Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
Samcro · 08/11/2022 09:36

all terminations should be allowed up to birth.

housemaus · 08/11/2022 09:29

cata09x · 07/11/2022 22:04

It is in New Zealand, they have some very controversial abortion laws including being allowed to abort just because you dislike the gender.

You should be allowed to abort for any reason.

LBB2020 · 08/11/2022 09:23

@Asher33 the screening test will show if you have a high or low “risk” (I prefer the word chance!) of having a child with Down Syndrome nothing else. The 20 week anomaly scan will check for physical markers (heart structure/length of limbs/nasal bone etc). Nothing can tell you the extent of developmental/learning delays

stuntbubbles · 08/11/2022 09:14

I don’t believe I am extremist, and I’m certainly not screaming. I simply refuse to debate my right to abort a pregnancy, because to debate it is the start of the road to eroding that right.

No one who is pro-choice, and wants zero restrictions on abortion, wants to see a 40-week gestation viable pregnancy aborted due to the baby’s sex: but we understand that (a) that would just never happen – who is making that choice, that late? Who is performing that operation, that late, for that reason? – but (b) if you restrict this never-going-to-happen scenario in law, you set a precedent for restricting all sorts of scenarios.

Saying you are open to all abortion, for whatever reason, as early as possible and as late as necessary, protects women. The law should be structured to trust women to make their own choice. Very few women have late-term abortions at all. I would argue that zero women have had or will ever have a full-term abortion on the grounds of the baby’s sex, and bringing it up as a “whatabout” is just another means of crowbarring open the “debate” on abortion to start restricting other rights.

Asher33 · 08/11/2022 09:13

When it comes to the screening tests, can they tell how disabled your child with DS will be? Or do they just know there's a high / low chance of the child having DS?

goldsparklyChocolate · 08/11/2022 09:03

Mandatorymongoose · 07/11/2022 23:33

@gogoldsparklyChocolate there have been a few cases where the court of protection have made decisions about if an abortion is to be performed or not (taking the choice away from the woman). They have generally been related to women with learning disabilities or severe mental health issues.

It would be under the mental capacity act usually that that choice was made. Although the mental health act may have some provision too.

The test for capacity is always the same, no matter the choice. You need to establish the person has an impairment of mind, then look at if they understand the specific decision to be made, if they can weigh up the pros and cons, if they can recall the information for long enough to make the decision and if they can communicate their choice. If they can't do ar least one of those then they lack capacity and the decision should be made in their best interests.

Best interests should consider what the person would want if they did have capacity. If there is any hope of the person regaining capacity and the decision can be put off until then then you should do that.

Few stories with different outcomes:

www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/11/woman-severe-learning-disabilities-abortion-judge-rules

www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jun/24/catholic-church-hits-out-at-court-over-abortion-ruling

www.theguardian.com/society/2001/oct/18/mentalhealth

In this scenario would the woman be informed - can it ever be done without her knowledge? I assume not as she would have to be formally assessed ? Or can a gp do this covertly somehow and that is enough ?

Tommyrot · 08/11/2022 08:49

Raddix · 07/11/2022 23:41

The fact that some people don't want to look after a disabled child is not an argument for treating them differently
Of course it is. Looking after a severely disabled child is a huge burden. Some parents commit suicide because it’s such a huge burden. People need to be able to choose not to take that on.

I said it is not a reason to treat them differently. Some people don't want a non disabled child either and would also see them as a burden but they aren't allowed to "choose not take that on."

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 07:16

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 05:58

The legal restriction of abortion in India is comparatively strict.

But the practise is not. Many clinics exist where you can find out the sex of a child and terminate if it's female not what you want (or what your husband/his family wants). The ramifications from that are not as liberating for women as you might think.

Hellothere54 · 08/11/2022 06:40

My mum chose not to have any tests on me as I was her first and they decided they knew the risks, but didn’t care. She did test for my brother as, they were both older parents so higher risk and were worried that the care of a child with high needs might fall to me as they got older or if they died. They are thankful they didn’t have to make that choice, but mum was glad that the option was there, if they felt they needed it.

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 06:06

MamGetUsOneOfThemToKeep · 08/11/2022 04:56

I agree with this ^^

You can't make a defined list because that is not how antenatal diagnosis works. You are trying to predict the medical future of a foetus that you can't see or touch directly. You are trying to make predictions about quality of life 20 or 40 years in the future from very limited information. There's rarely any black and white answers.

I think that facing a medical termination, facing the uncertainty, is one of the most horrible things that you can go through. I can imagine that having the decision taken away from you, made by people who don't know you, must make it so much worse.

BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 06:06

It's the wrong question.

UK support for people with disabilities, for families with a disabled child is dire. Absolutely nightmarish.

Improve that and you might see people less afraid to have a disabled child. But either way, I agree with as late as necessary, as early as possible.

sashh · 08/11/2022 06:01

Quote from the article

"Having Down's Syndrome is no big deal. We can do anything we set our minds to with just a little extra help and support."

Clearly shows she has no idea what she is talking about.

I hate that young adults with DS are being used by their parents and campaigners to talk about things they know nothing about.

Heidi Crowter is the same. I'm angry that she has been put on TV but I am also mad that interviewers treat her with kid gloves, if she is challenging the law she should be able to defend her position and, "It makes me sad" is not a good reason to change a law that protects women in extreme circumstances.

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 05:58

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:54

@Loopyloopy what about India? Or China? Both have significant population imbalances because male fetuses are favoured over females.

The legal restriction of abortion in India is comparatively strict.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 08/11/2022 05:57

Exactly. If your unborn baby is diagnosed with Down Syndrome it is assumed immediately that you will choose to abort. Indeed a friend who chose to keep her child was heavily pressured by medics around her who told her effectively what a burden her child would be.
Her child is thriving. They are a much loved and cherished member of their family. She is healthy and is most definitely not a burden. Based on how she is doing now she may well be able to live independently and work. Her life is valid

Her life is valid but not everyone wants a DS child. And no one should be forced to. Not all DS children are the same level

ChocolatRaisinz · 08/11/2022 05:50

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/11/2022 05:07

As a person with a disability and someone who chose not to have children because of that - it does properly piss me off when those rather lucky, privileged people with disabilities who got VERY lucky with their parents, who are minimally affected by their genetic condition... trundle off to be activists and speak seemingly on behalf of everyone else.

I don't see the 6ft 23 stone bloke who can't come out of his bedroom, has a severe heart condition, can't be left alone with women or children because he has no idea how to behave appropriately and lives a very frightened, uncertain life with his almost 70 year old parents (who are also pretty frightened about their lives and his future) campaigning... (not an invention, I know this person, he is a sweetheart but his life is hard to manage and hard to live!)

The only reason anyone needs for wanting an abortion is wanting an abortion.

Thats it, thats the bottom line for me - I'd be happy if abortion for that reason, any reason, were legal at any point.

Because as violent and horrific as a very late abortion might be - there is no comparison to a child leading a miserable life with parents who can't cope, or in the care system, with no parent at all.

Exactly ^^
I have met someone who can't not only be left alone with women or children, but also the cat.
Why don't they get these people on there to give a balanced view? The poster faces for this campaign are a tiny percentage of what the reality of living with that disability is like. However I also believe they are vulnerable and are being used.

ChocolatRaisinz · 08/11/2022 05:41

I would abort in that situation. I have even good reasons I could argue it , having seen disabilities like DS as they age, and the effect it has on siblings both before and after the parents death. I would have to abandon the baby if I was forced to carry it, or risk doing myself some serious damage in an illegal abortion.
however, what it comes down to is...:
Abortion is a highly traumatic experience, especially past 20 weeks. No woman would go through that without extremely good reasons. Reasons good enough that they'll be trying to do it regardless. Keep abortions safe.

user1477391263 · 08/11/2022 05:34

We do not live in a society with full bodily autonomy. We cannot sell our organs. We do not practice euthanasia. We place restrictions on termination and surrogacy.

This is an interesting and valid point. I'm always interested in the intersection of feminism where people are very anti-surrogacy yet are insistent that there should never be any limits on abortion whatsoever. I have no absolute views on either abortion or surrogacy, for the record.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/11/2022 05:09

custardbear · 08/11/2022 03:34

I am very pro choice. However I can't believe a baby would be aborted up til birth, what then? A baby can survive at that gestation, what do they do?
... off to read the article...

Its really never happened, it is so horrific for all concerned it seriously isn't a thing.

It is not something anyone is asking for on a whim, nor is it something any doctor would do without solid reason.

But the law has to be worded the way it is.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/11/2022 05:07

As a person with a disability and someone who chose not to have children because of that - it does properly piss me off when those rather lucky, privileged people with disabilities who got VERY lucky with their parents, who are minimally affected by their genetic condition... trundle off to be activists and speak seemingly on behalf of everyone else.

I don't see the 6ft 23 stone bloke who can't come out of his bedroom, has a severe heart condition, can't be left alone with women or children because he has no idea how to behave appropriately and lives a very frightened, uncertain life with his almost 70 year old parents (who are also pretty frightened about their lives and his future) campaigning... (not an invention, I know this person, he is a sweetheart but his life is hard to manage and hard to live!)

The only reason anyone needs for wanting an abortion is wanting an abortion.

Thats it, thats the bottom line for me - I'd be happy if abortion for that reason, any reason, were legal at any point.

Because as violent and horrific as a very late abortion might be - there is no comparison to a child leading a miserable life with parents who can't cope, or in the care system, with no parent at all.

MamGetUsOneOfThemToKeep · 08/11/2022 04:56

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 22:17

This is specifically about abortion after 24 weeks. At the moment there is not a defined list of what counts as significant disability to extend the abortion limit until birth. Obviously if a baby isn't compatible with life then it's not controversial but for other conditions, especially those with good life expectancy, I personally think abortion should not be allowed past 24 weeks unless in extreme circumstances

I agree with this ^^

GreenWheat · 08/11/2022 04:31

I think an important aspect of aborting because of a disability is that you find out quite far into your pregnancy that you are going to have an adult that will continue to need your care. That is a very different choice to wanting to have a child who then becomes independent and allows you to be free of caring responsibilities into your own old age.

custardbear · 08/11/2022 03:34

I am very pro choice. However I can't believe a baby would be aborted up til birth, what then? A baby can survive at that gestation, what do they do?
... off to read the article...

AntimemeticsDivision · 08/11/2022 03:23

Maternal love?

Fucking Hell.

What about maternal choice.

CHOICE.

What about women being able not to fuck our lives over.

What about that?

Coyoacan · 08/11/2022 03:04

I read an article by a doctor who explained how women abort out of maternal love and I've never forgotten it. Not everyone is in a position to give a disabled child a good quality life.

AntimemeticsDivision · 08/11/2022 02:47

I hate people with disabilities being used as a tool.

Abortion is an option.

It's a choice for women.

I hate abortion being seen as something that will hurt women.

Abortion frees women.

I've had five abortions.

None of them hurt me.

I keep seeing them as something that hurts women. As a thing that you won't get over.

It's very easy to get over an abortion.

It's not so easy to have a baby with a dickhead.

It's not so easy to have a baby with an abusive man.

A man who doesn't care.

Do. Not. Make. Your. Life. Shit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread