Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses’ pay compared with other jobs

216 replies

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 07/11/2022 20:56

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/11/2022 18:29

The figures given here also aren’t comparable because they’re for private services. What individual people are willing to pay for something discretionary is different to what government budgets afford their staff. A more reasonable comparison might be looking at what a standard tradesperson employed by the council / a housing association or a cleaner employed by a hospital earns - which is much less than most nurses.

Nurses getting higher pay (which I support) will mean all of us - and that means all of us, not just “those earning more than I do”, which is what too many people seem to think of as the criteria for increased tax rates - paying much more tax, even if you don’t think you could afford to.

This. I don’t disagree with pay rises for nurses but we have to be honest about how we pay for them and what it will cost.

MsPincher · 07/11/2022 20:48

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

To be fair a comparison with a self employed person isn’t comparing like with like as they are not getting paid holidays and pensions. Nurses (and public sector workers in general) do get generous pensions.

Rippled · 07/11/2022 20:46

"I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour."

That is either an absolute lie or you are terrible at your job.

Kitesk · 07/11/2022 20:36

@NearlChristmas @Vaccine001 genuine question why have you not left and applied as a HCA? What is stopping you? Nursing hones get away with unsociable hours simply because people are willing yo fill the role. There's money in the pot because when shifts aren't filled in the NHS they surge the wards (pay more).

dinozzo · 07/11/2022 20:31

I am 34 years qualified as a Staff Nurse and on £16.12p per hour. I work in a specialised area, I could probably earn more per hour going to work in the private sector, but it's not the same, I'm probably old school, I know just looking at a patient they are not well. My window cleaner charges £13 to clean my windows, it's a bungalow, takes him 10 minutes. In saying that, that's his trade and I like him, maybe when I retire I will join him.

NearlChristmas · 07/11/2022 20:08

Yep ---

"Vaccine001 · Today 19:38
Carers are always excluded from people's sympathy. No sick pay, days off, holidays, night shift premium etc." They don't count only nurses/teachers.

NearlChristmas · 07/11/2022 20:07

Agency nurses versus employed nurses
similar to agency pay rates for social workers, etc all get paid more but don't have the job protection/sick pay/holidays etc so to the person who mentioned agency cleaners/care workers/self employed workers who have to cover sick/holiday/NI/pension etc - it's really NOT comparable

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 07/11/2022 19:50

My handyman wouldnt get out of bed for less than 400 pounds a day. His day starts at 8 am and finishes at 1pm, latest at 2 pm

user1471453601 · 07/11/2022 19:45

Ffs, op, you earn just over what I pay my cleaner please, please, go on strike. Why should your Labour be the only thing that doesn't go up in price? I'm old now, and I've seen seeing one of my surgery nurses for six months (a wound that refuses to heal) they are nice and helpful. I don't also want them to be underpaid.

to save more old people, And others, strike now. There are over 46 thousand vacancies in the NHs. how many will die if you don't take action?

Bananarama21 · 07/11/2022 19:42

I did nursing, I also qualified as a swimming teacher and got 15 pounds an hour for less responsibility. I'm still a swimming teacher.

Kitesk · 07/11/2022 19:41

FallSpringing · 07/11/2022 18:02

We pay our cleaning lady £18 an hour and she deserves every penny. I'm not sure what you are really looking for from this thread? Validation about what a tragedy it is that these all these 'lowly uneducated' cleaners, gardeners and tradespeople earn more than you? Get over yourself, nurses are hardly the intellectual elite. Tradespeople and cleaners all deserve to be paid well, they are highly skilled. You also deserve to be paid well, just probably not the vast sums you have in mind.

This is an aggressive jump to assume OP was pulling other traded people down don't you think? I think OP was merely saying what's the point .. People could work else where! When you take into account parking to get to work which is astronomical alone for the NHS staff. A few of the admin staff have left where I work and it was to do with 30mins lunch, parking and the rubbish money.

I think people forget there's a lot of risk to nursing if you make a mistake sorry won't cut it you will likely loose your pin. I would never did it.

Overthebow · 07/11/2022 19:39

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 07/11/2022 19:36

NHS pensions is a 23% employer contribution.

That actually a lot higher than I thought. So need to add 20% on to nurses pay to compare against statutory pension jobs (statutory employer contribution is 3%), plus sick pay and extra holidays.

Vaccine001 · 07/11/2022 19:38

Carers are always excluded from people's sympathy. No sick pay, days off, holidays, night shift premium etc.

HeraldicBlazoning · 07/11/2022 19:38

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

Completely irrelevant.

Self employed tradesmen like cleaners or plumbers do not get a pension, or sick pay, or holiday pay, or any of the other benefits of being an employee with the UK's largest employer.

Watapalava · 07/11/2022 19:36

For comparison I’m a teacher of 22 years - further ed and manager responsibilities of a team of 8. Im on £19 an hour but again generous leave, sick and pension

pay for teachers and nurses may not seem high but we do have perks - no statutory benefits for us

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 07/11/2022 19:36

NHS pensions is a 23% employer contribution.

Overthebow · 07/11/2022 19:35

fortheloveofflowers · 07/11/2022 19:28

You realise we pay into our own pensions from our pay it’s not just government paying into it.

Yes, but your employer (government) contributions are a lot higher than most private sector jobs and self employed so that needs to be taken into account when comparing salaries.

Watapalava · 07/11/2022 19:32

To be fair op if you are still top band 5 after 32 years then that’s your choice

that’s a long time to be so low down the scale

flippetyflaps · 07/11/2022 19:32

fortheloveofflowers · 07/11/2022 19:28

You realise we pay into our own pensions from our pay it’s not just government paying into it.

Yes but the point is twofold - the government pays a significant amount and the pension is a guaranteed % of final salary. Private sector schemes typically have a modest contribution from the employer and are defined contribution schemes so you only get back what you've put in plus what the investments it has been put in to have returned, as an annuity. As I said earlier, about £600k saved would get an annuity of about £20k at the moment. Most pension pots have declined around 25% in value over the last 12 months because equity markets have fallen sharply given the macroeconomic environment which is bad news for anyone retiring soon with a DC arrangement that hasn't started to liquidate their investments.

ecnatsid · 07/11/2022 19:30

Nurses are desperately underpaid for what they're expected to do

fortheloveofflowers · 07/11/2022 19:28

You realise we pay into our own pensions from our pay it’s not just government paying into it.

Slushynana · 07/11/2022 19:27

Nurses also get shift premiums of 30% for Saturday, unsocial and night shifts and 60% for a Sunday or Bank holiday shift. After 5 years they are entitled to 6 months full pay and 6 months half pay sick pay. After 10 years they get 33 days plus 8 days bank holidays so a total of 41 days holiday entitlement every year. The government also pay 14.38% every month towards the pension which is having to increase to 20.6% to fund the pension this is on top of the employee contributions. If they qualify for maternity they are paid 8 weeks full pay and 18 weeks half pay plus statutory pay and just statutory for the remaining 13 weeks paid leave.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 07/11/2022 19:24

I'd be more inclined to compare similar professions with similar levels of responsibility, education etc ie social workers, teachers etc.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 07/11/2022 19:24

FixundFoxi · 07/11/2022 19:13

@HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie what job do you do ?

I'm an engineer. Qualified and chartered civil and electrical separately. Have intricate specialism in offshore project with a suite of quals to accompany.

Why do you ask, @FixundFoxi ?

RagzRebooted · 07/11/2022 19:22

AntlerRose · 07/11/2022 18:01

I think nurses are hugely underpaid,

but i dont think this is a useful comparison, as their hourly rate is not the full package. Their employer will also make a pension contribution and they should get paid annual leave. I dont know the sick pay terms but it is likely there would be a level of pay if you broke your leg and were off work for 6 weeks. Self employed trades have to cover those benefits in their hourly rate, plus have dead time securing work, sorting accounts, travelling between job etc.

Agree, it's not comparable. I'm a nurse (qualified 3 years, General Practice so not on Agenda for Change) and earn £18ph in my main job on paye, but I cost my employer a lot more than that when you consider the 20% pension contribution, NI, holiday, they pay my union fees and registration.

I charge £25ph for locum work, I don't get pension contributions on that or earn any holiday or get paid sick pay. So it is more money in my pocket, but fewer benefits.

I still don't think nursing is great pay for the responsibility we have, but it's the best paid job I have ever had and the pension will be a lifeline as DH has always been self employed and doesn't have one at all.

I still can't afford to buy a house though!