Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
HairyMcLarie · 08/11/2022 02:27

@NameChange1718 However, I’m not sure I can get on board with abortion of a baby that has reached term just because you don’t like the gender. How is that any different to euthanising newborn babies?

Where is this allowed?

CherryBlossomWinter · 08/11/2022 02:07

Although I think this debate detracts from what to me, is the more important debate - the actually quality of life and support for parents and kids with disabilities…
There IS a reality that there is a question about the quality of life for an unborn child and the ability of a parent to undertake a lifelong high need caring role. It is usually mothers who have to give up a lot to care, and there is a reality that for many the stress is immense, and for some kids their struggles are also immense. So for me, this is a different debate than ‘choosing’ sex by abortion. It is not very fair to ‘wheel out’ a person with disabilities who is milder and independent to speak for all of those without a voice.

The positive / social view of disability as merely difference and not struggle portrayed everywhere has a lot of well meaning behind it, is not always helpful. All life’s matter, including those with disabilities, and for me that is more of the focus - we are letting down those who are currently living, now, with families.

For me, I do passionately feel that we are letting down families and many kids do have an awful time because the services for disabilities are not there.

And sadly the reality is that being pregnant with a child with possibly severe disabilities is a concern for many mother’s, precisely because there is very little support and they will be on their own. So society, for me, should focus on providing every possible resource so that a mother to be can feel that she won’t be left stranded by a society which advocates that all lives matter, but won’t care if that parent sinks under the larger responsibilities of care.

sashh · 08/11/2022 02:04

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 21:59

Is it true that conditions such as cleft lip is considered a ‘severe disability’ when it comes to abortion ? Is there a list of conditions classified severe ?

It can be, a simple cleft lip no, a cleft lip where half the skull is missing yes.

A cleft lip with a number of other defects yes.

No there isn't a list because it would be impossible to do that.

Imagine a woman carrying a child that will have severe defects but as it is so severe no one has seen it before so it's not on the list.

NameChange1718 · 08/11/2022 02:00

This thread has made me feel very odd. I always considered myself prochoice. I thought the limits were good, including the extension for if the foetus is found to have a serious condition.
I think it’s fine to abort for any reason at all up to the cut off. I’d also agree that a short extension would be beneficial in many ways.

However, I’m not sure I can get on board with abortion of a baby that has reached term just because you don’t like the gender. How is that any different to euthanising newborn babies?

I’m pro euthanasia but only for those that can make the choice themselves. But also, I know how traumatic birth can be for mothers so I wouldn’t want to force that on anyone. But surely they’d still have to birth the foetus if they aborted them at term?

I do appreciate it would be a rarity for anyone to terminate up to term for a reason such as wrong gender. They would likely know much sooner and therefore make the choice much sooner so I suppose extension of the time period for abortions wouldn’t actually be utilised like this that often and is therefore a good thing…?

HairyMcLarie · 08/11/2022 01:58

goldsparklyChocolate
Is it true that conditions such as cleft lip is considered a ‘severe disability’ when it comes to abortion ? Is there a list of conditions classified severe ?

It is in New Zealand, they have some very controversial abortion laws including being allowed to abort just because you dislike the gender.
@cata09x

Highly misleading way of describing NZ abortion legislation. Abortion was only decriminalised in 2020 when the law was reformed. Now, before 20 weeks, abortion is permitted without any reason being provided. Correctly the reason for abortion is neither here nor there and therefore isn't asked. It's just access by right until 20 weeks. After that various conditions apply.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:54

@Loopyloopy what about India? Or China? Both have significant population imbalances because male fetuses are favoured over females.

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 01:49

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:21

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet and how well has that worked out in societies where its allowed?

In NZ (where the law is as close to this as we are really going to get) I believe that it's worked out quite well.

Nat6999 · 08/11/2022 01:45

My nephew was born disabled, he has autism, ADHD & a other disabilities, he is an IVF twin & very much loved but will never be able to live independently. I worry about what will happen to him when my brother & SIL aren't around any more, his twin sister while she has autism is at the other end of the spectrum to her brother, is very clever & has ambitions to be an actress. I worry that when her parents pass away she will end up being responsible for her brother. I know that autism can't be picked up before birth & the other disabilities aren't life threatening but they are life changing for any parent. I would support any woman choosing abortion if she found out she was carrying a disabled child.

Legallypinkish · 08/11/2022 01:40

ElizabethBest · 07/11/2022 22:42

i have a child with disabilities. To me, he is the entire universe. I love him so much it hurts to write it down. HOWEVER, it is fucking hard. So hard. DH and I have consciously chosen not to have more children in case they too are disabled and I 100% would have an abortion if I became pregnant again.

My life would not be better without DS in it because he is here and I know and love him, and I’ve counted his little freckles and seen him fall off the sofa because he laughed so hard at Andy and the Oddsocks, and watched him scream with joy on his first carousel ride and danced with him to abba. He has a lovely life and I love having him in my life. But knowing all the heartache and stress and sleeplessness and feelings of constant worry and failure that go alongside being a disability parent, if I could choose not to have children back before I had him, I probably would choose to remain childless.

Again, if DS had been born into a different family, who couldn’t cope with his very extensive needs, his life would be very different. That is exactly why we need to allow women to have their own individual right to choose and that needs to be protected.

I feel the same. My son is now an adult. He’s amazing but his life is hard and Our lives are absolutely nothing like I imagined either. Our other children have had lives completely different to their peers. They love their brother and despite being younger than him they are very protective. They’ve missed out of loads though, no holidays, no days out, no family get togethers, never been able to have friends round and of course our time with them has been very limited. They’ve grown into amazing young people though and are very self sufficient. Had I known before I had kids how things would turn out I’d never had had children. None of my other children ever talk about having their own children either. The eldest is mid 30’s and she definitely doesn’t want any.

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 01:34

moonypadfootprongs · 07/11/2022 23:57

Exactly. If your unborn baby is diagnosed with Down Syndrome it is assumed immediately that you will choose to abort. Indeed a friend who chose to keep her child was heavily pressured by medics around her who told her effectively what a burden her child would be.
Her child is thriving. They are a much loved and cherished member of their family. She is healthy and is most definitely not a burden. Based on how she is doing now she may well be able to live independently and work. Her life is valid.

Of course her life is valid. Some women choosing termination does not have any bearing on the value of a life of a person who has nothing to do with them.

DayOfTheTentacle · 08/11/2022 01:24

I have had two late term TFMRs (also known as compassionate induction). One post 21w, my baby was born live, wr were utterly blessed to meet then earthside.

People comment on the morality of it without being able to comprehend the sheer scale of the horror and grief. What they think they would do.

Not a single woman, family, who "choose" TFMR do it lightly it without considering every single side of the coin, every iota of what their child's life could be, good and bad.

Every woman who has to TFMR does so because they don't want their child to suffer. It is pure love. There is no hell like it.

Women deserve to have the time, and the space to make those impossible choices for their baby, themselves, their families.

The ripples of grief and loss come every day, and last a life time, and that's without the judgement from others. Having to be careful what you share, how you share it.

As early as possible, as late as necessary.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/11/2022 01:21

I personally do not think it's okay to use abortion as a form of "regular" contraception, if you're choosing to not be safe and "wing" it when it comes to having sex - like some people I know have done previously, then there will obviously be consequences.

Ugh this old chestnut.

Abortion isn’t contraception. Contraception is pregnancy prevention. And literallly now women say “Let’s bit use a condom because if I get pregnant I’ll just have an abortion”. I don’t believe for a minute that’s ever happened

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:21

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet and how well has that worked out in societies where its allowed?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/11/2022 01:16

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:36

I am pro choice but there has to be a line drawn I can’t see how anyone would abort just because they don’t want a baby of a specific gender. Medical
conditions affecting one gender only aside I just can’t see how it is right to abort based on gender preference

But why do you get to be the judge of what’s right and wrong? Another person will strongly argue that medical reasons are immoral too.

So it’s best just to be black and white: “Yes you can about. For any reason”

The end

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 08/11/2022 01:15

ClocksGoingBackwards · 07/11/2022 22:36

I’m all for women’s rights to reproductive autonomy, but you have to have a heart of stone and be very closed minded if you can’t at least see where this lady is coming from. She’s not trying to take rights away, she’s making the point that her life is still well worth living even if she has a disability.

And no one said it is t.

Taking rights away is exactly what she wants to do.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 00:49

@stuntbubbles Im pretty sick of extremists of all persuasions screaming "no debate".

We do not live in a society with full bodily autonomy. We cannot sell our organs. We do not practice euthanasia. We place restrictions on termination and surrogacy. You may believe that such restrictions are unnecessary, or you might favour some but not others, but who the hell are you to say they are not open for discussion?

It is possible to tell very early in pregnancy whether a fetus is male or female. If in a few years some company wants to offer an 8 week blood test and termination if you don't like the result combi deal I will oppose it. I won't pretend though that there is no debate to be had.

minipie · 08/11/2022 00:46

Thank you LangCleg. Quite.

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 00:42

Maybe it’s not their main aim (though I am still willing to bet that they have some sort of funding/backing from pro life groups).

https://makingrightsmakesense.wordpress.com/2022/01/21/a-cunning-fox/

minipie · 08/11/2022 00:32

so I suspect the campaigners, rather than wishing to restrict anyone’s right to an abortion, simply chose the option which has the most chance of success

But what they are campaigning for IS a restriction on rights to abortion. No way around that. And they realise this full well.

Maybe it’s not their main aim (though I am still willing to bet that they have some sort of funding/backing from pro life groups). But they’ve decided that making things equal for disabled foetuses is more important than preserving current abortion rights.

I do actually agree that the current law is ableist. But I can’t get on board with this as a solution. Extend the deadline for all.

SarahAndQuack · 08/11/2022 00:29

I don't agree there should be a limit on abortion, so I agree it is wrong that there's a limit that differs depending on diagnoses of conditions in utero.

But, if we accept - or feel we can't challenge - the idea that abortion should be limited, I think we have to acknowledge that not every pregnancy is the same. It's one thing to say to a parent who happens to want a girl that, at 33 weeks, they really shouldn't have an option to terminate because they're carrying a boy. It is quite another thing to say to a parent who has a child who will die in agony during labour, that they cannot terminate the pregnancy.

CrazyDogLady2022 · 08/11/2022 00:10

The issue is, the abortion limit should be the same regardless of disability. So many people are already uncomfortable with the limit of 24 weeks (thinking it’s too high) I can only imagine the uproar if this campaign was to increase/extend the abortion limit… so I suspect the campaigners, rather than wishing to restrict anyone’s right to an abortion, simply chose the option which has the most chance of success.

I have a child with Downs Syndrome. I hate that the law says later terminations are allowed for babies like him. I also find the idea of late term abortions utterly abhorrent, as I’m sure most people do. But I also believe that women must have bodily autonomy at all times and so really abortions should be legal for anyone who wants one, at any gestation, whatever their reason. I also think that will never happen…

moonypadfootprongs · 07/11/2022 23:57

ClocksGoingBackwards · 07/11/2022 22:36

I’m all for women’s rights to reproductive autonomy, but you have to have a heart of stone and be very closed minded if you can’t at least see where this lady is coming from. She’s not trying to take rights away, she’s making the point that her life is still well worth living even if she has a disability.

Exactly. If your unborn baby is diagnosed with Down Syndrome it is assumed immediately that you will choose to abort. Indeed a friend who chose to keep her child was heavily pressured by medics around her who told her effectively what a burden her child would be.
Her child is thriving. They are a much loved and cherished member of their family. She is healthy and is most definitely not a burden. Based on how she is doing now she may well be able to live independently and work. Her life is valid.

minipie · 07/11/2022 23:42

KitchiHuritAngeni · 07/11/2022 22:00

If the law has to be changed against any perceived discrimination then it should be to extend the current limit for all pregnancies not to reduce the limit for anyone.

They aren't asking for that though, almost like theres an agenda against women's reproductive rights.

This is exactly what I came on to say.

Yes arguably the current law is ableist.

This could be solved by extending the right to abortion when there is no disability, so that the deadline is the same as when there is.

Funnily enough they’re not arguing for that. Shows their true agenda is anti abortion, not anti ableism. I wonder who is backing them…

Raddix · 07/11/2022 23:41

The fact that some people don't want to look after a disabled child is not an argument for treating them differently
Of course it is. Looking after a severely disabled child is a huge burden. Some parents commit suicide because it’s such a huge burden. People need to be able to choose not to take that on.

Amortentia · 07/11/2022 23:41

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 21:59

Is it true that conditions such as cleft lip is considered a ‘severe disability’ when it comes to abortion ? Is there a list of conditions classified severe ?

Actually, a cleft lip can indicate a very serious genetic condition. It winds me no end when this is used as an example. It’s only very recently that this condition can be detected before birth and the outcome can be extremely bleak for the child and family.

Swipe left for the next trending thread