Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 07/11/2022 22:54

CherryBlossomWinter · 07/11/2022 22:47

I have a child with a severe disability, who is the light of my life. However I strongly feel that the debate we should be having is not so much abortion but around the quality of care and support for kids and their parents - it’s still absolutely terrible! After diagnosis I have had almost no support at all.

Getting the right school is like having to go into battle, and we still hear about abuse in residential homes, poor management, lack of continuing care. We as a society should hang our heads about this. People with learning disabilities have a much lower life expectancy (mostly preventable), and this is 2022! So I am very wary of this debate, it detracts from the real issues, that we do not give kids with disabilities anything like the best start in life. And unfortunately, that does mean it’s all on parents to sink or swim. Let’s pull together for that.

Amen.

SarahAndQuack · 07/11/2022 22:52

LBB2020 · 07/11/2022 22:45

I have a child with Down syndrome so this is a difficult one for me to comment on. Yes, a woman should 100% be able to abort for any reason (her body her choice) but that isn’t what this is about. It’s not about taking away a woman’s choice or rights it’s about levelling the playing field. Abortions up to 24 weeks or to full term for all, rather than singling out certain disabilities and saying those foetuses/babies can be aborted right up to birth

Are you saying that if a woman is pregnant with a baby she knows will not survive birth, or will not survive the early hours of life, she should be forced to put that baby through the stress and pain of labour? If that baby has a condition that means labour will be agonisingly painful?

I think that is utterly inhumane. I should be clear I'm not thinking of Down's. I am thinking of conditions where they process of labour - which is stressful and dangerous for any baby - would be actively agonising. It's my personal belief it is wrong to make that the only possibility.

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/11/2022 22:52

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:17

The minute you open the door a crack to say “oh, well, you can’t abort for that reason, it’s distasteful” the door flies wide open to restricting abortion altogether. Any reason, any time; as early as possible, as late as necessary.

Well it's interesting isn't it? If we are OK w termination for whatever reason, what might we be able to screen for and select for in future? Sexual orientation? Good looks? Skin tone?

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/11/2022 22:52

ClocksGoingBackwards · 07/11/2022 22:36

I’m all for women’s rights to reproductive autonomy, but you have to have a heart of stone and be very closed minded if you can’t at least see where this lady is coming from. She’s not trying to take rights away, she’s making the point that her life is still well worth living even if she has a disability.

They are absolutely trying to take rights away.

She might be able to life a normal life; many with DS cannot.

KitchiHuritAngeni · 07/11/2022 22:49

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:38

The difference is that in those scenarios the woman doesn’t want to be pregnant full stop

with gender selection abortion it’s saying pregnancy is ok with the preferred gender but not otherwise it’s like saying you want an abortion because your due date is in the wrong month or something !

One woman having an abortion isn't doing anyone else a disservice though.

If she made the same choice as someone else but for different reason then that's fine and noone else's business.

Not all abortions come with a traumatic backstory or heartbreaking reason.

"I don't wish to continue this pregnancy" is all that's needed. You may not like it but we need to trust women to choose for ourselves.

Hadalifeonce · 07/11/2022 22:49

As an older mother I was in a high risk category. We made the decision that if we tested positive for some disability, we would terminate.
When I told my mother, I expected her to be annoyed (I have a bother with learning difficulties) she told me that she wouldn't blame me as she wouldn't wish her life on anyone.

CherryBlossomWinter · 07/11/2022 22:47

I have a child with a severe disability, who is the light of my life. However I strongly feel that the debate we should be having is not so much abortion but around the quality of care and support for kids and their parents - it’s still absolutely terrible! After diagnosis I have had almost no support at all.

Getting the right school is like having to go into battle, and we still hear about abuse in residential homes, poor management, lack of continuing care. We as a society should hang our heads about this. People with learning disabilities have a much lower life expectancy (mostly preventable), and this is 2022! So I am very wary of this debate, it detracts from the real issues, that we do not give kids with disabilities anything like the best start in life. And unfortunately, that does mean it’s all on parents to sink or swim. Let’s pull together for that.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/11/2022 22:47

I voted YANBU because I agree abortion rights are a concern. However, I think this is just a nice photo op for Caring Rushi. I can't imagine this is or ever will be of any interest to him.

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 22:46

I personally do not think it's okay to use abortion as a form of "regular" contraception

I just don’t get this. Either a foetus is a full human and so has rights or it is not and therefore does not. I can understand those on both extremes of the argument about abortion, but I don’t understand the “women have rights over their own bodies, but only if I think their reasons are good enough” argument. At some stage you surely have to decide - does a foetus have personhood or not?

SheepySheepy · 07/11/2022 22:45

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:17

The minute you open the door a crack to say “oh, well, you can’t abort for that reason, it’s distasteful” the door flies wide open to restricting abortion altogether. Any reason, any time; as early as possible, as late as necessary.

I could not agree with this more, and I speak from personal experience having terminated a pregnancy due to genetic abnormality.

There is no “this is ok, this is not”. The woman has the right to choose.

LBB2020 · 07/11/2022 22:45

I have a child with Down syndrome so this is a difficult one for me to comment on. Yes, a woman should 100% be able to abort for any reason (her body her choice) but that isn’t what this is about. It’s not about taking away a woman’s choice or rights it’s about levelling the playing field. Abortions up to 24 weeks or to full term for all, rather than singling out certain disabilities and saying those foetuses/babies can be aborted right up to birth

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 22:44

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2022 22:34

Maybe making your views on this subject know to a rents of a child with a disability isnt such a great idea. Of course they will see it as a personal attack. I believe in abortion for any reason as a woman’s right. I wouldn’t discuss this with parents of a disabled child if I knew they strongly felt different to me.

But those parents are the ones seeking to change my rights, so why shouldn’t I be able to air my views?

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 07/11/2022 22:44

I think women ought to have autonomy over their bodies.

I'm also a worried about the way this campaign and others like it have been conducted. I'm thinking of this response:

I do think clarity is needed and a decisive list of conditions considered severe or criteria to be met not just individual non medical opinion on severity

This, to me, is a fundamental problem. Down's syndrome affects people very, very, very differently. It is one condition, but it is a huge spectrum of outcomes. It can be fatal in utero. It's not just a learning disability. Same with things like cleft palate. That condition is mentioned by campaigners who want us to imagine a child with a slight, winsome dent in their lip where a tiny split was surgically corrected. But if a cleft palate extends upwards into the middle of the skull/face, my understanding is it can be incompatible with life.

I think the emphasis on deciding which foetal conditions should be 'acceptable' reasons for abortion is another way to infantalise women. Pregnant women should be entitled to make their own decisions, and they should be given appropriate support to do that. I suspect that, on those stratospherically rate occasions when a foetus is terminated in late pregnancy, it is not because the mother though 'ugh, I don't like the look of a cleft palate' or 'ooh, I heard kids with Down's syndrome have learning disabiltiies!' It is far, far more likely the mother has heard that her child is likely to die.

cata09x · 07/11/2022 22:42

Interestingly enough I watched a video of someone interviewing women at a "pro choice" march the other day and it was interesting to see the amount of women there who actually disagreed with abortion after 12 weeks etc.

It's statistically impossible to know how many people are pro life / pro choice as people have too many differing views on it.

I think it's also unfair for people to think it's a majority of men though who are pro life as from experience I know many women who boarder the pro life side more than pro choice.

Abortion should be allowed IMO however there also needs to be lines drawn for when and with reason etc. which would then prevent people aborting for no reason.

I personally do not think it's okay to use abortion as a form of "regular" contraception, if you're choosing to not be safe and "wing" it when it comes to having sex - like some people I know have done previously, then there will obviously be consequences.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:42

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:38

That’s not pro choice, then.

I think a lot of women are so scared of the removal of their rights entirely that it clouds their judgement over ethical aspects of abortion and I do understand that but abortion based on gender isn’t ok ? What would be the reason ‘oh I don’t want another boy I’ve had 2 already ‘ or ‘I don’t like pink so I won’t have a girl’ .

Either you want to be pregnant or not . If not then go ahead and get an abortion. That’s the right thing to do but I can’t agree with the idea that abortion based on gender preference is ok ?

ElizabethBest · 07/11/2022 22:42

i have a child with disabilities. To me, he is the entire universe. I love him so much it hurts to write it down. HOWEVER, it is fucking hard. So hard. DH and I have consciously chosen not to have more children in case they too are disabled and I 100% would have an abortion if I became pregnant again.

My life would not be better without DS in it because he is here and I know and love him, and I’ve counted his little freckles and seen him fall off the sofa because he laughed so hard at Andy and the Oddsocks, and watched him scream with joy on his first carousel ride and danced with him to abba. He has a lovely life and I love having him in my life. But knowing all the heartache and stress and sleeplessness and feelings of constant worry and failure that go alongside being a disability parent, if I could choose not to have children back before I had him, I probably would choose to remain childless.

Again, if DS had been born into a different family, who couldn’t cope with his very extensive needs, his life would be very different. That is exactly why we need to allow women to have their own individual right to choose and that needs to be protected.

WarrickDavisAsPlates · 07/11/2022 22:41

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2022 22:34

Maybe making your views on this subject know to a rents of a child with a disability isnt such a great idea. Of course they will see it as a personal attack. I believe in abortion for any reason as a woman’s right. I wouldn’t discuss this with parents of a disabled child if I knew they strongly felt different to me.

It's not something I've ever brought up with them. They have told me their views in person and aired them on social media enough for me to know how they feel. I have simply suggested to them that our views may not align as we're coming at it from different perspectives.

I suppose when I say "a wedge between us" it's more one sided than that implies.

KiwiChch · 07/11/2022 22:40

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:06

That is extreme re gender

I do think clarity is needed and a decisive list of conditions considered severe or criteria to be met not just individual non medical opinion on severity

Abortion was decriminalised in 2020 in NZ and there are now no clinical or statutory requirements below 20 weeks. After 20 weeks, a clinician is involved in discussing the pregnancy. It is therefore the woman's choice whether or not to continue with a pregnancy as it should be.

They're not controversial here 🤷‍♀️ aside from a reasonably small group of vocal anti-women groups. We trust women to make healthcare decisions that work for them. It was supported in parliament and by the public.

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 22:40

you have to have a heart of stone and be very closed minded if you can’t at least see where this lady is coming from

I know a family involved in this case. They (the family I know) are completely anti choice. Using this as a wedge issue to try to roll back women’s right to abortion. I don’t have a heart of stone, I just don’t think that anyone has a right to determine what a woman should or should not do with her own body. I have more compassion for a fully formed woman than a foetus.

And, due to personal experience, I do not trust those involved in bringing / supporting this particular case.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:38

KitchiHuritAngeni · 07/11/2022 22:35

How on earth is another womans choice over her own body and life doing anyone else a disservice.

What a valid reason in your eyes?

Wrong father?

Wrong age?

Would mess up a career opportunity?

Doesn't want baby number 5?

All of those reasons could upset someone else because they made different choices. We only have a responsibility to ourselves.

The difference is that in those scenarios the woman doesn’t want to be pregnant full stop

with gender selection abortion it’s saying pregnancy is ok with the preferred gender but not otherwise it’s like saying you want an abortion because your due date is in the wrong month or something !

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:38

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:36

I am pro choice but there has to be a line drawn I can’t see how anyone would abort just because they don’t want a baby of a specific gender. Medical
conditions affecting one gender only aside I just can’t see how it is right to abort based on gender preference

That’s not pro choice, then.

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:37

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:34

Abortion purely on the basis of not wanting a boy or girl is so wrong I can’t see there would be many cases like that surely as it’s about as shallow as you could get and I doubt there are that many women like that out there

so you acknowledge it’s a strawman argument?

In any case, shallow women are allowed abortions too! You don’t have to wear sackcloth and ashes and be the perfect, tasteful example of abortion to be allowed to have one.

WarrickDavisAsPlates · 07/11/2022 22:37

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 22:26

@WarrickDavisAsPlates did she have a birth diagnosis?

Yes the baby diagnosed after they were born, which I know was a very scary and traumatic time for the family as the baby had to be rushed away for tests and the parents were completely unprepared.

Only days after giving birth the mother was being bombarded by information and having to make big choices while her baby was off in special care, not even knowing if they'd survive the coming days.

It's not a situation I'd wish on anyone and as we have the means to check for many of these health issues before the birth I'd always suggest that someone had the tests even if they wouldn't terminate as they could at least be prepared for the outcome.

Seeing someone bring up a child with special needs and disabilities only makes me more prochoice as I can see how difficult it is and how their entire family lives have had to change to fit around their child in a way other families don't even have to consider.

Pregnancy, childbirth and parenting are hard, physically and emotionally, no woman should ever be forced to go through it unless she is sure its what she wants.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:36

I am pro choice but there has to be a line drawn I can’t see how anyone would abort just because they don’t want a baby of a specific gender. Medical
conditions affecting one gender only aside I just can’t see how it is right to abort based on gender preference

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 22:36

Personally I couldn't understand aborting a baby almost fully formed just because I dislike the gender?

So don’t do it. But you shouldn’t (imo) get to decide what reasons are acceptable for another woman to continue with a pregnancy she doesn’t want or to terminate that pregnancy. Her body, her choice. I personally trust women to make the choice that is right for themselves. Forced pregnancy and forced birth is far more wrong than any other scenario.