Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:28

I think you are correct about their being too many people for continued growth to be sustainable @glowtorch . However as I have said a couple of times now, low birth rate will not fix population and overcrowding in the UK as we already have a low birth rate and an ageing population. The birth rate is not the issue. So a one child policy would not work here and may actually cause a problem as there would not be enough working aged people here to keep the country going. If we were to do it, we would have to make up for the shortfall somehow; probably by increasing immigration.

I don't think it is a good idea. It was you who suggested it!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:26

Rishi got so much flack - from climate activists and the opposition parties - until he said ok

Makes perfect sense, Marsha; I've been in the US for weeks and had missed this if it was recent?

As said, if one highlights the fact that travelling to these jollies isn't really necessary that spoils things for others - and I wouldn't expect the "others" to appreciate that, any more than those with multiple children appreciate it being pointed out that often folk don't "discover" climate issues until after they've had them

ILikeToSleepALot · 08/11/2022 12:26

The problem with action on climate is that most people (I'm including myself here!) are not willing to be inconvenienced in any way, not by protests, not by lifestyle changes that would make things better, and greatly resent any suggestion that they should accept personal inconvenience or discomfort for a greater purpose. Most of the responses in this thread are a great example of that mindset. We want to live our lives exactly as we are used to living them, and to occasionally make ourselves feel virtuous by giving up small things we didn't care about anyway and don't make a real difference, such as plastic drinking straws.

Any kind of climate action that would truly make a difference would require all of us, especially in the West, to change our lives to an unacceptable degree. No politician will commit to decisions to make this happen because they would be hugely unpopular. The comparison with suffrage protests etc doesn't work because giving women the right to vote didn't require everyone to downgrade their lifestyle to accommodate that.

Forfrigz · 08/11/2022 12:24

While I agree that in an ideal world we would take care of the planet and change our ways to save species etc but in reality that's not how humans work in general. I think the crisis will become horrific with major changes in climate, loads of animals and plants will be wiped out eventually and our ability to live will be hindered. Eventually, this will make us have to advance technology further to enable us to live but some parts of nature on this planet will be home forever. As always, it'll be the rich that live in comfort while the poor will live with the bad effects of ecological breakdown. There'll be a lot of migration worldwide away from places that become inhospitable and probably war. I think it's unavoidable ad its just the way it is. Unless the masses can do something, as it always comes down to the neverending problem of the ones at the top benefitting while the rest suffer.

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 12:24

I find the arguments that direct action is "necessary" because political action "doesn't work" rather weak.

The only reason political action doesn't work is that activists are not able to convince the majority of people to vote for parties that support their aims. Leaving aside the point that disruptive action puts people off supporting groups like XR, IB or JST, why are the organisers of these groups so incapable of persuading the public through peaceful, polite dialogue?

The biggest reason is surely that they know they don't have the answers themselves - they think something is wrong but don't have the practical answers as to how to solve things.

It's not good enough to demand change if you can't explain how that change should come about.

Just Stop Oil are basically the same as the English Defence League and other similar groups. They have an end aim but no idea as to how to get there, in practical terms, in a way that "normal" people can get on board with. Therefore the public just think of them as troublemaking idiots.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:23

CaptainMarvelDanvers · 08/11/2022 12:18

We need less people. It’s the only thing that will slow down the environmental damage for any hope that our species can survive.

Tbh I can’t even get wound up about the protestors having an effect on my life, they don’t. They are all based down South, I get that’s where the MP’s are but it makes it seem even more like a middle class get together.

The hippies I do know and have taken part in fracking protests, all use either alcohol or drugs and can’t string a sentence together unless it’s about Aliens. I love them but we need some better protestors up North. Not that it’s going to do anything because as I mentioned in my first sentence, we need less people.

So we need more protestors up North so they can do nothing?

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:22

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:15

It depends on the size of the population and the nature of the infrastructure of the country at the time you hypothetically legislate on their being one child born per couple. It would also depend on the details within said hypothetical legislation, so I cannot possibly answer as there is no such legislation. You came up with this brilliant proposal so maybe you could trot off and get a law and economics degree and get back to us when you've got it all sorted 😂 🙄

It's not a proposal, I think it's an overreach of control and would never support that kind of regulation of our choices.

It's just that I think the only thing that can have any impact whatsoever on manmade impact on climate change is ... well, less man.

I.e. fewer people. But populations are growing, so I wonder what the point in much of this is, especially sitting in a road. I've yet to hear from OP what impact that is supposed to have and I know full well that's because she herself has no idea.

AnnPerkins · 08/11/2022 12:22

I don't think your methods are working. Yes, when you close a motorway people are talking about you and you get a platform to talk about the issues, but you are too easy to demonise and therefore ignore. Now commentators have started saying how concerned they are about some young activists' mental health because holier than thou speeches, angry ranting or getting tearful in radio interviews is just not coming across well.

You need to work out how you can be the sort of people that powerful people want to emulate and align themselves with. Small example: DEPHER is a social enterprise that does useful, constructive work to help people in poverty. OK it's not about the climate emergency but it shows how you can get people's attention by constructive, useful means and take people with you. When James Anderson talks about poverty people listen. He has famous, wealthy supporters, nobody's demonising him, they want to be seen with him. If he was just glueing himself to old people's front doors and crying into a camera he would have absolutely no effect. DEPHER is a small community group based in the north of England but they have 80k followers on Twitter. JSO has 88k followers.

I just think ER and JSO's methods are very old hat. I respect useful people and I am very happy to support them and I think many others feel the same.

YellowTreeHouse · 08/11/2022 12:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 12:20

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:17

I can think of someone who tried not to attend. It did not go down well

Whether you mean someone known personally or some sort of leader I believe you completely, Marsha - once one breaks ranks it shines a light on everyone else's lack of thought and that'll never go down well

I was being a bit vague ; but Rishi got so much flack - from climate activists and the opposition parties - until he said ok

CaptainMarvelDanvers · 08/11/2022 12:18

We need less people. It’s the only thing that will slow down the environmental damage for any hope that our species can survive.

Tbh I can’t even get wound up about the protestors having an effect on my life, they don’t. They are all based down South, I get that’s where the MP’s are but it makes it seem even more like a middle class get together.

The hippies I do know and have taken part in fracking protests, all use either alcohol or drugs and can’t string a sentence together unless it’s about Aliens. I love them but we need some better protestors up North. Not that it’s going to do anything because as I mentioned in my first sentence, we need less people.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:17

I can think of someone who tried not to attend. It did not go down well

Whether you mean someone known personally or some sort of leader I believe you completely, Marsha - once one breaks ranks it shines a light on everyone else's lack of thought and that'll never go down well

EatYourVegetables · 08/11/2022 12:16

You guys are heroes.

The comments in this post are making me weep for the future.

Federal · 08/11/2022 12:15

@antelopevalley how would banning all wood burning stoves and 4x4s help those who don’t live in the city? In the city where there is no need, perhaps, but a blanket ban just wouldn’t work.
we aren’t all on a main road and have a gas line you know!

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:15

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:08

Yes, I'm asking by how must we would need to increase immigration.

Also asking which type of immigration you meant, and if you meant those coming to work here. How many do we allow each year currently and how much would we need to increase it by in your opinion?

It depends on the size of the population and the nature of the infrastructure of the country at the time you hypothetically legislate on their being one child born per couple. It would also depend on the details within said hypothetical legislation, so I cannot possibly answer as there is no such legislation. You came up with this brilliant proposal so maybe you could trot off and get a law and economics degree and get back to us when you've got it all sorted 😂 🙄

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 12:15

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:14

Climate change summits involving hundreds of people flying... why not do it online?

Because it's not as appealing as travelling somewhere nice for a jolly?

Considering the importance some delegates place on their own status, you didn't really think they'd hold themselves to the same standards they prech to everyone else did you?

I can think of someone who tried not to attend. It did not go down well.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:14

Climate change summits involving hundreds of people flying... why not do it online?

Because it's not as appealing as travelling somewhere nice for a jolly?

Considering the importance some delegates place on their own status, you didn't really think they'd hold themselves to the same standards they prech to everyone else did you?

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 08/11/2022 12:13

@ShallowHalWantsAGal why one child? If you REALLY cared you would have had none. Shocking

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2022 12:11

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:09

@MarshaBradyo - has you MP achieved anything effective in relation to the climate emergency?

They are voted in on the mandate so if you are convinced that the public want what you want we’d see it in votes - for the Green Party for example

You can’t force it through in another way, whoever makes the decisions needs to be elected

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:10

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:09

@MarshaBradyo - has you MP achieved anything effective in relation to the climate emergency?

So when you say emergency, how long do we have until it's catastrophic?

Userg1234 · 08/11/2022 12:09

Look you climate activists have got it all wrong. You are preaching doom and gloom at some unspecified time in the future.
THiS WINTER is your big chance. Explain how being green IE walking not driving, boiling only the water you need. Turn off lights, unplug non used electronic equipment etc will say people money right here right now
I am sceptical about climate change, but have done all the above, have solar panels, air fryer and slow cooker etc just because I am tight and don't waste money

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 12:09

We could make a start with smaller actions. Ban all wood-burning stoves for a start. Terrible for air pollution even the "environmental" ones. Ban all gas agas. Having an oven on all the time is a terrible waste of resources. Limit the size of private cars or tax to hell large ones. Estates with lots of seats are fine, but no one needs an enormous 4x4 to transport 2 kids.

But anything effective affects the rich and middle class most, which is why it will not happen.

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:09

@MarshaBradyo - has you MP achieved anything effective in relation to the climate emergency?

OP posts:
Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 12:09

You could write a rebuttal letter to Nature Physics where this was published in August 2022 and point out where Murphy goes all wrong @Daftasabroom

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:08

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:04

Sorry? I was responding to you saying there ought to be a one child policy which I believe would not work in the UK without increased immigration to make up for the shortfall in working aged people to run the country and fund it through taxes

Yes, I'm asking by how must we would need to increase immigration.

Also asking which type of immigration you meant, and if you meant those coming to work here. How many do we allow each year currently and how much would we need to increase it by in your opinion?

Swipe left for the next trending thread