Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 month old at funeral

139 replies

Jellywellyfish · 07/11/2022 19:58

My husbands grandad has just passed away and details of the funeral are being circulated. I would really like to go to pay my respects, but aibu to take our 10 month old to the service? My husband would sit at the front with his family and I thought I could sit at the back so I could leave if she starts being fussy.
thoughts?

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 08/11/2022 23:07

I did just that with DH and his grandmother’s funeral. It was either sit at the back with dd or not attend and I really wanted to be there. I did have to step out for a few minutes. It was not a big deal. I slipped out the first peep.

SirVixofVixHall · 08/11/2022 23:06

Yes it is nice. Babies help everyone afterwards when people are sad a tearful. My babies went to quite a few funerals. It wasn’t ever a problem.

MumofSpud · 08/11/2022 23:04

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 21:32

@DappledThings don't agree. One of the important parts of a funeral service is being able to hear people's eulogies. Pretty shit if you can't because they are drowned out by a child babbling, however cute you may generally find that.

I was surprised when I saw that my DH's eulogy was printed in the Order of Service Booklet

nocoolnamesleft · 08/11/2022 21:35

I remember my granddad's funeral. One of the few things that made it bearable for my grandma was the presence of a small cute great grandchild.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 21:32

@DappledThings don't agree. One of the important parts of a funeral service is being able to hear people's eulogies. Pretty shit if you can't because they are drowned out by a child babbling, however cute you may generally find that.

thankyouforthesun · 08/11/2022 21:22

@londongals we had my grandad's funeral videoed. He died during covid. Half his children and most of his grandchildren couldn't be there so a wobbly iPhone video was all we got. There is a place for most things even if they seem odd sometimes.

VenusClapTrap · 08/11/2022 19:49

DappledThings · 08/11/2022 18:32

I wanted to sit at the back, but was instructed to sit at the front with the chief mourners, but to take her out if she got noisy as it was a very formal, incense swinging high church affair.

She started babbling very early on and Dh gave me the nod to take her out.
Nobody needs to take a child out of any service for babbling. As someone who has grown up on a "very formal, incense swinging, high church" tradition I'd be amazed if anyone who was familiar with the church expected it. Children are welcome all the time at all the churches I've attended and some noise is expected. Those who have panicked about their child's normal noise and rushed out tend to be those not used to being in church in my experience

It was what the immediate family of the deceased wanted; the views of regular church goers don’t really come into it.

Survey99 · 08/11/2022 19:29

BuildersTeaMaker · 08/11/2022 18:10

What is it with this trend of keeping children and babies out of church ceremonies ..drives me nuts

babies, tantrumming toddlers, stroppy teenagers used to go to church each Sunday for whole communities until mid last century . I grew up in 60s where my dad was part of a lay community in a cathedral…I virtually grew up in that cathedral ..home work in the “choir”, being breast fed in the vestry .. doodling during sermons, or just staring at the gargoyles,. I’m sure there were times I wasn’t “well” behaved but most of the time my parents obviously managed just fine. There were always other kids about and even Christ himself actively encouraged children to be bought into his own sermons according to the bible

it is no problem having children in church. If they start to get noisy just take them into the porch and deal with it. For toddlers onwards it’s a firm boundary to say that everyone else is quite to listen and they can talk in a whisper or talk while every is singing. - but in my experience most even small kids clock something is different (echoing building and solemn adults does it normally) and “behave” in a suitable way,

it is important you are there - sit with your husband to support him . Pass the baby between you if needed. Try to ensure you have bottle/dummy ready . Change nappy just before you go into church- back of car job. Take baby with the full pram to lay them in . Maybe miss a nap to try to have them asleep but they make wake anyway. If they do start to fret or cry don’t panic, calmly take baby out to settle then return as soon as you can. Don’t fret about it.

yes you can give heads-up to family. But all church services are public so anyone, including some random off the street, can attend. That includes children of all ages .

Besides, the final justification lies in the bible : Luke 18: 16 “But Jesus called them unto him, and said, Suffer little achildren to come unto me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God. 17 Verily I say unto you, Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child shall in no wise enter therein.

so there!

OP didn't say it was a church, she mentions crematorium.

What is it with this trend of keeping children and babies out of church ceremonies ..drives me nuts

Then you have children in the service when you lose someone close, neither is right or wrong, and no one should be made to feel they are wrong when they are grieving. It is an individual choice for others and the feelings of the chief mourners should be respected above all else.

So (a much shorter) there!

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 08/11/2022 18:47

I'd take the baby. When DH's grandma died, she had 8 great grandchildren under 3. One by one they became restless and were taken out of the funeral service by their non-blood relation parent.

FiL - son of the deceased - sobbed his way through giving the eulogy, and says his heart lifted as his came out of the chapel and saw all his grandchildren and great nephews/nieces playing in the garden.

UWhatNow · 08/11/2022 18:47

FuzzyPuffling · 08/11/2022 13:40

I'm one of those who doesn't like small children at funerals. I honestly am not cheered up at all by a baby at such a sad time, and am glad no one brought babies to either of my parent's funerals.

Me too. Even the kerfuffle of someone clattering to take out a wailing baby is disrespectful. When I attended a family funeral recently, heartbroken and in the depths of grief, that is the last thing I would’ve wanted.

DappledThings · 08/11/2022 18:32

I wanted to sit at the back, but was instructed to sit at the front with the chief mourners, but to take her out if she got noisy as it was a very formal, incense swinging high church affair.

She started babbling very early on and Dh gave me the nod to take her out.
Nobody needs to take a child out of any service for babbling. As someone who has grown up on a "very formal, incense swinging, high church" tradition I'd be amazed if anyone who was familiar with the church expected it. Children are welcome all the time at all the churches I've attended and some noise is expected. Those who have panicked about their child's normal noise and rushed out tend to be those not used to being in church in my experience

Iamnotalemming · 08/11/2022 18:26

Sorry for your loss.
I recently lost my father and brought my DS, same age, to the funeral. A good friend offered to sit with him towards the back so that he wouldn't be upset by me crying and also so she could take him outside if he got too noisy and I wouldn't have to miss anything. Several people said to me afterwards how nice it was to hear a baby babbling in the room. Circle of life, etc.

Trinity65 · 08/11/2022 18:20

I don't think that is Unreasonable OP

You have already stated you would sit at the back and take DC out if need be.
Besides, having a baby there might be just what some Mourners would need.
Sorry for your DHs loss.

DoctorAcula · 08/11/2022 18:13

I took my 2 week old to my GDads funeral. I made the massive mistake of being boxed into a pew and couldn't escape once she kicked off. If you can scoot out quickly I don't see the problem.

VenusClapTrap · 08/11/2022 18:10

It’s a no from me. But I’m scarred by a horrible experience of taking dd to dh’s granny’s funeral when she was 18mo. I wanted to sit at the back, but was instructed to sit at the front with the chief mourners, but to take her out if she got noisy as it was a very formal, incense swinging high church affair.

She started babbling very early on and Dh gave me the nod to take her out. I had to walk all the way down the aisle, heels clacking, which was pretty mortifying. It was sleeting outside but I couldn’t get into the car because I realised too late that the car keys were in dh’s pocket. I decided to walk to a nearby cafe that MIL had suggested I could go to if necessary, but took a wrong turning and got lost.

It was a rural area, sleet getting worse, light fading, I had inadequately warm clothing because we’d been told to dress smartly, and dd was crying. I messaged and rang DH, SIL, BIL, but all their phones were on silent (obviously). Ended up sheltering in a bloody roadside shrine thing (not U.K.) until the funeral ended and they came to look for me.

I was blue with cold, dd was screaming the place down, and everyone was fucked off with me for causing a drama. It was horrible. I hadn’t wanted to take dd in the first place, but MIL had insisted it was the right thing to do. I cannot see how anyone benefitted from it.

BuildersTeaMaker · 08/11/2022 18:10

What is it with this trend of keeping children and babies out of church ceremonies ..drives me nuts

babies, tantrumming toddlers, stroppy teenagers used to go to church each Sunday for whole communities until mid last century . I grew up in 60s where my dad was part of a lay community in a cathedral…I virtually grew up in that cathedral ..home work in the “choir”, being breast fed in the vestry .. doodling during sermons, or just staring at the gargoyles,. I’m sure there were times I wasn’t “well” behaved but most of the time my parents obviously managed just fine. There were always other kids about and even Christ himself actively encouraged children to be bought into his own sermons according to the bible

it is no problem having children in church. If they start to get noisy just take them into the porch and deal with it. For toddlers onwards it’s a firm boundary to say that everyone else is quite to listen and they can talk in a whisper or talk while every is singing. - but in my experience most even small kids clock something is different (echoing building and solemn adults does it normally) and “behave” in a suitable way,

it is important you are there - sit with your husband to support him . Pass the baby between you if needed. Try to ensure you have bottle/dummy ready . Change nappy just before you go into church- back of car job. Take baby with the full pram to lay them in . Maybe miss a nap to try to have them asleep but they make wake anyway. If they do start to fret or cry don’t panic, calmly take baby out to settle then return as soon as you can. Don’t fret about it.

yes you can give heads-up to family. But all church services are public so anyone, including some random off the street, can attend. That includes children of all ages .

Besides, the final justification lies in the bible : Luke 18: 16 “But Jesus called them unto him, and said, Suffer little achildren to come unto me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God. 17 Verily I say unto you, Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child shall in no wise enter therein.

so there!

sjxoxo · 08/11/2022 17:57

I have a 10 mo and went to a funeral last week. Sat at back exactly like you said. Absolutely fine zero issues x

Blanketpolicy · 08/11/2022 17:54

A child that young will make noises and distract some people. If the chief mourners (the deceased wife and/or all his children) are fine with a young child there then it is ok.

If any of them have reservations they should be respected.

Moon22 · 08/11/2022 17:52

Absolutely reasonable. Nobody will object. Plenty of traditional funeral spaces; churches, crematoriums etc have 'crying rooms,' for this purpose. An if not, you just pop outside like you said.
Stop worrying over nothing!

bloodywitchescat · 08/11/2022 17:49

londongals · 08/11/2022 13:42

A video of a funeral
Really??????????????????????
Who on earth thinks that is acceptable

DH's was videoed because it was covid times and not everyone who wanted to be there could travel to it.

Workyticket · 08/11/2022 17:43

We took our 6 month old but that was at the request of the chief mourner (MIL)

MumofSpud · 08/11/2022 17:40

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/11/2022 17:22

A video of a funeral
Really??????????????????????
Who on earth thinks that is acceptable

Having a go at a widow's choices for her husband's funeral.
Really?
Who on earth thinks that's acceptable.

Thanks I responded

MumofSpud · 08/11/2022 17:39

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/11/2022 17:22

A video of a funeral
Really??????????????????????
Who on earth thinks that is acceptable

Having a go at a widow's choices for her husband's funeral.
Really?
Who on earth thinks that's acceptable.

Thanks I responded!

DannyGary · 08/11/2022 17:23

My grand-daughter (10 months) came to my MILs funeral recently.

They sat in the front row. She wasn't silent but she didn't cry/whinge and would have been taken outside if that was the case.

When the curtains closed at the end she clapped. It was lovely.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/11/2022 17:22

A video of a funeral
Really??????????????????????
Who on earth thinks that is acceptable

Having a go at a widow's choices for her husband's funeral.
Really?
Who on earth thinks that's acceptable.