Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
Plingston · 08/11/2022 04:56

I started learning violin in group lessons aged 7 and sounded shit for at least a couple of years. I think I was only grade 3 by the time I went to high school. At 18, I received a guaranteed, unconditional offer at a conservatoire with violin as my first instrument. Her progress sounds completely normal. The smaller sized, cheap violins aren't even capable of producing a pleasant sound.

girlmom21 · 08/11/2022 04:14

I think it's sad you don't think your daughter should be having fun in her violin lessons.

Your husband is an arse.

AloysiusBear · 08/11/2022 03:54

7 is actually really young to learn an instrument anyway, it will take longer to be good at that age than if she started at say 10 years old

This is terrible advice. Children who start later tend to simply give up a couple of years in because they get bored because they can't play anything decent & have higher expectations than a 7 yo does.

DN start cello about 9 months ago at just 7, having already started on piano at 5. One to one lessons with a decent teacher so is starting grade 1 pieces now.

AloysiusBear · 08/11/2022 03:49

Also 68 a term is v cheap. Is it a 30 min lesson or 20 min? Do the school subsidise? Lots do but also lots of councils pay very poor rates to peripatetic teachers so it tends not to attract the decent teachers these days.

For contrast I pay £18 for 30 mins one to 1 piano lesson and the teacher is relatively cheap locally.

AloysiusBear · 08/11/2022 03:42

Twinkle twinkle little star requires 3rd position for a start.

Eh? Im sure you can play a simple twinkle twinkle in 1st position

AloysiusBear · 08/11/2022 03:36

Is she having school lessons in a group? This is much slower progress than 1 to 1.

Also is it her first instrument? Some children will start on piano first and so can already read music and know the rhythms etc when starting a second, making it much quicker to pick up.

Violins do sound awful when they start but maybe this just isn't the instrument for her.

Conkersareback · 08/11/2022 03:19

Booklover3 · 08/11/2022 02:18

I honestly don’t believe you are for real. It’s been two months. Two months.

This YABU!

Your DH also sounds like a right know it all and you need to accept that your DD just isn't musical!

MyMumSaysALot · 08/11/2022 03:10

@MarkyMarky

Watch the movie “Music of the Heart,” with Meryl Streep.
It’s a true story about a woman who teaches a bunch of little kids the violin at a “poor school” in Harlem in NYC.

It won’t help your daughter, but it’s a very inspiring movie and it might take your mind off things for a bit and make you feel better.

The little kids in that movie practiced their hearts out — and their families supported them. It’s really uplifting. On second thought, it might help you and your daughter both. You’ll love it.

How did she get all those kids to Carnegie Hall all at one time?
Practice! Practice! Practice!

cynicbuthappy · 08/11/2022 02:26

Violin teacher in a previous life here. Your husband is wrong. Twinkle twinkle little star requires 3rd position for a start. Hot cross buns also and quaver bowing. Unlike cello, the violin is supported by the chin and shoulder blade (with chin and decent shoulder rest) to allow this. Your daughter will not have the strength or control to do this for at least 18 months. Lord save us from “accomplished” musicians who obviously know nothing!

Booklover3 · 08/11/2022 02:18

I honestly don’t believe you are for real. It’s been two months. Two months.

MeetPi · 08/11/2022 01:43

RoseslnTheHospital · 07/11/2022 20:39

Look your DH obviously thinks the teacher is doing everything wrong. So you aren't going to be able to get this teacher to do what he wants, so best to stop lessons with her now. Maybe find a Suzuki method teacher which sounds more like what your DH wants for your DD than the kind of teaching the current music teacher is doing

It does sound like the DH prefers a Suzuki-type method. My DD learned both violin and cello under a grades-based system, starting from about this age. She played violin up to about the 13 years old without tremendous progression - perhaps Grade 3 or 4 - and she didn't really enjoy it. She then moved to cello and the change was significant. She steamed through the grades, practiced constantly without being reminded, and as a young adult now, teaches others the instrument.

The basics are so very important - so much more so than just playing a simple tune. This stage is when children learn finger placement and correct bow hold. Rushing or skipping this can lead to injury down the line and/or frustration for the child when they cannot master the instrument.

shortandpaleandoldandugly · 08/11/2022 01:28

Twinkle Twinkle involves using fingers up to the third finger. No beginner will be playing that for a long time. You and your DH know nothing. Give the teacher a break though and withdraw. Let another child have the space. I'm certain the (highly qualified and clearly knowledgeable) teacher will breathe a sigh of relief to have rid of you.

canonlydoblue · 08/11/2022 01:28

I struggle to believe your husband is an accomplished musician if he doesn't understand that it takes years of hard work and practice to get any instrument, especially a stringed one, to make a decent sound.

Legallypinkish · 08/11/2022 01:24

YABU. My daughter plays violin. She’s nearly 17 and has been playing since year 1. It was a good year before she sounded ok. 3 years before she did grade 1. She rarely practiced though 🤦‍♀️ Every child is different . I saw other kids at orchestra speed past her with grades and ability early on and others go a lot slower. The important thing is that she enjoys it and if you pressure her I can guarantee she’ll end up hating it and give it up.

raincabin · 08/11/2022 01:17

Seriously?

She's 7. The violin is hard.

onlythreenow · 08/11/2022 01:16

Your husband sounds like an idiot, but if he is so wonderful (in his own mind) then I suggest he teach your daughter to play the violin.

YABVU.

Sugargliderwombat · 08/11/2022 01:08

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 21:15

Ok fair enough, they are reasonable qualifications but surely a teaching qualification is more relevant to the role of teaching within schools?

maybe I was a bit quick to jump to conclusions. It does seem from the responses that our expectations are unrealistic.

DD does enjoy the lessons. She says her teacher is fun and makes them all laugh by making faces silly faces while speaking on her violin (I assume intentionally!).

I think the group lessons are more suited for younger children. I think at 7 DD should be more violin focused and I think I’ll go down the route of individual lessons.

🤣 oh yeah suck all the joy. Poor child is enjoying the bloody lessons leave her alone !

Canthave2manycats · 08/11/2022 00:53

Give the teacher a chance - your 7 year old DD isn't going to be Vanessa Mae in 2 months, and she may never be within touching distance!!

I didn't have the benefit of music lessons - my parents couldn't afford it, though they did buy a piano (which was pointless without lessons tbf).

However my older two showed some musical talent. DD1 played piano, cello, guitar and tin whistle in primary school, and went on to achieve grade 6 in cello and grade 7 in piano. DD2 played piano, clarinet and guitar. She didn't enjoy clarinet though she persevered but only achieved a grade 4 (am so sorry I didn't send her to singing lessons instead!) She got a merit in Grade 8 piano.

Wanting to give DS the same chance, he had piano and guitar lessons. Both were pretty much a disaster as he really wasn't that interested; piano teacher lost patience because he just wouldn't practice, so he gave that up after grade 2. He enjoyed his guitar lessons so he did those for 8/9 years before I finally called time as he was about to sit his A levels and hadn't progressed beyond grade 3....

Swings and roundabouts!!! I will never forget the horrendous caterwauling of a badly played cello lol!

mydogsteppedonabee · 08/11/2022 00:48

What does your daughter think about it?

DixonD · 08/11/2022 00:39

Eastangular2000 · 07/11/2022 19:04

So you want to complain to the teacher because your child is shit at violin!

Why are you quoting the OP so early in the thread? It’s unnecessary and quite frankly, irritating.

UhhhhhhhOK · 08/11/2022 00:38

UhhhhhhhOK · 08/11/2022 00:37

Why don't your learn violin as well?

you not your

UhhhhhhhOK · 08/11/2022 00:37

Why don't your learn violin as well?

Notatallanamechange · 08/11/2022 00:14

I love when someone with no expertise in an area (mum) and similar but not correct, nor professional experience (dad) think they know better than the experienced, educated person (well educated teacher of the specific instrument). Good luck to your daughter, I suspect she probably already know you think she’s ‘shit’. moving her, despite her abilities being where they should be, will shatter her confidence no end.

Livinginanotherworld · 08/11/2022 00:06

You and you husband sound like an absolute nightmare. Neither of you know what you are talking about……if your husband is that accomplished musically, then I’m gobsmacked, he’s talking out of his backside ! Your teacher sounds very well qualified and is teaching exactly the correct way for a 7 year old beginner. I feel sorry for your daughter, she will never live up to your uneducated standards. Oh…and private 1-1 lessons around here are about £40 a pop. …..£65 per term…..bloody hell !

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/11/2022 00:05

Your DH sounds like a total tool. Of course her playing sounds like a cat fight - she's 7 and she's been playing for 2 months. The violin sounds truly awful for ages - like brace yourself for 2 years. The Cello is quicker, but even so - it's not that quick, she would not yet be playing tunes.