Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:06

moonypadfootprongs · 07/11/2022 23:57

Exactly. If your unborn baby is diagnosed with Down Syndrome it is assumed immediately that you will choose to abort. Indeed a friend who chose to keep her child was heavily pressured by medics around her who told her effectively what a burden her child would be.
Her child is thriving. They are a much loved and cherished member of their family. She is healthy and is most definitely not a burden. Based on how she is doing now she may well be able to live independently and work. Her life is valid.

But you must understand that now every DS child thrives? And medics cannot pretend everyone is going to be like your friend’s child - they have an obligation to give parents the absolute facts. People are adults, why do they want to be lied to?

Peachi82 · 09/11/2022 08:03

We have declined any screening for genetic abnormalities in both pregnancies. However, I was alwys very relieved that the 20 weeks scan did show us an all clear.

I am not against the screening or the offer of an abortion, I am more pro awareness what choices the screening will give you and I'm pretty sure many people never thought about what they would do in case of a concerning result.
And the awareness that a lot of disabilities will present themselves later in life/cannot be screened for in utero.

It is a very difficult discussion.

sashh · 09/11/2022 06:48

PBSam · 09/11/2022 06:16

I'm pro life but don't think it's right to bring a baby into the world who will suffer and die shortly after birth. Obviously not good for the child and the parents.

No you are pro choice, just in limited circumstances.

If you are truly in the 'prolife' camp then you would object to the treatment of ectopic pregnancy, the morning after pill and the coil.

PBSam · 09/11/2022 06:16

I'm pro life but don't think it's right to bring a baby into the world who will suffer and die shortly after birth. Obviously not good for the child and the parents.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 09/11/2022 06:09

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 21:59

Is it true that conditions such as cleft lip is considered a ‘severe disability’ when it comes to abortion ? Is there a list of conditions classified severe ?

A cleft lip and palate can be really very severe, such as this case from Thailand (graphic photos)
www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/doctors-remove-eyes-baby-girl-9326889.amp

They are also very often associated with foetuses that have other problems too, and sometimes any one health problem would be reasonably resolvable in isolation, but several put together start to interact, compound and ultimately signify a syndrome of some variety.

I very much doubt you'd find a doctor willing to abort after 24 weeks for a relatively mild cleft lip and no other abnormalities.

Ekátn · 09/11/2022 05:18

I think it’s quite clear the campaigners are simply anti choice.

If they actually cared about the issue, they would be campaigning to improve services for those with disabilities or with disabled children. They want to force more women to give birth to children they don’t want, not giving a shit about the quality of life any of the people involved will have.

The families who are campaigning are usually in a privileged position where their/their childs disabilities has been well managed. Either due to their finances or severity of disability. They clearly don’t care that many families may end up trapped in poverty, not have access to support and treatments and therapies and respite care in or out of the home. They don’t care about the quality of life of the person with the disability. Not everyone has the capacity or resources to provide the care someone needs.

You only need to read the boards here where women are trapped in bad or, even, abusive marriages and can’t leave because their children are disabled and they haven’t been able to work. Because there’s no outside support available. School places that are suitable aren’t available. Support caters aren’t available.

There’s not enough support or help for people with disabilities or with children who have disabilities. Why are they not thinking ‘Actually, if society had plenty of easily available support for those with disabilities, and who care for those with disabilities, many people may actually choose to proceed with their pregnancy and the children that are born (and their families) would have a much better quality of life’

Because it’s not about disability discrimination. It’s about reducing abortion rights.

And yes, many use their disabled children as a shield to avoid being robustly challenged.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 09/11/2022 03:57

I think abortion law is exactly right in the UK.

sashh · 09/11/2022 03:45

lawofselfish · 08/11/2022 17:23

Aborting because you don't like the sex of the baby is abhorrent.

It's a 50/50 chance.

Shouldn't get pregnant in the first place.

And the families you sometimes get in magazines where they have 18 kids because they wanted a girl and the first 17 were boys isn't?

You are basically saying to the younger kids at least, you are only alive because I wanted your sister not you.

@LangClegsInSpace

I find that campaign sinister, they actually want more babies with disabilities to be born, I don't know any other support group that are campaigning for that.

ghostyslovesheets · 08/11/2022 22:13

minipie · 08/11/2022 21:05

Think you missed out a “not” there ghost Grin

Oh fuck! Yeah I did - I am not a forced pregnancy zelot!

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 21:36

Mamansparkles · 08/11/2022 11:02

Given the screening for Down's is at 12 weeks, 16 at the latest, and the cut off point for abortion for any reason is 24 weeks, there is really no need for abortion for Down's to be allowed right up to 40 weeks. It isn't about whether you keep the baby or not, there are 10 whole weeks between the results of the screening and the usual cut off point.
Extending the cut off by 16 weeks right up to well after many babies are born for conditions that are screened for well before 24 weeks is unnecessary clinically (because it can be done in a timely manner before 24 weeks) and therefore discriminatory.
For conditions only picked up at an anomaly scan at 20 weeks that then needs further tests you would want a bit more leeway say up to 28. But everyone I know (including myself) who has had something picked up at 20 weeks has had it investigated in time for the 24 week usual cut off.
For serious conditions picked up much later you would want some flexibility in the law at a doctor's discretion, but for conditions picked up early like Down's there is no need for there to be one law concerning disabled foetuses and another concerning (possibly) healthy.

The people who are currently attempting to criminalise abortion past 24 weeks in the case of disability are exactly the same people who have been campaigning against early testing for trisomies for quite a few years now.

https://dontscreenusout.org/

Like many other conditions, DS is a spectrum. A simple diagnosis, or probability of diagnosis, from a blood test at 12 weeks, is not enough to determine the extent of the foetus's likely disability. It's not unreasonable for women to want to wait until 20 weeks to get a better idea of the prognosis for their baby before they make a decision. Even then of course there are no guarantees.

But limiting abortion to 24 weeks for some or all conditions will likely result in more abortions for DS because the option of waiting for more info about their specific baby's health will be taken away. I wouldn't take that risk. (OK, women theoretically would have 4 weeks between scan and time limit but that depends on everything happening on time and even then it doesn't leave enough time for further investigations).

There should be no list of conditions. Abortion should be a clinical decision made on an individual basis between a woman and her doctor.

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 21:08

Ugh I wish MN would fix the stupid list feature or just turn it off.

LangClegsInSpace · 08/11/2022 21:08

There are so many strawmen (straw pregnant women?) on this thread it's worth looking at the actual law in the UK as it currently stands.

The Offences Against The Person Act 1861 outlaws abortion. The penalty for both the woman and the person performing the abortion is penal servitude for life.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/24-25/100/contents
(see S.58, S.59)

The Abortion Act 1967 creates a set of exceptions to the above law. It says:

'a person shall not be guilty of an offence under the law relating to abortion when a pregnancy is terminated by a registered medical practitioner if two registered medical practitioners are of the opinion, formed in good faith ...'

... and then it lists the specific exceptions. To summarise:

  1. Before 24 weeks, that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman or any existing children of her family

  2. At any gestation, that the termination is necessary to prevent grave permanent injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman

  3. At any gestation, that the continuance of the pregnancy would involve risk to the life of the pregnant woman, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated

  4. At any gestation, that there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped.

For any of these conditions to be valid exceptions to the law which criminalises abortion, two registered medical practitioners must be of the same opinion, formed in good faith.

There is one additional exception that does not require the agreement of two doctors in a case where one doctor is of the opinion, formed in good faith, that the termination is immediately necessary to save the life or to prevent grave permanent injury to the physical or mental health of the pregnant woman.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1967/87/section/1

We do not have abortion on demand in the UK.
We do not have a right to abortion. We are permitted one if two doctors agree.
There is no legal sex selective abortion.
There is no legal late abortion just because.
Partial birth abortion is made up anti-choice propaganda.

I think abortion law in the UK works reasonably well, certainly compared with most other countries. Despite the noisiness of this disingenuous group of 'disability rights activists' I don't think the law is particularly under threat because it's primary legislation, not case law as was the situation in the US when Roe V Wade fell. Also because we do not have a large, organised, religious right wing in this country and votes on amendments to abortion law have always been free votes.

But as long as there is a time limit, and as long as there is a specific set of conditions, these can be chipped away at, through private members' bills or through the courts.

I like the sound of NZ abortion law. It seems very sensible to me and much less vulnerable to attack.

minipie · 08/11/2022 21:05

Think you missed out a “not” there ghost Grin

ghostyslovesheets · 08/11/2022 19:58

Women who do not want to be pregnant should be forced to be

Her body - her choice

her reasons are irrelevant

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 19:51

Chouetted · 08/11/2022 13:32

Just a look at the male:female birth ratios for various countries will tell you that something is going on.

I wouldn't be terribly surprised to find out that those who think it's abhorrent are actually in the minority.

It's a problem in India and China, due to issues embedded in cultures there. It's actually illegal in India. This demonstrates that the answer is not to legislate abortion, but to solve the cultural issues that force women into it (gender equality in India, disability support in the UK).

Loopyloopy · 08/11/2022 19:35

Mamansparkles · 08/11/2022 11:02

Given the screening for Down's is at 12 weeks, 16 at the latest, and the cut off point for abortion for any reason is 24 weeks, there is really no need for abortion for Down's to be allowed right up to 40 weeks. It isn't about whether you keep the baby or not, there are 10 whole weeks between the results of the screening and the usual cut off point.
Extending the cut off by 16 weeks right up to well after many babies are born for conditions that are screened for well before 24 weeks is unnecessary clinically (because it can be done in a timely manner before 24 weeks) and therefore discriminatory.
For conditions only picked up at an anomaly scan at 20 weeks that then needs further tests you would want a bit more leeway say up to 28. But everyone I know (including myself) who has had something picked up at 20 weeks has had it investigated in time for the 24 week usual cut off.
For serious conditions picked up much later you would want some flexibility in the law at a doctor's discretion, but for conditions picked up early like Down's there is no need for there to be one law concerning disabled foetuses and another concerning (possibly) healthy.

You're assuming that all these tests work as planned. Things are often missed, unfortunately, as that's the nature of the tests. Sometimes things are picked up on growth scans later in the pregnancy. It is possible to not get a diagnosis of Down's until, say, 28 weeks.

NameChange1718 · 08/11/2022 19:28

HairyMcLarie · 08/11/2022 02:27

@NameChange1718 However, I’m not sure I can get on board with abortion of a baby that has reached term just because you don’t like the gender. How is that any different to euthanising newborn babies?

Where is this allowed?

I’m not aware of it being allowed anywhere. It was just in reply to the argument that if I’m pro-choice there shouldn’t be any conditions applied to this otherwise I am not pro-choice.

It’s difficult as the only time I would ever consider an abortion for myself is if the baby would be likely to suffer but I respect the choices of other women. However, since I’d never choose one for myself I do attach certain emotions to abortions (which I’d never share with anyone IRL) and thus would struggle with extension of the limit mentally but would also feel like I had to get behind it in order to protect the choices of other women. If that makes sense..?

Endwalker · 08/11/2022 18:00

lawofselfish · 08/11/2022 17:23

Aborting because you don't like the sex of the baby is abhorrent.

It's a 50/50 chance.

Shouldn't get pregnant in the first place.

And yet the majority of abortions in the UK take place before 13wks, long before its possible to know the sex. Only 1% take place between 20wks and 24wks which is when most people find out the sex. This would suggest that only a very small number of abortions are due to to sex and, those that are, are taking place within the parameters of the law.

As I said upthread, you don't have to like someone's reasons for having an abortion (despite those reasons being none of your business) but they have a right under law to make a choice for themselves exactly as you have a right to make a choice for yourself.

lawofselfish · 08/11/2022 17:23

Aborting because you don't like the sex of the baby is abhorrent.

It's a 50/50 chance.

Shouldn't get pregnant in the first place.

chaosmaker · 08/11/2022 17:17

The debate isn't even named properly. It should be pro-woman or pro-foetus. Those are the sides. Personally abortion should be for any reason and at any time. I think that women that 'use it for contraception' need to be offered a more permanent form of contraception (ie implants or something of that nature) and the damage to their bodies be thoroughly explained if they are repeat aborters.

When I had mine, the nurse actually said to me that I might not ever be able to have children because I'd had an abortion. I think she must have been pro-foetus but it was not appropriate at that time to voice her thoughts and as it was after the fact, would not have made any difference anyway. This was back in the 90's but still wrong.

Disability is life long and parents are not. The provision for disabled people in the UK is woeful and also something that you have to consider when going ahead with the pregnancy. One of the people I care for is in their 70's and the siblings have spent their whole lives looking caring for them. Something they had no say in either.

Bringing emotive preferences in just damages women's rights imo and gives the pro-foetus's more ammunition to interfere with our lives.

TooBigForMyBoots · 08/11/2022 15:05

Forced birthers are using disabled people to push their misogynist agenda and it's disgraceful. If only they would spend more time listening to the voice of women instead of voices in their head "the voice of the unborn".AngryAngryAngry

Rishi Sunak recently appointed a prominent pro-life MP, Maria Caulfield as Women's minister.Hmm Our right to abortion is under threat!

Anon778833 · 08/11/2022 15:04

CherryBlossomWinter · 08/11/2022 14:18

@AnnesBrokenSlate I also very much agree with this. In countries with strict anti-abortion laws they are not better at supporting families of kids with disabilities. It does not come from a place of care for the child with disability, it comes from a place of control over women and motherhood.

Exactly!! Also, such countries usually have the death penalty. So they’re not concerned about preserving life, are they?

CherryBlossomWinter · 08/11/2022 14:18

@AnnesBrokenSlate I also very much agree with this. In countries with strict anti-abortion laws they are not better at supporting families of kids with disabilities. It does not come from a place of care for the child with disability, it comes from a place of control over women and motherhood.

CherryBlossomWinter · 08/11/2022 14:16

BertieBotts · 08/11/2022 06:06

It's the wrong question.

UK support for people with disabilities, for families with a disabled child is dire. Absolutely nightmarish.

Improve that and you might see people less afraid to have a disabled child. But either way, I agree with as late as necessary, as early as possible.

100% agree with this.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 08/11/2022 13:51

We need to be careful of people from the US pushing the Overton window in the UK. At a point when there are challenges in the US, trying to make abortion rights a topic for debate in the UK isn't actually beneficial, especially when vocal 'campaigners/agitators' are trying to push limits that have been generally accepted.
Whether inadvertently or deliberately, what they are doing is creating space for a pushback by saying abortion is absolute (eg up till birth in all circumstances).
The bandying about of 'choice' is also a bit of a misnomer. If I tell you, you can order anything you want from a menu but actually there's only fish. I've given you the illusion of choice.
There's a deep-seated privilege inherent in presenting the illusion that choice is made independently in a vacuum - it closes down any conversations about coercion; about medical attitudes to disability; about how governments prioritise spending; about cultural and religious pressure (both pro and anti abortion); about workplace culture to pregnancy and mothers, etc. True 'choice' becomes a luxury of financially wealthy, independent, privileged, healthy women at the expense of vulnerable women.
As for abortions because of sex, they do happen. And until the underlying social and cultural issues are addressed, sex selection will continue to lead to a disproportionate number of girls being aborted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread