Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
Chouetted · 08/11/2022 13:32

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 13:09

In most cases people will know if a foetus has a disability within the 24 weeks and can make an informed decision. If a condition is a danger to the mother or is incompatible with life a baby can be aborted to term.

We more or less have abortion on demand up to 24 weeks.

Do we actually need any changes to the law?

Abortion purely on the basis of not wanting a boy or girl is so wrong I can’t see there would be many cases like that surely as it’s about as shallow as you could get and I doubt there are that many women like that out there

In certain cultures there is a definite desire to abort girls. When I was pregnant with ds my local hospital had a policy of not telling you the sex of the baby at the 20 week scan, so it was obviously a problem.

Just a look at the male:female birth ratios for various countries will tell you that something is going on.

I wouldn't be terribly surprised to find out that those who think it's abhorrent are actually in the minority.

nanodyne · 08/11/2022 13:25

I recently had a baby who, at his 20 week scan, was indicated to have soft markers for downs. We needed follow-up with foetal medicine who could not see us until 24 weeks due to case loads. Fortunately he did not have have any conditions but if we had discovered that to be the case I absolutely would have aborted. The thought that 24 weeks could be the absolute limit when the NHS is as stretched as it is and with no private medical cover available for such things is scary.

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 13:09

In most cases people will know if a foetus has a disability within the 24 weeks and can make an informed decision. If a condition is a danger to the mother or is incompatible with life a baby can be aborted to term.

We more or less have abortion on demand up to 24 weeks.

Do we actually need any changes to the law?

Abortion purely on the basis of not wanting a boy or girl is so wrong I can’t see there would be many cases like that surely as it’s about as shallow as you could get and I doubt there are that many women like that out there

In certain cultures there is a definite desire to abort girls. When I was pregnant with ds my local hospital had a policy of not telling you the sex of the baby at the 20 week scan, so it was obviously a problem.

PearlclutchersInc · 08/11/2022 13:06

I wonder if parents of disabled children (and those of very disabled children) are as vocal on the subject.

Have no doubt that it alters the family dynamic and not always positively. Some people cope well, others find it very difficult.

Mandatorymongoose · 08/11/2022 12:59

@gogoldsparklyChocolate

It would never be a choice just made by a GP to force an abortion or force someone to carry to term. It would always go through the courts given the seriousness of the decision and the person would be spoken with to assess their capacity. (There might be some room in this around if you have a power of attorney in place or are talking about someone not gillick competent but I don't know of any particular cases around this).

The mental capacity act is really clear that making choices for someone is the last resort and people need to be supported to make their own choices in every manageable way. Any capacity assessment is decision specific too so you couldn't say for example that because a person can't manage their own money that means they can't decide if they want to go skydiving.

People are also entitled to make unwise decisions (so I could decide to give away every penny and live on the streets, you might think I was stupid but unless I lacked capacity to decide that you can't take that choice off me).

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 11:04

Bretontops · 08/11/2022 09:38

This ‘group’ is alarming me with their reach at the moment. The High Court, meeting the Prime Minister. They lost their court case, that’s been decided (for now) so I’m not sure how they’re still managing such a high profile.

There have been many occasions where I have wanted to challenge the group members on social media but feel unable to do so as they often centre their argument around their own lovely child. And know anyone opposing it will therefore look heartless, because who wants to have such a debate in front of a picture of a gorgeous toddler?

They haven't yet lost their court case.

They originally made three claims: that the different time limit directly discriminates against disabled foetuses, that undue pressure to terminate is a breach of article 8 rights (private and family life), and that the different time limit indirectly discriminates against disabled people by implying their lives are worth less.

In the first judicial review they lost all three arguments but were given leave to appeal on their indirect discrimination claim. That appeal hearing was held in July and we are now awaiting judgment.

I expect they will fail again, not sure if they can go to ECtHR in that case. I think it might depend on the judge giving permission.

Mamansparkles · 08/11/2022 11:02

Given the screening for Down's is at 12 weeks, 16 at the latest, and the cut off point for abortion for any reason is 24 weeks, there is really no need for abortion for Down's to be allowed right up to 40 weeks. It isn't about whether you keep the baby or not, there are 10 whole weeks between the results of the screening and the usual cut off point.
Extending the cut off by 16 weeks right up to well after many babies are born for conditions that are screened for well before 24 weeks is unnecessary clinically (because it can be done in a timely manner before 24 weeks) and therefore discriminatory.
For conditions only picked up at an anomaly scan at 20 weeks that then needs further tests you would want a bit more leeway say up to 28. But everyone I know (including myself) who has had something picked up at 20 weeks has had it investigated in time for the 24 week usual cut off.
For serious conditions picked up much later you would want some flexibility in the law at a doctor's discretion, but for conditions picked up early like Down's there is no need for there to be one law concerning disabled foetuses and another concerning (possibly) healthy.

JusteanBiscuits · 08/11/2022 10:55

"Abortions may be performed after 24 weeks in certain circumstances, for example, if the mother's life is at risk or the child would be born severely disabled. Abortions where gestation is 24 weeks or over account for a very small number of abortions (0.1% of the total). There were 276 such abortions in 2021"

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/abortion-statistics-for-england-and-wales-2021/abortion-statistics-england-and-wales-2021#:~:text=Abortions%20may%20be%20performed%20after,276%20such%20abortions%20in%202021.

Idrinkandiknowthings1 · 08/11/2022 10:52

@SnotRag22 i am so, so, so sorry for both your losses, there are truly no words that can ever be enough. Please take care of yourself xxxx

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 10:50

@DayOfTheTentacle, @SnotRag22 and @Badger1970 thank you for sharing your stories. I'm so sorry for your loss Flowers

Bumpitybumper · 08/11/2022 10:47

Posted too soon.

Anyway, my point is that I can totally understand how someone that could cope with parenting a non disabled child, would not be able to cope with a disabled child. It is not a judgement of the child or suggesting that they are in any way less worthy, but it is about the parent's capacity to give the child what they need.

Although society seems tolerant and supportive , all too often there are massive holes in the care and support that the state system can offer and it is parents left picking up the pieces. If a parent knows that they are unsuitable to take on such a role then I don't really see how restricting their access to abortion will benefit them or the unborn child. It is a scary world to be born into, especially if you're particularly vulnerable and don't have a parent who is in a position and has the desire to advocate and care for you.

Bumpitybumper · 08/11/2022 10:38

I am trying to word this post as sensitively as possible but apologise in advance if I upset anyone.

My experience of having a disabled person in the family is that the experience of having a disabled child can be completely different and infinitely harder than have a baby born without a disability. With something like DS it can represent a lifelong commitment to someone that will probably have some level of dependency on you their whole life even when you age and your own health and independence begins to fade. The reality is that a lot of adults with DS live with their parents for many years and many of those that don't still rely on their parents to offer support with lots of aspects of life. Even those that are considered to be the most independent still need lots of support m

Bretontops · 08/11/2022 10:27

Heidi Crowter is the same. I'm angry that she has been put on TV but I am also mad that interviewers treat her with kid gloves, if she is challenging the law she should be able to defend her position and, "It makes me sad" is not a good reason to change a law that protects women in extreme circumstances.

I suspect this is why they have individuals with DS doing the interviews- they know full well they can’t be rigorously challenged and that it would be almost distasteful to do so.

OP posts:
Clymene · 08/11/2022 10:27

As early as possible, as late as necessary. Either we extend the abortion limit to all pregnancies - regardless of foetal health or we keep things as they are.

This is just another attempt to roll back abortion rights with an emotional twist.

sashh · 08/11/2022 10:17

Asher33 · 08/11/2022 09:13

When it comes to the screening tests, can they tell how disabled your child with DS will be? Or do they just know there's a high / low chance of the child having DS?

That depends on the individual. Eg one feature of DS is congenital heart defects some can be picked up on US pre birth, but not all.

The tests cannot tell if someone will be able to live independently or be verbal or incontinent.

The tests cannot tell you if the bay will be blind, or deaf or both. Or if your child will get Leukemia which is more common in people with DS.

Anon778833 · 08/11/2022 10:13

AnnesBrokenSlate · 08/11/2022 10:11

The governmental push to abort children with any kind of disability or because of their sex is about capitalism and economics. They don't care about women's rights. It's about valuing life dependent on what it can bring to the workplace. It's the exact same principles that put DNR sheets into older patients' files against their wishes and that lobbies for euthanasia even if extended to teens with depression.
Quality of life isn't just about whether you can work. A person's value shouldn't be judged simply on how much income they can produce or cost the state. But no-one is having those debates in public. Lawyers are having them behind closed doors.
Choices aren't made in a vacuum and the complete failure to discuss what people value in society is failing everyone. It allows people to ignore the shortfalls in funding for DCs with disabilities; the lack of MH support for teens; etc. It means billions can be given to the government's friends on fake contracts whilst families are told their DCs' care costs too much.

I agree with all of the above.

Anon778833 · 08/11/2022 10:12

XenoBitch · 07/11/2022 22:05

You should be allowed to abort just because you don't want to be pregnant.

With no limit on how developed the baby is?

Having read about partial birth abortion I do hope that’s not what you’re advocating for.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 08/11/2022 10:11

The governmental push to abort children with any kind of disability or because of their sex is about capitalism and economics. They don't care about women's rights. It's about valuing life dependent on what it can bring to the workplace. It's the exact same principles that put DNR sheets into older patients' files against their wishes and that lobbies for euthanasia even if extended to teens with depression.
Quality of life isn't just about whether you can work. A person's value shouldn't be judged simply on how much income they can produce or cost the state. But no-one is having those debates in public. Lawyers are having them behind closed doors.
Choices aren't made in a vacuum and the complete failure to discuss what people value in society is failing everyone. It allows people to ignore the shortfalls in funding for DCs with disabilities; the lack of MH support for teens; etc. It means billions can be given to the government's friends on fake contracts whilst families are told their DCs' care costs too much.

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 08/11/2022 10:09

And badger

💐so sorry for everyone who has suffered and is suffering

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 08/11/2022 10:08

Almost wish I hadn't read your post snotrag

Obviously I know it must be unbearably painful but you've written so eloquently, thank you

💐

Badger1970 · 08/11/2022 09:54

I had a stillbirth at 26 weeks, and it was a truly dreadful experience. Having to arrange a funeral and tell everyone what had happened then coming home without them, having all the usual post partum pain and then milk coming in? It was a deeply upsetting and traumatic experience and one that I'm still not entirely sure that I've truly made peace with many many years later.

I can't imagine that anyone goes through an abortion at that stage without feeling the same degree of loss.

It's not a choice that thankfully I had to make - my darling boy gave up the fight and we were spared the pain of having to make that heinous decision. I have enormous sympathy for any mother who has to do so.

SnotRag22 · 08/11/2022 09:47

It wouldn't, and doesn't happen that term babies are aborted, just because. Ever.

Babies who have DS, when their mothers choose TFMR are, overwhelmingly, born shortly after the dating scan. Anomalies that necessitate a late TFMR often can't, or aren't picked up until the anatomy scan, which can be anywhere from 18-21w.

When a mother chooses compassionate induction for a late term baby, it's because that baby will suffer and then die. And the mother cannot bear to watch her darling baby fade away in pain.

Once you have been through the anatomy scan. Then there's a very detailed and lengthy follow up scan in fetal medicine, and then often another "making absolutely sure scan". You are referred to a specialist medical team who discuss your baby's diagnosis with you. There is often a bereavement MW present. You are given the full picture. Sometimes tests need to be done another few weeks down the line, so you wait, and hope, and pray. And google, and find articles and websites. Any knowledge or facts that you can.

If the worst happens, and your baby continues to deteriorate, or their prognosis/diagnosis becomes even poorer, then you have to choose. It's not a real choice. You spend the time between appointments desperately hoping that their heart will stop on its own so you don't have to choose. It's already your fault that they're poorly, now you have to make this choice for them. The hell of it is something I can't accurately describe.

You have to give birth regardless. And you pack a bag for a child that will never come home, and go to hospital knowing that you will leave with empty arms. You take a fluffy blanket to wrap them in, a book to read them "guess how much I love you". Maybe the baby bubble bath you'd already bought and put in the cupboard with a packet of newborn stashed nappies that you picked up after your 12w scan. "Getting prepared" you thought to yourself at the time.

I was encouraged to have a D&E under general anesthesia with my second TFMR but was made aware that they were generally only done up to 15/16w so I needed to think quickly as it becomes riskier for the mother. I didn't choose that method with either of mine.

You are told that they cannot feel pain yet, not before 26w, they're not sentient, their brains haven't developed those receptors. And you take that and hold it and hope that they only ever know warmth, love, and your heartbeat. That they've never known pain, fear, hunger and never will

Between then and 22w you give birth without having to consider the injection.

Post 22w then it is offered to have the injection. Not necessarily for all conditions, some babies will not survive the trauma of birth regardless of their gestation.

You have to sign things to say you understand that your baby won't be given medical assistance etc and you swallow a pill to begin your labour.

You give birth to your precious baby, name them and begin memory making, hand and footprints, reading them stories, sing to them, just being with them. You apologize "Mammy is so sorry, she's so sorry my baby, she loves you more than you can ever know". And you carry your cold, dead baby up to a mortuary, you kiss their head, weep and hand them to a nurse who will place them in a cold cot . You leave, amongst happy, excited new dads with car seats, waddling new mums who are smiling, content. Then you begin to plan their funeral and start a life which is different from the one before. You are forever changed. You are not the same person. And you can never be sure, if you share your story, that the person won't react with disgust at you and never look at you again in the same way. You can never be guaranteed kindness in your loss and grief.

Nobody would choose this because the baby was the sex they didn't want or because they didn't fancy being pregnant any longer. Nobody.

It is unpalatable for people to imagine a fully formed baby being "killed", but you cannot imagine the horror of having to live it. These are not unwanted babies, they have been planned for, hoped for, prayed for. They are named and remembered and loved.

Curtayne · 08/11/2022 09:41

BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 06:06

It's the wrong question.

UK support for people with disabilities, for families with a disabled child is dire. Absolutely nightmarish.

Improve that and you might see people less afraid to have a disabled child. But either way, I agree with as late as necessary, as early as possible.

I agree that is a very important point.

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 09:38

Asher33 · 08/11/2022 09:13

When it comes to the screening tests, can they tell how disabled your child with DS will be? Or do they just know there's a high / low chance of the child having DS?

Testing can tell you if your child has Down syndrome, but not how disabled they will be ( although you can see some heart problems, especially later in pregnancy ). I think if you could tell, fewer people would terminate. I think most people would be happy to raise a child that was going to have some degree of independence - it's the other end of the spectrum that drives a lot of decisions.

Bretontops · 08/11/2022 09:38

This ‘group’ is alarming me with their reach at the moment. The High Court, meeting the Prime Minister. They lost their court case, that’s been decided (for now) so I’m not sure how they’re still managing such a high profile.

There have been many occasions where I have wanted to challenge the group members on social media but feel unable to do so as they often centre their argument around their own lovely child. And know anyone opposing it will therefore look heartless, because who wants to have such a debate in front of a picture of a gorgeous toddler?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread