Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses’ pay compared with other jobs

216 replies

Pinkapron · 07/11/2022 17:40

Would anyone be prepared to share what they pay tradespeople in their homes, eg cleaners, gardeners, plumbers, electricians etc, per hour please?
I am a staff nurse, 32 years qualified, with post graduate qualifications, and earn £16.84 per hour.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 08/11/2022 21:51

When I was a TA , I earned around £9000 pa.

Tontostitis · 08/11/2022 20:17

Sick pay, maternity pay, holiday pay, job security. Apples and pears tbh.

alwaysstressed · 08/11/2022 20:13

Im a dog groomer and work for myself and I make roughly £20 p/h

user1484264563 · 08/11/2022 20:07

Agreed re. the daily rates which sting a bit but you're not comparing like with like. If it's going through the books 20% of that is vat and a nurse who is full time gets 28 days paid holiday plus sick pay etc and quite decent pension contributions all of which have to be factored in for self employed.

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 18:39

@OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide but that's the point isn't it. Not all band 5 nurses have the same job description. An icu nurse will have a different job description to a general ward nurse. And A&E nurse will have a different job description to a primary health nurse. A theatre nurse will have a different job description to a school nurse. They are different roles with different responsibility levels but they are all band 5 and as you say banded together.

We need nurses who have been years in these roles and know it inside out to keep experience and continuity. It's not all about moving up to management.

Personally I do feel a lot of these roles should be on a band 6. Management should be on band 7 and above. And the wider NHS roles (HCA, physiotherapists, junior doctors, radiology and many more) need to be paid in accordance with their responsibilities. Management and unions need to support and be brutally honest with the responsibility their staff members hold.

TopBitchoftheWitches · 08/11/2022 18:23

I'm a domcillary carer and get £10.80 an hour. I'm responsible for adminstering medication, safely moving service users. Some of these are half hour calls so £5.40. I wish we could strike.

RVNsareheroes · 08/11/2022 18:08

@Schnauzersaremyheros @LucyBMummy @HellsAngel81 Sorry - don't think my post re union for vets/RVNs above tagged you all properly. Sorry for repeat posting if it did!

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 08/11/2022 18:08

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 16:09

Not all nurses are Band 5.

But most are, and do you believe all band 5 nurses are paid fairly and been assessed on their individual roles?

No need to assess those with the same job descriptions. But if something changed, eg management responsibility or specialism, then yes.

Kitesk · 08/11/2022 17:14

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 12:18

The unions need to look at NHS roles individually and look at what responsibility each role holds.

For example, a paramedic is a band 6 as standard after the initial 2 years because they are generally away from a team of people and making decisions on their own. Most ambulance trusts now have ambulance technicians at a band 5 because the responsibility they hold is very similar to a paramedic making decisions without a team behind them often working with another technician or as the senior clinician on scene.

I think we should stop looking at "I studied for x years and hold x qualification" and look at the responsibility the role holds to determine the pay band. In a lot of cases nurses hold a lot of responsibility which doesn't correlate to a band 5. A nurse is such a varied role with lots and lots of different areas (ward, intensive care, A&E, district, primary health). So saying a nurse as standard should receive X band won't work.

HCA and carers are always well and truest shafted, they do all the traditional nursing duties (personal care, observations, assisting with living and mobility etc.) are band 2 (21,000 a year). These are the guys we should be fighting for higher and fair pay.

Unison are fighting for band 2/3s currently. The NHS has been forced to look at each area and what a band 2 is allowed to do. It's about time because if you want a HCA to admitt a nurses patient in a hospital bed they should be paid accordingly.

RVNsareheroes · 08/11/2022 16:33

@Schnauzersaremyheros @LucyBMummy @HellsAngel81 and anyone else who may be in the veterinary profession - whilst we don't have a long tradition of unionisation we do now have the British Veterinary Union in Unite. It's relatively early days but with growing corporatisation it may be that union recognition may become more of a feature in the future in addition to the other benefits which come from being in a union. As with any union it will become as strong as it's membership allows.

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 16:09

Not all nurses are Band 5.

But most are, and do you believe all band 5 nurses are paid fairly and been assessed on their individual roles?

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 08/11/2022 15:56

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 15:04

This is exactly what job banding under Agenda for Change looks at. :-s

But it hasn't worked has it? Because all nurses are lumped together in a band 5. There are so many different areas, maybe it's time to change the name of nurse to the specific role they have and re-grade them. You can have an ITU nurse dealing with complex needs and drug therapy Vs a primary health nurse working 9-5 in a small village. I'm not saying one role is more important than the other, but they are different roles which require different responsibilities.

Not all nurses are Band 5.

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 15:04

This is exactly what job banding under Agenda for Change looks at. :-s

But it hasn't worked has it? Because all nurses are lumped together in a band 5. There are so many different areas, maybe it's time to change the name of nurse to the specific role they have and re-grade them. You can have an ITU nurse dealing with complex needs and drug therapy Vs a primary health nurse working 9-5 in a small village. I'm not saying one role is more important than the other, but they are different roles which require different responsibilities.

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 08/11/2022 14:52

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 12:18

The unions need to look at NHS roles individually and look at what responsibility each role holds.

For example, a paramedic is a band 6 as standard after the initial 2 years because they are generally away from a team of people and making decisions on their own. Most ambulance trusts now have ambulance technicians at a band 5 because the responsibility they hold is very similar to a paramedic making decisions without a team behind them often working with another technician or as the senior clinician on scene.

I think we should stop looking at "I studied for x years and hold x qualification" and look at the responsibility the role holds to determine the pay band. In a lot of cases nurses hold a lot of responsibility which doesn't correlate to a band 5. A nurse is such a varied role with lots and lots of different areas (ward, intensive care, A&E, district, primary health). So saying a nurse as standard should receive X band won't work.

HCA and carers are always well and truest shafted, they do all the traditional nursing duties (personal care, observations, assisting with living and mobility etc.) are band 2 (21,000 a year). These are the guys we should be fighting for higher and fair pay.

This is exactly what job banding under Agenda for Change looks at. :-s

Peekachoochoo · 08/11/2022 13:09

@PomRuns That's a bit of an assumption.

I work alongside nurses. I know what's going on. The same thing happens in a lot of industries. It's not just nurses.

I never went into nursing as it was common knowledge that it was low paid despite having far better benefits and security than the vast majority of jobs. People never went into it to earn mega bucks. Life has moved on though and the role is more respected than it's ever been.

What could you compare it to in terms of salary expectations though? There are lots of jobs that require technical expertise and experience that tail off after the £35k/£40k mark, teaching included. Most people wanting to get beyond those salary thresholds need to look at other options.

RiverSong200 · 08/11/2022 12:18

The unions need to look at NHS roles individually and look at what responsibility each role holds.

For example, a paramedic is a band 6 as standard after the initial 2 years because they are generally away from a team of people and making decisions on their own. Most ambulance trusts now have ambulance technicians at a band 5 because the responsibility they hold is very similar to a paramedic making decisions without a team behind them often working with another technician or as the senior clinician on scene.

I think we should stop looking at "I studied for x years and hold x qualification" and look at the responsibility the role holds to determine the pay band. In a lot of cases nurses hold a lot of responsibility which doesn't correlate to a band 5. A nurse is such a varied role with lots and lots of different areas (ward, intensive care, A&E, district, primary health). So saying a nurse as standard should receive X band won't work.

HCA and carers are always well and truest shafted, they do all the traditional nursing duties (personal care, observations, assisting with living and mobility etc.) are band 2 (21,000 a year). These are the guys we should be fighting for higher and fair pay.

LucyBMummy · 08/11/2022 09:42

Schnauzersaremyheros · 08/11/2022 07:09

Not to mention the fact that we have to legally be registered in order to practice, be CPD compliant to stay on register, and can be struck off the register for any fuck-ups!

And I don't think we would EVER get the option to strike either - we don't even have a union soley for veterinary nurses.

Yes!! We can only hope these conversations will bring (small) change for our industry too.

banjaxxed · 08/11/2022 09:42

The point is though that for any job (NHS, private, whatever) there is a salary ceiling for the level of responsibility it carries.

In this case, it's c£32K for a band 5 (I assume that's base pay though before shift/unsociable hours)

Whether that salary is high enough for that level of role is the question.

PomRuns · 08/11/2022 08:26

What nonsense @Peekachoochoo you can’t speak for the majority of nurses or have insight into hours and grades..

Peekachoochoo · 08/11/2022 08:12

Pinkapron · 08/11/2022 00:43

To clarify, I’m not a liar, and I am very good at my job. I have previously been at a higher grade, in a different speciality (also have a post grad qualification for that one), I have taken time out of nursing for family reasons, and done a return to practice course, after which I was paid as a newly qualified nurse, rather than one with many years of experience and a relevant post grad qualification.
I have applied for a higher band, but it has gone to someone with less experience, without the relevant post grad course, who was obviously better at ‘talking the talk’ at interview.
I work part time, and love my job. I’m known for being very good at it, and am valued by my patients and my colleagues. I don’t want to change jobs, as DH encourages, because I enjoy it, and my colleagues, and feel very loyal towards them, although it is very stressful, and completely knackering. ATM though, it feels like we’re rats jumping off a sinking ship! So many staff have left over the last few years, and the new staff take time to train into the very specialised role. Quite often they leave just when we’ve got them trained up, usually for better pay and/or conditions.
I have voted to strike, with a heavy heart, not because I want to, but for the future of recruitment and retention, for the future of the profession I love, and always have, and most of all, for the safety of our patients, because something has to change.

With all due respect, this would be exactly the same in a lot of other careers.

I was a PA in the region of 20 odd years. I worked at senior level and maxed out my salary at the £40k mark. I had a lot of knowledge and experience and worked for some very big bosses running multi million pound companies. I could have potentially earned more if I worked in London but I was already working very long hours and received next to nothing in terms of time off in lieu or bonuses for the privilege. It was also incredibly stressful. My pension has never been as good as an NHS pension and part-time was never an option at that level. You just can't do that role on reduced hours due to the pace of change and workload.

Towards the end I decided that I had just had enough. I changed careers a few years ago and do something completely different now.

I've thought about going back to that several times recently but know that I would have to step back in at a much lower level for a lower salary which I know I wouldn't particularly enjoy as there is a very high possibility I would have to work for a large team doing run of the mill work rather than a 1:1 role with lots of project work and autonomy.

The NHS is one of the very few employers with a glut of part-time roles and lots of women at senior level. Being part-time isn't sniffed at and you don't constantly receive barbed comments from male colleagues about what you're doing on your 'day off'. Look at the management structure of the majority of companies and it will be a miracle if you see one woman in amongst the white middle aged men. It is almost impossible to rise the ranks in most companies due to the patriarchy and having to compete in a man's world. Yes, some people on here manage it but they've generally had to sacrifice their lives at the lower level to get into a position where they are respected enough to get the work flexibility.

At the end of the day it is what it is. You're doing a Band 5 role and that's what it pays. You want to earn more but only want to work part-time/do this job because you like the status quo. I'm not really sure what you think the solution is. There are loads of women on these threads who have stepped down from really decent jobs pre-children and find it impossible to get back at that level without doing full time roles at huge expense to their physical and mental health. Lots of women give up work then scratch around looking for work and end up working part-time low paid jobs in schools, admin or healthcare. You just need to hang around the employment boards for a while to realise that this is a real problem.

My eyes roll back in my head when I hear some of my NHS colleagues. The majority of them haven't got a clue what goes on in the 'real world'.

Schnauzersaremyheros · 08/11/2022 07:09

LucyBMummy · 08/11/2022 04:53

Yes HellsAngel, I have been thinking this today while listening to all of the news. Registered Veterinary Nurses have a starting salary of 20-22k a top salary for a senior nurse is likely to be 32k this is with years of experience and post graduate qualifications. While doing a comparable job to their human nursing colleagues.
The veterinary industry too is understaffed at the moment.

Not to mention the fact that we have to legally be registered in order to practice, be CPD compliant to stay on register, and can be struck off the register for any fuck-ups!

And I don't think we would EVER get the option to strike either - we don't even have a union soley for veterinary nurses.

PomRuns · 08/11/2022 07:07

jonojo · 08/11/2022 06:39

She earns 33-40k working as a shop assistant? Hmm What kind of shop is it? I don't believe this for one second.

It doesn’t matter what you believe. No need to be so abrasive.

Steakandquinoa · 08/11/2022 06:55

When talking about nurses, I think we should remember our Healthcare Assistants who do a very responsible, mentally and physically hard job earning between 21,000 and 22,000 pa. They’re the reason I voted to strike!

jonojo · 08/11/2022 06:39

Mamai90 · 08/11/2022 05:48

My sister is a band 6 nurse and gets the same wage as my SIL who works in a shop (not in a managerial role). This really shocked me.

She earns 33-40k working as a shop assistant? Hmm What kind of shop is it? I don't believe this for one second.

PomRuns · 08/11/2022 06:28

jonojo · 07/11/2022 22:43

Also most trusts pay for the training on the job, I've never known any nurse to have to pay for their own training such as prescribing or clinic skills etc. so I'm baffled as to where you got this information from.

This is trust specific. Many staff - drs, nurses, ahps have to pay for courses including prescribing. Also no study leave given - not unique to the nhs of course.

Swipe left for the next trending thread