Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "can't" do 50/50 shared care then they shouldn't be walking out

115 replies

Klinec · 07/11/2022 22:13

I'm talking about the men who walk out on their families whilst the kids are young and then say they can't do shared care because, for example:

He has shacked up with the OW and she doesn't have room for his DC to stay over because she's got loads of her own (and she doesn't want them there anyway)

He is sofa surfing / bunking on a mate or relatives sofa and can't have his DC live there regularly either.

His work schedule isn't compatible with having his DC overnight.

He works nights and isn't awake to collect them from school.

He can't have them at the weekend because he has to work etc etc.

Those are just a few shitty excuses some of these men give, I'm sure many of you can think of more.

I've just been thinking to myself that (in the absence of abuse ofc) if a man "can't" participate in shared care of his DC when he leaves the family home because he has no stable home to bring them to, then he should bloody well make sure he has a stable environment to go before he ups and leaves so he can begin sharing the childcare immediately.

Don't just walk out and leave it all to the mother, you shithouse.

If he's walking out with no long term plan and only somebody else's sofa in sight then he shouldn't be leaving at all until he has his "ducks in a row" IMO.

OK so I'm not suggesting anybody stay in a relationship they don't want to be in but it infuriates me how some men think its acceptable to just up and leave without any intention to continue looking after his own DC.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 20:26

Onlyforcake · 10/11/2022 20:20

Obviously not. But then I've not met a guy who left his wife who asked for 50/50 either. Maybe there's something wrong with the low expectations of men as parents or women too high? Either way. I am faitly sure men as RP are a minority? Or are you denying that?

I've met quite a few! Weird.

I certainly don't have low expectations of men, either.

I haven't said men as RP are a majority - I'm not even sure this is aimed at me sorry Blush

Onlyforcake · 10/11/2022 20:20

Obviously not. But then I've not met a guy who left his wife who asked for 50/50 either. Maybe there's something wrong with the low expectations of men as parents or women too high? Either way. I am faitly sure men as RP are a minority? Or are you denying that?

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 20:11

But it does work like that for some people..

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 20:11

AuntieDickhead · 10/11/2022 20:01

Wouldn't it be nice if it did work like that! In my case what would happen is I'd get a message, maybe the Day before, maybe 5 mins before ex was due saying
"Sorry, can't have kids. I'm working/ helping a mate/whatever"
I'd reply "right. I'm also working. It's your day to have them"
Him "not my problem"

Right thanks.
What was even worse was that according to the CMS he doesn't work so doesn't pay any maintenance at all.

Well obviously nobody is condoning that behaviour.

AuntieDickhead · 10/11/2022 20:01

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 19:11

Personally I think whoever has the child that day is responsible for the childcare. The maintenance is a contribution for the time under 50% that the other parent has them. I don't think the other parent is responsible for paying for childcare the rp has chosen, whether that's a man or a woman.

Wouldn't it be nice if it did work like that! In my case what would happen is I'd get a message, maybe the Day before, maybe 5 mins before ex was due saying
"Sorry, can't have kids. I'm working/ helping a mate/whatever"
I'd reply "right. I'm also working. It's your day to have them"
Him "not my problem"

Right thanks.
What was even worse was that according to the CMS he doesn't work so doesn't pay any maintenance at all.

Straighouttaluck · 10/11/2022 19:49

Personally I would just like him to see the 3 children under 5 once a week, and declare his actual wages so I'm paid more than £7 a month.
But instead he turns up when he fancies and I get paid nil-£7 a month. Ohhhh how the men live.
On the bright side he's an abusive prick and atleast my kids won't learn his behaviours!

napody · 10/11/2022 19:24

110APiccadilly · 10/11/2022 11:08

Would you also take the view that the mother can't kick the father out unless he has somewhere to go that's big enough to have the children? Relationships break down from both sides. In my experience, both mothers and fathers often fail to consider the children's best interests when breaking up.

It should be more widely known that your parents breaking up is as damaging to a child, according to research, as one of them dying. I'm not saying people should stay though abuse or cheating (they absolutely shouldn't) but IMO some people end relationships that might be savable because they don't want to put the effort in, and either don't care or aren't aware how terrible that is for their children. And I've known that happen with both men and women instigating the break up.

Citation please.
If you're talking about ACEs there is a lot of debate about equating all these different events (such as death and divorce) without considering the context.

napody · 10/11/2022 19:20

wibblewobbleboard · 07/11/2022 22:21

I did weird hours.

I'm female.

Are you suggesting I should've stayed and continued to be abused because I worked shifts and relied on childcare?

Eh? You sorted childcare, therefore you sorted it. Unless you relied on your ex for the majority of childcare (which I very much doubt). OP is talking about the person leaving dumping it all on their ex partner.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 19:20

Onlyforcake · 10/11/2022 19:17

You're expecting someone who isn't prioritising relationship/ children/ family to just do those things?

I've never met a man that asked for 50/50. There's a reason their partners are through with them.

What so all relationships are ended by women who are totally blameless are they?

Onlyforcake · 10/11/2022 19:17

You're expecting someone who isn't prioritising relationship/ children/ family to just do those things?

I've never met a man that asked for 50/50. There's a reason their partners are through with them.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 19:12

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 15:15

Maintenance isn’t to cover the cost of the childcare that the other parent would pay!!! It’s to cover the expenses that the resident parent incurs!

If the NRP needs childcare for thr times they have their OWN kids they need to sort and pay for that themselves, not expect the other parent to do it for them!!! What if, god forbid, she had something better to do…?

It's a contribution to the child, it's not a payment for the other parent doing childcare, which is what a pp suggested should be paid. I think you have completely misunderstood what I actually said there.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 19:11

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 18:18

I really want to hear more from @Ineverwannabelikeyou about this! Please explain why his childcare is my problem???

Personally I think whoever has the child that day is responsible for the childcare. The maintenance is a contribution for the time under 50% that the other parent has them. I don't think the other parent is responsible for paying for childcare the rp has chosen, whether that's a man or a woman.

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 18:18

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 17:53

Exactly. It's unclear why NRPs should be entitled to treat RPs as cheap/free childcare, but it seems that many believe this to be OK.

I really want to hear more from @Ineverwannabelikeyou about this! Please explain why his childcare is my problem???

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 17:53

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 15:15

Maintenance isn’t to cover the cost of the childcare that the other parent would pay!!! It’s to cover the expenses that the resident parent incurs!

If the NRP needs childcare for thr times they have their OWN kids they need to sort and pay for that themselves, not expect the other parent to do it for them!!! What if, god forbid, she had something better to do…?

Exactly. It's unclear why NRPs should be entitled to treat RPs as cheap/free childcare, but it seems that many believe this to be OK.

ApexLegend · 10/11/2022 15:15

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 13:33

Were not talking about the ones that don't pay. Let's face it, if they don't pay they're not going to have their child 50% of the time. I'm specifically talking about reduction of maintenance not being okay but a direct reduction being fine.

Of course they could pay for childcare, but again that's not what was said. It was "change jobs and take the financial hit" without any regard for the child.

Why would they pay the market rate to the other parent? That's what maintenance is for.

Maintenance isn’t to cover the cost of the childcare that the other parent would pay!!! It’s to cover the expenses that the resident parent incurs!

If the NRP needs childcare for thr times they have their OWN kids they need to sort and pay for that themselves, not expect the other parent to do it for them!!! What if, god forbid, she had something better to do…?

SudocremOnEverything · 10/11/2022 15:02

So much of this discussion seems to position the children as objects or possessions to be shared out in a divorce settlement. There’s lots of talks about what parents want or will allow, but (as os so often the case) little consideration about what the children might need.

OP83 · 10/11/2022 14:33

Most men would want 50/50 (in my experience) but end up with far less time with their children than they would like. Most women on the other hand (again, most, and only in my experience) wouldn't be happy with a 50/50 split of time spent with their children.

Every situation is different and every separation is different so there is no 'one size fits all' solution. I think that any implication, however, that men get a 'good deal' in separation is a bit of a fantasy.

Scarlettpixie · 10/11/2022 14:12

TimBoothseyes · 07/11/2022 23:35

Yeah because him buggering off to see the OW every day would be great for the kids and their mum wouldn't it? I'd rather he left than deal with that.

This 100%. When my ex had an affair and decided he ‘couldn’t give her up’ I didn’t want him here at all. The nights he was out with her until the early hours while we tried to maintain an air of normality for DS (then 12) were incredibly hard. I was so relieved when he moved out (even without him having a home to go to where he could have DS). Initially he did visit DS most days.

DS sleeps here 7 days a week and now spends the day at his dad’s once a week. My ex knows I would move heaven and earth for DS so he doesn’t have to. He leaves most of the parenting and all the organisation to me. I also work full time.

While sometimes I wish his dad was a bit more involved, I would hate a 50/50 arrangement. DS and I are a great team and luckily he seems happy with the set up. He knows he could sleep over at his dad’s but has no wish to and that is fine with me.

kingtamponthefurred · 10/11/2022 14:05

How do you propose to enforce this?

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 13:33

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 13:11

Given 4 in 10 NRPs pay no maintenance whatsoever and many more fail to pay what they should or end up paying a pittance (the CM calculation amount is hardly generous in a lot of cases), it's hard to take arguments around the NRP needing to not financially disadvantage the children particularly seriously. In any case, they could always pay for childcare so they could do their job, couldn't they? That's what most parents do to enable them to work... pay for childcare, including out of hours if needed. Or they could pay the market rate to the RP.

Were not talking about the ones that don't pay. Let's face it, if they don't pay they're not going to have their child 50% of the time. I'm specifically talking about reduction of maintenance not being okay but a direct reduction being fine.

Of course they could pay for childcare, but again that's not what was said. It was "change jobs and take the financial hit" without any regard for the child.

Why would they pay the market rate to the other parent? That's what maintenance is for.

Oopsiedaisyy · 10/11/2022 13:15

"How many mums do you know who’d want 50/50, no maintenance, not getting more than half of any assets there are? Losing half the time with their kids? Having to consider the other parent a proper equal?"

Me, that's what I wanted and have right from the start, because the kids needed both parents in their lives.

MintJulia · 10/11/2022 13:11

AuntieDickhead · 07/11/2022 22:22

My ex didn't do school runs when we were together. Not sure why I'd expect him to when he left.

Mind you I was 'lucky' if he saw them one day per week let alone anything more so my opinion is skewed.

Same here. My ex morphed into 1950s man as soon as ds was born. He's never done a night feed, he only changed about 4 nappies and he's never looked after him for more than a couple of hours straight.
I had no expectation of that changing when we split. We split BECAUSE he refused to do.

By then I couldn't have cared less, I was just glad to see the back of him.

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 13:11

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 13:03

A lot of the time though the parent recieving significant maintenance from a pilots salary don't want to take the financial hit. You see on here over and over again how these men must not disadvantage their children by taking a lower income and paying less maintenance. But if they have 50/50 care then it's fine to financially disadvantage their children. Righty ho.

Given 4 in 10 NRPs pay no maintenance whatsoever and many more fail to pay what they should or end up paying a pittance (the CM calculation amount is hardly generous in a lot of cases), it's hard to take arguments around the NRP needing to not financially disadvantage the children particularly seriously. In any case, they could always pay for childcare so they could do their job, couldn't they? That's what most parents do to enable them to work... pay for childcare, including out of hours if needed. Or they could pay the market rate to the RP.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 10/11/2022 13:03

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 11:43

No it really isn't. Lone parents have to fit their work around the childcare they have available. They can't just abandon their children to work a shift.

If you're a pilot or lorry driver working irregular hours and don't have childcare, unfortunately you need to take the financial hit and change careers.

A lot of the time though the parent recieving significant maintenance from a pilots salary don't want to take the financial hit. You see on here over and over again how these men must not disadvantage their children by taking a lower income and paying less maintenance. But if they have 50/50 care then it's fine to financially disadvantage their children. Righty ho.

vivainsomnia · 10/11/2022 12:59

No it really isn't. Lone parents have to fit their work around the childcare they have available. They can't just abandon their children to work a shift
No they don't. They can opt to reduce their working hours and claim benefits instead. The requirements to work are a but more strident now but still offers much flexibility that non residents parents don't have.