Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Problem with DD violin teacher

436 replies

MarkyMarky · 07/11/2022 19:02

DD 7 started violin lessons in sept and I don’t feel she has made much progress. I encourage her to practise most days but the noise is atrocious. I contacted the violin teacher to ask why it’s so bad. The violin teacher basically said in not so many words that we must be patient and the violin takes time as it’s a very difficult instrument and implied that maybe she needs to practise more. This rubbed me up the wrong way as we are already practicing.

however DH is an accomplished cellist and said it must be the teacher as he’s musical and knows how to played stringed instruments. He said DD should be using her left hand fingers by now and making a ‘half decent’ sound.

I contacted the teacher again and said I’d appreciate more detail as what is covered in lessons as I wasn’t satisfied. She has ignored me so I contacted the local music service who basically said it’s down to the teacher to liaise directly with us, I explained that she was ignoring us.

I spoke with the school who said the same thing, the teacher needs to speak to us as there’s no-one else who will be able to help us.

AIBu to now make a complaint as we are not being listened to and we are paying a fortune for lessons?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nospringchix · 11/11/2022 11:52

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 19:10

You're expecting a seven year old to be already good at getting a bearable sound out of a (assuming quarter or half size) violin after 5-9 weeks?

Give over!

If your husband’s so good, why doesn't he help her out.

Yes ^this. It is very early days, and DD is only 7. It does take time to get a good sound out of a violin. It also depends on the violin itself.

I played the violin growing up starting from age 11. Some of my friends started aged 8 and still didn't sound great at 11 ( neither did I). By 13 we sounded great though. Just give it time.

Dotcoe · 11/11/2022 11:18

Please please let your kid give up those lessons so a kid with supportive, understanding and respectful parents can get the place!

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 22:02

bringincrazyback · Today 17:29

I don't think maths or reading are useful comparison points as those are essential skills, music competence is a 'nice to have'.

I realise what you mean here by essential, but there is an argument for saying it is essential, it just isn’t recognised as such in.our society. If everyone were taught music properly quite a lot would get turned around for the better.

Violinist64 · 10/11/2022 21:32

Lil50 · 10/11/2022 17:45

You’ve got a kid who is very young starting on one of the most difficult instruments. When my kid started on the violin it was a horrible noise. She will need to have a very good ear to play the violin. Mine didn’t as a hearing problem. So take it easy. Not everyone is going to be a Sarah Chang

You can have a good musical ear and have hearing problems. I have heard problems with my ears all my life and wear two hearing aids. It has not stopped me from my achievements as a professional musician. I have perfect pitch, which helps. I think learning music is a very good idea for children with impaired hearing as it teaches them to listen. Perhaps not necessarily the violin but there are many other instruments to choose from.

randomsabreuse · 10/11/2022 20:54

My DD is mostly interested in playing duets with me (on the flute or violin). We've got a load of stuff with open strings plus "teacher" part and still play the easier things as well as the new pieces.

Her tone is ok (as far as 1/4 size goes) but her teacher does still help her with bowing

Lil50 · 10/11/2022 17:45

You’ve got a kid who is very young starting on one of the most difficult instruments. When my kid started on the violin it was a horrible noise. She will need to have a very good ear to play the violin. Mine didn’t as a hearing problem. So take it easy. Not everyone is going to be a Sarah Chang

Mirabai · 10/11/2022 17:40

Ime the main reason people give up (aside from disliking it) is because they don’t make sufficient progress for it to be enjoyable.

Good teaching from the start ensures that progress is made while learning is fun and enjoyable. No need for pressure.

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 17:31

Mirabai · 10/11/2022 15:49

Yes, giving up.

IMO (and IME) that's far more likely to happen if a child starts feeling pressured.

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 17:30

^getting sidelined, not sidelines, obviously

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 17:29

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 16:44

Re a deadline.
Say you want to be able to sight-read, play some beautiful pieces, and join the school orchestra. To get to that stage by say about age 12 -13 even if that is just around grade 5, then you want to be practising a bit everyday from about 7 or that may not be possible. After that age life gets busier and more complicated, so it’s nice to have reached a level of competence as a basis for as much enjoyment and further progress as possible before leaving school.

it’s a bit like saying ‘Is there a deadline?’ for basic maths or reading. Of course there isn’t but it will be a lot easier to get well started by 7 or 8.

Agreed, but I think the important thing here is what the OP's DD wants out of the lessons, and I personally feel that's getting sidelines. I don't think maths or reading are useful comparison points as those are essential skills, music competence is a 'nice to have'.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 16:44

Re a deadline.
Say you want to be able to sight-read, play some beautiful pieces, and join the school orchestra. To get to that stage by say about age 12 -13 even if that is just around grade 5, then you want to be practising a bit everyday from about 7 or that may not be possible. After that age life gets busier and more complicated, so it’s nice to have reached a level of competence as a basis for as much enjoyment and further progress as possible before leaving school.

it’s a bit like saying ‘Is there a deadline?’ for basic maths or reading. Of course there isn’t but it will be a lot easier to get well started by 7 or 8.

Mirabai · 10/11/2022 15:49

Yes, giving up.

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 15:32

Mirabai · 10/11/2022 11:56

I asked whether you played because your original comment seemed rather naive.

Seven is not particularly young to start a stringed instrument, so lessons need to be focused from the start even while lessons are fun. It does take time to learn, so you don’t have time to waste.

Why? Is there a deadline?

Mirabai · 10/11/2022 11:56

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 10:02

I played a different instrument in school (and had all the enjoyment sucked out of it by an overly pressured approach to learning, sadly) but know several people who played the violin and found it very difficult. Others on this thread with experience of string instruments have attested to the fact that they're difficult and need time to learn.

But in any case, whether I play/ed it or not is irrelevant to my point, because my point is that all this pressure to get good at an instrument (any instrument) within a short space of time feels like too much pressure for a 7-year-old, together with (what's really getting my goat) a sense that the OP is more interested in being able to show off her DD's 'accomplishments' than what her DD is deriving personally from the lessons.

I asked whether you played because your original comment seemed rather naive.

Seven is not particularly young to start a stringed instrument, so lessons need to be focused from the start even while lessons are fun. It does take time to learn, so you don’t have time to waste.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 11:21

The fun and pleasure comes from being able to play a tune well, but the catch is that to do that takes practice and good teaching.

’Just have fun’ doesn’t always lead to fun. It can lead to a feeling of never getting anywhere and getting bored.

bringincrazyback · 10/11/2022 10:02

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 13:30

?? Do you play the violin?

I played a different instrument in school (and had all the enjoyment sucked out of it by an overly pressured approach to learning, sadly) but know several people who played the violin and found it very difficult. Others on this thread with experience of string instruments have attested to the fact that they're difficult and need time to learn.

But in any case, whether I play/ed it or not is irrelevant to my point, because my point is that all this pressure to get good at an instrument (any instrument) within a short space of time feels like too much pressure for a 7-year-old, together with (what's really getting my goat) a sense that the OP is more interested in being able to show off her DD's 'accomplishments' than what her DD is deriving personally from the lessons.

JonahAndTheSnail · 10/11/2022 08:44

Of course if she's having group lessons than her progress is going to be slower.
I don't get why you think her being taught to read music, develop her ear and a good playing technique is somehow wasting time. £68 a term seems very cheap even for a group lesson. In the private market, £68 would likely only get you an hour to 90 minutes of 1 to 1 tutoring.

I've known a few peri teachers with a long list of teaching qualifications and degrees and diplomas who frankly sound shit when they play. They're technically procifient but never mastered making a decent sound and their intonation is poor. I learnt to play a few wind instruments as a kid and everyone (including the teachers who taught me the other instruments) agreed I was much more confident and sounded the best playing saxophone. That's because I was taught by a highly experience musician (with zero formal teaching qualifications) who would often spend entire lessons focussing on how to produce a great tone on each note of a scale.

Star11111 · 10/11/2022 08:00

My dd is 6 and started violin 4 months ago one to one. She is still playing tunes on open strings. However the notes she does play on open strings all sound pleasant to the ear.

Her teacher has her practice the same tunes until she gets the bow hold correct, posture correct, tempo and rhythm correct as well as ensuring she is looking at the music and not the violin, and then they move on.
I do not play violin, but piano, but there’s so much more that seems to go into learning simple sounds on a violin. She seems to be really enjoying the challenge of perfecting something before moving on and there’s no screeching or horrible sounds. Looking at her music book the next song starts to introduce finger position.
In her lesson.
she also does music theory in her lesson and is currently learning about more complex time signatures and dotted and barred notes so I think it also takes time for theory to catch up to practice as well to be able to read he music and understand what she is seeing.

As an aside we did make sure to get our violin from a professional shop where they swapped to better strings for her on a decent 1/4 size (although a 1/4 size is never going to sound absolutely fantastic) and it was worth the extra money and I imagine contributes to the nicer tone.

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 22:25

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 21:36

@Mirabai, we can agree to disagree but please do not accuse me of being amateurish. I have an extremely professional approach to my teaching and my pupils, their parents, local schools, examiners and anyone who has heard them in concert would concur with that.

If you read my post more carefully I didn’t accuse you personally of being amateurish - I’ve no idea what your teaching is like.

My comment was referring to your apparent endorsement of this teacher’s approach - which no more than a form of general introduction. She should have advised the OP that if her DD is genuinely interested in learning the violin, there is no substitute for individual lessons.

musicalmrs · 09/11/2022 21:37

Musician here. Several musical hats, but I teach piano/woodwind. Not strings, but my children have both chosen to play stringed instruments (probably so I can nag them less!). I can play the basics on both to pick out a tune, mainly to demo them when I run general musicianship sessions for younger children.

I can confirm that stringed instruments are incredibly hard to learn, and that there are a lot of open strings to begin with - you have to get used to holding the instrument, bow hold, and getting the bow to sound right on the strings!

Violin automatically is harder to sound nice at than the cello because of the frequencies involved. I can attest to this as I've had beginners in both!

All the other elements of general musicianship that you've mentioned are an incredibly important part of lessons, be they one to one or group lessons. As is having fun - at 7 their teacher needs to engage them via musical games (where they don't realise they're learning!) etc too. Very frequently you find a student who has been pushed ahead without learning these fundamentals has huge gaps in their learning which others of us have to plug later...

Violinist64 · 09/11/2022 21:36

@Mirabai, we can agree to disagree but please do not accuse me of being amateurish. I have an extremely professional approach to my teaching and my pupils, their parents, local schools, examiners and anyone who has heard them in concert would concur with that.

mangoesaretheonlyfruit · 09/11/2022 21:28

YABVU
The teacher’s reply was completely reasonable. It sounds like an excellent start to learning the violin. Unless your child already plays another instrument, there is a lot to learn initially. Your expectations are unrealistic and I find it hard to believe your husband has much musical knowledge from his take on this. Get a new teacher and give this lovely one a break…

XelaM · 09/11/2022 21:27

I'm from Russia and I can confirm that music is taught a lot better there than in the UK. It still depends on the teacher of course, bit it's taken a lot more seriously than here.

toomuchlaundry · 09/11/2022 21:24

So how do they afford the lessons?

Mirabai · 09/11/2022 21:17

Nothing to do with wealth, if anything talent may be seen as a route out of poverty. Not particular to those countries either - same is true in Western Europe and the US, but in those countries there’s more of a mix.

If you don’t get the right basics even an beginner level it’s not a fun introduction it’s just a dead end (and a waste of money).