Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the tightest of tight?

71 replies

Frightenedbunny · 07/11/2022 19:09

So I’ve seen this happen too many times now. Initially thought it was an oversight but I can now count at least 5 times it’s happened. Sister in law buys one of our children a birthday gift, if for any reason it’s unsuitable, she agrees to take it back for an alternative but the goods never arrive. She bought my son a game at Christmas, he already had it. She agreed to take him to shop to get an alternative, it never happened. She’s recently bought my daughter a jacket for her birthday. It was too small. My daughter was very polite and honest and said it wasn’t really her style. (She’s 14). She agreed to return it for a gift card. It’s now disappeared. We’ve seen her multiple times the past month and no mention of it. Just for info, she lives alone, very low mortgage and is financially secure.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Imisssleep2 · 24/07/2023 20:33

Most shops will exchange without a receipt, so I would smile and say thank you then seek to exchange it myself, if that isn't possible, sell it online and use the money made for something the kids do want.

purplehair1 · 11/11/2022 21:41

She may be very disorganised like me - my lovely sister had a birthday in August and I still haven’t sorted out her birthday present. Plus I’m sure I owe my nephew a replacement present for one which didn’t fit…. Hang on is this question about me?

Ibizamumof4 · 09/11/2022 08:38

Sounds like she is been passive aggressive. I don’t think it’s rude to say to family if somethings wrong (like I wouldn’t bother with small gifts for birthdays etc) but you need to say would it be easier if a) you don’t do presents b) you do money gift cards etc c) you provide gift receipts d) you give her a list of things they want with sizes etc

Welshmonster · 09/11/2022 08:13

Maybe say for future gifts no clothes as children grow so fast or say that you think it’s time to stop exchanging gifts with cost of living etc

MeridaBrave · 09/11/2022 08:04

It’s a gift. Smile and say thanks.

Would never expect someone to be taking stuff back. Regift or charity shop.

Shiningstarr · 09/11/2022 07:42

Just seen it's your sister in law, not your sister. So can your DH speak to her about it?

Shiningstarr · 09/11/2022 07:41

If she has promised to replace the jacket and game, then she absolutely should. To be honest, she's taking a bit of a gamble buying a 5 year old a game if she hasn't asked if he already has it.

Also, a bit silly buying someone a jacket - how do you know it will fit and is in the style they like?

It sounds to me as if she gets these 'gifts' for next to nothing, or perhaps she bought them ages ago hence not being able to return them. Maybe they were gifts for her own children and she's re-gifting them on yours.

I wouldn't be happy. It would be better if she just didn't give a gift or have a gift voucher.

I do think you need to mention the jacket and game though, just ask her when they will be getting the replacements. There's nothing rude about that. I don't think it's fair to do that to a 5 year old.

HuggsBosom · 09/11/2022 07:24

@Beachloveramy did she actually give the present back? Or expect you to pick it up?

Beachloveramy · 09/11/2022 07:21

My DS 4 chose a present for his cousin (6) and my SIL called and said he already had it and didn’t like it and asked me to change it.
I was offended, I thought how ungrateful.

For context, money is tight for me and I couldn’t find the receipt so I didn’t end up replacing it. Time passed and I forgot about it until now, maybe that’s what’s happened here.

If this has happened five times I’d think you were being unnecessarily spiteful and ungrateful.

elh1605 · 09/11/2022 07:20

But surely that's life.
I have 1 DD my friends and family have 2+ DC and I always buy them all gifts and receive 1 for DD. I wouldn't expect a gift for me or DH just because I'm buying them 2 or 3 gifts for their DC's.
I'm thinking the SiL is just forgetful but maybe it's time to ask for gift cards instead of gifts.

KirstenBlest · 08/11/2022 20:37

@Forfukzsake , you really think that a child wants to receive a gift of clothing 3 sizes too small that were bought 5 years ago?

Forfukzsake · 08/11/2022 20:06

"She was then told, they’d been in the sale 5 years previously!!"

Someone still gifted them to her. Is a gift only appreciated if someone has recently spent money on it? Sometimes people just don't have the money to be buying everybody they know a gift as well as buying all the children in all their children's classes gifts for their birthday parties.

If someone hasn't the money but has a gift they bought a while back in the cupboard should they be shamed for gifting it?

It's mean spirited.

Smashingpumpkins2022 · 08/11/2022 17:44

I remember when my sister was young, clothes that were 3 sizes to small from next- my mum took them back. She was then told, they’d been in the sale 5 years previously!!

runlittlemonster · 08/11/2022 17:28

If you mean telling someone you don’t like a gift and expecting them to replace it, then yes - that is embarrassingly tight

Forfukzsake · 08/11/2022 16:53

You keep giving her back her gifts and asking for different ones. Is she rude?

creamwitheverything · 08/11/2022 16:05

Smile say thank you flog them on facebook market place and give the kids the cash to get something else..job done no hurt feelings no confusion

RobertaFirmino · 08/11/2022 15:41

Just have a Martyn Lewis No Present Pact from now on. Saves so much pissing about.

Sunbun19 · 08/11/2022 15:09

Jumberoo · 07/11/2022 20:16

How can it be tight if she’s spent the money in the first place though? It’s more likely she’s disorganised or can’t be bothered enough.

My thought too, she's spending money on the original gifts without knowing they're unsuitable so she isn't tight

KirstenBlest · 08/11/2022 15:05

@donttellmehesalive , it wasn't great. One relative is notoriously bad at presents. It's not the gift itself but they don't seem to be matched to the recipient. They're not even the 'generic adult female/male type gifts' like the lynx or soap&glory gift sets. They are things that look like they've been grabbed out of the cupboard and wrapped. I've had the years old unused item, a man's top in her DH's size, a child's toy, a rather hideous designer top in her size but way too small for me.... Another relative got a cheap french press two years running, and they were not the sort to drink anything other than instant.

LicoricePizza · 08/11/2022 14:45

The alternative is that they can’t be returned for whatever reason - (she doesn’t have the re option, she’s re-gifting etc) your post implies she’s not overly thoughtful about getting sizing of your DC right etc when she has her own kids so wld prob know correct sizes etc.
Are you saying she just doesn’t care & doesn’t follow through either?

Either way - they’re only gifts & usually you make the right noises, are gracious & minimise any fuss.

Not everyone is going to do gifting the way you’d expect or want it.

What’s your relationship with her like in general?

I’d just give presents that are matched to hers in terms of level of effort & budget.

donttellmehesalive · 08/11/2022 12:27

KirstenBlest · 08/11/2022 07:55

@donttellmehesalive , I take it you've not returned something and been told that they stopped selling the item years previously.

No never. That would be annoying!

melj1213 · 08/11/2022 10:59

Frightenedbunny · 07/11/2022 23:59

@SwaffhamCurious I’m not sure where you’ve got that information from. It’s not a full family rejecting things. It’s the occasional gift that doesn’t fit. I’m not sure why we should lie and waste her money. We don’t pursue the exchange, she offers but never replaces the gifts as she stated she would. It’s only the kids stuff she appears to Mis-size. If she gets gifts for myself or my husband we gracefully accept regardless of whether or not it’s to our taste. It just seems odd to me. Personally I’d rather she never bothered with any gifts than manage them the way she does.

If it's just the occasional thing that doesn't fit, when she says "Oh I'll take it back and exchange it for you" then why not just say "Oh that's OK, we're going into town at the weekend so we'll just exchange it ourselves. It's so much easier for the DC to try the clothes in the shop and we can make sure it's the right size, and if they don't have the right size of <wrong size gift item> then DC can pick something else in exchange"?

When DD gets gifted anything that's the wrong size I always make sure I'm the one putting in the legwork, not the gifter, so I just take it back and exchange it for the right size or something else (and if the gifter asks about the item then I just say it was the wrong size and there were no right sizes in the shop so let DD choose something else).

The only time I ever get the gifter involved in a return is if it's somewhere that needs a reciept for a return, and in that case I just send them a message asking "Do you still have the receipt for<gift>? It's the wrong size so I was going to exchange it but the store says I need the receipt. Let me know and I'll pop round and pick it up ... If not no worries, I'll just get her something else and donate this one as there's no way it will fit her xxx"

Youdoyoutoday · 08/11/2022 10:23

Frightenedbunny · 07/11/2022 23:59

@SwaffhamCurious I’m not sure where you’ve got that information from. It’s not a full family rejecting things. It’s the occasional gift that doesn’t fit. I’m not sure why we should lie and waste her money. We don’t pursue the exchange, she offers but never replaces the gifts as she stated she would. It’s only the kids stuff she appears to Mis-size. If she gets gifts for myself or my husband we gracefully accept regardless of whether or not it’s to our taste. It just seems odd to me. Personally I’d rather she never bothered with any gifts than manage them the way she does.

So tell her to stop wasting her time and money then. You clearly don't want or even like the gifts she gives so just be upfront about it. No gifts this Xmas, we trying to declutter/cut back etc. If she does insist, ask for vouchers for the kids only.

knittingaddict · 08/11/2022 08:19

KirstenBlest · 07/11/2022 19:56

I hate it when someone says thank you graciously when they aren't delighted.
I have family members who do this, but another family member is blunt and will say 'so-and-so never wears that colour' or 'that garment you got so-and-so didn't fit' or 'your DParent can't eat nuts any more'

If they let me think that they like it, then how am I supposed to know next time?

That's how we would do it. Probably not over a colour we didn't like, but definitely if it was the wrong size or a duplicate. However it would be up to the recipient to change it if they could. We don't hand back gifts to the giver for them to sort out. That's where op is going wrong.

sunglassesonthetable · 08/11/2022 08:08

Everyone's present culture is different in terms of saying if things are suitable or not. And kids tend to be quite straightforward about things. " I've already got this"
and it's obvious if things don't fit .

But I don't think it's about the presents tbh it's about saying she'll do something and then doesn't. To Kids.

That's the kicker.

Not great.

I suspect she's bought them from somewhere they can't be exchanged or changed. That sort of thing.

I don't think you you should say or do anything really. They are gifts. Gifts aren't always what you want. Its a shame but It's more about preparing your children's expectations.