Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question WhatsApp group on personal phone for work?

79 replies

Diedre44 · 07/11/2022 22:40

WFH permanently small team Customer Service for local government housing association. Got an email from manager today stating for business continuity and case of emergency everyone needs to be contactable and if don't already have it please download WhatsApp and let us know when you have so we can create a WhatsApp group.
I'm just confused as to why we are being "told" to do something on our own personal phones. I do not use my personal phone for work. I am contactable by telephone, I'm available on teams whilst working, email etc.
My manager knows I have WhatsApp already, we speak outside of work on occasion. I just find this strange all of a sudden.
I don't know how to approach it with them as don't want to seem to have an issue. Surely if it is needed as a "needs of business" issue they should provide a work phone.
AIBU to be sceptical?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
parsniiips · 10/11/2022 16:21

It depends what their intentions are.

If it's for one off emergency messages once in a blue moon that you would actually be grateful to receive then I can't get worked up about it. Such as if the phone lines are down, server is down etc and instructions on what to do or to keep you updated.

If they are going to be firing messages left right and centre about things that aren't important and could be sent via work email or teams then I'd just be honest and say you prefer to keep work and personal completely separate and would prefer communication vis official work channels.

You can hide your online status too if you wanted to switch it off during working hours so nobody can see if you are online.

LadyHarmby · 10/11/2022 16:14

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 10/11/2022 15:03

But HR and your boss have your contact details so if there is an emergency they can text or phone you. That’s fine. But a WhatsApp group means they’re expecting you to install an app (OK, one most people already have but the principle of it), and more significantly, make your phone number available to anyone they decide to add to the group.

Ok I accept that. I have seen it from the other side where we have had to contact all of our reports out of hours due to terrorist attacks (we had a policy checking on everyone who might have been in the vicinity) and it took ages, looking up almost 40 people's personal mobile numbers and contacting each individually. But people have a right not to have their personal phone numbers made available to others if they don't want to.

In our firm, there was a cascade as someone mentioned above. So the text went to the directors, who sent it to the senior managers that report to them, who sent it to their direct reports, who sent it to their teams and so on. How well that works depends on the size of the business and the hierarchy I guess - sounds like it wouldn’t work as well in your place. But as a general thing, all businesses should have some type of contingency plan in place, one that doesn’t depend on WhatsApp groups on personal phones.

TealAndTurquoise · 10/11/2022 15:09

We have one on our personal phones as not everyone has a work mobile. It's only used for business continuity although people working at home occasionally post to say their broadband has gone down and that sort of thing. No one abuses it as the purpose was made clear at the outset and I hardly get any messages. I've got the option of muting or leaving if I get fed up with it.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 10/11/2022 15:03

But HR and your boss have your contact details so if there is an emergency they can text or phone you. That’s fine. But a WhatsApp group means they’re expecting you to install an app (OK, one most people already have but the principle of it), and more significantly, make your phone number available to anyone they decide to add to the group.

Ok I accept that. I have seen it from the other side where we have had to contact all of our reports out of hours due to terrorist attacks (we had a policy checking on everyone who might have been in the vicinity) and it took ages, looking up almost 40 people's personal mobile numbers and contacting each individually. But people have a right not to have their personal phone numbers made available to others if they don't want to.

DappledThings · 10/11/2022 14:59

I have a WA with my direct reports. It is literally there for business continuity as yours has been recommended. As we haven't had a BC situation since it was established it's never been used. No big deal in the least.

There is also a phone tree established so if there is a BC situation I will get a call from my manager and will call my 2 reports. They will cascade down too.

If they really mean it's for BC then you aren't going to be getting any messages via it other than in an emergency. Don't get the big deal.

Whatafustercluck · 10/11/2022 14:45

Security policy states we can't have WhatsApp on our work phones. My team has an urgent group on our personal mobiles - I didn't 'expect' this of them, it was by mutual agreement. But we work in communications and urgent contact outside of 9-5 is sometimes necessary. I can't expect them to carry their work phones around with them 24/7.

Your work cannot and should not 'expect' it though.

LadyHarmby · 10/11/2022 14:44

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 16:53

I think that they need to supply a work mobile which you can use during work hours & switch off at the end of the working day.

This would be a fair comment if they were wanting you to be contactable on the phone on a daily basis. But they have said it's only for business continuity/emergency use. If that is genuinely the case then I can't understand why you have an issue with it.
If it starts to become the regular way of expecting you to be contactable, or they start contacting you without good reason out of hours, then it's fair enough to expect a work phone to be provided. . From what they have said it will be used for, you can't expect them to provide a phone. If you are going to refuse to hand over your personal phone details, then be prepared to suggest an alternative that is as effective and efficient .

But HR and your boss have your contact details so if there is an emergency they can text or phone you. That’s fine. But a WhatsApp group means they’re expecting you to install an app (OK, one most people already have but the principle of it), and more significantly, make your phone number available to anyone they decide to add to the group.

LadyHarmby · 10/11/2022 14:38

We have work phones and are told very firmly to keep everything separate. They said if we downloaded any apps that we use for work onto our personal phones, such as MFA, they could (in theory) wipe the personal phone in order to protect company security in the event of a breach.

BrokenWing · 09/11/2022 11:40

CottonSock · 08/11/2022 17:39

Yeah I refused to give my personal number for business continuity messages. Eventually our company realised it was an invasion of privacy and relented. I opted in to start with but really didn't need to know covid had closed an office 5 hours away on my day off.

They need a better business continuity system. Ours is a global system but very targeted. We get an bi-annual test which we are prewarned about and is sent during working hours. In 10 years any messages have always been relevant to me and saved me a few 40 mile round trips when the office has been shut.

Think ours is a software called Everbridge.

RedRiverShore2 · 08/11/2022 17:42

We had a WhatsApp group at work, I wasn't on it, I don't use WhatsApp for my personal use so I certainly wasn't going to use it for work on my personal phone, they just had to contact me via email for anything important work related, which wasn't very often.

CottonSock · 08/11/2022 17:39

Yeah I refused to give my personal number for business continuity messages. Eventually our company realised it was an invasion of privacy and relented. I opted in to start with but really didn't need to know covid had closed an office 5 hours away on my day off.

Womencanlift · 08/11/2022 17:36

Meh I couldn’t get worked up about it. I have been contacted on my personal phone for business continuity purposes for years, way before WhatsApp was a thing.

I particular remember the phone call saying the building is flooded, don’t come in just as I was about to get into the shower. That was sweet, free day off so straight back to bed. I would have been seriously pissed if I had got ready, drove to work to find it was closed

These days such chats are usually “I can’t get logged in, does anyone have the IT help desk number” or “trains are running late I will be in at 9.30”. I mute all group chats anyway so having this one muted too is no big deal. They were more active during lockdown but that’s stopped now. Even then it didn’t bother me

Sniffypete · 08/11/2022 17:33

LaBellina · 07/11/2022 23:00

I would consider this a big violation of my personal privacy and I think from a legal point of view, it is. Anyone in this group can see your personal phone number once you join it. If they want you to join a work what’s app group they can provide you with a work phone.

I agree. There are some people that I don't want having my personal phone number and a group chat means that they would have my number.

I was asked to install an app to authenticate login on work systems and I refused as I don't want any third-party app on my phone that wanted access to microphone, camera etc as well as tracking that my employer could potentially see. I said that if they want me to do that they need to provide a device. They soon found another method!

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 08/11/2022 16:53

I think that they need to supply a work mobile which you can use during work hours & switch off at the end of the working day.

This would be a fair comment if they were wanting you to be contactable on the phone on a daily basis. But they have said it's only for business continuity/emergency use. If that is genuinely the case then I can't understand why you have an issue with it.
If it starts to become the regular way of expecting you to be contactable, or they start contacting you without good reason out of hours, then it's fair enough to expect a work phone to be provided. . From what they have said it will be used for, you can't expect them to provide a phone. If you are going to refuse to hand over your personal phone details, then be prepared to suggest an alternative that is as effective and efficient .

thehorsehasnowbolted · 08/11/2022 16:35

I've never understood why people seem to restrict Whatsapp to non-work communications only. Is it because of the 'status' that often contains personal pictures, etc?

XAQ · 08/11/2022 16:16

We use WA daily in my team. People aren't forced to join and its perfectly okay for them not too. Many of them mute the group and don't look until they are back in work (shift work). My team doesn't have work computers/phones.

We don't use it for jokes or general chat. It's mostly used for offering extra shifts, giving phone numbers for team meetings, sharing the rota or passing on messages.

I just received a call from someone who had called work (I'm working from home - manager so do have a laptop) and couldn't get through. WhatsApp'ed the group and asked worker to call the person. They check phones more regularly than the desk top computers.

Halstead · 08/11/2022 16:11

I’ve worked in an organisation that encountered a cyber attack a few years ago.

Access to all our systems went down. Email, teams, authentication required to access work mobiles. Everything.

If it’s only for use in circumstances like that, it seems a sensible BCP measure to me.

londongals · 08/11/2022 16:08

My company has a group
I am not on it
If anyone really needs to contact me when I am at home or with friends they can call

twinmum2022 · 08/11/2022 16:06

I think I'd clarify it'll only be used during working hours. They already have your number so I don't know why they'd need to set up a group - personally I wouldn't want to be in it but that's because I know I'd be contacted at anytime day or night.

Context of the group will be key - is it emergency use only? Or just ANOTHER way of communicating because if it's the latter I'd be less inclined.

Princessglittery · 08/11/2022 16:02

FleshLiabilities · 08/11/2022 14:34

I find this interesting as my employer is requiring us to install an app on our personal mobile devices to enable two factor authentication. Without the app we won't be able to access our work systems. This seems a little out of the ordinary and I'm wondering if it's even legal.

I have had this in a previous employment. I chose not to have a work phone so agreed to it on my personal phone. 2 factor authorisation is very common.

IANAL but I think you can refuse on your personal phone doe to data collection aspects. Ask for a work phone.

FleshLiabilities · 08/11/2022 14:34

I find this interesting as my employer is requiring us to install an app on our personal mobile devices to enable two factor authentication. Without the app we won't be able to access our work systems. This seems a little out of the ordinary and I'm wondering if it's even legal.

AriettyHomily · 08/11/2022 12:32

I'm in a WhatsApp personal phone group with my team but out of choice, it's used for what we want to say but done want on work mobile / teams records.

I wouldn't be in a company wide or bigger group on my personal phone.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 08/11/2022 11:24

We have a work WhatsApp group that most people use their personal phones for. It is used exclusively for the following
Train is cancelled I’ll be in at half 9
Do we need milk.

that’s literally it. Can’t get mad about it

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 08/11/2022 11:22

Speedweed · 07/11/2022 23:06

I find work related whatsapp groups are only for bullying and harrassment. I wouldn't join, if they want to contact me they can either provide a suitable work phone or if it's an emergency, get my personal details from HR and call me.

It’s a shame you’ve had a bad experience, but I don’t think this the norm for most people in work related WhatsApp groups.

Personally, I prefer to avoid all WhatsApp groups whether they are personal or professional. I just don’t like them, but never once felt bullied or harassed whenever I have been in them.

LadyHarmby · 08/11/2022 10:01

I wouldn’t agree to this. I don’t want my colleagues to have my personal phone number, there’s no need for it. My boss can get it from HR in the event of an emergency, which has happened once in four years.