Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunatic's money claim and Practise direction 3.a striking out a claim

121 replies

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 11:54

Being pursued for compensation by the owner of a venue I hired.

The signed contract between him and myself contains no references of damage, the person being taken to SCC isn't the hirer, I am, and the claimant has no proof of the damages either.

(It's over a stained tablecloth)

He obviously hasn't replaced them and shown us a receipt, he's sent an invoice that we're of course not obliged to pay.

How can I speed up this case being struck off, can I do something to apply for it to be thrown out under section 3.4

(3) those which contain a coherent set of facts but those facts, even if true, do not disclose any legally recognisable claim against the defendant.
Do I write to the court office?

OP posts:
1Wanda1 · 07/11/2022 14:57

@Heronwatcher. You'd pay £275 of your own money to apply for summary judgment (an application which is more likely than not to fail, because all the claimant has to prove is that he has a reasonable chance of success in the claim - a SJ hearing is NOT a hearing of that evidence; it is a determination of whether there is a properly arguable claim), rather than either pay the £120 claimed or just wait for the final hearing of the claim?

That is not sensible advice.

Mummytutoo · 07/11/2022 14:56

It's an N244 application and £275 fee. I'd just wait for hearing if I were you

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:55

WHEREEL · 07/11/2022 14:26

I’ve been on the other side of one of these claims and won. I wouldn’t spend any money and go on a free fishing expedition . Put in a DSAR request for any data they have on your friend e.g CCTV images. Also set up a few reminders to chase them for the evidence re the table cloth damage. This way you’ll start to build up a bundle to show there is no evidence of the claim.

Until you have any concrete evidence I wouldn't stress. The process shouldn’t take more than a day; writing a quick defence, a couple of emails re the data the other side have, maybe an hour writing a witness statement and a few hours in court. I’d image the other side will give up if they don’t have any evidence and it’s clear your not an east target to build up their bank balance

Free fishing! That's an excellent idea and sounds like it might eventually wear him down, he still hasn't read my dispute form because it's very detailed, so he doesn't realise how much we've already put together.

OP posts:
LocalMum21 · 07/11/2022 14:47

Have you got a Notice of Hearing with a Hearing date? That will tell your friend the exact dates when both parties need to file key documents/bundles in support of their claim/Defence. A word of warning given your comment about being a robust witness, I would watch your ‘robustness’ as you’re likely to annoy the DJ and lose the claim for your friend. Keep to the facts, keep calm. Review once you have CL’s evidence and statement. Whose paying the £181 (or whatever it was) for the Listing Fee when it’s only for £120? If you don’t pay your friends Defence will be struck out. Is it definitely your friend who has to pay this or CL? I suspect CL. His court fees are recoverable if he wins, your friends won’t be if he successfully defends. I know it’s a bitter pill to swallow but look at the financials and decide whether it’s worth cutting off your nose for a hollow (and expensive) victory.

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:41

Heronwatcher · 07/11/2022 14:36

hallellis.co.uk/summary-judgment-applications-defences/

This sets out the details- you don’t need to wait until 14 days prior to the hearing- especially if you put him on notice (by writing to him) that unless he provides the evidence by X date you’ll apply for summary judgment. The court might give him one last chance by issuing a direction after you make the application too.

I don’t disagree that paying the madman off is also a legitimate way to proceed but if you’re not going to I’d definitely apply for SJ rather than wait for a trial.

That's a good idea and I'd like to think it might help, even if I don't intend to do it

OP posts:
QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:38

He who has the last laugh wins ;)

It's been an interesting thread though!

QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:36

Water damage to a tablecloth is quite a leap really lol.

But your friend is stressed, so pay the asshole.

Word of mouth (nothing in writing) about this venue, will cost him far more than a water spill on a tablecloth. Who the fuck sues someone for water damage to a tablecloth ffs? He's clearly deranged, so view it as a charitable act.

You WILL laugh about this in time to come.

Heronwatcher · 07/11/2022 14:36

hallellis.co.uk/summary-judgment-applications-defences/

This sets out the details- you don’t need to wait until 14 days prior to the hearing- especially if you put him on notice (by writing to him) that unless he provides the evidence by X date you’ll apply for summary judgment. The court might give him one last chance by issuing a direction after you make the application too.

I don’t disagree that paying the madman off is also a legitimate way to proceed but if you’re not going to I’d definitely apply for SJ rather than wait for a trial.

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:35

scarletisjustred · 07/11/2022 14:28

Have you even got rights to appear as a non-lawyer? Assuuming you do, I hope your submissions are a lot a clearer than your post. For what it's worth lawyers try really hard to make their submissions easily understood rather annoying the judge with a jumbled mass of confusing material.

I don't know if I can speak on his behalf at the hearing, but if I can't then I'll be one hell of a witness.

OP posts:
HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:34

Longdarkcloud · 07/11/2022 14:29

Surely he expected the tablecloths to be used as tablecloths and food and drink stains are “ normal wear and tear”. I doubt many people would want to hire a venue where their guests’ messy eating might expose them to a claim for hundreds of ££ compensation.
Is this place on Trip Advisor? Or could you use Twitter etc to see if others have been subjected to vexatious claims?

There are very few reviews but some of them suggest that the man is question is a nasty piece of work

OP posts:
HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:32

scarletisjustred · 07/11/2022 14:28

Have you even got rights to appear as a non-lawyer? Assuuming you do, I hope your submissions are a lot a clearer than your post. For what it's worth lawyers try really hard to make their submissions easily understood rather annoying the judge with a jumbled mass of confusing material.

Don't assume I'm posting in the manner I've assembled the dispute response. It's very clearly set out in a detailed timeline with all supporting documents.

OP posts:
QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:29

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:24

My friend is in bits but of course doesn't want to pay for something he didn't do and let the bully have the satisfaction.

I might mention he told us while we were setting up that he often has problems "getting money from people" after the event and we didn't really pay him much heed as it was literally the day before my wedding, but another friend asked him what he meant and it sounds like he does this to everyone.

For you friend's peace of mind - I'd pay this twat. Honestly, I thought I'd vomit at the injustice of paying that fucking fine, but once I paid it - done, dusted, they thought they won but I won really. I could still be disputing that bloody fine! I mean I did say 'I like wasting police time' lol. Oh God, maybe just pay the arsehole and have this as an anecdote to tell your grandchildren. Nobody is winning with a twat like him. Being the bigger person is sometimes reward in itself. Your friend will be relieved and believe me, you'll be relieved.

Longdarkcloud · 07/11/2022 14:29

Surely he expected the tablecloths to be used as tablecloths and food and drink stains are “ normal wear and tear”. I doubt many people would want to hire a venue where their guests’ messy eating might expose them to a claim for hundreds of ££ compensation.
Is this place on Trip Advisor? Or could you use Twitter etc to see if others have been subjected to vexatious claims?

LocalMum21 · 07/11/2022 14:28

All CL will do if you do get it struck out, or they lose at the SCT Trial, is reissue against you as the hirer. Is it just £120.00 they are claiming? Did you include within your defence they have sued the wrong person? I wouldn’t issue a strike out app as it’s cheaper to pay the £120.00. You may not get it back if you succeed as it’s a SCT matter and run the risk of having to pay the £120.00 plus the issue fee (and fixed costs if they have legal rep) so you’ll be even more out of pocket. Plus the Listing Fee you refer to. I’d just cut your losses as it’s going to potentially cost you a lot more in the long run. You also don’t get any costs as a defendant in a SCT matter. Just the knowledge you have won unless you can prove unreasonable conduct. I’ve never seen this happen, and I doubt it will happen if CL is representing themselves.

scarletisjustred · 07/11/2022 14:28

Have you even got rights to appear as a non-lawyer? Assuuming you do, I hope your submissions are a lot a clearer than your post. For what it's worth lawyers try really hard to make their submissions easily understood rather annoying the judge with a jumbled mass of confusing material.

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:27

Thanks everyone by the way for talking to me about this - whether you agree or not it's nice to hear from a mix of people.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 07/11/2022 14:27

He does not need to disclose his evidence yet. The particulars of claim are just that - particulars. Evidence comes at a later stage .

WHEREEL · 07/11/2022 14:26

I’ve been on the other side of one of these claims and won. I wouldn’t spend any money and go on a free fishing expedition . Put in a DSAR request for any data they have on your friend e.g CCTV images. Also set up a few reminders to chase them for the evidence re the table cloth damage. This way you’ll start to build up a bundle to show there is no evidence of the claim.

Until you have any concrete evidence I wouldn't stress. The process shouldn’t take more than a day; writing a quick defence, a couple of emails re the data the other side have, maybe an hour writing a witness statement and a few hours in court. I’d image the other side will give up if they don’t have any evidence and it’s clear your not an east target to build up their bank balance

Oysterbabe · 07/11/2022 14:25

Litigation is supposed to be last resort. He should have submitted his claim and supporting evidence before taking any action.

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:24

QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:21

How does your friend feel about this? Is it stressing them out?

I know you feel responsible as you've been put in an almost impossible situation - your friend was helping you out and they now have a court case (some people find that incredibly stressful).

TBH - the cost of the application sounds more costly than actually paying £150 to a solicitor.

I know it's hard to let go sometimes. But when you let go and let them have their victory, it's you who wins in the end.

My friend is in bits but of course doesn't want to pay for something he didn't do and let the bully have the satisfaction.

I might mention he told us while we were setting up that he often has problems "getting money from people" after the event and we didn't really pay him much heed as it was literally the day before my wedding, but another friend asked him what he meant and it sounds like he does this to everyone.

OP posts:
QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:23

AegeanBlue · 07/11/2022 14:18

I totally get that you don’t want to give him money. He is a jerk and you don’t want to reward him.

however. You have to ask yourself though - is it really worth fighting? It may take a lot of time, energy and headspace to bring this to a close. And so any victory will be pyrrhic. Redefine winning as making this go away for a relatively small amount of money.

In your shoes, galling as it is, I would give your friend the money to settle and put this nonsense behind you.

I spent 2 solid weeks debating whether to pay or dispute my fine. Once I finally paid the fucking thing, peace descended on me. Shit like this can just eat you up. Will I? Won't I? Of course you don't want a liar to win but equally, you want peace of mind - and believe me you cannot put a price on peace of mind.

QwithaC · 07/11/2022 14:21

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:17

If he has evidence failed to include it on his claim form, and he failed to show it to us for five weeks before filing it despite being repeatedly asked to show us.

How does your friend feel about this? Is it stressing them out?

I know you feel responsible as you've been put in an almost impossible situation - your friend was helping you out and they now have a court case (some people find that incredibly stressful).

TBH - the cost of the application sounds more costly than actually paying £150 to a solicitor.

I know it's hard to let go sometimes. But when you let go and let them have their victory, it's you who wins in the end.

1Wanda1 · 07/11/2022 14:20

@HeadacheEarthquake

"I think the timeline here is relevant, in that he claimed all of this five weeks before the money claim, so it was us asking him repeatedly for five weeks to show us the "diagnosis" from his laundry advisor (he doesn't have one) or any photos or receipts. It wasn't all in the space of a week, it was repeatedly made clear to him that we required evidence for five weeks, where he just repeatedly said no, pay me or I'll take legal action."

None of that makes any difference to his claim.

Given the minimal value of this claim, I would strongly recommend ignoring the advice on this thread (which appears to come from non-lawyers) to spend a £275 court fee filing an application for strike out or summary judgment, both of which would be likely to fail. Your friend is the defendant in this claim. Why on earth would he want to spend more money than the sum actually claimed on speeding up the process? Just let it run its course to a final hearing (which will take ages, annoying the claimant), and on the basis of what's been said on this thread, the claimant will probably lose.

Or just pay the £60 or £120 or whatever it is and move on. Points of principle are not points to litigate, unless you have Rebekah Vardy's wallet. And even she regretted it.

AegeanBlue · 07/11/2022 14:18

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 13:13

He started by demanding we send him £60 with no details evidence provided (as we just had paid him around £7000 for his venue) then he changed his mind and upped it to another price of £120 when we asked for some proof and sent an invoice.

He phoned us screaming and shouting when we queried it which made me absolutely not want to give him any money.

I totally get that you don’t want to give him money. He is a jerk and you don’t want to reward him.

however. You have to ask yourself though - is it really worth fighting? It may take a lot of time, energy and headspace to bring this to a close. And so any victory will be pyrrhic. Redefine winning as making this go away for a relatively small amount of money.

In your shoes, galling as it is, I would give your friend the money to settle and put this nonsense behind you.

HeadacheEarthquake · 07/11/2022 14:17

Mummbles · 07/11/2022 14:14

He has until 14 days before the hearing as standard. Unless we're within that time frame, he's entitled to not show his hand (although the court may well keep that in mind when determining a costs order).

If he has evidence failed to include it on his claim form, and he failed to show it to us for five weeks before filing it despite being repeatedly asked to show us.

OP posts: