Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
Theydoyaknow · 07/11/2022 20:17

😂

Ballsaque · 07/11/2022 20:08

I’m a professional violinist (I play,don’t teach).

Read the post by @Ilovewheelychairs She is spot on and knows what she’s talking about.

Antnotdec · 07/11/2022 20:04

I played violin for 10 years. I always sounded awful. I didn't actually want to play it at all. You sound like a nightmare to be honest.

DietColaBreak · 07/11/2022 19:59

!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I played violin to grade 8. It sounded awful even up to grade 6 when practising! Im afraid that's the nature of the violin! Unless you are very good, and playing a lovely piece, on an expensive instrument, it just won't sound good during practise when you are trying to get the piece right! In the beginning, at the low grades, it's an awful sound! My son has been playing for a term and I swear my ears are going to fall off!!

Poor teacher! It's not her fault! If you DC is going to be a violinist, get used to this!! It won't sound beautiful for many years!!!

randomsabreuse · 07/11/2022 19:56

My DD started violin last year and spent most of the year working on open strings, and octave harmonics. She started first finger before the summer holidays and has been consolidating it on all 4 strings along with adding 2nd finger.

I'm happy with her progress, we spent the first year working on using her bow properly and play a lot of duets (I play flute rather than my very beginner violin) so she's not bored by open string music and is used to playing with good tone. She also does a lot of duets with her teacher which helps with tone.

Violin is tough to learn and it sounds horrid at times, especially fractionals. She should play with your DH and learn about pulse and tone from him.

Flute sounds less horrid at the beginning but you pay when you get to G7/8 scales, orchestral "decorative" bits in the top octave and the awkward corners of more advanced pieces, in much longer bites than a beginner violinist has to practice! Basically practicing is never going to sound good, repeating stuff you can do well isn't practice!

SeaCreatureCool · 07/11/2022 19:56

Violin is hard, but I would first of all get her ears checked - the number of kids I have seen who have struggled with the violin due to ear problems is very, very high.

I would say starting between 3 - 7 is optimal; how much is she actually practicing? It does need to be for more then ten minutes here and there in the early days - she'll get more enthusiastic about practicing as it starts to sound nicer.

YANBU that the teacher should be updating you with what she is teaching, how she is teaching and her views on your daughter's progression.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 07/11/2022 19:50

Get your DH to teach her then?

As an aside, I have never understood why so many schools start DC music lessons with violin. It is hard and it sounds awful until it doesn't. Bring back the recorders, I say.

Aleaiactaest · 07/11/2022 19:46

3 of my DC started violin age 5. All did well with it. I had to learn with them. They all took ages to take to the right bow hold but all were on grade 3 by year 2. Grade 8 by year 6 or 7. Because I spent every day practising with them in the early years for 10-20 minutes. Made them sing the tune, listen to the correct note on the piano, do the exercises. Violin Star 1 is your friend with the CDs. Mine were all playing Christmas tunes using 2-3 fingers by Christmas of their first term.
you can download a fingerboard online - there are endless apps like smart scales, Abrsm practice app etc once you start the grades. For now learning open strings, finger 1, then 2 then 3 on all strings and reading the music. Write out the lines for her to copy etc

Mnbvcxz123 · 07/11/2022 19:45

I’m a violinist, my daughter is 6 and has been playing since she was 3, daughter 4 has been playing cello since she was 3. We use the Suzuki method. This is all just for context.

There are a few things you need to do (and I mean you really need to do these) if you really want her to progress any more quickly than she is doing right now:

  1. a parent (preferably your husband) needs to sit in on lessons

  2. same parent needs to supervise practice

  3. practice needs to happen every single day - at least the instrument needs to be picked up anyway

  4. practice needs to be kept short so that she’s not practising errors

  5. (and most important) you yourself need to completely reset your idea of progress on the violin. It’s one of the hardest instruments and takes years (and I mean years) longer than the cello to make a good sound. Now might be the time to switch if this is a problem to you.

I suppose you could invest in a nicer instrument if you’re just hiring a Stentor or Primavera, but the difference will be minimal compared to the above. I realise that these things might not be possible, especially if she is having lessons in school, in which case I would either switch teacher so you can do it out of school and do all of the above things, or else just chill out as honestly you’re not going to have Nicola Benedetti on your hands in only a few months!

Good luck! Do come back and let us know what you end up doing and how she is getting on!

Irridescantshimmmer · 07/11/2022 19:44

Instructions for the Hand frame.
Play D on the A string, listen for the resonance. Adjust if needed

Play G on the D string and listen again for resonance. Move finger back and foward if sharp or flat A on the G string. Do the same for all strings in 1st position and repeat many times if needed.

She just needs to keep playing simple scales, focusing on hearing the resonance and onnce her hand frame is established you will all hear the difference.

Don't give up on the teacher, or your daughters playing. It took me 5 months of teaching myself before I could make a nice sound that did not make my ears bleed.

Hope this helps😀

CaronPoivre · 07/11/2022 19:41

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 19:25

@FlirtyMelons

7 isn't you g actually, most start the violin young. Dd was 3. Her class was 3-5 year olds (Suzuki) and she switch to traditional lessons at 5. Blowing instruments tend to be older

Yes ours was four when she started.

adultingforever · 07/11/2022 19:40

If the teacher does not allow a parent to observe lessons and take notes so they can help with home practice, it will take a very long time for the child to play well. I would look for a Suzuki trained teacher, as they require parents to attend and help at home. I have heard very young students who sound quite good, though they are still playing very simple things. Who would practice if they never sound good? The teacher needs to focus on helping her to sound good and have good position habits before doing anything else, and young students do need help or supervision at home.

Gagaandgag · 07/11/2022 19:39

You are being unreasonable! You
sound like a bully! If you can’t respect the teacher then why can’t your husband teach her?

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 19:39

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 19:25

@FlirtyMelons

7 isn't you g actually, most start the violin young. Dd was 3. Her class was 3-5 year olds (Suzuki) and she switch to traditional lessons at 5. Blowing instruments tend to be older

Just reread this, 3 is absolutely not the norm to start violin. Great if their concentration is good enough but in my opinion it's totally pointless.

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 19:37

Sorry that above post was to @gogohmm

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 19:37

I play several instruments to a high level including violin and started younger than 7 however children most definitely pick up instruments much quicker older though and can learn in a few months what takes a 5 year old several years. Many music teachers won't take under 8s for this reason as well as potential lack of concentration. I am not saying they shouldn't start young but I don't think OP can expect miracles in 2 months.

Frazzled2207 · 07/11/2022 19:37

7 is very young for violin which is HARD. And she can’t have had more than 7 lessons?

if she is playing open strings it shouldn’t be that excruciating- ask your dh to make sure it’s properly tuned. I think you need to be a bit more patient.

Beanbagtrap · 07/11/2022 19:33

Violin sounds awful until you get to at least grade 6. Invest in some ear defenders!

NotAKnowitall · 07/11/2022 19:31

NotAKnowitall · 07/11/2022 19:22

Has it even been a month yet?! If it was September 2021 that she started then I'd understand your frustration but not for the September that finished 7 days ago. How many lessons has it even been? You need to give it time like the teacher said.

Ha! I've just realised we are infact in NOVEMBER! Christ on a stick this year is going fast! Still, it's still too soon to be complaining about lack of progress. Give it more time.

GoldenSpiral · 07/11/2022 19:30

Blergh. Get back in your box.

Feysriana · 07/11/2022 19:27

Seven is really young.

Two months is no time at all.

Violin is extremely hard (I played as a child and hated it). Most schools start children on recorder/choir, then progress to ukelele/guitar, before an instrument like violin.

(If you don’t want your child to play horrible-sounding music I strongly recommend she quit violin as it takes years to sound good! Guitar would be a much better choice, beginners guitar can sound lovely.)

If you aren’t happy with this teacher, you can easily quit school lessons and hire a different teacher at weekends. But I think your time would be better spent pondering why you have such unrealistically high expectations of a 7 year old violinist with two months experience. If you maintain those unrealistically high expectations throughout her school years you are going to make each other very unhappy.

MsRosewater · 07/11/2022 19:27

I played cello- I wanted to learn, started @10 (already played piano and read music etc) and it still sounded shit after a year

Give the kid (and teacher!) a break

ThirdTimeIsTheCharm · 07/11/2022 19:26

If you are making a complaint you will kill the relationship teacher-pupil, The teacher will still be professional but the chemistry will be broken.
Violin takes a very long time to produce a semi-pleasant sound.
Change teacher, change instrument. Cello is completely different, you have a better full view of your hands, your neck is not in an awkward position.
Poor teacher

RedDwarfGarbagePod · 07/11/2022 19:26

Are you the poster who complained about her DD's violin teacher being rude a month or so ago and had her arse handed to her over her unreasonableness?

Or do you just remind me of her for some reason...

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 19:25

@FlirtyMelons

7 isn't you g actually, most start the violin young. Dd was 3. Her class was 3-5 year olds (Suzuki) and she switch to traditional lessons at 5. Blowing instruments tend to be older