Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
Ballsaque · 07/11/2022 22:54

@Mnbvcxz123 I’m just being a bit sarcastic.

I have a lot of respect for the Suzuki method. As the OP thinks she knows better than the teacher then the Suzuki approach may be good for all of them because of the parental inclusion. They will be there to see the teacher in action.

Chickychoccyegg · 07/11/2022 22:53

Surely a reverse or more likely a troll? No set of parents can both be this stupid can they?
Off chance it's real....poor kid,I feel very,very sorry for her!.

bringincrazyback · 07/11/2022 22:51

Sure, what does fun & the social benefits of group learning have to do with the fact that you've paid good money & want instant results? Keep hothousing & helicoptering OP. It's not important that your child enjoys music & learning for its own sake - you need accomplishments to parade to your peers.

Couldn't have put it better myself. Op, if you're not careful you'll put your DD off learning music at all. (I speak as someone who had a very similar experience of music lessons, albeit I was older than your DD. But a very similar scenario in terms of pressure to improve, and it led to my abandoning lessons altogether.)

She's 7. The lessons should be fun at this age, and it sounds like the teacher is accomplishing this. I get that the lessons are expensive, but that's not a reason to be as desperate for results as you seem to be.

Hawkins001 · 07/11/2022 22:50

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 20:27

We are not able to sit in on the lessons as they take place in school.

I’ve found the email response from the violin teacher….

“we have been working on the fundamentals of music such as pulse, rhythm, pitch and aural skills through singing and musical games and activities. We have also learned to hold the violin as correct posture is really important as it directly effects the sound which is produced. The four strings can be identified as G, D, A and E and we are familiar with the concept of pitch from playing low to high (G to E) and high to low (E to G).

An introduction to bow has been made and reinforced through exercises holding a pencil. We have practised using full bows on the D and A strings and have introduced rhythmic patterns using crotchets and quavers. I have encouraged practise at home using a mirror to ensure the bow remains parallel to the bridge, I have also encouraged practise without looking into a mirror to think about how it feels to cross from the D to the A string and encourage muscle memory.

I place a lot of importance on getting the basics correct to avoid problems further down the line. I would recommend at least 10 practise most days at this level”

DH says it’s a load of waffle and DD should be playing tunes. We should get a different teacher right? I mean it’s supposed to be a violin lesson nota general music lesson

Let's say you get a different teacher, then it's same results, then another teacher and it's the same then what ?

Mnbvcxz123 · 07/11/2022 22:50

Ballsaque · 07/11/2022 22:45

You are the perfect parent to go down the Suzuki route.

Your DD’s teacher has given a very good description of her teaching method which in my opinion sounds very good.

You DH is talking shit btw

No no!
We are a Suzuki family and can assure you we aren’t like OP at all! Of course we take it seriously and I’m in lessons and practice with my children BUT we have a real respect for the teacher, a realistic view of what children can achieve, and certainly don’t aspire to creating prodigies. I appreciate that this isn’t what the thread is about but if anyone is reading and is out of Suzuki then please don’t be - get the right teacher and it can be a joy!

warmeduppizza · 07/11/2022 22:48

#teamteacher

DH doesn’t have a clue.

cantforthelifeofme · 07/11/2022 22:48

I mean it’s supposed to be a violin lesson nota general music lesson

😆yeah! Of COURSE you can play violin without understanding music 🤦‍♀️

BeardyButton · 07/11/2022 22:47

when I read threads like this…. My heart hurts a little for the children involved.

PaniniHead · 07/11/2022 22:46

Must be difficult to play the violin with hairy hands

Ballsaque · 07/11/2022 22:45

You are the perfect parent to go down the Suzuki route.

Your DD’s teacher has given a very good description of her teaching method which in my opinion sounds very good.

You DH is talking shit btw

Abundanceofcare · 07/11/2022 22:44
  1. Twinkle twinkle uses all fingers and has a string crossing. It wl be AGES before she can do that.
  1. The singing is crucial for pitching. Violin doesn't have frets like a guitar, so you have to use your ears to play in tune. If you can sing it in tune, much easier to play in tune.
  1. Mirror is essential. Violin requires an unnatural posture to hold. Bowing must be straight, you can't always see that from an angle, mirror is helpful to align elbow and wrist.
  1. No point in learning an instrument and not musicianship. Teacher is totally on it.
  1. I think group lessons are nowhere near as good as individual. Students get less attention and progress is slower.
  1. I spent more on violins (£500 for half size, £750 for 3/4 size) and it made a difference. Also a decent bow, not the shitty (and heavy!) bow that cones with the stentor I).
  1. Those qualifications are very high standard and not handed out like confetti. Some players and not good teachers and vice versa. Some are good at both. Qualifications don't really give you an insight. I think the teacher sounds excellent.
  1. We pay £16 per 30 mins for a teacher to come to our home. I would say that's cheap.

9.my dd started at 4. It took her 2 months of plucking before she was allowed to pick up the bow. She is 9 now, between gr 3 and 4. She makes a tolerable sound and plays in tune because....... she sang a lot, clapped a lot, used mirrors, practiced daily, had a nice instrument and wasn't pressured after 2 months to play whole pieces with string crossings and all 4 fingers!

  1. I don't think your husband played twinkle on his cello after 2 months, unless he started much later. Even on the piano that would be going some for a child that also had to learn to read music in 2 clefs.
BeardyButton · 07/11/2022 22:43

Wow teacher sounds marvellous. If you gave out their details, I d bet they d have a lot of business from this thread.

Not only is the work she is currently doing of benefit to your daughters playing it will benefit her health too if she carries on. Many of the people I learned with have repetitive strain injury as a result of playing. My wrists are a bit knackered. Violin especially - a good friends neck is not right at all. Good position is v v important.

Im genuinely baffled at your husband the ‘accomplished’ cellist. By accomplished you mean??!! Professional? Plays in an a orchestra? Teaches? Or played as a kid to grade 3 and hasn’t picked it up since?

ShandaLear · 07/11/2022 22:40

The teacher is rubbish and your precious child should be playing like Vanessa Mae by now 😂😂😂

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 07/11/2022 22:39

The teacher's approach is very good. Get the basics right from the start (posture, bow grip, bowing) so she doesn't have to unlearn bad habits later on. She needs to learn how to cultivate a good tone before she can play tunes. Once she makes a good sound, it all falls into place. The cello isn't the same as the violin. Husband can support her, but can't teach her. She needs a good teacher. Later on they will be able to play together, if she sticks with it.

titchy · 07/11/2022 22:37

Your dh is an arsehole. Does he actually spend time with her when she practices? Does he think she has mastered posture, bow hold, bow technique, rhythm, notation et etc? Perhaps he could get her to practice everything she has been taught and get her fluent by Christmas?

BeardyButton · 07/11/2022 22:37

You what now?! The biggest shocker in the is the accomplished cellist you feeds fodder to your fire. As an ‘accomplished’ (grade 8 and all) cellist… it takes YEARS before a students’ offerings do not resemble a strangled cat. YEARS!!! And even then, only the ‘accomplished’ ones will manage it. Honestly! I think stringed instruments may not be for you. Best go with something like the piano (grade 5 here). Sounds okish from the start and takes years to realise that actually the student will never really progress from ok to making the instrument sing.

ps, if that teacher has any sense they ve seen the humour in your reaction.

HoppingPavlova · 07/11/2022 22:35

DH says it’s a load of waffle and DD should be playing tunes. We should get a different teacher right? I mean it’s supposed to be a violin lesson nota general music lesson

And yet, your DH has not been able to achieve this with her whilst helping her practice! Given his musical ability he should be doing her lessons and responsible for her progress.

LaGioconda · 07/11/2022 22:32

DH says it’s a load of waffle and DD should be playing tunes. We should get a different teacher right? I mean it’s supposed to be a violin lesson nota general music lesson

Have you actually read the responses on the thread, including from those with actual experience in teaching violin to young children? Do you think they might know more than your husband? You have to teach basic music principles as part of the process of teaching any musical instrument.

Powderherface · 07/11/2022 22:31

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 20:27

We are not able to sit in on the lessons as they take place in school.

I’ve found the email response from the violin teacher….

“we have been working on the fundamentals of music such as pulse, rhythm, pitch and aural skills through singing and musical games and activities. We have also learned to hold the violin as correct posture is really important as it directly effects the sound which is produced. The four strings can be identified as G, D, A and E and we are familiar with the concept of pitch from playing low to high (G to E) and high to low (E to G).

An introduction to bow has been made and reinforced through exercises holding a pencil. We have practised using full bows on the D and A strings and have introduced rhythmic patterns using crotchets and quavers. I have encouraged practise at home using a mirror to ensure the bow remains parallel to the bridge, I have also encouraged practise without looking into a mirror to think about how it feels to cross from the D to the A string and encourage muscle memory.

I place a lot of importance on getting the basics correct to avoid problems further down the line. I would recommend at least 10 practise most days at this level”

DH says it’s a load of waffle and DD should be playing tunes. We should get a different teacher right? I mean it’s supposed to be a violin lesson nota general music lesson

Teacher sounds pretty good actually! Your daughter is lucky. I would be quite dubious about your husband's poohpooing of focusing on the basics. By all means your daughter should be playing little open string "tunes" and rhythms but especially in a group lesson it would be foolish to introduce the left hand before the students are set up well. Have you googled the teacher? Apart from the professional qualifications do they have some experience teaching as well as performing?
BTW practising every day is great and she should definitely do this, but actually be focussed on what the teacher has said and be supported by a positive environment at home. Please don't tell her she sounds awful and at 7, do sit with her in her practise and remind her of what the teacher has said to practise.

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 22:30

If you go down the individual route I hope you have deep pockets. DD's teacher charges £52/hour (diploma level though) cheap compared to her singing teacher, he charges £78/hour! (Disclaimer we don't pay it's funded by her course)

JonesTheSteam · 07/11/2022 22:28

Your DH doesn't have a clue about teaching, does he?

What do you mean by an 'acccomplished cellist'?

Does he still play?

lottiegarbanzo · 07/11/2022 22:28

The teacher's response sounds really clear and sensible.

Your DH sounds foolish. He's going to make fools out of both of you, if you carry on parroting his silliness.

He's clearly forgotten what the early stages of learning were like, doesn't know about violins, doesn't teach, has no patience for normal child development and no respect for professionals.

MapleLeafForever · 07/11/2022 22:24

This is so obviously a reverse.

LouLou789 · 07/11/2022 22:24

Violin pupils all sound horrendous at first. It’s a very difficult instrument. Your DC has only been learning a matter of weeks. If it still sounds horrendous six months in, then maybe consider.

Basilthymerosemary · 07/11/2022 22:18

Sorry OP but I think the problem is you and your husband's unrealistic expectations.

A teaching qualification is sometimes pointless. Most specialist music 'teachers' (DC in were in independent schools) are musicians without a PGCE and instead have the music qualifications such as AGSM,GGDM etc. They are very talented and know their stuff.

Just because your husband is talented does not mean your daughter will be. And 2 months is a ridiculous amount of time to expect her to play twinkle twinkle.

Do everyone a favour and pull her out. It will go around the tutors that you are a difficult parent and no one will take her on.