Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses’ pay compared with other jobs

216 replies

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

OP posts:
KangarooKenny · 08/11/2022 06:20

I think we need to look at pension too if comparing jobs. I believe NHS pension is one of the good ones.

flowerycurtain · 08/11/2022 06:17

I very much sympathise with the issues in NhS re pay.

However you can't compare a tradesman wage in that way. Self employed people get no pension, sick pay, parental leave, maternity/paternity pay or holiday pay. All of which are significant elements of NHS wage package.

A skilled farm worker (e.g drill or spray operator) will be on somewhere in the region of £18 per hour if self employed.

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 08/11/2022 06:12

How can you possibly compare the hourly rate of a Self Employed gardener with a nurse's hourly rate? My friend is a SE gardener and his rate is £18 ph but estimates that half of that goes on the many business and running costs. So he's actually on less than minimum wage. No paid holidays either.

autienotnaughty · 08/11/2022 06:07

edwinbear · 07/11/2022 17:59

I pay my cleaner £14ph. She dosn't get sick pay, holiday pay and I don't make pension contributions for her. (I did pay her throughout Covid though).

That was a good thing to do

FixTheBone · 08/11/2022 05:54

Not the point, I know, but the total remuneration is a bit better than the headline figure.

Employer contributions to the pension scheme, and the maternity / sick pay and death in service benefits etc also add value compared to having to take out insurance policies for those things if you were self employed...

That being said, it is ridiculous to hear of highly trained essential workers resorting to second jobs and food banks in order to make ends meet.

Bramblejoos · 08/11/2022 05:51

Tradesmen aren't guaranteed work.
Round here there's been a shortage of them and they are/were run off their feet. Post covid work , people working from home and wanting to change things. However we are heading for a recession so I suspect some of the work will dry up.

So they might have less income. Gardeners that I know work much less in the winter so it's not a continuous income. Cleaner is 15 pounds an hour but has travel costs (we live in the country).

Mamai90 · 08/11/2022 05:48

My sister is a band 6 nurse and gets the same wage as my SIL who works in a shop (not in a managerial role). This really shocked me.

MrsMorrisey · 08/11/2022 05:43

I am a nurse in Australia but no longer working. I did the conversion of 16.84 to Australian dollars and it's $29.98.
I used to get exactly the same.
I now work as a self employed support worker with a disabled person and get $61.83 and hour.
Nursing is not worth it.

TheFuckingDogs · 08/11/2022 05:14

Support the nurses right to strike!
I do a very easy job. I earn £35 per hour. Don’t work long hours, all fits around my family life. Yes it’s no sick pay/holiday pay/pension BUT I’m incredibly lucky as I have a job that works for me and my family and is zero stress
nurses have trained hard to ge their degrees, do one of the most important jobs in our society, work long shifts, Christmas Day miss being with their families etc and they deserve a fucking pay rise.

and the person upthread saying they work in disability support and are low wage, shit conditions. Quite agree - you and social care generally also need a fucking pay rise.

LucyBMummy · 08/11/2022 04:53

HellsAngel81 · 07/11/2022 18:28

It would be better to compare your wage to a similar profession OP.

For example, I am a registered veterinary nurse on just over £13 pH. I have been qualified just over 20yrs, and have always worked full time - 40hr/week.

Yes HellsAngel, I have been thinking this today while listening to all of the news. Registered Veterinary Nurses have a starting salary of 20-22k a top salary for a senior nurse is likely to be 32k this is with years of experience and post graduate qualifications. While doing a comparable job to their human nursing colleagues.
The veterinary industry too is understaffed at the moment.

Pinkapron · 08/11/2022 00:43

To clarify, I’m not a liar, and I am very good at my job. I have previously been at a higher grade, in a different speciality (also have a post grad qualification for that one), I have taken time out of nursing for family reasons, and done a return to practice course, after which I was paid as a newly qualified nurse, rather than one with many years of experience and a relevant post grad qualification.
I have applied for a higher band, but it has gone to someone with less experience, without the relevant post grad course, who was obviously better at ‘talking the talk’ at interview.
I work part time, and love my job. I’m known for being very good at it, and am valued by my patients and my colleagues. I don’t want to change jobs, as DH encourages, because I enjoy it, and my colleagues, and feel very loyal towards them, although it is very stressful, and completely knackering. ATM though, it feels like we’re rats jumping off a sinking ship! So many staff have left over the last few years, and the new staff take time to train into the very specialised role. Quite often they leave just when we’ve got them trained up, usually for better pay and/or conditions.
I have voted to strike, with a heavy heart, not because I want to, but for the future of recruitment and retention, for the future of the profession I love, and always have, and most of all, for the safety of our patients, because something has to change.

OP posts:
Kitesk · 07/11/2022 23:41

jonojo · 07/11/2022 22:42

Very untrue. This certainly isn't the case in my trust and specifically where I work in the community. They usually progress within a few years. Also have quite a few nurse friends who are late 20's/early 30's who work for a different trust and are now all at least a band 6, 2 are a band 7. The only reason I see someone staying at a band 5 for this huge length of time is unwillingness or as another poster suggested, probably not very good at their job.

I'm not arguing with you. This issue and debate isn't about the trust you work in or I per say. This is across the board nursing as a whole what are you suggesting that there are more Sisters and above posts than band 5 nurses?? A band 6 still works on the ward well the good ones do!

Nurses in general stay at a band 5 because the responsibility of a band 6 isn't really worth it from a band and those that are recruited after a few years out of uni 🙄..... its because no buggy wants that department.

You sound like "Matron"

StrataZon · 07/11/2022 23:28

But in reality, how do you propose that would work?

I think @Peekachoochoo by having more band 6 roles available at ward/dept level. Band 6 is still very much a clinical grade so having opportunities for developing skills and moving into a promoted, but still very much clinical role

Alexandernevermind · 07/11/2022 23:19

Where I live £16ish per hour would be considered very respectable. Tradespeople don't necessarily work the straight 10 hours for one customer, they have to factor in fuel between customers and travel time, plus as others said holiday pay, sick pay, insurance, car, fuel, pension. Many self employed people I know would happily take a pay drop for job security and the paid holidays etc.

Peekachoochoo · 07/11/2022 23:16

StrataZon · 07/11/2022 22:59

But surely we don't want loads of nurses moving into management to earn more?
Should we not be recognising and rewarding the contribution of nurses who stay at the coal face providing direct patient care? Surely that is what the public would prefer?

But in reality, how do you propose that would work?

A high proportion of the working population are in exactly the same predicament. If you want to earn more you often have to step away from the 'frontline' operational roles and step up into management which is a different job and probably completely different skillset.

I was absolutely amazed when I joined the NHS at the sheer number of training and self development opportunities available. The offering in terms of training, benefits, pension, etc. has been far better than what i've experienced in private sector.

A lot of NHS staff assume that the grass is much greener in private sector but I think they would be pretty disappointed at the reality.

TomTraubertsBlues · 07/11/2022 23:08

NamelessNancy · 07/11/2022 23:07

Is it really helpful to pitch one profession against others? The crazy inflation we are seeing at the moment is affecting people across many career paths. We should all be standing together, not picking and dividing. Totally support the nursing strike action as well as all others who can.

Agree with this

NamelessNancy · 07/11/2022 23:07

Is it really helpful to pitch one profession against others? The crazy inflation we are seeing at the moment is affecting people across many career paths. We should all be standing together, not picking and dividing. Totally support the nursing strike action as well as all others who can.

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 23:06

StrataZon · 07/11/2022 22:59

But surely we don't want loads of nurses moving into management to earn more?
Should we not be recognising and rewarding the contribution of nurses who stay at the coal face providing direct patient care? Surely that is what the public would prefer?

We do need good nurses moving into management also though, no one wants someone with no clinical experience running a clinical department. Many don't want to stop working on the front line though and end up going into management to earn more and they are not always good at it. They definitely need to be paid more IMO.

TomTraubertsBlues · 07/11/2022 23:02

Rippled · 07/11/2022 22:51

But there is no scope for greater efficiency? None?

If you honestly believe you are running at max efficiency, I would rather the NHS collapse then tip even more money into its big black hole of inefficiency and entitlement.

As it goes, I'd rather you reform, but you never will because you honestly believe that you are running that massive behemoth at max efficiency and with minimal bureaucracy. No way are you. No where near.

I don't work for the NHS so not sure why you're asking me if I'm running at maximum efficiency. I used to, and it was bloody hard work.

You clearly know fuck all about the topic, and therefore fuck all about how efficient the NHS may or may not be.

The fact that your first thought was "stress yoga" workshops rather than the many, many essential corporate epartments in a hospital says a lot about your facility for critical thinking.

StrataZon · 07/11/2022 22:59

Peekachoochoo · 07/11/2022 22:53

Sorry if I've offended anyone but there are absolutely loads of jobs out there where earning capacity is limited unless people upskill and move up into a specialist role or management. It doesn't matter how much experience you have.

This applies to private sector just as much as the NHS. In fact, having worked in both I'd say it's almost worse in private sector.

But surely we don't want loads of nurses moving into management to earn more?
Should we not be recognising and rewarding the contribution of nurses who stay at the coal face providing direct patient care? Surely that is what the public would prefer?

Egghead68 · 07/11/2022 22:57

My (non-emergency) plumber charges £120 an hour plus callout fee…

Worriedddd · 07/11/2022 22:55

Desiredeffect · 07/11/2022 22:40

Support working with very challenging adults with disabilities. I dispense meds and give insulin and only paid £10.50 an hour. I should be on so much more specially when I get hit most days a work and my company won't pay us challenging behaviour pay which is £11.55 an hour

Move to the wards. Social care expected you to work with the same person for 14 hours a shift then sleep jn. Minimal training I didn't even have breakaway or MVA restraint training. I moved onto the wards and later did my nurse training. Even as a HCA you would be rotated hourly and the pay was more fair.

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 22:54

Rippled · 07/11/2022 22:51

But there is no scope for greater efficiency? None?

If you honestly believe you are running at max efficiency, I would rather the NHS collapse then tip even more money into its big black hole of inefficiency and entitlement.

As it goes, I'd rather you reform, but you never will because you honestly believe that you are running that massive behemoth at max efficiency and with minimal bureaucracy. No way are you. No where near.

You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about clearly.

Peekachoochoo · 07/11/2022 22:53

Sorry if I've offended anyone but there are absolutely loads of jobs out there where earning capacity is limited unless people upskill and move up into a specialist role or management. It doesn't matter how much experience you have.

This applies to private sector just as much as the NHS. In fact, having worked in both I'd say it's almost worse in private sector.

FlirtyMelons · 07/11/2022 22:52

TomTraubertsBlues · 07/11/2022 22:47

This comment shows you to be incredibly ignorant. Even an average sized district general hospital trust will employ 5000+ staff - these are huge organisations.

Who do you should propose should run payroll, recruitment, HR?
What about estates and building maintenance?
Finance, cashflow, capex planning?
IT, telecomms?
Procurement of meds and equipment?

Those are all corporate functions, and all 100% essential.

Thank you, I should have made the effort to post this myself really in response to that comment but I assumed someone who could be so nasty/ignorant was not worth responding properly to.

The corporate functions work extremely hard, I hate the awful reputation they have as its certainly not been my experience in the NHS trusts I have worked for over the last 25 years. We work many many hours over what we are paid for, worked solidly throughout lockdown with no bank hols or leave at all and mucked in with clinical services and then the vaccine centres over and above our jobs. Nothing different to many other jobs and obv the benefits are good don't get me wrong, but we do work hard nonetheless and for a lot less than in the private sector.