Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 09/11/2022 15:12

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:42

OK, it’s like comparing oranges and bicycles.

Surrogacy is using someone else’s body. The abortion only involves one person and THEIR decision only has an impact on THEM.

Surrogacy involves a woman consenting to carrying a baby for another person or couple. Just because the people she is carrying the baby don’t have to go through the hardships of pregnancy, doesn’t mean they are not involved or impacted. If a surrogate is told that the baby she is carrying for someone else will not survive she and the person and people she is carrying for are still impacted.

Georgieporgie29 · 09/11/2022 15:06

ElizabethBest · 09/11/2022 14:57

@Georgieporgie29 He really is! He's got the world's biggest smile, and a riot of red curls, and very flamboyant taste in trainers, loves sequins, mexican food, and cinnamon buns. He's passionate about 80s music, the Wiggles, Yolanda Brown, Andy and the band and Fireman Sam.

He also doesn't sleep more than an hour at a stretch, has no sense of danger or safety, and can be incredibly violent and aggressive - he kicks, he bites, he pulls hair with enough force to tear your scalp. He smashes everything he lays hands on, puts everything in his mouth, and bolts the minute he's not physically restrained. He's been in and out of hospital all his life and I've had to give him CPR leading to my having severe PTSD.

Children and adults with SEN can do all the amazing things and have all the amazing qualities in my first paragraph. BUT everything in the second paragraph can be completely soul destroying and nobody should be forced to choose it.

💐❤️ much love to you. I can only imagine how difficult life is for all of you. You sound like an absolutely amazing parent.

ElizabethBest · 09/11/2022 14:57

@Georgieporgie29 He really is! He's got the world's biggest smile, and a riot of red curls, and very flamboyant taste in trainers, loves sequins, mexican food, and cinnamon buns. He's passionate about 80s music, the Wiggles, Yolanda Brown, Andy and the band and Fireman Sam.

He also doesn't sleep more than an hour at a stretch, has no sense of danger or safety, and can be incredibly violent and aggressive - he kicks, he bites, he pulls hair with enough force to tear your scalp. He smashes everything he lays hands on, puts everything in his mouth, and bolts the minute he's not physically restrained. He's been in and out of hospital all his life and I've had to give him CPR leading to my having severe PTSD.

Children and adults with SEN can do all the amazing things and have all the amazing qualities in my first paragraph. BUT everything in the second paragraph can be completely soul destroying and nobody should be forced to choose it.

HotCoffee22 · 09/11/2022 13:19

DayOfTheTentacle · 08/11/2022 01:24

I have had two late term TFMRs (also known as compassionate induction). One post 21w, my baby was born live, wr were utterly blessed to meet then earthside.

People comment on the morality of it without being able to comprehend the sheer scale of the horror and grief. What they think they would do.

Not a single woman, family, who "choose" TFMR do it lightly it without considering every single side of the coin, every iota of what their child's life could be, good and bad.

Every woman who has to TFMR does so because they don't want their child to suffer. It is pure love. There is no hell like it.

Women deserve to have the time, and the space to make those impossible choices for their baby, themselves, their families.

The ripples of grief and loss come every day, and last a life time, and that's without the judgement from others. Having to be careful what you share, how you share it.

As early as possible, as late as necessary.

I’m so sorry for your experience. Thank you for sharing that. It’s so important. This is not a choice - it’s the lesser of two evils.

LangClegsInSpace · 09/11/2022 13:17

Foetuses do not have rights. Human rights begin at birth. That's why most of the claims in the Judicial Review were rejected and why they were only given leave to appeal on their claim that the different time limit indirectly discriminates against disabled people who have already been born.

Granting human rights (i.e. personhood) to foetuses is a slippery slope which never turns out well for women.

You can still have laws governing how foetuses are treated, just as we have laws about how embryos and human gametes must be treated in research labs and IVF clinics.

Onlyforcake · 09/11/2022 13:11

It's another way that pressure groups want to put the fetus above the mental health of the mother or parents. I don't think this will ever be resolved because women are very much of lower importance to these people.

EntertainMe2022 · 09/11/2022 13:08

Schroedingersimmigrant · 07/11/2022 22:13

Well Millie there will not be the one caring 24/7 for a child with disability. It's not for everyone, not everyone can do it and survive it intact.

Precisely. I have first hand experience of a disabled child who will require round the clock, life long care, supervision and never have any sort of independence. Sedated to keep them on a level. They are not worthless but there is a cost both financially and mentally to their parents. Millie isn’t representative of every child brown with DS. Many have other Co-morbidities which make their lives far more complex and challenging.

I feel very uncomfortable about full term abortion but strongly believe this should be a discussion between a doctor(s) and their patients.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 13:03

A foetus may have rights, maybe be considered ‘alive’ and may be considered important - it the woman’s rights, life and importance trumps that of the foetus. Every. Single. Time.

LemonDrop22 · 09/11/2022 13:01

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 22:46

I personally do not think it's okay to use abortion as a form of "regular" contraception

I just don’t get this. Either a foetus is a full human and so has rights or it is not and therefore does not. I can understand those on both extremes of the argument about abortion, but I don’t understand the “women have rights over their own bodies, but only if I think their reasons are good enough” argument. At some stage you surely have to decide - does a foetus have personhood or not?

Either a foetus is a full human and so has rights or it is not and therefore does not.

That's incredibly binary and overly simplistic.

Perhaps they have rights when they are viable outside the womb, or any other number of interpretations.

Branleuse · 09/11/2022 12:56

That poor woman has been groomed into believing that women who have abortions for medical reasons would wish that she herself hadnt been born. Theyve made her take it personally. Its cruel to her and its not even true.

TooBigForMyBoots · 09/11/2022 12:55

Not when it comes to abortion rights that only impact one section of the general public. What is worrying is that he has also appointed a prominent pro-life MP who wants to be the voice of the unborn to Women's minister.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 12:50

I personally am 100% pro choice but I see no reason why he shouldn't meet with her. At the end of the day the prime minister is a public servant and needs to listen to and serve the entire public so part of that is bound to be listening to concerns people may have regardless of topic. If they only meet with and speak with one section of the general public then to me that would be problematic in itself?

AllOfThemWitches · 09/11/2022 12:49

Parenting a severely disabled child is fucking HARD. I love my son more than anything but I would not choose to have another child with additional needs. Or at all tbh.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:44

It’s interesting isn’t it how these groups aren’t advocating for better lifelong care and provision for disabled children. They aren’t fighting to make it so much easier to have a disabled child, and you can say “Would you struggle to cope? Fear not - we have a world class infrastructure, with a commitment to the next 200 years, so your struggles are kept to an absolute minimum and that’s guaranteed”. We have nothing like that now - but that’s not what these groups are fighting for. They just want to damage women.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:42

phoenixrosehere · 09/11/2022 12:34

And apples and oranges are both fruit. Surrogacy and abortion still involve consent of a pregnant woman regardless if the woman is raising the baby or not. A woman’s body is still the centre of it all.

OK, it’s like comparing oranges and bicycles.

Surrogacy is using someone else’s body. The abortion only involves one person and THEIR decision only has an impact on THEM.

phoenixrosehere · 09/11/2022 12:34

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:24

Surrogacy involves using another woman’s body. Abortion literally only affects the woman having the abortion.

Its like comparing apples with oranges

And apples and oranges are both fruit. Surrogacy and abortion still involve consent of a pregnant woman regardless if the woman is raising the baby or not. A woman’s body is still the centre of it all.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:29

Re the (imaginary) scenario where a woman aborts a term pregnancy because of gender: it makes me feel uncomfortable and I very much wouldn’t make that choice.

However I’m not arrogant enough to think I’m judge and jury of what’s right and wrong so have no interest in restricting abortion for the reason because it just opens the door to be subjective about what is a ‘wrong’ reason for abortion. And before you know it, abortion is unavailable altogether

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:27

Anon778833 · 08/11/2022 10:12

With no limit on how developed the baby is?

Having read about partial birth abortion I do hope that’s not what you’re advocating for.

You shouldn’t read a load of crap then.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 12:24

stuntbubbles · 08/11/2022 09:14

I don’t believe I am extremist, and I’m certainly not screaming. I simply refuse to debate my right to abort a pregnancy, because to debate it is the start of the road to eroding that right.

No one who is pro-choice, and wants zero restrictions on abortion, wants to see a 40-week gestation viable pregnancy aborted due to the baby’s sex: but we understand that (a) that would just never happen – who is making that choice, that late? Who is performing that operation, that late, for that reason? – but (b) if you restrict this never-going-to-happen scenario in law, you set a precedent for restricting all sorts of scenarios.

Saying you are open to all abortion, for whatever reason, as early as possible and as late as necessary, protects women. The law should be structured to trust women to make their own choice. Very few women have late-term abortions at all. I would argue that zero women have had or will ever have a full-term abortion on the grounds of the baby’s sex, and bringing it up as a “whatabout” is just another means of crowbarring open the “debate” on abortion to start restricting other rights.

This is an excellent post and summarises my feelings also, absolutely spot on!

I will never, ever debate mine or my daughter’s right to our OWN bodily autonomy.

Georgieporgie29 · 09/11/2022 10:40

SnotRag22 · 08/11/2022 09:47

It wouldn't, and doesn't happen that term babies are aborted, just because. Ever.

Babies who have DS, when their mothers choose TFMR are, overwhelmingly, born shortly after the dating scan. Anomalies that necessitate a late TFMR often can't, or aren't picked up until the anatomy scan, which can be anywhere from 18-21w.

When a mother chooses compassionate induction for a late term baby, it's because that baby will suffer and then die. And the mother cannot bear to watch her darling baby fade away in pain.

Once you have been through the anatomy scan. Then there's a very detailed and lengthy follow up scan in fetal medicine, and then often another "making absolutely sure scan". You are referred to a specialist medical team who discuss your baby's diagnosis with you. There is often a bereavement MW present. You are given the full picture. Sometimes tests need to be done another few weeks down the line, so you wait, and hope, and pray. And google, and find articles and websites. Any knowledge or facts that you can.

If the worst happens, and your baby continues to deteriorate, or their prognosis/diagnosis becomes even poorer, then you have to choose. It's not a real choice. You spend the time between appointments desperately hoping that their heart will stop on its own so you don't have to choose. It's already your fault that they're poorly, now you have to make this choice for them. The hell of it is something I can't accurately describe.

You have to give birth regardless. And you pack a bag for a child that will never come home, and go to hospital knowing that you will leave with empty arms. You take a fluffy blanket to wrap them in, a book to read them "guess how much I love you". Maybe the baby bubble bath you'd already bought and put in the cupboard with a packet of newborn stashed nappies that you picked up after your 12w scan. "Getting prepared" you thought to yourself at the time.

I was encouraged to have a D&E under general anesthesia with my second TFMR but was made aware that they were generally only done up to 15/16w so I needed to think quickly as it becomes riskier for the mother. I didn't choose that method with either of mine.

You are told that they cannot feel pain yet, not before 26w, they're not sentient, their brains haven't developed those receptors. And you take that and hold it and hope that they only ever know warmth, love, and your heartbeat. That they've never known pain, fear, hunger and never will

Between then and 22w you give birth without having to consider the injection.

Post 22w then it is offered to have the injection. Not necessarily for all conditions, some babies will not survive the trauma of birth regardless of their gestation.

You have to sign things to say you understand that your baby won't be given medical assistance etc and you swallow a pill to begin your labour.

You give birth to your precious baby, name them and begin memory making, hand and footprints, reading them stories, sing to them, just being with them. You apologize "Mammy is so sorry, she's so sorry my baby, she loves you more than you can ever know". And you carry your cold, dead baby up to a mortuary, you kiss their head, weep and hand them to a nurse who will place them in a cold cot . You leave, amongst happy, excited new dads with car seats, waddling new mums who are smiling, content. Then you begin to plan their funeral and start a life which is different from the one before. You are forever changed. You are not the same person. And you can never be sure, if you share your story, that the person won't react with disgust at you and never look at you again in the same way. You can never be guaranteed kindness in your loss and grief.

Nobody would choose this because the baby was the sex they didn't want or because they didn't fancy being pregnant any longer. Nobody.

It is unpalatable for people to imagine a fully formed baby being "killed", but you cannot imagine the horror of having to live it. These are not unwanted babies, they have been planned for, hoped for, prayed for. They are named and remembered and loved.

❤️

Georgieporgie29 · 09/11/2022 10:26

ElizabethBest · 07/11/2022 22:42

i have a child with disabilities. To me, he is the entire universe. I love him so much it hurts to write it down. HOWEVER, it is fucking hard. So hard. DH and I have consciously chosen not to have more children in case they too are disabled and I 100% would have an abortion if I became pregnant again.

My life would not be better without DS in it because he is here and I know and love him, and I’ve counted his little freckles and seen him fall off the sofa because he laughed so hard at Andy and the Oddsocks, and watched him scream with joy on his first carousel ride and danced with him to abba. He has a lovely life and I love having him in my life. But knowing all the heartache and stress and sleeplessness and feelings of constant worry and failure that go alongside being a disability parent, if I could choose not to have children back before I had him, I probably would choose to remain childless.

Again, if DS had been born into a different family, who couldn’t cope with his very extensive needs, his life would be very different. That is exactly why we need to allow women to have their own individual right to choose and that needs to be protected.

Perfect post. I completely agree with everything you say.

Your DS sounds adorable.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:24

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:15

That’s a by prodigy t of rampant sei sim and there is no reason for the rest of the world to suffer the impact of that by reducing abortion rights

That should say a by product of rampant sexism

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:24

user1477391263 · 08/11/2022 05:34

We do not live in a society with full bodily autonomy. We cannot sell our organs. We do not practice euthanasia. We place restrictions on termination and surrogacy.

This is an interesting and valid point. I'm always interested in the intersection of feminism where people are very anti-surrogacy yet are insistent that there should never be any limits on abortion whatsoever. I have no absolute views on either abortion or surrogacy, for the record.

Surrogacy involves using another woman’s body. Abortion literally only affects the woman having the abortion.

Its like comparing apples with oranges

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:15

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:54

@Loopyloopy what about India? Or China? Both have significant population imbalances because male fetuses are favoured over females.

That’s a by prodigy t of rampant sei sim and there is no reason for the rest of the world to suffer the impact of that by reducing abortion rights

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/11/2022 10:11

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 01:21

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet and how well has that worked out in societies where its allowed?

What do you mean?

Well in societies where a woman can abort for any reason it’s worked out incredibly well as that means a woman doesn’t have a baby she doesn’t want and literally nobody else is affected. I have no idea who has and hasn’t had abortions - and I NEVER need to know because it doesn’t affect me.

Do you think it’s worked out badly for societies that women get to do things that are nobody else’s business?

Swipe left for the next trending thread