Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
biome · 08/11/2022 14:46

Perhaps you think our politicians are going to save us? They are not. Only protests have brought the situation into focus and will continue to do so. The guardian will write about it but all the right wing media will not. Protesr may be unpopular but will keep climate action on the agenda. We need citizens assemblies with the power to change legislation to guide us out of this situation. www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/nov/07/the-guardian-view-on-rishi-sunaks-cop27-trip-placing-the-planet-on-a-road-to-hell?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 14:45

midgetastic · 08/11/2022 13:19

Sorry

Why isn't it viable to target the super rich as I suggested

Make a public list of everyone rich or famous and list everything that you can find that is carbon intensive with approximate carbon footprint - name and shame

Flights
Food
Heating a large house
Dining out on imported beef
Buying lots of stuff

Estimate for each and every famous person how much more carbon they produce than the average person, how much more they produce than is reasonable

Two problems I can see there for a start - the definitions of 'super rich' and 'reasonable.' Not to mention that your list is a tacit incitement to some idiot taking direct action against some members of the 'super rich' daring to dine out and eat imported beef. And it's probably harassment, as well.

Pompomsfantastix · 08/11/2022 14:42

The ‘mood in the country’ is not changing based on the actions of JSO and ER. It’s based on the tabloid headlines, which in turn is based on/set by people with vested interests in maintaining the status quo, ie Murdoch and his cronies.

People who think small individual actions ‘will all add up’ are deluded. You are p!ssing in the wind.

I have marched but that’s it in terms of protest. I feel I owe it to my kids to get more involved. They will all hate us in 20 years and I want to be able to look mine in the eye and have them believe I cared, and more importantly, tried.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:38

We have lost 70& of invertebrates just in Britain. All those insects, spiders and butterflies are essential for our ecosystem. Their loss is not as high profile as the extinction of large mammals, but it is already causing real issues in this country.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:36

I can't believe some people are still arguing the climate emergency is not real.

biome · 08/11/2022 14:29

The climate chaos that will come unless there is systemic change will overwhelm the NHS. Many healthcare workers are now members of XR because they understand the risks we are facing. Go and find an activist to talk to and check out their lifestyle. You will find them trying to live more sustainably and involved in nature restoration projects but they know that is not enough.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 14:29

I’m glad at least you have spared your son some of these apocalyptic views. You need not be so anxious about the futures. Here’s a great NYT article about how we are actually NOT doomed: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/10/26/magazine/climate-change-warming-world.html

An interesting passage given the Western protests:

The West has always had a problem with millenarianism — the fall, Christianity, all that,” says Tim Sahay, a Mumbai-born climate-policy wonk and co-founder of the new Polycrisis journal. “It’s ineradicable — all we see are the possibilities for doom and gloom.” The challenges are real and large and fall disproportionately on the developing world, he says, but they are not deterministic, or need not be. “We’re riding down the dark mountain,” he says. “That’s scary in ways, of course, but there are also so many possible outcomes. I find it all exciting. What kind of cities will Brazil build? What will Indonesia be?

Personally I am confident that better infrastructure for the developing world will
help reduce loss of life and they need to continue to develop along East Asian lines. Recall that as a country develops the birth rate will fall, too.

You of course will disagree.

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:28

PaperDoves · 08/11/2022 08:38

It didn't work for suffrage and many people at the time considered extremist acts to have delayed the cause. It's just that now we only hear about the crazy things they did and laud them as heroes.

Literally everyone is fully aware of the climate emergency at this point. I understand your frustration. But extreme acts aren't going to effect any change and I can't see why you'd even think so. What would the reasoning be? The government will absolutely never engage with people causing extreme disruption or, worst case, terrorism.

Actually the government did engage with Extinction Rebellion and declared a climate emergency based on their civil disobedience. Can you name some successful campaigns that achieved change on a large scale which didn’t use civil disobedience?

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:22

Onlyforcake · 08/11/2022 08:32

It doesn't matter now. I know the evidence and the pleas suggest otherwise but it's very clear the tipping point is now behind us.

That’s not true actually

oldperson1 · 08/11/2022 14:22

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:48

@girlmom21 - I would arrange childcare for the 24-48hrs associated with arrest

What would happen to your little boy if you were sent to prison for a few months

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:21

Chomolungma · 08/11/2022 08:34

The Just Stop Oil protests are counter productive in my opinion. They annoy so many people (by causing massive delays for drivers) that it turns people against the cause rather than towards it. Even though they are making some valid points, they're not succeeding in winning public support. Politicians won't care until there is public support (as that's what affects votes). They're shooting themselves in the foot IMO.

There’s a distinction between support for the cause and support for the methods. If protest increases support for the cause then that matters to the government, even if the methods are unpopular. There is evidence that extinction rebellion increased public concern about climate change dramatically with their actions.

38thparallel · 08/11/2022 14:19

Flights
Food
Heating a large house
Dining out on imported beef

Buying lots of stuff

Midgetastic how would anyone know if these rich people were dining out on imported beef and buying lots of stuff?

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 14:17

No one has offered a viable alternative strategy to try and mitigate the climate emergency
Neither has ER/JSO. The draw a lot of attention, and they disrupt a lot of ordinary people's lives. But I don't see them putting candidates forward for local or national elections where they could take responsibility for making changes. Particularly at the local level there's a lot of change that could be delivered, and the one thing that previous protest movements have shown is that the demand for change must be created from the ground up.

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:17

Popgoestheweaselagain · 08/11/2022 08:40

It's not clear that it worked for women's suffrage. The chaining themselves to railings approach actually may have actually set the movement back as it made women look a bit hysterical and not the kind of rational, level-headed people you could trust with the vote - jury is out on that one. With Civil Rights, weren't they getting arrested for breaking laws that shouldn't have been there in the first place? There's a really big difference between getting arrested for sitting down in a seat on a bus that you've paid for and blocking the motorway so that people can't get their kids to school or sick relatives to hospital.

A woman from Extinction Rebellion came knocking on my door the other day to ask what my perception was, and I had to be honest. I told her, I know that they block roads and cause problems, I couldn't tell you what their actual message is - not getting it across very well.

The civil rights movement did block highways actually

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:15

The civil rights movement did block highways actually

medicellen · 08/11/2022 14:13

@Popgoestheweaselagain

  1. 75% YABU.
  2. Unfounded along the lines of "you are all middle-class twats", founded - there is likely to be a negative impact on some people
  3. Its not feasible to outline all of the possible NVDA activities - they range from blocking roads, to throwing soup, to breaking windows of big polluters. to spray painting Tufton street. By definition any NVDA will cause disruption to someone, somewhere
OP posts:
carefulcalculator · 08/11/2022 14:12

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:07

Actually the government did engage with extinction rebellion and declared a climate emergency in response to their civil disobedience.

Words are cheap. This particular government is an environmental disaster.

antelopevalley · 08/11/2022 14:10

But the government are doing nothing about practical actions.

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 14:07

Actually the government did engage with extinction rebellion and declared a climate emergency in response to their civil disobedience.

Popgoestheweaselagain · 08/11/2022 14:06

medicellen · 08/11/2022 13:15

The messages I have taken away from the discussion thus far are:

  1. The majority do not support non-violent civil disobedience as a form of protest
  2. The same majority offer a range of founded and unfounded criticisms about protests and protesters
  3. No one has offered a viable alternative strategy to try and mitigate the climate emergency
  1. We haven't said that. We don't think it's working in this context.
  2. would help if we know which were founded and which were unfounded
  3. we've asked you a number of times to more clearly outline what kind of civil disobedience plans are and what specifically you hope to achieve. You haven't answered us.
Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 14:03

medicellen · 08/11/2022 13:48

@Daftasabroom - I agree with what you think "we" should be doing. But the government are not doing it and have been found to have a legally inadequate strategy to get to net zero. So the how is about how we get them to do what is needed

They are doing it. I am absolutely no fan of the Tories, have never and are very unlikely to ever vote for them but offshore wind is due to increase by 500% in the decade. They are also putting huge sums into R&T.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 13:58

medicellen · 08/11/2022 13:48

@Daftasabroom - I agree with what you think "we" should be doing. But the government are not doing it and have been found to have a legally inadequate strategy to get to net zero. So the how is about how we get them to do what is needed

I agree with this. I just disagree that the methods currently being used by the XR activists are likely to be effective. In fact, I think they're going to have the opposite effect.

Words · 08/11/2022 13:57

Please don't do this. A criminal conviction will follow you forever.

I understand your sense of powerlessness, but with your skills and training there are better and more constructive ways to deploy them, as many posters have suggested upthread.

I also agree with what other people have said that this method of protesting is doing a lot of harm to the cause, and no good that I can see. The strategy needs to change- which is where your training could be of value.

medicellen · 08/11/2022 13:48

@Daftasabroom - I agree with what you think "we" should be doing. But the government are not doing it and have been found to have a legally inadequate strategy to get to net zero. So the how is about how we get them to do what is needed

OP posts:
Meseekslookatme · 08/11/2022 13:40

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:31

@MyLovelyPen - if it worked for suffrage and civil rights, why should be doomed for this cause?

Because it hurts ordinary working people.

Imagine you live paycheck to paycheck and can't get to work for 2 days because of protestors, you get deeper into debt because you aren't paid, maybe even lose your job.
Imagine you've waited a year and a half for a hospital appointment for treatment that may improve your life significantly, you miss that appointment and get put to the end of the queue again.

It's not hurting the people that can actually do something, it's hurting the most needy, the people that can afford it least.

Think about that.

The daft little teens on TV chucking food at things, they are privileged idiots, why the hell should someone on minimum wage look at them and decide now is the time to change?

I'd applaud protests at the houses of Parliament, hardly anything seemed to happen last year at cop26, etc. It's all just hurting the people that struggle the most.

That prick on YouTube on the gantry over the M25 stopping thousands of people getting to work? Pathetic. That pretend weeping that didn't even reach her eyes, whiney little twerp. "We don't want to do this!"
Well do something else then.
It really does drive a hell of a lot of people from the cause. I used to care a lot more until this bunch of middle class fuckwits decided that everyone should "wake up!" And be just as smart as you.