel companies and their finances
Heavy green taxes on those who use a disproportionate amount of resoucres

Explain how your protests achieve this.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:04

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:02

Are you talking about work visas?

How much do we allow now and how much do you want us to allow exactly?

Sorry? I was responding to you saying there ought to be a one child policy which I believe would not work in the UK without increased immigration to make up for the shortfall in working aged people to run the country and fund it through taxes

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:02

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - the Brexit decision was influenced by a media and politicians with vested interests who deployed frank lies to the public. I dont think it is because they are incapable of making a sensible decision

Nothing is truly objective but a CA would be considerably better than existing structures (parliament) both in terms of representativeness and coming to the fairest possible decisions.

Clearly this is highly complex but there could be immediate CA votes on issues such as:
Ban all private jets
Limit business travel and holiday travel to x number flights per year
Massive taxes on fossil fuel companies and their finances
Heavy green taxes on those who use a disproportionate amount of resoucres

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 12:02

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 11:41

@Daftasabroom You could read the blog post I linked to or you could try to understand what I'm actually saying. I'm not saying it's driving climate change now, but that on the long run, if you keep expanding energy consumption it will add to the overall heating of the planet beyond sustainable levels.

No you are wrong, the blog is a totally hypothetical look 2500 years into the future.

Enthalpy essentially means that in a closed system energy can be transferred from on place to the other and from one form to another - e.g. kinetic energy from wind into electricity. But the release of greenhouse gases, primarily from the burning of fossil fuels means that earth absorbs more of the suns energy, the enthalpy is changing. This absorption of that energy is what is driving climate change.

Assuming we get to net zero and a constant amount of GHGs in the atmosphere the enthalpy we also be constant so it doesn't matter how many times you move the energy about the total will remain fixed.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:02

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:58

Low birth rate isn't always the best option all round. Larger populations in Western countries is usually down to higher life expectancy which itself leads to lower birth rate, so we end up with an ageing population which can be problematic. So I'm not sold on the one child policy necessarily. But perhaps in the UK we could if we allowed more immigration. But then think how that idea would go down with the electorate and no right minded politician would go with it

Are you talking about work visas?

How much do we allow now and how much do you want us to allow exactly?

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 11:59

In a battle for hearts and minds speak to both...

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:58

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:53

I think fewer people is really the best and only solution personally, and fewer carbon-based lifeforms in general.

Shut down the entire meat and dairy industry for one and adopt a one child policy - these would have the biggest impact.

I don't drive, eat animals, and have one child. I'm never going to do anything more than that because I want to enjoy life. I don't fly.

I still would like to know from OP what exact outcome she wants from the protest and how the protest will achieve it. She'd do well to ask herself that question but I 100% believe XR are all about virtue signalling and being pleased with onesself.

Low birth rate isn't always the best option all round. Larger populations in Western countries is usually down to higher life expectancy which itself leads to lower birth rate, so we end up with an ageing population which can be problematic. So I'm not sold on the one child policy necessarily. But perhaps in the UK we could if we allowed more immigration. But then think how that idea would go down with the electorate and no right minded politician would go with it

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 11:58

Does civil disobedience work?

People always point to the suffragettes as the classic example but it's not that simple.

Its been argued that whilst it drew attention to the cause, it didn't change opinions.

What changed opinions were the less hailed and unfashionable suffragists and circumstances changing to force necessities to change (WWI).

We are at a moment where energy prices are focusing minds far more than protestors on the M25. And where the politics of dealing with certain countries is pushing the political agenda to seek energy security long term. In terms of science if the uk can get its act together there's money to be made in renewable technology.

If the wise push this angle its far more likely to be successful than dickheads in art galleries.

Make it connect with day to day life in a positive way to get people on board.

medicellen · 08/11/2022 11:57

@Theluggage15 - do you advocate giving up and doing nothing?

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 11:57

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:33

Ok, so are you saying that a lot of the work on this has actually been done and that ER have already drawn up detailed, costed policy proposals etc, with full impact assessments, plans on how these policies could be practically implemented, considerations about how to minimise the impact on the most vulnerable etc? And that the main problem is that politicians from all parties are failing to engage with their recommendations?

Giving some credit to ER, People's Assembles should not be about detailed solutions. They should be about demonstrating a commitment and desire to accept solutions in principle. Trying to get consensus on detail is an impossible task (you run headfirst into Parkinson's Law of Triviality).

Fair enough if that isn't the point of them... I have never really understood the point of them in any case.

I don't think we need a citizens' assembly to demonstrate a commitment to do something/a desire to accept solutions. Either that commitment and desire is there or it isn't, and a representative assembly will reflect the mixed views of the population as it stands at the moment.

Creating a citizens assembly to resolve that we should "do something" seems utterly pointless to me. Just a talking shop to tell us what we already know. Most politicians have already seen enough of the science to know that action is required. The question is what.

Of course, trying to get consensus on the detail is incredibly difficult, and that's what is holding us back at the moment. Nobody really knows how to do what we need to do because it is clear that it will have a major impact on how we live. The detail is the only important bit, though....it is the only hope we have.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:54

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:51

No. It's your posts to the thread as a whole. Coming straight out of the manmade climate change denier playbook.

You thinking I deny manmade climate change doesn't explain how you could think I deny climate change is a thing because I think it happens naturally.

Are you able to explain that one?

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:53

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:51

We may be able to reverse climate change but (imo) you and I probably won't be around to see it. Yes, we can reduce our impact in a and we can mitigate against the affects of climate change too to protect ourselves, future generations and the rest of our planet. It won't be perfect, but that doesn't mean you do nothing.

(But I would see glueing myself to a motorway as basically doing nothing in terms of impact so I won't be doing it)

I think fewer people is really the best and only solution personally, and fewer carbon-based lifeforms in general.

Shut down the entire meat and dairy industry for one and adopt a one child policy - these would have the biggest impact.

I don't drive, eat animals, and have one child. I'm never going to do anything more than that because I want to enjoy life. I don't fly.

I still would like to know from OP what exact outcome she wants from the protest and how the protest will achieve it. She'd do well to ask herself that question but I 100% believe XR are all about virtue signalling and being pleased with onesself.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:51

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:51

No. It's your posts to the thread as a whole. Coming straight out of the manmade climate change denier playbook.

Nice, but what's your answer to the actual questions.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:51

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:47

So we can't reverse climate change but we can reverse our impact on climate change, is that what you're saying?

We may be able to reverse climate change but (imo) you and I probably won't be around to see it. Yes, we can reduce our impact in a and we can mitigate against the affects of climate change too to protect ourselves, future generations and the rest of our planet. It won't be perfect, but that doesn't mean you do nothing.

(But I would see glueing myself to a motorway as basically doing nothing in terms of impact so I won't be doing it)

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:51

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:46

So you assume because I think the climate changes naturally I am in denial that the climate changes?

No. It's your posts to the thread as a whole. Coming straight out of the manmade climate change denier playbook.

borderterrierr · 08/11/2022 11:50

Do you you glue yourself to things? What have you done?

I agree with the sentiment but we had to cancel a heart transplant last week because the ambulance transporting the organ got stuck behind people who had glued themselves to the road. No way round.

Theluggage15 · 08/11/2022 11:50

The middle class handwringing over this issue is pathetic. If the U.K. disappeared tomorrow it would make absolutely no difference to the climate. But yeah stop people getting to work, delay ambulances while you fuck about and piss people off.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 11:48

medicellen · 08/11/2022 11:17

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - XR have held exploratory CAs to test the model, but they are aware that they are not necessarily representative of the whole population and therefore any concrete proposals would not be valid. A CA needs time, funding, input of multiple scientific and social experts and government endorsement. An example is the CA held in N Ireland about abortion. CA about climate action is likely to be much more complex

One of the key questions is where funding for carbon cuts will come from - the government will never redistribute large sums from rich to poor unless the population tells them that is what is needed

Yes, I agree that funding is one of the major challenges. I also agree that governments won't act to redistribute wealth unless there is significant pressure to do so. I just don't agree that the protests that are happening right now will be effective in applying that pressure. Quite the opposite, actually...I think the extreme protests make the message less credible and more easily dismissed.

I do take your point that it would be hard for XR to organise a forum that was truly representative of the whole population, but I'm not sure that the government could realistically achieve that either. I'm also very sceptical about the value of citizens' assemblies on a topic that is so complex. If Brexit taught us nothing else, it demonstrated that ordinary citizens typically have a limited understanding of complex matters which makes informed decision- making difficult. We could just end up investing an awful lot of time and money into something that wouldn't actually produce viable solutions.

We actually already have an assembly of elected representatives in the shape of the House of Commons. We pay these people to get their heads around these complex issues and to legislate on our behalf. I'm not really sure what the value of creating another assembly would be...if the representatives were elected, then how would that really be different from what we have in our current Parliament? If they were unelected/selected by government bodies, then how would their recommendations have any democratic validity?

Personally, I think it would be better to focus on the representative assembly that we already have (Parliament), and to find a way of making it work more effectively to tackle these issues. We need to take the party politics out of it, and to get a cross party group of MPs to drive the strategy forward. That group of MPs should be advised by a panel of experts in a range of relevant fields who could help them to understand the decisions that they're making and the likely implications of those. The process can include a public consultation if needed, but we don't need to assemble another random bunch of semi- informed citizens to address these issues...we already have that. What we really need is a way of bringing together the very best brains in the country, with expertise across a whole range of different fields, in order to find a way through this, and we then need those experts to work with our elected representatives who have the power to legislate in order to implement their recommendations.

I still don't see how glueing yourself to the road is going to move us any further forward.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:47

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:45

It is man made climate change @glowtorch. That is refuted by almost nobody.

So we can't reverse climate change but we can reverse our impact on climate change, is that what you're saying?

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:46

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:43

House!

(we're playing climate change denial bullshit bingo, right?)

So you assume because I think the climate changes naturally I am in denial that the climate changes?

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 11:45

It is man made climate change @glowtorch. That is refuted by almost nobody.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:44

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:43

House!

(we're playing climate change denial bullshit bingo, right?)

I'm interested in how you can reverse a natural process that's happened over millennia when we are the cause of accelerating it. If we are the cause how can it ever be reversed with us even present?

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 11:43

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 11:40

Does the climate not change anyway naturally?

House!

(we're playing climate change denial bullshit bingo, right?)