Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
potniatheron · 09/11/2022 14:07

ZiriForEver · 09/11/2022 13:58

It is standard for string instruments to spend some time with open strings only. Depending on the instrument and methodology it can take shorter or longer, but it is perfectly normal thing to do.

You need to get an ear for their different sounds, names and written form, holding the instrument, right hand technique, bow technique, sound, rhythm, fluency.

My guitar teacher let me sing a song and use open strings as a bass line in the same stage.
With violin, the hearing and working towards the sound is even more important.

I know that with recorder, children can learn a new note each lesson, but it comes with different notes requiring different level of general technique. Strings have different learning curve

Also, where did OP say her DD is learning proper bow technique?

If DD's hand and wrist are in perfect alignment with the bow in a drop hold and her left perfectly tensile under the neck, then DD would be producing a lovely clear sound. But if the sound she produces is not good, then she's not doing any of that, she's just sawing away, and has not been taught anything.

Also how will DD get her left hand placement right unless she is producing notes?

definitely find a proper teacher.

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 14:02

ZiriForEver · 09/11/2022 13:58

It is standard for string instruments to spend some time with open strings only. Depending on the instrument and methodology it can take shorter or longer, but it is perfectly normal thing to do.

You need to get an ear for their different sounds, names and written form, holding the instrument, right hand technique, bow technique, sound, rhythm, fluency.

My guitar teacher let me sing a song and use open strings as a bass line in the same stage.
With violin, the hearing and working towards the sound is even more important.

I know that with recorder, children can learn a new note each lesson, but it comes with different notes requiring different level of general technique. Strings have different learning curve

No it's definitely not "standard". The kid should at least be playing Twinkle Twinkle by now. Twinkle Twinkle is the standard for total beginners because you move up and down in tones and can easily learn the placement of fingers on the board (because it goes 3,2,1 etc).

I don't play guitar so can't comment there.

This is not standard at all and it sounds like the teacher is more of a generalist music teacher than a violin teacher.

ZiriForEver · 09/11/2022 13:58

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 13:29

But that's the problem. From what OP says, her DD hasn't been taught ANY NOTES AT ALL. After 2 months of lessons, that's pathetic.

It is standard for string instruments to spend some time with open strings only. Depending on the instrument and methodology it can take shorter or longer, but it is perfectly normal thing to do.

You need to get an ear for their different sounds, names and written form, holding the instrument, right hand technique, bow technique, sound, rhythm, fluency.

My guitar teacher let me sing a song and use open strings as a bass line in the same stage.
With violin, the hearing and working towards the sound is even more important.

I know that with recorder, children can learn a new note each lesson, but it comes with different notes requiring different level of general technique. Strings have different learning curve

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 13:30

bringincrazyback · 09/11/2022 13:10

I still think the OP's DD is too young and too new to the instrument for a more focused approach to be needed right now.

?? Do you play the violin?

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 13:29

Irridescantshimmmer · 07/11/2022 19:44

Instructions for the Hand frame.
Play D on the A string, listen for the resonance. Adjust if needed

Play G on the D string and listen again for resonance. Move finger back and foward if sharp or flat A on the G string. Do the same for all strings in 1st position and repeat many times if needed.

She just needs to keep playing simple scales, focusing on hearing the resonance and onnce her hand frame is established you will all hear the difference.

Don't give up on the teacher, or your daughters playing. It took me 5 months of teaching myself before I could make a nice sound that did not make my ears bleed.

Hope this helps😀

But that's the problem. From what OP says, her DD hasn't been taught ANY NOTES AT ALL. After 2 months of lessons, that's pathetic.

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 13:27

When you say "she should be using her left hand fingers by now", do you mean that your daughter has literally not been taught any notes yet, and is just sawing away on the four open strings???

Ifso, then absolutely, you're right to complain. All she's currently doing is exactly what she'd be doing if she'd had no lessons at all.

bringincrazyback · 09/11/2022 13:10

Mirabai · 08/11/2022 21:48

I didn’t say they were. It’s possible to have enjoyable lessons in which you actually learn to play the violin rather than fiddling around in a group.

I still think the OP's DD is too young and too new to the instrument for a more focused approach to be needed right now.

mycatisannoying · 08/11/2022 23:36

Sorry, but you sound like a nightmare parent!

canyouextrapol · 08/11/2022 23:14

Charcy · 08/11/2022 10:58

Gotta be a troll post. Surely no parents are this fucking dumb?!

You'd hope so!

Mirabai · 08/11/2022 21:48

I didn’t say they were. It’s possible to have enjoyable lessons in which you actually learn to play the violin rather than fiddling around in a group.

bringincrazyback · 08/11/2022 21:25

Mirabai · 07/11/2022 23:03

She's 7. The lessons should be fun at this age, and it sounds like the teacher is accomplishing this. I get that the lessons are expensive, but that's not a reason to be as desperate for results as you seem to be.

It depends what you want out of it. If she just wants to have fun DD can just scrape about a bit; if she actually wants to learn the violin, then she needs to take it seriously and find a teacher who does too.

I'd argue that at 7, that desire to learn and improve can only be fostered by lessons a child actually enjoys. And I disagree that having fun and learning are mutually exclusive.

Poppyscot87 · 08/11/2022 19:33

This cannot be serious?

Mirabai · 08/11/2022 17:51

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 17:41

@Mirabai - re bowhold, his thumb and index and pinkie were textbook, just his middle and ring finger would sometimes randomly trail in mid air. I also felt he should hold the violin up a bit higher and play closer to the bridge as a default rather than so close to the fingerboard. However, even amongst professional violinists you get very different styles and angles the violin is held at, how much the violinists move around etc In any event, this DS completely changed his style by 13 after watching lots of famous professionals and deciding who he wanted to be like. That kind of mentalisation comes with age.

You hold the bow with your thumb, middle and ring finger; the pinkie and index finger are placed very lightly and there for balance. You should be able to use the bow with your pinkie and index in the air. Sounds like he needs his bow hold sorting asap, otherwise it will hold him back technically.

You do get different styles of holding the violin it’s true, but bowing is less variable - well other than some very stiff hands and bow arms.

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 17:41

@Mirabai - re bowhold, his thumb and index and pinkie were textbook, just his middle and ring finger would sometimes randomly trail in mid air. I also felt he should hold the violin up a bit higher and play closer to the bridge as a default rather than so close to the fingerboard. However, even amongst professional violinists you get very different styles and angles the violin is held at, how much the violinists move around etc In any event, this DS completely changed his style by 13 after watching lots of famous professionals and deciding who he wanted to be like. That kind of mentalisation comes with age.

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2022 17:24

Start tiny children off.

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2022 17:23

“I was just looking at her website and she doesn’t even appear to have a teaching qualification. Just a degree, DipABRSM and LRSM.“

She wouldn’t have these qualifications if she did not understand a lot about music and if she were not a good musician herself. Someone with a teaching qualification might easily have fewer qualifications/know less about good violin playing.

So if you change teachers watch out that the teaching qualification is on top of the teacher having the best qualifications as a musician. Teaching qualifications may help but are not everything. Chopin used to give lessons, as did many great pianists, but they didn’t have teaching qualifications.

Her letter was all about getting fundamental technical aspects correct, and about building up an understanding of music. That shouldn’t be skipped.

When your husband says she “should be” playing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star by now, I wonder if he was thinking of a child being taught through the Suzuki method? I think this technique uses tunes more immediately - maybe another poster would know more. These lessons often start to y children off. If your DD had Suzuki lessons though you would need to go to all of them and learn a lot yourself and be with her for her practising.

HappyDays40 · 08/11/2022 16:51

I played violin for years and was awful at it despite daily practice. I got pleasure from it but alas it was not to be. My parents didn't blame the teacher.
I think you need to accept that your daughter may not be as talented as you think she is, she may not have inherited her dad's flare for music and the violin and cello are two completely different instruments.

Mirabai · 08/11/2022 16:43

The 10 year old who got a Distinction in his Grade 8 violin exam and 99 per cent in Grade 5 ABRSM music theory age 8 definitely still did not have perfect bowhold by the time he took Grade 8.

The problem with that is that it’s much harder to correct poor technique than it is to get the fundamentals right from the start. I’m sure you know bow hold is key to bow technique - good tone, control and string crossing etc.

There’s no excuse for not having a perfect bow hold by 10, the teacher just didn’t do their job. Some techniques start with the bow hold first.

SezFrankly · 08/11/2022 16:36

Listen to yourself. Your 7 year old child has played for only 8 weeks.

IndysMamaRex · 08/11/2022 14:42

Wow I bet it’s a barrel of laughs at your house. Your child isn’t some musical genius after 2 months (likely less than 10 hours individual time with teacher) and your blaming the teacher…really? This is the most entitled/middle class post I think I’ve ever read on here. YABEU! A few questions

why is it so important your child is good at
violin?

did/does your child even want to play (as I wouldn’t of I had this level of expectation from my parents)

Have you ever heard the phrase practice makes perfect?

are you this pedantic with everything in your child’s life?

LilMissNurse1 · 08/11/2022 14:36

8 weeks! 8 weeks is all she’s been learning for! Have you tried playing the violin? It’s flippin hard and she’s only 7. I think you need to lower your extremely high expectations of your poor DD, I played it when I was 8, I practiced and after a couple of years I was still really bad at it, I also played the cello for 3 years and I detested it by the end from being pushed so hard by the teacher, I quit the second I could and it felt so good! i was good with music in general, I got a grade 3 on the saxophone and played the piano but string instruments are a whole different ball game and my parents never pushed me, it was all me. If you keep pushing her so hard she will learn to hate it rather than love it. Let your daughter be herself, just because DH is good at the cello doesn’t mean your DD will have a natural ability for it. Did she choose the violin? Or did you choose it for her?

Ninabean17 · 08/11/2022 14:13

Hoping this is a wind up. If not, your are being completely, utterly, ridiculous.

thelonghaul · 08/11/2022 12:55

Get a f***g grip!!!!! You are the problem here.
Not the teacher.
Not your daughter.
Seriously, started in Sept. Still crap in Nov. Shocker.

Mischance · 08/11/2022 12:38

I think at 7 DD should be more violin focused .... hmmmm.

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 11:57

OK well if she is doing group lessons rather than individual of course there is less progress….
Music teachers do differ massively in their approaches. On the one extreme, you get the one who insist on open strings for ages until posture, bow hold etc absolutely correct and won’t let the kid take Grade 1 until they are guaranteed a high distinction in the 140 range and have practised endlessly including all supporting tests ad inifintum. We had one of those for Grade 8 for one of my kids and it took 2 years on Grade 8 - she did do incredibly well in the actual exam but was bored out of her mind by then.
However, our main violin teacher is not like this. My 5 year olds couldn’t hold the bow properly but they could read music pretty well and actually all produced a good sound within weeks and have excellent hearing. No scratching here! They also learnt to read fluently age 4 and read heavy Russian literature by age 8 (I never stopped them doing that either although they wouldn’t have understood the in depth historical references). I never stopped them progress in music, neither did their violin teacher. The 10 year old who got a Distinction in his Grade 8 violin exam and 99 per cent in Grade 5 ABRSM music theory age 8 definitely still did not have perfect bowhold by the time he took Grade 8. He played beautifully though. There are definitely violin teachers who would have delayed his Grade 8 because of his bowhold and not perfect posture. Also, he never liked playing in the basic orchestras and a lot of them would tut tut because of that because he didn’t have “orchestra spirit” (basically happy to play really simple tunes and help others even if it is not extending for the child itself). Thankfully he developed that orchestra spirit just fine as a teen.
Get a 1 to 1 child let teacher and get your husband fully involved. Typically kids get as much out of it as you are willing to put into it