Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 13:04

@ILikeToSleepALot Any kind of climate action that would truly make a difference would require all of us, especially in the West, to change our lives to an unacceptable degree.

But this is a myth perpetuated by the right wing press, the changes we need to make will improve our lives not make them worse.

2bazookas · 08/11/2022 13:04

Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage

Back when arrested women had so little to lose.

Few had any education, qualifications , personal money or a bank account. So court fines were meaningless. Being called terrorists, had nothing like the impact it does today.

Today, protesters convicted of terrorism, arson, criminal assault and violent crimes are likely to suffer lifetime consequences in employment , housing, and much else.

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 13:04

Just Stop Oil are basically the same as the English Defence League and other similar groups. They have an end aim but no idea as to how to get there, in practical terms, in a way that "normal" people can get on board with. Therefore the public just think of them as troublemaking idiots.

You can't equate JSO with the EDL. The EDL are racist white-supremacist thugs.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 12:58

TumbleFryer · 08/11/2022 12:49

I disagree. If the activists weren’t doing those things the media wouldn’t pay them any attention at all. I expect a lot of people though the suffragettes were lunatics at the time. But what they did worked.

We need to do whatever we can to draw attention to the issue. Most people are happily just burying their heads in the sand.

We will have to agree to disagree about whether their tactics are working. You think it's getting media attention. I think it's encouraging people to dismiss them as extremists who are just out to cause trouble.

We are both concerned about people burying their heads in the sand about this issue. You think that the extreme protests will wake people up to what's happening. I think they will just give people an excuse to dismiss the activists as extremists and to bury their heads in the sand further.

Popgoestheweaselagain · 08/11/2022 12:57

medicellen · 08/11/2022 09:53

@LemonTT - the action I am suggesting is non-violent civil disobedience. This is the same approach advocated by MLK, which also involved roads blocks and the breaking of the law

Yes, but what would this non-violent civil disobedience look like?

The thing about the Civil Rights movement was that a minority were being seriously disadvantaged by discriminatory laws and so they said 'we're going to disrupt the lives of the majority until we get treated equally'. The public perception of ER is that a minority of relatively well-off and socially advantaged people (scientists for example) are disrupting the lives of ordinary people over a problem that ordinary people aren't responsible for creating and that is affecting all of us (not just the minority protesting) - it's a whole different look. I don't think you can employ the same tactics.

TheSomersetGimp · 08/11/2022 12:55

TumbleFryer · 08/11/2022 12:49

I disagree. If the activists weren’t doing those things the media wouldn’t pay them any attention at all. I expect a lot of people though the suffragettes were lunatics at the time. But what they did worked.

We need to do whatever we can to draw attention to the issue. Most people are happily just burying their heads in the sand.

It's not getting people on side though is it. And plenty of us do care about climate change. But really this insane behaviour will make people turn their backs. Climate change has been on the agenda long before the just stop oil brats got on the scene.

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 12:53

Igneococcus · 08/11/2022 12:09

You could write a rebuttal letter to Nature Physics where this was published in August 2022 and point out where Murphy goes all wrong @Daftasabroom

It's a maths game, he assumes that the increase in energy use by mankind will continue along the same trajectory it has for the last few thousand years and that at some point that energy demand will be more than all the energy available in the galaxy.

To quote: The purpose of this exploration is to point out the absurdity that results from the assumption that we can continue growing our use of energy

Nobody, but nobody is suggesting we increase our use of energy indefinitely.

This is one of the real issues we face with the media and reporting of climate change, a hypothetical piece of maths fun can be interpreted by some as a statement of science fact. And this is true on both sides.

And you bought into the absurdity as fact.

TumbleFryer · 08/11/2022 12:49

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 12:41

Indeed!

The thing is, activists chucking soup at paintings, pouring milk all over the floor and glueing themselves to the road are not going to persuade ordinary people to make changes in their own lives, nor to vote for politicians who will be brave enough to legislate for those changes. The activists just make themselves look like nutters tbh, and they weaken the very argument that they are trying to make.

I disagree. If the activists weren’t doing those things the media wouldn’t pay them any attention at all. I expect a lot of people though the suffragettes were lunatics at the time. But what they did worked.

We need to do whatever we can to draw attention to the issue. Most people are happily just burying their heads in the sand.

MrsKeats · 08/11/2022 12:48

Agree about the stupid 4x4 thing.
They should be massively taxed and the money put towards green initiatives.
Unless you have a good reason to have one.

TumbleFryer · 08/11/2022 12:45

GloomyDarkness · 08/11/2022 12:33

I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

What effect do you think this will have?

I personally would have thought it would have zero effect - as people are fully aware of the problem but feel either powerless or confused about what they can do to help as there is so much green washing out there.

I would have thought it would massively adversely affect your 8 year old son - especially if it did lead to prison.

I think a lot of these protests are just pissing people off and making more people feel powerless and switch off or makes it easier to put in nut case fringe folder and forget or dispute as they hate the protestors.

I completely disagree that most people are fully aware of the problem.

OP, if you can do this without risking your career then go for it. I wish I could join you.

GloomyDarkness · 08/11/2022 12:44

We don't drive - we live in city so it was manageable but recent train and local bus strikes have massively affected us - price increases post covid and disruption services do mean I wonder if we will have to drive at some point.

I have to admit I eye rolled when a "green journalist living in London claimed he couldn't manage without car because he had a grown son and a cat.

I live in a city with much less well subsidized and extensive public transport - in fact several locations - we manged with work children and cats not to drive.

He also mention two flight holidays in one year - and then lectured about CO2 emissions - I haven't been on a plane in 20 years.

Better public transport - road changes to make cycling safer - I could get behind but only party here last election talking about that was Tories - not even the green candidate was.

CatJumperTwat · 08/11/2022 12:43

the Brexit decision was influenced by a media and politicians with vested interests who deployed frank lies to the public. I dont think it is because they are incapable of making a sensible decision

So not only do you admit that green measures are untenably unpopular with the voting public, but also that the voting public is unable to critically evaluate what they're told by people with vested interests. And yet you believe the solution to climate change is to let an assembly of the voting public make the decisions. Can you explain how that works?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 12:41

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 12:34

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I agree people will not make changes. They won't even make small changes like buy a smaller car. Everyone with a large 4x4 insists they need it.

Indeed!

The thing is, activists chucking soup at paintings, pouring milk all over the floor and glueing themselves to the road are not going to persuade ordinary people to make changes in their own lives, nor to vote for politicians who will be brave enough to legislate for those changes. The activists just make themselves look like nutters tbh, and they weaken the very argument that they are trying to make.

2bazookas · 08/11/2022 12:39

Back in my protest days , we were very carefully trained in the difference between legal protest, and behaviour that risked or invited arrest. Plus, our legal rights when arrested.

MrsKeats · 08/11/2022 12:36

And gluing yourself to a Van Gogh etc is going to help how exactly?
If anything it's turning people away from helping.
Blocking ambulances? Despicable.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 12:34

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I agree people will not make changes. They won't even make small changes like buy a smaller car. Everyone with a large 4x4 insists they need it.

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:33

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:31

I see two narratives in this thread:

We are years away from a disaster

We are decades away from the impact from any measures

See the problem?

Yes, this is how I see it too.

BUT, mitigating against the impacts of climate change while also reducing emissions means we may be better prepared to deal with the 'disaster' and we also prevent it getting worse in the future.

At no point will throwing soup at a painting help (imo) but there you are

GloomyDarkness · 08/11/2022 12:33

I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

What effect do you think this will have?

I personally would have thought it would have zero effect - as people are fully aware of the problem but feel either powerless or confused about what they can do to help as there is so much green washing out there.

I would have thought it would massively adversely affect your 8 year old son - especially if it did lead to prison.

I think a lot of these protests are just pissing people off and making more people feel powerless and switch off or makes it easier to put in nut case fringe folder and forget or dispute as they hate the protestors.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 12:33

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 12:24

I find the arguments that direct action is "necessary" because political action "doesn't work" rather weak.

The only reason political action doesn't work is that activists are not able to convince the majority of people to vote for parties that support their aims. Leaving aside the point that disruptive action puts people off supporting groups like XR, IB or JST, why are the organisers of these groups so incapable of persuading the public through peaceful, polite dialogue?

The biggest reason is surely that they know they don't have the answers themselves - they think something is wrong but don't have the practical answers as to how to solve things.

It's not good enough to demand change if you can't explain how that change should come about.

Just Stop Oil are basically the same as the English Defence League and other similar groups. They have an end aim but no idea as to how to get there, in practical terms, in a way that "normal" people can get on board with. Therefore the public just think of them as troublemaking idiots.

Well said.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 12:32

The climate emergency is now. The impact is now. It will get worse.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 12:31

medicellen · 08/11/2022 12:02

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves - the Brexit decision was influenced by a media and politicians with vested interests who deployed frank lies to the public. I dont think it is because they are incapable of making a sensible decision

Nothing is truly objective but a CA would be considerably better than existing structures (parliament) both in terms of representativeness and coming to the fairest possible decisions.

Clearly this is highly complex but there could be immediate CA votes on issues such as:
Ban all private jets
Limit business travel and holiday travel to x number flights per year
Massive taxes on fossil fuel companies and their finances
Heavy green taxes on those who use a disproportionate amount of resoucres

Of course the media and politicians with vested interests influenced the decision on Brexit, but what makes you think that those individuals won't be equally invested in influencing decisions on climate change? Ordinary citizens with jobs and lives to worry about don't typically have the time to immerse themselves in the research and evidence to the extent that they have a detailed understanding of the issues that will enable them to cut through the lies and propaganda promoted by politicians and the media. That's what our elected representatives are paid to do, and we should be pushing them to fulfil this responsibility properly.

I don't understand how a CA would be fairer or more representative. How would its members be appointed? What qualifications would they need? How much time would they have to give? Would they be compensated for this time? How would they be accountable to rest of us?

As for the votes that you propose, we need Parliament to legislate on these issues. A CA vote is meaningless withoutthe legislation to back it up. Also, are we even confident that a representative majority of the population would vote in favour of the changes that we are going to need to make? I'm not convinced that they would tbh. Banning private jets is an easy sell because it will never affect most of us. But would most people support a ban on the meat and dairy industries, I wonder? A one-child policy? Limits on flying? If the majority of people were really committed to making these tough decisions, wouldn't that be reflected in the politicians that they elected to govern us?

I think most people are burying their heads in the sand and hoping that it will go away to be honest. Most will readily agree to taxes on the rich, on big companies etc, but when it comes to making real changes in their own lives...I don't think the majority of people have accepted this yet and I don't think a CA would vote for anything really radical that would impact in any major way on their own lives. Everyone is looking for someone else to fix the problem/foot the bill. That's why the politicians are scared of taking action. I can't see how a CA would change that, personally.

glowtorch · 08/11/2022 12:31

I see two narratives in this thread:

We are years away from a disaster

We are decades away from the impact from any measures

See the problem?

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 12:31

Federal · 08/11/2022 12:15

@antelopevalley how would banning all wood burning stoves and 4x4s help those who don’t live in the city? In the city where there is no need, perhaps, but a blanket ban just wouldn’t work.
we aren’t all on a main road and have a gas line you know!

Do it in stages. Ban all wood-burning stoves where houses also have gas and electric - could do that immediately.
In twelve months ban them for all houses that have close access to gas and electric suppliers.
Two years ban them for all who have houses with electricity.

Two years gives you enough time to sort out an alternative. Any house that does not have electricity is likely to be very remote and it is such a tiny number of houses it does not matter/

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 08/11/2022 12:29

Also, population size alone is not the problem. Already said, but a large family in parts of Africa for example has a smaller carbon footprint than a single, childless westerner (statistically). So there is more to it. But population is an issue

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2022 12:28

Dotjones · 08/11/2022 12:24

I find the arguments that direct action is "necessary" because political action "doesn't work" rather weak.

The only reason political action doesn't work is that activists are not able to convince the majority of people to vote for parties that support their aims. Leaving aside the point that disruptive action puts people off supporting groups like XR, IB or JST, why are the organisers of these groups so incapable of persuading the public through peaceful, polite dialogue?

The biggest reason is surely that they know they don't have the answers themselves - they think something is wrong but don't have the practical answers as to how to solve things.

It's not good enough to demand change if you can't explain how that change should come about.

Just Stop Oil are basically the same as the English Defence League and other similar groups. They have an end aim but no idea as to how to get there, in practical terms, in a way that "normal" people can get on board with. Therefore the public just think of them as troublemaking idiots.

Superb post - I wish I could write like that

Swipe left for the next trending thread