Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "can't" do 50/50 shared care then they shouldn't be walking out

115 replies

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:13

I'm talking about the men who walk out on their families whilst the kids are young and then say they can't do shared care because, for example:

He has shacked up with the OW and she doesn't have room for his DC to stay over because she's got loads of her own (and she doesn't want them there anyway)

He is sofa surfing / bunking on a mate or relatives sofa and can't have his DC live there regularly either.

His work schedule isn't compatible with having his DC overnight.

He works nights and isn't awake to collect them from school.

He can't have them at the weekend because he has to work etc etc.

Those are just a few shitty excuses some of these men give, I'm sure many of you can think of more.

I've just been thinking to myself that (in the absence of abuse ofc) if a man "can't" participate in shared care of his DC when he leaves the family home because he has no stable home to bring them to, then he should bloody well make sure he has a stable environment to go before he ups and leaves so he can begin sharing the childcare immediately.

Don't just walk out and leave it all to the mother, you shithouse.

If he's walking out with no long term plan and only somebody else's sofa in sight then he shouldn't be leaving at all until he has his "ducks in a row" IMO.

OK so I'm not suggesting anybody stay in a relationship they don't want to be in but it infuriates me how some men think its acceptable to just up and leave without any intention to continue looking after his own DC.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 07/11/2022 23:01

@AnneLovesGilbert hi...I'm absolutely what you describe. I'd happily forego maintenance and the relentless drain of single parenting 24/7 alongside a full time job for a 50/50 arrangement. A lot of the single, professional mums I know feel the same, contrary to what's been said here. On a more wholesome note, I'd love for my kids to have a closer relationship with their dad and not to feel like he chose his life with ow over them, which is what he did when he pissed off and dumped all the parenting of preschool age kids onto me 28/30 days. It never seemed to occur to him that he couldn't do that, just upped and did it. Now for the princely of 18 or 20% of his salary he gets to basically act like they don't exist most of the time. With a number of caveats, I agree with the OP.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/11/2022 23:00

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:55

I'm going to have to throw out a MN favourite, she knew what she was getting into when she entered into a relationship with a man who has children.

The children are part of the package when you take on the man, or should be.

Nope. They are his responsibility.

SheilaWilcox · 07/11/2022 22:58

If my husband left, I'd have so much less to do, I wouldn't give a monkeys what his living situation was. Quite capable of giving my daughter what she needs without him.

JessesMum777888 · 07/11/2022 22:57

Coffeaddict · 07/11/2022 22:33

This.

DPs ex had an affair and left with her bit on the side while DP was at work. She went to live with him and immediately had DSS ( 2 at the time) calling new man daddy.

DP had to fight to get the 40% custody he now has. Alot of women don't want to give up their time with their children, which I can see.

I'm not saying there aren't shit father's out there but there are also plenty of women who don't put the best interest o f their children first.

Yep 👍 x

TokenGinger · 07/11/2022 22:57

I know the angle you're coming from, OP, and I agree.

If DP and I were to split, we've already said how neither of us would move out as it means one of us missing out on DS, and neither of us is prepared to take that hit. His house that we rent out isn't practical for DS's school as it's in a different city, so it'd mean DP missing out of overnights during the week and seeing much less of him, and we've both agreed that neither of us would be prepared to see DS anything less than every single day. We'd have to continue cohabiting and co-parenting.

All theoretical of course as a split isn't even nearly on the cards, but we both feel very strongly about being with DS 100% of the time.

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:56

I don't buy the children are part of the package.

They're his responsibility. Not hers. At all.

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:56

I had to work weekends.

I didn't "have" my kids. They were in childcare or with friends and family.

I fail your test. Basically.

And yet I'm a mum and I was a bloody hard working one.

Nintendonasalspray · 07/11/2022 22:55

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:13

I'm talking about the men who walk out on their families whilst the kids are young and then say they can't do shared care because, for example:

He has shacked up with the OW and she doesn't have room for his DC to stay over because she's got loads of her own (and she doesn't want them there anyway)

He is sofa surfing / bunking on a mate or relatives sofa and can't have his DC live there regularly either.

His work schedule isn't compatible with having his DC overnight.

He works nights and isn't awake to collect them from school.

He can't have them at the weekend because he has to work etc etc.

Those are just a few shitty excuses some of these men give, I'm sure many of you can think of more.

I've just been thinking to myself that (in the absence of abuse ofc) if a man "can't" participate in shared care of his DC when he leaves the family home because he has no stable home to bring them to, then he should bloody well make sure he has a stable environment to go before he ups and leaves so he can begin sharing the childcare immediately.

Don't just walk out and leave it all to the mother, you shithouse.

If he's walking out with no long term plan and only somebody else's sofa in sight then he shouldn't be leaving at all until he has his "ducks in a row" IMO.

OK so I'm not suggesting anybody stay in a relationship they don't want to be in but it infuriates me how some men think its acceptable to just up and leave without any intention to continue looking after his own DC.

AIBU?

Most leave because they don't want/can't be arsed with the kids. So of course they're not going to bother with that.

This is why I don't understand why people have relationships with men who have kids they don't live with.

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:55

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:44

Also. If he chooses to shack up with any other woman, why is it her issue that HE hasn't considered room for his kids? She will have her house set up that works for her. If he isn't considering his own children that's on him, not her.

I'm going to have to throw out a MN favourite, she knew what she was getting into when she entered into a relationship with a man who has children.

The children are part of the package when you take on the man, or should be.

OP posts:
wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:54

How do they swap the kids if they are working nights? Young children under school age you expect a surgeon or lorry driver to work on no sleep for example?

I used to do weird hours and go to bed when they went to school but that's not possible if they're under compulsory school age.

If they're not doing it when you're together why would you expect that they'd change?

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:52

I never got maintenance so I don't have skin in that particular game.

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:52

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:40

I mean.

If someone works nights, what do you expect them to do? Give up work and claim benefits (but only single person ones obviously because they how would they be entitled to anything for the children?)

No of course they shouldn't give up their job and claim benefits.

Plenty of single parents have to work nights and they make it work because they have to.

OP posts:
forevercooking · 07/11/2022 22:50

I kind of get where you're coming from. I'm separated with two young DC. Ex works lates/night shifts on a completely random pattern. I'd love to have a proper 'every other weekend' schedule for my own sanity but unfortunately that doesn't happen. He does take the children to his (lives with his mother) when he has weekends off and more recently if he has a few days off in the week. Also he will come and stay at my house with them if i need to be somewhere. (For instance I start work one day a week at 7am instead of 9.30 - if he can't have them the night before then he will come here from his night shift at 5am. Shut his eyes on the sofa for a coupes of hours - I go off to work and he gets up with them, gives them breakfast and takes them to school and then goes home to sleep). This only works because we've both worked hard to stay amicable as that's what best for the boys. Also if he's starting really late like 7pm he'll pop over after school and have dinner before he goes to work. We do this because it's what's best for the kids. In an ideal world he would have his set times and I could say join a club or a class and socialise and talk to people (I see the same 3 faces in the office and his and the kids and that's pretty much it as my few friends are also single parents and our schedules rarely match up).

It's hard being away from the children but equally gives me time to recharge and refresh. More than 2 days does start to make me low though but I know they're enjoying time with their dad and his family.

In short - is there ever a right answer?

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:50

Aarohi · 07/11/2022 22:32

If I can rephrase your post (sorry if this is not what you meant): each parent has the responsibility for 50% of the child's parenting, care, and well-being. It there is some reason that cannot happen right away after a split it should be an ongoing top priority.

This sounds much more reasonable than my OP, thank you for rephrasing.

Absolutely this.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 07/11/2022 22:45

Well in this perfect world of Great Great Britain, the departing man could just buy another house or rent another house with some of that spare cash every family has just lying around. We have a crisis here of making money faster than we can spend it, so quite right OP no excuse to leave until you own two houses or can pay rent on two houses.

And jobs are a dime a dozen, no excuse to be working any antisocial hours or weekends whatsoever. Every man planning to leave has no excuse for having a low paid shift job, he’s got to be a CEO and make his own hours of day 10-2 four days a week.

Yes OP, you are quite right 100%. In fact, I’d advise women don’t get pregnant until that second UK home is bought as insurance policy against him deciding to leave one day. Prioritise it over buying a holiday home abroad, it’s not hard. Just good planning and making good life choices.

Rtmhwales · 07/11/2022 22:45

Most of the men I know want 50/50 (and where I live abroad still have to pay maintenance on 50/50) but the mothers refuse. Constantly on here it's stated that it's not in the child's best interest for 50/50. So what's the real solution..?

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:44

Also. If he chooses to shack up with any other woman, why is it her issue that HE hasn't considered room for his kids? She will have her house set up that works for her. If he isn't considering his own children that's on him, not her.

SpinningFloppa · 07/11/2022 22:41

I see posts on here from women who resent their ex having the children every other weekend, sad thing is some women do think they own the children and they are “letting” their ex see them. Post after post from women saying they can’t cope being separated from their kids eow can you imagine them wanting 50/50? I would say the vast majority of women don’t want 50/50 and men that do want 50/50 apparently it’s only so they don’t have to pay maintenance.

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:40

I mean.

If someone works nights, what do you expect them to do? Give up work and claim benefits (but only single person ones obviously because they how would they be entitled to anything for the children?)

SallyAnn32 · 07/11/2022 22:40

I wouldn't want 50/50 but my ex won't even have the kids half the school hols so if all comes down to me. He said he didn't do that when he lived with us so why should he now 🤦🏻‍♀️ his GF walked out on her 3 children and they spend 5/7 days with their dad.

PeekAtYou · 07/11/2022 22:38

Yabu

Sometimes parents need to travel eg lorry drivers or work overnight eg police officers so can't have the kids 50/50. It's unreasonable to expect a world where parents can only work hours that fit with nursery hours.

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/11/2022 22:37

How many mums do you know who’d want 50/50, no maintenance, not getting more than half of any assets there are? Losing half the time with their kids? Having to consider the other parent a proper equal?

If you know lots they’re certainly not hanging around on here. Men who want shared care are usually considered selfish and cheap and the kids described as victims having no real home.

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:37

Also. Is 50/50 best for the kids?

Interviewnamechange · 07/11/2022 22:34

In that case the child benefit would need to be shared and neither of the parents would be entitled to financial support from the government as they both have the same earning opportunities.

WeWantBoo · 07/11/2022 22:34

CaronPoivre · 07/11/2022 22:29

I think it’s less about the equal rights of parents, more about what is best for the children. I can’t believe feeling like an inconvenience or having to constantly swop homes is in their best interests.

I actually very much agree with this.

Ultimately I think in most cases it’s too much disruption for the kids. Shuttled about half the week/month/holidays etc is a lot.

I say this as a child of divorced parents who’s split was probably 70/30.