Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/11/2022 22:33

LemonDrop22 · 09/11/2022 16:09

You can still have laws governing how foetuses are treated

What do you think the basic laws should be?

Incidentally a v late term foetus would be termed a baby if outside the womb. Literally a layer of muscle and a birth process between the two.
Why should they have no rights to life inside the womb but a right to life outside it.

Because you have to draw the line somewhere.

Being independent of another person’s body is a pretty good line IMO

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/11/2022 22:32

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/11/2022 16:05

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet surrogacy involves a woman making decisions about the contents of her uterus, just as with termination. Either that's ok and she should be allowed to do so with no questions asked, or it isn't and conditions and limitations may be applied to provide wider societal protections.

Ok then let me ask you this - why can’t I sell my organs? It’s my body, right?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/11/2022 22:31

phoenixrosehere · 09/11/2022 15:12

Surrogacy involves a woman consenting to carrying a baby for another person or couple. Just because the people she is carrying the baby don’t have to go through the hardships of pregnancy, doesn’t mean they are not involved or impacted. If a surrogate is told that the baby she is carrying for someone else will not survive she and the person and people she is carrying for are still impacted.

This is about bodily autonomy.

The bodies of the womb hirers, sorry bio parents, are NOT impacted by the surrogacy.

I can’t believe I have to point out the difference.

HotCoffee22 · 11/11/2022 21:05

whatkatydid2013 · 10/11/2022 06:24

The two friends I have who had late terminations were absolutely devastated their babies were not compatible with life. Both of them were diagnosed with Anencephaly at the 20 week scans (actually closer to 22 weeks in one case) and they needed time to process that news and explore if there was any real chance their much loved and wanted babies could be ok. In reality women who have late abortions are pretty much exclusively women who have just had the worst news of their lives at a scan halfway through a pregnancy they are excited about. There are already few abortions after the first trimester at all even though the current law allows them up to 24 weeks. If there really are women who would choose to abort after 24 weeks because they just don’t fancy having a baby and didn’t get round to doing anything sooner then I’d suggest you consider what kind of parent they’d make. I don’t think these women actually exist though. They are just a convenient construct to make us question women’s rights to bodily autonomy that are trotted out by groups that don’t want any access to abortion at all but know their true position isn’t likely to sway many people.

Heat hear.

pikiwop54 · 11/11/2022 16:16

I might believe this was just a photo op for him if it wasn't for his choice of minister for women.

Tommyrot · 10/11/2022 08:06

sashh · 10/11/2022 07:57

That's ridiculous.

Yes looking after a baby, any baby, is hard but when the baby needs to be fed by tube, hooked up to machines, have drips inserted. then there is no comparison.

If someone has a condition that means they need to be fed by tubes, have trips inserted then that would be covered under "poor quality of life."

sashh · 10/11/2022 07:57

Tommyrot · 10/11/2022 07:31

All babies need parental care or other care. If access to parental care isn't taken into account for those that aren't disabled people it shouldn't be for disabled.

That's ridiculous.

Yes looking after a baby, any baby, is hard but when the baby needs to be fed by tube, hooked up to machines, have drips inserted. then there is no comparison.

Tommyrot · 10/11/2022 07:31

GreenWheat · 10/11/2022 05:30

The only exception should be if the child would clearly have a very poor quality of life if born.

The difficulty with that is defining "poor quality". Some would say Down's means poor life quality. It's not as straightforward as deciding which conditions lead to poor life quality because some of "life quality" in disability depends what access to care the disabled person has, including parental ability to care for them.

All babies need parental care or other care. If access to parental care isn't taken into account for those that aren't disabled people it shouldn't be for disabled.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/11/2022 06:24

The two friends I have who had late terminations were absolutely devastated their babies were not compatible with life. Both of them were diagnosed with Anencephaly at the 20 week scans (actually closer to 22 weeks in one case) and they needed time to process that news and explore if there was any real chance their much loved and wanted babies could be ok. In reality women who have late abortions are pretty much exclusively women who have just had the worst news of their lives at a scan halfway through a pregnancy they are excited about. There are already few abortions after the first trimester at all even though the current law allows them up to 24 weeks. If there really are women who would choose to abort after 24 weeks because they just don’t fancy having a baby and didn’t get round to doing anything sooner then I’d suggest you consider what kind of parent they’d make. I don’t think these women actually exist though. They are just a convenient construct to make us question women’s rights to bodily autonomy that are trotted out by groups that don’t want any access to abortion at all but know their true position isn’t likely to sway many people.

PawPaworPapaya · 10/11/2022 06:12

I think it's important that the discussion about this issue includes what happens after these disabled babies are born. The two things should go hand in hand.

If they want more women having severely disabled children then they need to make some very drastic changes to support this. As far as I can see, services and support are being brutally cut back, rather than improved.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/11/2022 06:11

SnotRag22 · 08/11/2022 09:47

It wouldn't, and doesn't happen that term babies are aborted, just because. Ever.

Babies who have DS, when their mothers choose TFMR are, overwhelmingly, born shortly after the dating scan. Anomalies that necessitate a late TFMR often can't, or aren't picked up until the anatomy scan, which can be anywhere from 18-21w.

When a mother chooses compassionate induction for a late term baby, it's because that baby will suffer and then die. And the mother cannot bear to watch her darling baby fade away in pain.

Once you have been through the anatomy scan. Then there's a very detailed and lengthy follow up scan in fetal medicine, and then often another "making absolutely sure scan". You are referred to a specialist medical team who discuss your baby's diagnosis with you. There is often a bereavement MW present. You are given the full picture. Sometimes tests need to be done another few weeks down the line, so you wait, and hope, and pray. And google, and find articles and websites. Any knowledge or facts that you can.

If the worst happens, and your baby continues to deteriorate, or their prognosis/diagnosis becomes even poorer, then you have to choose. It's not a real choice. You spend the time between appointments desperately hoping that their heart will stop on its own so you don't have to choose. It's already your fault that they're poorly, now you have to make this choice for them. The hell of it is something I can't accurately describe.

You have to give birth regardless. And you pack a bag for a child that will never come home, and go to hospital knowing that you will leave with empty arms. You take a fluffy blanket to wrap them in, a book to read them "guess how much I love you". Maybe the baby bubble bath you'd already bought and put in the cupboard with a packet of newborn stashed nappies that you picked up after your 12w scan. "Getting prepared" you thought to yourself at the time.

I was encouraged to have a D&E under general anesthesia with my second TFMR but was made aware that they were generally only done up to 15/16w so I needed to think quickly as it becomes riskier for the mother. I didn't choose that method with either of mine.

You are told that they cannot feel pain yet, not before 26w, they're not sentient, their brains haven't developed those receptors. And you take that and hold it and hope that they only ever know warmth, love, and your heartbeat. That they've never known pain, fear, hunger and never will

Between then and 22w you give birth without having to consider the injection.

Post 22w then it is offered to have the injection. Not necessarily for all conditions, some babies will not survive the trauma of birth regardless of their gestation.

You have to sign things to say you understand that your baby won't be given medical assistance etc and you swallow a pill to begin your labour.

You give birth to your precious baby, name them and begin memory making, hand and footprints, reading them stories, sing to them, just being with them. You apologize "Mammy is so sorry, she's so sorry my baby, she loves you more than you can ever know". And you carry your cold, dead baby up to a mortuary, you kiss their head, weep and hand them to a nurse who will place them in a cold cot . You leave, amongst happy, excited new dads with car seats, waddling new mums who are smiling, content. Then you begin to plan their funeral and start a life which is different from the one before. You are forever changed. You are not the same person. And you can never be sure, if you share your story, that the person won't react with disgust at you and never look at you again in the same way. You can never be guaranteed kindness in your loss and grief.

Nobody would choose this because the baby was the sex they didn't want or because they didn't fancy being pregnant any longer. Nobody.

It is unpalatable for people to imagine a fully formed baby being "killed", but you cannot imagine the horror of having to live it. These are not unwanted babies, they have been planned for, hoped for, prayed for. They are named and remembered and loved.

I’m so very sorry for your loss.

GreenWheat · 10/11/2022 05:30

The only exception should be if the child would clearly have a very poor quality of life if born.

The difficulty with that is defining "poor quality". Some would say Down's means poor life quality. It's not as straightforward as deciding which conditions lead to poor life quality because some of "life quality" in disability depends what access to care the disabled person has, including parental ability to care for them.

sashh · 10/11/2022 05:24

Tommyrot · 09/11/2022 17:19

What lies are they being "fed"? They have been told that it is legal to have a late abortion if someone has down's syndrome (as they do) but not if they don't. That's true and I can see that it would probably be quite upsetting to feel that their lives aren't valued as much as non-disabled people. I personally think that late abortions are either okay (regardless of disability) or they aren't. The only exception should be if the child would clearly have a very poor quality of life if born.

They are told that people like them are aborted.

So they think all people with DS are the same as them, they are not told about the people who are incontinent, without speech, violent, deaf and blind.

They are told babies are aborted for a cleft lip.

They are probably told all the rubbish I was told at school / VI form (RC schools).

Tommyrot · 09/11/2022 18:48

I'd love to interview either of them, properly and ask them how they think a child who has no parents at all and lives in the state care system feels? Or how their parents might feel if they were in their 60's or 70's with little money and no external support. Or how they might feel if they knew they were going to have a baby that would live a short, painful life and might kill them on the way out.

Maybe they would say that non disabled children are also sometimes brought up in care with no parents or have parent in their 60s or 70s but it is still not legal for those children to be aborted late in pregnancy so why is it okay if they have DS? It is different if the baby would only live a short painful life but otherwise, I think late abortions are either okay (regardless of disability) or they aren't.

CherryBlossomWinter · 09/11/2022 18:41

ElizabethBest · 09/11/2022 14:57

@Georgieporgie29 He really is! He's got the world's biggest smile, and a riot of red curls, and very flamboyant taste in trainers, loves sequins, mexican food, and cinnamon buns. He's passionate about 80s music, the Wiggles, Yolanda Brown, Andy and the band and Fireman Sam.

He also doesn't sleep more than an hour at a stretch, has no sense of danger or safety, and can be incredibly violent and aggressive - he kicks, he bites, he pulls hair with enough force to tear your scalp. He smashes everything he lays hands on, puts everything in his mouth, and bolts the minute he's not physically restrained. He's been in and out of hospital all his life and I've had to give him CPR leading to my having severe PTSD.

Children and adults with SEN can do all the amazing things and have all the amazing qualities in my first paragraph. BUT everything in the second paragraph can be completely soul destroying and nobody should be forced to choose it.

@ElizabethBest you sound like a great parent, and a lovely son. Your story is the one we should be hearing, and the one Rishi Sunak should be hearing. It’s real, raw, loving and honest. I could write similar about my DS. I am coping and DS is thriving, but partly because I no longer work and have a lot of skills to help me. Other parents I know are not able to cope, I also see schools and institutions not coping and the kids are not thriving. It’s this reality that needs to be bought to the highest level.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/11/2022 18:12

Tommyrot · 09/11/2022 17:19

What lies are they being "fed"? They have been told that it is legal to have a late abortion if someone has down's syndrome (as they do) but not if they don't. That's true and I can see that it would probably be quite upsetting to feel that their lives aren't valued as much as non-disabled people. I personally think that late abortions are either okay (regardless of disability) or they aren't. The only exception should be if the child would clearly have a very poor quality of life if born.

That DS is the only reason - it isn't.

That they are wholly representative of the lives that would not exist if someone chooses to abort - they are not, they are the extreme end of a scale, the other end of that scale they are not likely to be shown, let alone imagine!

That the world wants rid of disabled people - I don't believe thats true, I think some people think that but some people think abhorrent things about any group you care to name.

They're pushed to make it personal and keep it personal - I could do the same, we all could - if our mothers had decided to abort, we would not be here.

It isn't a useful argument for the whole population though is it - because not every disabled child will be exactly like them, not even every child with Down Syndrome will be like them.

There are so many variables, but both these ladies show no awareness of them - that some people are much more severely disabled, some peoples parents are far less able or totally unable to care for them, that some people desperately need support they will never get...

I'd love to interview either of them, properly and ask them how they think a child who has no parents at all and lives in the state care system feels? Or how their parents might feel if they were in their 60's or 70's with little money and no external support. Or how they might feel if they knew they were going to have a baby that would live a short, painful life and might kill them on the way out.

But that would be cruel and unethical.

BaileySharp · 09/11/2022 17:31

Growing up my neighbours had a disabled child, it's not something that could have been picked up before birth in that case but I did see how difficult it made life for them. The child is now an adult but will always need parents or siblings to help them out at least a little (the eldest sibling already does quite a bit to help and will probably become responsible for sibling when the parents are no longer around). This mad me feel that if I had a choice, if I knew my child was likely to be disabled, I probably would abort. Sorry if that offends anyone, but it's something that affects the whole family not just the child in question and parents. Parents should have the choice.

Whilst I personally disagree with aborting for 'frivolous' reasons such as wanting a different sex, I actually would rather it be legal to do so to give women more autonomy over their own bodies

Tommyrot · 09/11/2022 17:19

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/11/2022 16:01

The more I read about these campaign groups using very highly functional, well supported 'poster child' DS people to front their campaigns, the more angry I get.

The ladies I've seen involved absolutely do not have the mental capacity to understand the complexity of the debate - they are fed lies, and set up to feel as if the world wants them to not exist.
I think it is truly sick that their parents have encouraged and supported this - they should be advising and protecting their kids from such organisations and such exploitation!

What lies are they being "fed"? They have been told that it is legal to have a late abortion if someone has down's syndrome (as they do) but not if they don't. That's true and I can see that it would probably be quite upsetting to feel that their lives aren't valued as much as non-disabled people. I personally think that late abortions are either okay (regardless of disability) or they aren't. The only exception should be if the child would clearly have a very poor quality of life if born.

LangClegsInSpace · 09/11/2022 17:17

@LemonDrop22 I think New Zealand's law sounds sensible.

The implications of granting foetuses personhood and human rights are well set out in this guardian article:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jul/04/marshae-jones-alabama-fetal-rights-alarmed

A woman was convicted of manslaughter because she got into a fight and was shot, she survived but her unborn child didn't.

Instead of being offered health interventions and support, pregnant women with drug or alcohol problems are convicted of chemical endangerment of their unborn children.

Women are closely monitored throughout pregnancy and drug tested without their knowledge. If they test positive for any substance they are reported to the police.

Theoretically, women could be prosecuted for perfectly legal activities such as drinking a glass of wine or playing sport.

Women who have a miscarriage or a stillbirth are placed under suspicion and if it can be shown that something they did contributed to the loss of the pregnancy they can be convicted of manslaughter.

Granting personhood and human rights to foetuses would also mean that unborn children could be made wards of court, with all that implies for the rights and freedom of the women in whose bodies they reside.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11648578/

Thats all before we get to abortion rights. You could be extremely pro-life and still think the above situations are terrible for women and should be avoided.

But obviously granting foetuses personhood and human rights would also have a massive impact on a woman's right to end a pregnancy at any stage.

https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v40/n10/sally-rooney/an-irish-problem

It would also allow men the right to advocate on behalf of their unborn child and to seek an injunction to prevent the mother from having an abortion.

www.womenslinkworldwide.org/en/gender-justice-observatory/court-rulings-database/paton-v-british-pregnancy-advisory-service-trustees-and-another-1978-qb-276

TooBigForMyBoots · 09/11/2022 16:57

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/11/2022 16:01

The more I read about these campaign groups using very highly functional, well supported 'poster child' DS people to front their campaigns, the more angry I get.

The ladies I've seen involved absolutely do not have the mental capacity to understand the complexity of the debate - they are fed lies, and set up to feel as if the world wants them to not exist.
I think it is truly sick that their parents have encouraged and supported this - they should be advising and protecting their kids from such organisations and such exploitation!

I completely agree @WiddlinDiddlin. I find this abhorrent.

Daleksatemyshed · 09/11/2022 16:57

Until there is way more help available for the parents of disabled children then no one has the right to judge a women for aborting a baby with disabilities. Unless these people are willing to help fund, or give care, for all the less advantaged families then this is not a fight they should win.

GrapesAreMyJam · 09/11/2022 16:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

LemonDrop22 · 09/11/2022 16:09

You can still have laws governing how foetuses are treated

What do you think the basic laws should be?

Incidentally a v late term foetus would be termed a baby if outside the womb. Literally a layer of muscle and a birth process between the two.
Why should they have no rights to life inside the womb but a right to life outside it.

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/11/2022 16:05

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet surrogacy involves a woman making decisions about the contents of her uterus, just as with termination. Either that's ok and she should be allowed to do so with no questions asked, or it isn't and conditions and limitations may be applied to provide wider societal protections.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/11/2022 16:01

The more I read about these campaign groups using very highly functional, well supported 'poster child' DS people to front their campaigns, the more angry I get.

The ladies I've seen involved absolutely do not have the mental capacity to understand the complexity of the debate - they are fed lies, and set up to feel as if the world wants them to not exist.
I think it is truly sick that their parents have encouraged and supported this - they should be advising and protecting their kids from such organisations and such exploitation!