Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses’ pay compared with other jobs

216 replies

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 07/11/2022 22:00

Sparklynewname · 07/11/2022 21:54

Also, the pension is not all that great!
I was looking at my statement on Friday and I have been paying in for 23 years. I currently pay in £287 per month (then add employers contributions). However, on my statement, for the past multiple years, less than £600 PER YEAR has been put into my pension.
I have a £14k lump sum and will get a pension of £8k per year on todays figures. That’s bugger all compared to what I and my employer are paying in!
we also used to get a £100 voucher for 20 years service in our trust. That has been changed to a badge. For 20 years of loyalty to one trust.

There must be an error somewhere if you've been paying that much plus employer conts but they aren't showing up.

Employers aren't allowed to take money for pensions and put it somewhere else.

You should contact your payroll and get them to look into it for you.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 07/11/2022 21:56

I have friends on a band 6 in the NHS whose job it is to do social media posts and put stuff on the website.

Most nurses are a band 5

Lj8893 · 07/11/2022 21:54

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 21:51

Nurses do get paid a lot more than that op. My friend told be he earned £60k as a Psychiatric nurse, danger money! My ex sil is a nurse practitioner and earns over £50k because she was complaining about the child benefit reduction

In the NHS if you are earning £60k then you haven’t given clinical care in a long time, that’s very top manager pay!

£50k is band 8 too, so not a staff nurse level.

Sparklynewname · 07/11/2022 21:54

Also, the pension is not all that great!
I was looking at my statement on Friday and I have been paying in for 23 years. I currently pay in £287 per month (then add employers contributions). However, on my statement, for the past multiple years, less than £600 PER YEAR has been put into my pension.
I have a £14k lump sum and will get a pension of £8k per year on todays figures. That’s bugger all compared to what I and my employer are paying in!
we also used to get a £100 voucher for 20 years service in our trust. That has been changed to a badge. For 20 years of loyalty to one trust.

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 21:51

Nurses do get paid a lot more than that op. My friend told be he earned £60k as a Psychiatric nurse, danger money! My ex sil is a nurse practitioner and earns over £50k because she was complaining about the child benefit reduction

trilbydoll · 07/11/2022 21:45

You do need to look at the overall package. DH was comparing his current role with a new job and he'd need a huge pay rise to compensate for his current employer pension contributions.

I pay my cleaner £16 but she has to drive from house to house and no employment benefits so it is not really comparable.

I think a more useful comparison might be what do other civil servants earn (to account for the job security and pension etc) and do they need degrees etc.

banjaxxed · 07/11/2022 21:45

It's also not helpful to compare years of experience IMO.

Experience only takes you so far for pay if fundamentally the job and responsibilities aren't altered.

So a nurse on Band 5 with 10 years exp shouldn't be paid less that someone with 30 years if they are both the same grade and have similar responsibilities

NHS pensions, job security sick pay and holiday also needs to be massively factored in

Sparklynewname · 07/11/2022 21:41

I would just like to point out to those who are surprised by people staying at top band 5 after a long career that there are very few band 6 or 7 or 8 roles and that it is almost impossible to advance up the ladder. Competition is extremely high and I’m going to say it… men ime go farther, faster.
20 years, vast experience, still band 5. People who have passed me on the ladder are staggered when they hear I am still a 5 and ask why. Because I didn’t get the 6 I interviewed for! It went to a man who does eff all!

Turkey18 · 07/11/2022 21:40

Civil Service Administration officer £21,688. Never had a decent pay rise for years!

cushioncovers · 07/11/2022 21:39

Nhs staff have to pay for parking but actually finding a parking space is like finding hens teeth.

StrataZon · 07/11/2022 21:39

Overthebow · 07/11/2022 21:27

So looking at the pay nurses have stated, is the actual problem that there isn’t increased pay for experience past a certain point? taking into account all the benefits, £27k starting salary is pretty good. £35k for 5-8 years experience, also not bad. £35k for 15-20 years experience, awful. Maybe there should be further technical bands instead of needing to go up in responsibility that pay more for good performance and more years of experience.

The vast majority of nursing posts are band 5. They will get to top of the pay scale in a few years and will then be stuck on about £33k for rest of their career.
To get to band 6 you need to be a clinical nurse specialist, band 7 is ward charge nurse level.. But the proportion of band 6 and 7 nursing posts in each hospital is tiny.

Lj8893 · 07/11/2022 21:36

I didn’t say it wasn’t, I just wanted to point out the costs nurses and similar professions have.

I didn’t include commuting, purely for the reason you suggest, that most people have some sort of commute to work.
But NHS parking costs are usually extremely high!

Overthebow · 07/11/2022 21:33

Lj8893 · 07/11/2022 21:30

Sorry if this has already been said.

I completely understand everybody saying nurses need to factor in annual leave, pension, sickness etc.

But that also means nurses have to factor in paying an annual registration fee (£120), a union fee (approx £20 a month) and whatever absurd parking costs they need to pay!

I think the pension, annual leave and sick pay is worth a lot more than £30 per month (plus commuting fees that most people no mater what job needs to factor in).

Lj8893 · 07/11/2022 21:30

Sorry if this has already been said.

I completely understand everybody saying nurses need to factor in annual leave, pension, sickness etc.

But that also means nurses have to factor in paying an annual registration fee (£120), a union fee (approx £20 a month) and whatever absurd parking costs they need to pay!

user1487194234 · 07/11/2022 21:30

Pay cleaner £15 an hour

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 07/11/2022 21:29

The NHS and Education ( to a certain extent) are wasting so much money on agency and supply staff.
Staff earn so much more if they're not contracted to local government directly.

Surely NHS/Education departments should be paying a decent salary in the first place?

I've heard school supply staff say that they'd never go back to a permanent school contract. Good pay and none of the after school shite.

I've heard nurses say that they love the hours that they've chosen to do .

You can see why there's a crisis in both those departments.

Overthebow · 07/11/2022 21:27

So looking at the pay nurses have stated, is the actual problem that there isn’t increased pay for experience past a certain point? taking into account all the benefits, £27k starting salary is pretty good. £35k for 5-8 years experience, also not bad. £35k for 15-20 years experience, awful. Maybe there should be further technical bands instead of needing to go up in responsibility that pay more for good performance and more years of experience.

Rippled · 07/11/2022 21:19

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 21:15

Either way, the public sector would be forced to reform massively, which I think would be in everyone's interests.

Oddly enough, the public sector hasn’t reformed despite the complete inability to attract or retain physics / maths teachers. Instead, we’ve accepted frankly shit education for a huge number of kids. Not all - there’s still lots of excellent dedicated teachers. But huge numbers are receiving sub-standard teaching.

The exact same thing is happening in nursing, and it is depressing.

Public sector reform will not happen by staff leaving. All that will happen is public sector collapse. And those still working in it seem to care enough to make one last stand. I didn’t - I moved to private ages ago.

The bureaucracies we have are so big and stuck in their ways that I think they have to collapse - because I don't think they can reform. That isn't just the NHS, btw. It's all bloated and broken. In the 80s, our school pretty much had an old lady with a typewriter doing all the admin, now their are entire "teams" doing it.

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 21:15

Either way, the public sector would be forced to reform massively, which I think would be in everyone's interests.

Oddly enough, the public sector hasn’t reformed despite the complete inability to attract or retain physics / maths teachers. Instead, we’ve accepted frankly shit education for a huge number of kids. Not all - there’s still lots of excellent dedicated teachers. But huge numbers are receiving sub-standard teaching.

The exact same thing is happening in nursing, and it is depressing.

Public sector reform will not happen by staff leaving. All that will happen is public sector collapse. And those still working in it seem to care enough to make one last stand. I didn’t - I moved to private ages ago.

Tethersend01 · 07/11/2022 21:14

My DH earns just under 100k a year. Generous sick and holiday pay. Has around 600k in his pension fund which he hasn’t paid a penny into personally. Highest qualification- GCSE!!!

Me- been a nurse for 24 years. Deal with sad, distressing and challenging situations daily. I earn just over £20 an hour- I’m not in the nhs oension scheme so no employer contributions . Reasonable sick and holiday pay. My job has made me ill (stress) many times 🙁

Window cleaner charges £60 for 45 mins. Gardener £20. Cleaner £15.

There is a reason why, despite the ‘good’ benefits etc the NHS is struggling so badly to recruit and retain staff- the working conditions are appalling and have the potential to break you.

Also please remember most nurses now do the job of a junior Doctor, is it ok to pay people a few pounds more than they would get in a low stress low skill job? You decide!!

Mrsherdwick · 07/11/2022 21:11

@Rippled and when I came out of retirement to give Covid vaccines I was paid £12.70 per hour.
You owe the poster upthread an apology for calling them a liar.

FacebookPhotos · 07/11/2022 21:10

I pay my cleaner £20 per hour, but she’s self employed. It’s social hours, though, and low stress. In my (not expensive) area, shop jobs are being advertised at £13 per hour (low stress, not self-employed but definitely hard work). I don’t know why nurses stay in their roles tbh.

missingeu · 07/11/2022 21:04

We are have to work weekends /nights etc. Bank holidays and christmas.
We pay into our pensions.
If you go sick, depending on the trust - yes you get sick pay but you're constantly called to come to back work and made to feel bad for being ill.
We pay £120 to NMC
We mostly work without our proper breaks due the understaffing and patient ratio.
We mostly do between 5-15 hours unpaid work every week to get our the paperwork completed.

Rippled · 07/11/2022 21:03

Mrsherdwick · 07/11/2022 21:00

@Rippled I also was a qualified nurse for 40 years and earned £15 per hour at the end of my career.
Was I a terrible nurse? Or did I just want to do the job I trained for and stay a bedside nurse looking after patients.
Patients deserve to be nursed by experienced nurses - or don’t you believe that?

Quite frankly, I wish all you moaning nurses and teachers would either shut up or quit for all those better jobs you think are begging to take you.

Either way, the public sector would be forced to reform massively, which I think would be in everyone's interests.

Mrsherdwick · 07/11/2022 21:00

@Rippled I also was a qualified nurse for 40 years and earned £15 per hour at the end of my career.
Was I a terrible nurse? Or did I just want to do the job I trained for and stay a bedside nurse looking after patients.
Patients deserve to be nursed by experienced nurses - or don’t you believe that?