Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "can't" do 50/50 shared care then they shouldn't be walking out

115 replies

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:13

I'm talking about the men who walk out on their families whilst the kids are young and then say they can't do shared care because, for example:

He has shacked up with the OW and she doesn't have room for his DC to stay over because she's got loads of her own (and she doesn't want them there anyway)

He is sofa surfing / bunking on a mate or relatives sofa and can't have his DC live there regularly either.

His work schedule isn't compatible with having his DC overnight.

He works nights and isn't awake to collect them from school.

He can't have them at the weekend because he has to work etc etc.

Those are just a few shitty excuses some of these men give, I'm sure many of you can think of more.

I've just been thinking to myself that (in the absence of abuse ofc) if a man "can't" participate in shared care of his DC when he leaves the family home because he has no stable home to bring them to, then he should bloody well make sure he has a stable environment to go before he ups and leaves so he can begin sharing the childcare immediately.

Don't just walk out and leave it all to the mother, you shithouse.

If he's walking out with no long term plan and only somebody else's sofa in sight then he shouldn't be leaving at all until he has his "ducks in a row" IMO.

OK so I'm not suggesting anybody stay in a relationship they don't want to be in but it infuriates me how some men think its acceptable to just up and leave without any intention to continue looking after his own DC.

AIBU?

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 09:49

How many single mothers would cope looking after their children if it wasn't for the benefits they can claim? How many mums say they can't work FT because of caring duties.

Maybe if fathers could claim benefits too, more would be able to provide more care for their kids.

littlepeas · 10/11/2022 09:23

All situations are different. I would be much more angry if my dh left me and then took my kids away from me 50% of the time - I would accept it more easily if it was my choice to leave.

StrawberrySquash · 10/11/2022 09:21

If there's a family home and you aren't selling it and splitting the proceeds then it's going to make having two 'decent' homes more difficult. And lots of people might choose not to to give the kids stability. With the current cost of housing having two homes is going to be difficult whatever; it's just an unfortunate fact of life that it's more efficient to live as a couple. Not a reason to be useless, buying things aren't always that simple.

OhamIreally · 10/11/2022 09:16

PlainBobRob · 08/11/2022 00:19

I truly believe a lot of men don’t get what 50/50 means. My supposedly intelligent ex husband couldn’t wrap his head around that I wasn’t his childcare. It didn’t compute. He still can’t work out that if he needs to be elsewhere on his days (3 nights a month) he needs to get childcare. Instead he just cancels and I am forced to pick up the slack.

Initially he seemed to think that he would have them for 6 months out of 12, so I said ok, so you continue to work full time long hours, so you’ll either have to drop your hours or get wrap around care to do school runs/cover for when you’re away. He was GOBSMACKED. He said how could he possibly do that, that’s insane, it wouldn’t be worth going to work, why couldn’t I have them whilst he worked, etc.

I pointed out it cut both ways and whilst he was being super-dad I could go off and earn buckets contracting and not have to worry about the kids. He said “that’s not fair.”

And what WAS fair in his eyes was that we continued as we had when we were married, which was that I did all the childcare, all the school runs and restricted my career options to fit around the kids so that Johnny Big Bollocks could carry on being a captain of industry. And not pay me maintenance. It was loopy. No understanding whatsoever of reality.

I think this is so true that it literally does not compute with this type of man.

It's the same mindset that leads to them simply getting up and leaving for work in the morning with no consideration for the school or nursery run.

Same mindset that allows them to feel entitled to go to the pub/gym/golf course or play football all day and just assume the mother will care for the children (if they think about it at all).

My ex is OUTRAGED that I split the holidays as to what is most convenient for me. Says it's not fair etc. Doesn't enter his head that it might not be fair that I've done all the school runs, all the cooking and laundry and homework alone, with no opportunity to go to the gym, or adult social events or an evening class for years.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 08/11/2022 07:31

Not all single parents get benefits. I work the same job as my ex, exactly the same, but have to juggle it with the kids and the childcare bill, when they were younger, fell to me. Some of that was covered by CTC but not all of it. I don't get help with housing or anything else beyond CB which again, I'd be happy to share in return for his time with them.

As others have said, it's not just number of overnights either..unless they also take on full responsibility for the mental load stuff on their time, it's just babysitting. If it still falls to the mum to remember kit, costumes, school email responses etc, that's not 50/50.

PlainBobRob · 08/11/2022 00:19

I truly believe a lot of men don’t get what 50/50 means. My supposedly intelligent ex husband couldn’t wrap his head around that I wasn’t his childcare. It didn’t compute. He still can’t work out that if he needs to be elsewhere on his days (3 nights a month) he needs to get childcare. Instead he just cancels and I am forced to pick up the slack.

Initially he seemed to think that he would have them for 6 months out of 12, so I said ok, so you continue to work full time long hours, so you’ll either have to drop your hours or get wrap around care to do school runs/cover for when you’re away. He was GOBSMACKED. He said how could he possibly do that, that’s insane, it wouldn’t be worth going to work, why couldn’t I have them whilst he worked, etc.

I pointed out it cut both ways and whilst he was being super-dad I could go off and earn buckets contracting and not have to worry about the kids. He said “that’s not fair.”

And what WAS fair in his eyes was that we continued as we had when we were married, which was that I did all the childcare, all the school runs and restricted my career options to fit around the kids so that Johnny Big Bollocks could carry on being a captain of industry. And not pay me maintenance. It was loopy. No understanding whatsoever of reality.

Changemaname1 · 08/11/2022 00:09

I take your point op totally see what you mean men who leave then assume the woman will do the majority and they will see the kids when they are free

in saying that I’d have been gutted to have not seen the dc for half the week when they were that little . We do more like 70/30 split now and that works well for me . Best of both worlds

shieldmaiden7 · 07/11/2022 23:46

@Klinec its been a bumpy road, they were assigned a family support worker from the local council to help them understand his behaviour as the couple of months leading up to his departure she was emotionally abusive to the children and on the odd occasion physically too. My 16 year old DS got kicked out of school due to rebelling against the situation and took vodka of his dads into school to get his attention and got caught with it and thanks to her barricading my 9 year old in a room with her until he admitted he was autistic had huge anxiety and separation issues after.
This year things have improved a lot. He's not really in contact with them. He won't reach out as, and I quote "they expect replies to quickly" so we have settled into our own life. Paid of the mortgage, got married and had a baby. The adore my new husband and baby brother. They are thriving in school and my 9 year old is like a new child. No worries or anything. Can even take himself to bed again. Life is peaceful.

Hawkins001 · 07/11/2022 23:41

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:22

Also. I left late at night with zero plan. Because abuse. Are you saying I should've stayed?

If you had read the op, the op did understand that point

Klinec · 07/11/2022 23:35

shieldmaiden7 · 07/11/2022 23:33

We had 50/50 for 3 years after I walked from the abusive marriage. He met his gf who was horrid to my children. He moved in with her, didn't have room for them anymore. He's seen them 5 hours this year.
He did set up a nice home for them, is a high earner and provided for them well until she got involved and it went from happy families to him not having room for them in 3 months. They have lived with me full time now for 2 years.

This makes me so sad. I'm so sorry. What a spineless waste of space he is.

How have they coped? They must feel so hurt.

OP posts:
TimBoothseyes · 07/11/2022 23:35

Yeah because him buggering off to see the OW every day would be great for the kids and their mum wouldn't it? I'd rather he left than deal with that.

shieldmaiden7 · 07/11/2022 23:33

We had 50/50 for 3 years after I walked from the abusive marriage. He met his gf who was horrid to my children. He moved in with her, didn't have room for them anymore. He's seen them 5 hours this year.
He did set up a nice home for them, is a high earner and provided for them well until she got involved and it went from happy families to him not having room for them in 3 months. They have lived with me full time now for 2 years.

LoveMyCats1 · 07/11/2022 23:27

Posted to early! Higher rate for both kids.

LoveMyCats1 · 07/11/2022 23:27

Plus you then get the higher rate of child benefit.

LoveMyCats1 · 07/11/2022 23:25

If there's more than 1 child you can claim child benefit for 1 each and each go on the housing register for a 2 bed property and get relevant benefits. I know someone that's done this but they're basically still one family and the kids go to the same school it just means dad managed to get a 2 bed house for when they stay at his.

butterfliedtwo · 07/11/2022 23:23

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:56

I don't buy the children are part of the package.

They're his responsibility. Not hers. At all.

This.

He's the parent.

LoveMyCats1 · 07/11/2022 23:18

YANBU OP. It's infuriating when people assume the other parent will do everything.

Klinec · 07/11/2022 23:17

AloysiusBear · 07/11/2022 23:05

Part of the issue is that only one parent can be deemed the RP & receive housing & other benefit support.

In some circumstances the mother is receiving it, but the father isn't, so can't afford to rent any where.

Oh course plenty of fathers are also a waste of space. But our financial system isn't set up for it to be affordable for each parent to separately manage a family sized home.

That is a good point.

When XH walked out, post affair, to pitch up in his DF's place which enabled him to come and go as he pleased - he was always very quick to point out that he can't afford to get a house here (in London) on his wage alone. We both earn a low-ish wage.

He knew he wouldn't be able to afford a house (or even a decent 2 bed flat) when he left but it didn't stop him doing it. He didn't give it a seconds thought.

In order to be able to conduct his relationship with OW he made himself (as the council told him) intentionally homeless.

It never seemed to occur to him that he couldn't do that, just upped and did it.

This, with bells on. This is the problem. They just fuck off without a backwards glance because to them its perfectly acceptable to just pass all of the responsibilities onto the mother.

My jaw would hit the floor if somebody suggested to me that this would be an acceptable way for me to behave.

Again, I'm not referring to relationships where there is abuse.

OP posts:
wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 23:05

AloysiusBear · 07/11/2022 23:05

Part of the issue is that only one parent can be deemed the RP & receive housing & other benefit support.

In some circumstances the mother is receiving it, but the father isn't, so can't afford to rent any where.

Oh course plenty of fathers are also a waste of space. But our financial system isn't set up for it to be affordable for each parent to separately manage a family sized home.

Also. This.

AloysiusBear · 07/11/2022 23:05

Part of the issue is that only one parent can be deemed the RP & receive housing & other benefit support.

In some circumstances the mother is receiving it, but the father isn't, so can't afford to rent any where.

Oh course plenty of fathers are also a waste of space. But our financial system isn't set up for it to be affordable for each parent to separately manage a family sized home.

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 23:04

@Klinec whatever arrangement a man makes for his children are on him and him alone. I don't agree with the perspective you say is the prevailing one on here.

I'm just saying if you go by your op I fail your test.

Klinec · 07/11/2022 23:03

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:56

I don't buy the children are part of the package.

They're his responsibility. Not hers. At all.

Thats not what complaining step mothers are told on here every day though, is it?

And no you don't fail my 'test' don't be daft.

I'm pissed off at the people who up and leave the family home, leaving the DC with the other parent, make no attempt to actually contribute anything to the child rearing and make excuses as to why that is.

I think you know you don't fall into that category.

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 07/11/2022 23:01

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:23

But you see.

If you listen to my ex there was no abuse.

Snap!

Klinec · 07/11/2022 23:01

forevercooking · 07/11/2022 22:50

I kind of get where you're coming from. I'm separated with two young DC. Ex works lates/night shifts on a completely random pattern. I'd love to have a proper 'every other weekend' schedule for my own sanity but unfortunately that doesn't happen. He does take the children to his (lives with his mother) when he has weekends off and more recently if he has a few days off in the week. Also he will come and stay at my house with them if i need to be somewhere. (For instance I start work one day a week at 7am instead of 9.30 - if he can't have them the night before then he will come here from his night shift at 5am. Shut his eyes on the sofa for a coupes of hours - I go off to work and he gets up with them, gives them breakfast and takes them to school and then goes home to sleep). This only works because we've both worked hard to stay amicable as that's what best for the boys. Also if he's starting really late like 7pm he'll pop over after school and have dinner before he goes to work. We do this because it's what's best for the kids. In an ideal world he would have his set times and I could say join a club or a class and socialise and talk to people (I see the same 3 faces in the office and his and the kids and that's pretty much it as my few friends are also single parents and our schedules rarely match up).

It's hard being away from the children but equally gives me time to recharge and refresh. More than 2 days does start to make me low though but I know they're enjoying time with their dad and his family.

In short - is there ever a right answer?

It sounds like you have found a system that works for you and the DC, and thats great.

In the absence of being able to set up home when leaving, if more men would be prepared to do something like your arrangement it would alleviate so much pressure from the mothers.

I don't think I thought out the 50/50 statement before I posted in haste (and frustration to be honest)

Ideally, and I know we don't live in an ideal world, the men who leave their W's and DC would prioritise doing their share of looking after the DC, however works best for everybody so long as it remained a priority (as PP kindly rephrased for me!)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread