Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To risk arrest for protesting about the climate emergency?

693 replies

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:25

I have recently taken part in climate protests with Extinction Rebellion but have stopped short of activities that would lead to an arrest.

I am a scientist and it has been beyond doubt for some years that the climate emergency is accelerating.

And yet, global carbon emissions continue to increase. Our government is granting new licences for fossil fuels, whilst oil companies rake in massive profits. This is utter madness (aka "collective suicide" according to the lead of the UN).

I have an 8-year old son who says one day he might like to have children. I have avoided saying that this may be either not possible or not desirable due to the state of the climate by then.

Petitions, campaigning, pleas, marches have failed. In my mind, the only option left is civil disobedience. Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 17:07

Weefreetiffany · 08/11/2022 17:05

Can you direct it at the actual rich people who are capable to change policy and companies and who use private jets? Not everyday people on their way to hospital or to work who will end up emoting more carbon fumes sitting in the traffic Jams the disruption creates.

i can life with paper straws but how many coal plants are being created per year and does blocking the m25 really stop that?

Where are the protests for sustainable energy or a decision on a nuclear power station?

Its just petulant 'we don't like this' without grown up solutions that aren't going to devastate us economy and leave us even more at the mercy of a global elite.

Galaktoboureko · 08/11/2022 17:07

Mass arrests advanced the causes of suffrage and civil rights and I am now contemplating arrest as the only meaningful contribution I have left.

It wasn't really the suffragettes so much as the war effort. Many other countries already allowed women to vote and we were seen as a bit behind the times. Women got the vote at the same time as most men (previously only war veterans and land owners could vote).

Weefreetiffany · 08/11/2022 17:05

Can you direct it at the actual rich people who are capable to change policy and companies and who use private jets? Not everyday people on their way to hospital or to work who will end up emoting more carbon fumes sitting in the traffic Jams the disruption creates.

i can life with paper straws but how many coal plants are being created per year and does blocking the m25 really stop that?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 16:59

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 16:48

Sure:

Thackeray et al. 2020. Civil disobedience movements such as School Strike for the Climate are raising public awareness of the climate change emergency. Global Change Biology. DOI: 10.1111/gcb.14978

I know correlation doesn’t equal causation, but obviously you can’t create a randomised controlled trial for this. When you have consistent spikes in public awareness in correlation with protests without an alternative explanation, I think that’s as good evidence as you’re going to get. Perhaps I should have said awareness rather than concern.

Sorry, I might not have made myself clear. I am definitely not saying that protest never works. I thought that was clear from my earlier posts but you may not have read them or connected them with me. My issue is with the type of protest that XR is using and to my perception that they are alienating people rather than promoting their cause.

The reference you have provided looks like it relates to the school strikes rather than to the kind of tactics that XR is using? I think the voices of young people like Greta Thunberg and others have been incredibly powerful and certainly encourage people to think about the issues, not least becausewe all know that the younger generation are the ones who are going to have to face the impact of all this. Throwing soup at paintings, pouring milk on the supermarket floor and glueing people to roads is a bit different, though. Do you have any evidence that those types of protest in particular are effective in changing public views? I'm talking specifically about the types of protest where people are essentially engaging in antisocial behaviour in order to draw attention to their message, rather than the school strikers who were not going to school buy not causing trouble either.

Meseekslookatme · 08/11/2022 16:58

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 16:52

Much of China's emissions are directly attributable to products manufactured and sold to the west. It's basically massively hypocritical unless you stop buying Chinese made products

This really is overstating things, and even in the export-led sector, a lot of those goods are going to Asia, the Middle East and Latin America.

I work in manufacturing.
It is absolutely impossible to boycott China, you simply can't get some components without going to China.
We've brought as much back local as we can and are very proud of that, but we risk losing custom thanks to pricing and lack of parts.
China are too powerful globally, but that's another issue altogether.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 16:57

Making people poorer, giving them fewer choices, forcing them to share wealth and resources fairly on a global scale and reduce their standard of living? Not going to happen in a democracy

👆this is their goal. Eco-extremists want to make you poorer and engineer a drop in your living standards.

Doubtful that they’d make any difference in the developing world either, only thing that has ever elevated the common person is a robust industrialisation policy, as in East Asia.

Sixpence1977 · 08/11/2022 16:55

The best thing anyone can do is not have children and buy as little as possible and travel as little as possible. Just go without. Everything else is just pissing in the wind really. Can hardly have a global cull Logan’s run style but that’s the real problem there are just too many of us that live too well.

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 16:55

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 16:52

Much of China's emissions are directly attributable to products manufactured and sold to the west. It's basically massively hypocritical unless you stop buying Chinese made products

This really is overstating things, and even in the export-led sector, a lot of those goods are going to Asia, the Middle East and Latin America.

I agree but it wouldnt hurt to 'ban the plastic tat' each Christmas and for birthdays tbh on a voluntary basis.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 16:52

Much of China's emissions are directly attributable to products manufactured and sold to the west. It's basically massively hypocritical unless you stop buying Chinese made products

This really is overstating things, and even in the export-led sector, a lot of those goods are going to Asia, the Middle East and Latin America.

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 16:51

Pompomsfantastix · 08/11/2022 14:47

We need a carbon tax for starters. Why don’t we have one already?

We've had carbon taxes for over 15 years. Have you not been paying attention?

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 16:49

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 16:37

Ban all wood-burning stoves where houses also have gas and electric - could do that immediately

Are there going to be special hit squads kicking down people's doors to check their heating arrangements?

Would give the Wah Wah Wah crew their fix and have them doing something practical I guess.

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 16:48

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 16:27

I'd be happy to reevaluate if I had actually seen any evidence but I haven't.

Correlation doesn't equal causation. XR have stepped up their protests in recent years as the impact of climate change has become increasingly clear. Public concern has increased in the same period, but I haven't seen any evidence to support the idea that public concern has increased in response to the protests rather than in response to the overwhelming evidence that is actually out there. Could you point me towards this evidence, please?

Sure:

Thackeray et al. 2020. Civil disobedience movements such as School Strike for the Climate are raising public awareness of the climate change emergency. Global Change Biology. DOI: 10.1111/gcb.14978

I know correlation doesn’t equal causation, but obviously you can’t create a randomised controlled trial for this. When you have consistent spikes in public awareness in correlation with protests without an alternative explanation, I think that’s as good evidence as you’re going to get. Perhaps I should have said awareness rather than concern.

Chocchops72 · 08/11/2022 16:48

OP

i admire your efforts, and those of the other demonstrators.

We already know what needs to be done: what politicians don’t know is how to get re-elected once they’ve done it - so they won’t do it. Making people poorer, giving them fewer choices, forcing them to share wealth and resources fairly on a global scale and reduce their standard of living? Not going to happen in a democracy. Look at the posters on here, thinking that bamboo toothbrushes and other small voluntary measures will maker even the slightest difference? Humans aren’t good at big-scale thinking, or indeed caring too much about the distant future. We focus on our tribe and on what’s happening now.

neither human nature nor our political systems are capable of forcing through the huge social, economic and cultural changes that are needed on a global scale - and certainly not in the timescale that we currently face.

I have a science background: we were studying these issues in 1992 when the first Rio conference happened: nothing has changed since then - if anything things are much worse and much more urgent.

So campaign if you must. I would love to hope that you all can break through. But I don’t think it’s going to happen.

RedToothBrush · 08/11/2022 16:47

I think one of my biggest problems with XR is the attitude.

The attitude that they are morally superior and that anyone who thinks they are a bunch of bellends isn't interested in the environment.

The Wah Wah Wahing is alienating.

I think we should be chucking a shedload into sustainable energy, to build up our sector and take the lead in it, because there is money in whoever does it first.

That means jobs and it means security and it means it benefits public pockets in the long run. It reduces reliance on fossil fuels so you don't have to cut back on them. In the long run they naturally become economically unviable. And thats the thing.

Make it hit a tipping point where fossil fuels aren't worth buying!

As i say, it's viable especially given this winter and the politic changes it makes (which are driving public concern far more than trespassing muppets).

I completely echo MrsBennetsPoorNerves comments above.

Make it affordable to switch because that's one of the biggest rubs. People are limited by what they can afford and if they are parents they are often limited by the time they have to run away doing all the jobs they need to.

Indirect policies like like greater on site child care at work would have a bigger impact than many other things like total bans.

Why?

Because it would reduce the number and length of journeys people have to make. Public transport doesn't work for working parents (particularly women) with kids because they multi stop to child care and then to work. This would improve quality of life for parents.

Equally up money for training in installation of things like solar panels and insulation. Change planning law to insist on charging points and solar panels especially on council owned buildings (Inc non residential).

Genuinely have some policies that relate to day to day lived experiences and problems and give a green solution to them.

People would soon get on board.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 16:37

Ban all wood-burning stoves where houses also have gas and electric - could do that immediately

Are there going to be special hit squads kicking down people's doors to check their heating arrangements?

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 16:30

Federal · 08/11/2022 16:27

Do it in stages. Ban all wood-burning stoves where houses also have gas and electric - could do that immediately.
In twelve months ban them for all houses that have close access to gas and electric suppliers.
Two years ban them for all who have houses with electricity.

Two years gives you enough time to sort out an alternative.

@antelopevalley yeah forcing rural folk to buy electric radiators whilst China/India/Russia push out tonnes of crap and people fly on their private jets. Great idea! 😫

Wood burning from sustainable sources is climate neutral.

Some of the utter tosh posted is unbelievable.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 16:30

In fact, I would argue that the protests are a symptom of growing public concern rather than the cause of it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 08/11/2022 16:27

Burningsky · 08/11/2022 15:58

It’s just a fact that public concern about climate change consistently increased in response to Extinction Rebellion actions, it’s got nothing to do with being patronising. Now that you know that will you change your mind in response to evidence? It’s actually very deluded to think that public opinion just follows facts rather than being influenced by things that grab people’s attention. The science on climate change has been clear for about 50 years, why is it people weren’t more concerned before? Because of oil company and right wing media propaganda.

I'd be happy to reevaluate if I had actually seen any evidence but I haven't.

Correlation doesn't equal causation. XR have stepped up their protests in recent years as the impact of climate change has become increasingly clear. Public concern has increased in the same period, but I haven't seen any evidence to support the idea that public concern has increased in response to the protests rather than in response to the overwhelming evidence that is actually out there. Could you point me towards this evidence, please?

Federal · 08/11/2022 16:27

Do it in stages. Ban all wood-burning stoves where houses also have gas and electric - could do that immediately.
In twelve months ban them for all houses that have close access to gas and electric suppliers.
Two years ban them for all who have houses with electricity.

Two years gives you enough time to sort out an alternative.

@antelopevalley yeah forcing rural folk to buy electric radiators whilst China/India/Russia push out tonnes of crap and people fly on their private jets. Great idea! 😫

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 16:15

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 16:08

The problem is that annoying the ordinary person on the street in the U.K. will not make any difference to your cause. You need to basically go to places like China and get them to shut down their huge power stations to actually make a difference (but I guess that’s too difficult/politically incorrect, so you’ll just keep irritating people here for no reason).

Much of China's emissions are directly attributable to products manufactured and sold to the west. It's basically massively hypocritical unless you stop buying Chinese made products.

BerriesOnTop · 08/11/2022 16:14

Its so hard being a parent at this time and worrying about the future our children will have to face

They are among the luckiest generation of humans to be born. Life used to be a misery and very difficult for the common person. Fossil fuels spread comfort and wealth that a rich person 200 years ago could not even contemplate.

And also to be aware of the horrors that mothers in the global south are already dealing with. I saw a doctor on TV recently talking about having to tell a mother her child had died due to climate related famine. Just awful

Were you born yesterday? Famine was a fact of life for many around the globe until recently. Deaths due to famines have dropped precipitously since records have been kept, despite the huge jumps in population: ourworldindata.org/famines

Daftasabroom · 08/11/2022 16:12

medicellen · 08/11/2022 16:03

@Alexandernevermind - I haven't replied because I haven't seen any. We cannot tech our way out of this, our current political system is not fit for purpose, personal lifestyle choices are insufficient, small local activities help locally but do not change the coming impacts of the climate emergency. Our only chance is major systematic reform delivered by government and they are not doing it, as evidence by a recent case taken against them

With all due respect I've offered positive suggestions of things every individual can do and links to government initiatives. You might do well to read your own thread.

jtaeapa · 08/11/2022 16:09

OP: seeing the actions of extremists makes me so angry, to the extent that I want to come home, turn on all my gas hobs and just let them burn all evening for the sake of it. And then chuck all my recycling in landfill. You need to understand that severely pissing people off and messing with their essential activities such as getting to school/hospital/work doesn’t help the climate emergency. It actually hinders it - it’s not even a neutral action - it is an extremely provocative action that has negative consequences for the cause.

FrippEnos · 08/11/2022 16:09

medicellen · 08/11/2022 08:31

@MyLovelyPen - if it worked for suffrage and civil rights, why should be doomed for this cause?

It didn't work for suffrage if you read up on it it harmed the cause more than promoted.

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 16:08

The problem is that annoying the ordinary person on the street in the U.K. will not make any difference to your cause. You need to basically go to places like China and get them to shut down their huge power stations to actually make a difference (but I guess that’s too difficult/politically incorrect, so you’ll just keep irritating people here for no reason).