Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 09/11/2022 20:59

@Mirabai do all children in those countries start violin at that age or just those from wealthy families

Maybe some people just want their children a fun introduction to learning an instrument not expecting them to be a world leading maestro.

Of the OP thinks £68 is expensive they aren’t going to fork out for private lessons too

Mnbvcxz123 · 09/11/2022 20:48

Even with Suzuki (which she won’t be doing if she is starting at 7), she would still be pre-twinkling 2 months in. Rhythms, bowhold, position of feet etc, bowhold again, more rhythms, etc would be first. Then the Monkey song. Oh and did I mention more bowhold?

OP has unsurprisingly gone v quiet! But I’m surprised at those saying the little girl should be twinkling by now - I think it unlikely with a good Suzuki teacher anyway.

Suboptimalsitch · 09/11/2022 20:32

When your husband says she “should be” playing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star by now, I wonder if he was thinking of a child being taught through the Suzuki method? I think this technique uses tunes more immediately - maybe another poster would know more. These lessons often start to y children off. If your DD had Suzuki lessons though you would need to go to all of them and learn a lot yourself and be with her for her practising.

That's right. Suzuki method works on imitation and they go from open strings to twinkle twinkle and other simple tunes much quicker than other more traditional methods. They are still very hot on stance, bow hold and violin grip as get off to bad habits with those and you're at a huge disadvantage

Abundanceofcare · 09/11/2022 20:30

Also, you don't move in tones, there is a semi tone in there between the 3rd and 4th scale degrees

Abundanceofcare · 09/11/2022 20:28

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 14:02

No it's definitely not "standard". The kid should at least be playing Twinkle Twinkle by now. Twinkle Twinkle is the standard for total beginners because you move up and down in tones and can easily learn the placement of fingers on the board (because it goes 3,2,1 etc).

I don't play guitar so can't comment there.

This is not standard at all and it sounds like the teacher is more of a generalist music teacher than a violin teacher.

Twinkle twinkle goes 3,2,1?

Do you know a different tune?

It goes: 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 3 3 2 2 1 1 0 in first position.

Any 7 year old that can play that with a nice sound, in tune and rhythmically on the violin after 8 weeks of group lessons is a prodigy and the teacher a genius.

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 19:48

In a list of the top 20 greatest violinists the world has ever seen the U.K. would not figure.

We’re not going to agree: you think an amateurish approach is fine, I think it’s a bit dismal.

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 19:06

Oh, and for your information, I play a lot by ear as well as from music. Aural skills are very important.

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 19:04

*in the UK, l should have said.

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 19:03

I am not trashing teaching in the rest of the world nor am I jingoistic. There have been a number of world class musicians from the UK as you well know. There are world class musicians from other countries. I was fed up with you continually saying how much better music teaching is elsewhere in the world. There is good and bad everywhere, including the UK. I was merely pointing out that giving up an instrument for whatever the reason is not solely something that happens to the UK. I also strongly feel that hothousing is not the best approach for most people. My approach works for me and for my pupils.

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 18:39

How incredibly middle England to trash music teaching in the rest of the world, despite the fact the U.K. don’t produce a huge number of world class musicians.

Of course a straightforward point about the fact this teacher isn’t giving the OP the advice she should, or that any starter musician should be able to pick up Twinkle by ear, would be turned into cringey jingoism.

The vast majority of people who start an instrument in this country give up never to touch their instrument again - and no small part of that is a poor standard of teaching.

Montymorency · 09/11/2022 17:40

accomplished cellist here. you're a complete peasant....

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 17:40

Oh, and those musicians from the Far East who give up never to touch their instrument again have lost all enthusiasm and enjoyment of music. Very sad.

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 17:38

@Mirabai, l notice that you have had a lot to say about how the violin is taught in other parts of the world. It obviously would there - or does it? My very musical daughter had a friend from Moscow. She was always harping on about how much better the Russian system was but was not a very good musician. In the Far East, there is a lot of pressure placed on parents and children to start lessons at a very young age and to practise intensely. Sometimes it works really well but more often than not, children get to grade 8 at a young age with no real understanding of the music and give up because it is too much hard work. A music examiner told me that some of the poorest players he examined were in the Far East. I have mixed feelings about the Suzuki system. It can work really well but, as a Western music teacher with 35+ years’ experience, I stand by what works for my pupils and me.

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 17:26

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 17:18

Ah, absolutely no qualifications to teach violin. In common with a small number of other people who play an instrument to a good standard, including the OP’s husband, you feel free to criticise what sounds like a very good teacher. Have you ever taught beginner violinists in groups? I have and it is not easy. A good bow technique is fundamental. The teacher will certainly not allow “sawing on open strings” but will be encouraging long bows with the children listening to the sound they are making. Twinkle Twinkle really is not as easy as you think as the children need to be able to read music fairly fluently and make their own notes so that they are perfectly in tune. If they have not learned how to use the bow properly, they really will be “sawing.”

She doesn’t sound like a particularly good teacher to me, why has she not advised the OP that if her DD really wants to play the violin she needs private lessons. Group lessons are useful addition to private but on their own they’re, at best, simply an introduction.

You don’t need to be able to read music to play Twinkle or to play in tune. In Russia, E.Europe and E.Asia, where it’s standard to start aged 3-5, students learn pieces by ear while concentrating in the fundamentals of technique.

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 17:18

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 16:05

No formal qualifications, but I played for many years (before a severe injury to my right wrist) and led a children's orchestra.

Ah, absolutely no qualifications to teach violin. In common with a small number of other people who play an instrument to a good standard, including the OP’s husband, you feel free to criticise what sounds like a very good teacher. Have you ever taught beginner violinists in groups? I have and it is not easy. A good bow technique is fundamental. The teacher will certainly not allow “sawing on open strings” but will be encouraging long bows with the children listening to the sound they are making. Twinkle Twinkle really is not as easy as you think as the children need to be able to read music fairly fluently and make their own notes so that they are perfectly in tune. If they have not learned how to use the bow properly, they really will be “sawing.”

MargaretThursday · 09/11/2022 17:06

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 14:02

No it's definitely not "standard". The kid should at least be playing Twinkle Twinkle by now. Twinkle Twinkle is the standard for total beginners because you move up and down in tones and can easily learn the placement of fingers on the board (because it goes 3,2,1 etc).

I don't play guitar so can't comment there.

This is not standard at all and it sounds like the teacher is more of a generalist music teacher than a violin teacher.

Not sure you're correct for all teaching.

I learnt the violin and we did get onto fingers very quickly-I think by the second or third lesson.
My ds learnt the violin and far more emphasis was put on technique at the beginning. I think he was still on open strings for 2-3 months, but a lot more emphasis about how he held the bow and the violin. It meant a slower start, but once he started fingering he moved forward very quickly.

I found that when I got to grade 4/5 my technique really held me back and it was too much effort (as a teen) to relearn it so I gave up.

Heavymetaldetector · 09/11/2022 17:03

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 14:02

No it's definitely not "standard". The kid should at least be playing Twinkle Twinkle by now. Twinkle Twinkle is the standard for total beginners because you move up and down in tones and can easily learn the placement of fingers on the board (because it goes 3,2,1 etc).

I don't play guitar so can't comment there.

This is not standard at all and it sounds like the teacher is more of a generalist music teacher than a violin teacher.

It is standard.
The teacher has several respected qualifications in violin teaching as OP has even said herself.
In order to play twinkle twinkle on the violin you need good secure bow hold, ability to read music, knowledge of 1st, 2nd and 3rd finger. All of this will not yet have been covered yet in only 6 or 7 group lessons.
Signed,
String teacher.

I often wonder if teachers of other subjects get these entirely fabricated deadlines and goals pressed upon them by parents with no abilities or qualifications in the subject eh DD HAS BEEN IN RECEPTION FOR 7 WEEKS WHY HASNT SHE LEARNT TRIGONOMETRY YET DH SAYS HE WAS ON QUANTUM PHYSICS BY AGE 2 SHALL I COMPLAIN TO THE LEA

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 09/11/2022 16:58

Good grief... if you think £68 a term for lessons is "paying a fortune" then you're in for a nasty shock.

I paid £35 for a single 1 to 1 lesson last week for DD for a new instrument she wanted a bit of help with, and I reckoned that was pretty cheap.

The violin teacher you have is also extremely well qualified.

Violin is incredibly hard to learn to play well in the early stages.

Even things like piano, most children take 1-2 years before doing Grade 1. An exceptionally musical child might manage it in under a year.

I think you are being very unrealistic.

Anonymous48 · 09/11/2022 16:28

The lessons sound perfect for beginner 7 year olds. Sounds like they are learning the fundamentals in a fun, age appropriate way, and it's only been a few weeks. YABVU.

And 68 pounds a term is a fortune? 😂😂😂

zingally · 09/11/2022 16:22

I played violin myself, from the age of 7 to 16. And can confirm it's a tricky instrument! I'm surprised your expert DH isn't more encouraging!

She's 7, been playing 2 and a bit months. Even being generous, that's maybe 10 lessons, half an hour each. 5 hours of instruction, and a bit of unguided practise in between.
What on earth happened to just letting kids have a bit of fun with music?! So what if she's not a prodigy? She's 7. Lighten up.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 16:20

Some people think OP may be right So perhaps she should post on a board where teachers answer.

Crunchymum · 09/11/2022 16:10

You sound incredibly pushy OP.

Your child is 7. Ease up a little.

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 16:05

sanityisamyth · 09/11/2022 15:43

And what qualifications to teach the violin do you have?!

No formal qualifications, but I played for many years (before a severe injury to my right wrist) and led a children's orchestra.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 15:52

Is AIBU the right place for this OP?
isn’t there an education or music education board in mumsnet where violin teachers might answer you, including Suzuki violin teachers?

sanityisamyth · 09/11/2022 15:43

potniatheron · 09/11/2022 13:27

When you say "she should be using her left hand fingers by now", do you mean that your daughter has literally not been taught any notes yet, and is just sawing away on the four open strings???

Ifso, then absolutely, you're right to complain. All she's currently doing is exactly what she'd be doing if she'd had no lessons at all.

And what qualifications to teach the violin do you have?!