Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "can't" do 50/50 shared care then they shouldn't be walking out

115 replies

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:13

I'm talking about the men who walk out on their families whilst the kids are young and then say they can't do shared care because, for example:

He has shacked up with the OW and she doesn't have room for his DC to stay over because she's got loads of her own (and she doesn't want them there anyway)

He is sofa surfing / bunking on a mate or relatives sofa and can't have his DC live there regularly either.

His work schedule isn't compatible with having his DC overnight.

He works nights and isn't awake to collect them from school.

He can't have them at the weekend because he has to work etc etc.

Those are just a few shitty excuses some of these men give, I'm sure many of you can think of more.

I've just been thinking to myself that (in the absence of abuse ofc) if a man "can't" participate in shared care of his DC when he leaves the family home because he has no stable home to bring them to, then he should bloody well make sure he has a stable environment to go before he ups and leaves so he can begin sharing the childcare immediately.

Don't just walk out and leave it all to the mother, you shithouse.

If he's walking out with no long term plan and only somebody else's sofa in sight then he shouldn't be leaving at all until he has his "ducks in a row" IMO.

OK so I'm not suggesting anybody stay in a relationship they don't want to be in but it infuriates me how some men think its acceptable to just up and leave without any intention to continue looking after his own DC.

AIBU?

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 12:54

Ok my ex has his own place but still doesn’t have them at all so I was just wondering how you can prove the ones that don’t bother to see them but would still claim money for kids they don’t see
Neither did my ex, but for many dad, it is a genuine reason. Or working shifts etc...

Work doesn't fit round child care obligations? - you need a new job
But that doesn't apply to mums though. You hear all the time here how mums can't increase their hours because of childcare or their jobs don't allow it. No one tells them to go and apply for another job that fits around it.

Paramedics, police officers, nurses, and many other jobs work in shifts and are quite niche so it's not a case of just looking for another job 9-5 that pays the same.

Getting housing benefits as a single man requires a very low income, getting social housing almost impossible.

Of course some dads are shit and only use excuses but others would live to see their kids more but their housing and job options -income- are more limited.

pickledplump · 10/11/2022 12:01

Well I assume a lot of these men don't do 50:50 when they are there nevermind when they leave.

Regardless though, it's all very well and good saying 'you shouldn't leave unless you can provide another house big enough for our children to have their own rooms and shouldn't ever need to work more than 50% of the week' but in reality that's often not how it works. In a failing relationship, SOMEONE needs to be the one to leave and, whilst I agree there will be tonnes of men who use all the excuses under the sun, there will be others who are just trying to get on their feet once they've left. If it was mainly women leaving the family home or who had worked full time whilst the father stayed home or worked part time, I imagine you'd often find the same situation at least at the time of the initial separation. It's not always possible to leave and then immediately go to complete 50:50 care if that hasn't been your set up until that point.

And who'd want some dick head hanging around longer than necessary either?! If my husband cheated or abused me id want him gone, not hanging around until he was in a position to do X Y and Z, even if that meant him bunking on a mates sofa for a bit or moving into a smaller property for a while/finding another job etc...

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 11:50

110APiccadilly · 10/11/2022 11:08

Would you also take the view that the mother can't kick the father out unless he has somewhere to go that's big enough to have the children? Relationships break down from both sides. In my experience, both mothers and fathers often fail to consider the children's best interests when breaking up.

It should be more widely known that your parents breaking up is as damaging to a child, according to research, as one of them dying. I'm not saying people should stay though abuse or cheating (they absolutely shouldn't) but IMO some people end relationships that might be savable because they don't want to put the effort in, and either don't care or aren't aware how terrible that is for their children. And I've known that happen with both men and women instigating the break up.

A lot of relationships aren't really 'savable' though beyond both parents managing to coparent relatively amicably in the same house. Intimate relationships typically involve sharing bedroom space and having sex, neither of which people should be expected to do against their will just to 'save the relationship' for the sake of the children.

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 11:43

PeekAtYou · 07/11/2022 22:38

Yabu

Sometimes parents need to travel eg lorry drivers or work overnight eg police officers so can't have the kids 50/50. It's unreasonable to expect a world where parents can only work hours that fit with nursery hours.

No it really isn't. Lone parents have to fit their work around the childcare they have available. They can't just abandon their children to work a shift.

If you're a pilot or lorry driver working irregular hours and don't have childcare, unfortunately you need to take the financial hit and change careers.

Sunshine847 · 10/11/2022 11:34

My DH would absolutely love 50:50 split. Separated nearly 10 years ago and used to do all nursery runs but only got 1 night and EOW. Tried to go through mediation a few years ago to get more time and ex made life hell on earth. Not got the money to go to court and not sure our marriage would survive the levels of abuse she’d give us… (not sure how we are still married from the stress she’s caused over the time we’ve been together).

So there is another side to this where dads want 50:50 but it is so hard to get 😢 (live walking distance from their school, they have their own rooms here and would like this)

Simonjt · 10/11/2022 11:18

So you find out your husband is having an affair, he can’t afford to rent his own property, this means you have to continue living with him, even if you don’t have a spare room and have to share a bed with him.

So not only is this crap, you’re insisting the children are being brought up in an unhappy and high stress home. Why do you think children should be forced to put up with that? How will you personally deal with the later issues those children suffer as their ACEs increase?

Notarealmum · 10/11/2022 11:13

I strongly agree with this view, @110APiccadilly

Sellorkeep · 10/11/2022 11:11

I have many friends and family with broken relationships that have children. All are present and responsible fathers in their children’s lives.
I voted unreasonable as you yourself acknowledge that it’s not right to stay in an unhappy relationship and because I don’t see much of what you describe around me. I also see around me a children getting screwed up as the parents are together in an unhappy relationship. And I have many adult friends who are still suffering the effects of this from their childhood.

110APiccadilly · 10/11/2022 11:08

Would you also take the view that the mother can't kick the father out unless he has somewhere to go that's big enough to have the children? Relationships break down from both sides. In my experience, both mothers and fathers often fail to consider the children's best interests when breaking up.

It should be more widely known that your parents breaking up is as damaging to a child, according to research, as one of them dying. I'm not saying people should stay though abuse or cheating (they absolutely shouldn't) but IMO some people end relationships that might be savable because they don't want to put the effort in, and either don't care or aren't aware how terrible that is for their children. And I've known that happen with both men and women instigating the break up.

ReallyITV · 10/11/2022 10:55

Oh yes and often have this ‘discussion’ with my friends who say they can’t afford to leave their husbands - we’re talking about ex Lawyers and accountants here whose husbands are in the same careers but have risen ahead with the wives having pregnancies and Mat leaves

ReallyITV · 10/11/2022 10:54

Is it just that he’s a wanker he doesn’t give a shit about the kids and men basically get to do what they want!

gogohmm · 10/11/2022 10:48

There are many scenarios where 50/50 doesn't work, in fact here in Mumsnet many women don't want 50/50 (perhaps for cms reasons) everyone is different, what is important is children are put central to the decision making process.

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 10:47

vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 09:49

How many single mothers would cope looking after their children if it wasn't for the benefits they can claim? How many mums say they can't work FT because of caring duties.

Maybe if fathers could claim benefits too, more would be able to provide more care for their kids.

What are you talking about? Fathers CAN claim in exactly the same way as mothers.

But society expects that the father, who may well be the higher earner as the mother will possibly have taken the hit on her career to have the children in the first place, to go out to work and for the mother to carry on doing the childcare and then attempting to fit work around it.

The rub however, for the father, is that he has to do the childcare bit as well. And a lot don’t see that as their domain. Or they’ve simply left. Or they can’t conceive of having to make the compromises women make to juggle everything, say in and day out.

AntlerRose · 10/11/2022 10:43

No one wants to be forced to stay with a partner that doesnt want to be there
The problem is housing and childcare.

Both are not available in the quanity and type needed and are expensive.

Sistanotcista · 10/11/2022 10:42

DaisyDozyDee · 10/11/2022 09:57

But selling a 3 bedroom house won’t let you suddenly afford two 3 bedroom houses.
When my dad moved out of the family home, he couldn’t have us over night for years because he lived in a bed sit while paying for the house we were actually living in. Doesn’t make him a bad parent.

@DaisyDozyDee - sounds like he was a great parent, actually - he sacrificed his own time with the kids that he clearly loved loved to ensure they had a secure home, and that their lives were not disrupted by having to move home, schools, areas etc. 50/50 is not all about equal time - its about equal contributions that are decided upon with the best interested of the kids at heart.

SudocremOnEverything · 10/11/2022 10:41

I think the starting assumption that 50/50 should be the aim is entirely inaccurate.

It might be. For some children and in some
circumstances.

But very often 50-50 is about the parents’
wants (and possibly financially motivated) rather than the best interests of the children.

Sistanotcista · 10/11/2022 10:34

luxxlisbon · 07/11/2022 22:21

In this situation does it matter if they are together or not though? I can only assume that a man who leaves his partner and kids and says he “can’t” do 50/50 care of the children after he moves out likely wasn’t doing close to 50/50 while he lived there anyway.

Totally agree. Sadly, this is the crux of the matter - men who are caring, involved fathers don't just walk out on their kids without having a plan for their (the children's) future. Only shitty fathers do that.

DoYouKnowTheBishopOfNorwich · 10/11/2022 10:33

It depends on so many things. I don't think 50/50 is always best for the kids (already been mentioned - I know it's a cliché). If one of you I'd a sahp for example and the other is something like a surgeon or a pilot who has to travel or work crazy hours, it makes way more sense for the sahp to have the kids more.

But then you'd expect the high earning partner to contribute financially if they can't contribute by looking after dcs. So if you mean they shouldn't leave if they can't contribute either practically or financially I do see what you mean. I do think a lot of men do bail out when they have young kids as it's such hard work and they just want out. But you can't do that as you're still a parent, so you have to care for them yourself or outsource that somehow.

CecilyP · 10/11/2022 10:31

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:26

Not everybody is a home owner though.

My ex left our (rented) family home and pitched up on his DF's sofa.

But, presumably, you stayed in the rented home you previously shared. Unless you to were pitching on a friends sofa with your kids.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 10:27

declutteringmymind · 07/11/2022 22:28

I agree, but nesting is also an alternative (in a non abusive relationship.

It's not a realistic option for most people though is it?

Sprogonthetyne · 10/11/2022 10:26

I don't nessercerily think it needs to be in place before leaving, but almost all mothers would incorporate their children's needs into their leaving plan, and arrange their life/work/living arrangements occordingly. So why shouldn't there be the same expectation on farther?

Work doesn't fit round child care obligations? - you need a new job

House not suitable for DC to stay? - find somewhere else/ sacrifice area for size

New partner doesn't like kids? - don't start a relationship with them

SpinningFloppa · 10/11/2022 10:23

vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 10:16

How would that work? I imagine many dead beat dads would claim it and still not bother to see the children
And many would be able to have their own place and therefore have their kids more often.

Ultimately, it's much easier to care for kids when the system give you money that results in much less pressure to get any job to support you and your children.

Ok my ex has his own place but still doesn’t have them at all so I was just wondering how you can prove the ones that don’t bother to see them but would still claim money for kids they don’t see

vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 10:16

How would that work? I imagine many dead beat dads would claim it and still not bother to see the children
And many would be able to have their own place and therefore have their kids more often.

Ultimately, it's much easier to care for kids when the system give you money that results in much less pressure to get any job to support you and your children.

SpinningFloppa · 10/11/2022 10:01

vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 09:49

How many single mothers would cope looking after their children if it wasn't for the benefits they can claim? How many mums say they can't work FT because of caring duties.

Maybe if fathers could claim benefits too, more would be able to provide more care for their kids.

How would that work? I imagine many dead beat dads would claim it and still not bother to see the children

DaisyDozyDee · 10/11/2022 09:57

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 07/11/2022 22:23

Well the family home would need to be sold and everything split so there's 2 stable homes

But selling a 3 bedroom house won’t let you suddenly afford two 3 bedroom houses.
When my dad moved out of the family home, he couldn’t have us over night for years because he lived in a bed sit while paying for the house we were actually living in. Doesn’t make him a bad parent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread