Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think she needs to just accept it?

57 replies

totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 10:44

My gran is 86 and is feeling very down about her life. I've spoken to her yesterday and it's all doom and gloom, she's stuck at home, she never goes out anywhere, there's no light at the end of the tunnel and she has nothing to look forward to ever again, no trips, no holidays. They have enjoyed a lovely long retirement for about 25 years and gone on lots of holidays until a few years ago so it is a big change for them. They had remained in really good health for their age for a long time but now my grandad is in worse health and can't really leave the house often anymore as he is reliant on oxygen. They go out for lunch every few weeks for lunch with friends and my gran does go to the local shops quite regularly and hairdresser weekly.

She asks me what I'm up to with my young family and I feel bad telling her about our busy lives and all the things we're doing. I wish I could do something to help, but AIBU to think that she needs to accept that her time is nearly up and be grateful for what she does have? (Still has her husband, no money worries, lovely warm comfy flat, some family nearby). Unfortunately I live ~5 hours drive away and can't get up to see her regularly due to working full time and young children. I do get it and it must suck to realise that your life is basically over but it comes to us all! What can I do to help her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bluelavender · 07/11/2022 13:07

Some harsh comments here- It sounds like OP is attentive; and it can be challenging to have circular conversations with elderly relatives that are bleak in tone- there is an emotional cost to this; particularly if you feel that there is nothing you can do to make it better.

The OPs gran sounds depressed; and depression in older adults is not often taken seriously. Could you try saying' I'm so sorry to hear that you are feeling this way; have you spoken about it with your GP?'

I think a carers's assessment would be a great idea

UnderHisPie · 07/11/2022 12:54

My grandma is a bit like this. She is in her 90s, is pretty pragmatic about death, lost her husband 20 years ago and now lives in an annex in my Dad's house.

She has led a full and happy life and would appear to be facing a relatively comfortable and secure last few years.

She has a lot to be thankful for. But I also get how desperately sad it must be to feel like all your fun is done, all your usefulness is gone, and you're basically just reading library books and watching Miss Marple until your time is up (is how she views it).

I am not sure there is much of a cure, except to make sure she feels loved.

Things that have helped a little:

  • A family whatsapp group. She's not great with tech but slowly has been helped to figure this out. We all post regularly with pics about our days. Nothing especially exciting (the dog lying in a funny pose, for exmaple). But it allows her to feel more connected and involved in everyone's lives.
  • A digital picture frame that cycles through all her photos (we scanned them all) so she still feels like she 'sees' loved ones every day, and gets reminded of everything she's done.
  • Doing the same things together but apart. For example, this year a few of us are growing the same new flower in each of our gardens (a specific dahlia). My grandma can manage this and when we talk, we compare notes and it's a bit like a joint acitvity
User57713 · 07/11/2022 12:38

I think you worded your posts badly op, you sound like you care very much that your gran is unhappy.

I can sort of relate, your life does change as you get older. It gets smaller, it's a natural process and you can't change it. You stop being able to do things you could before. That's just how it goes. Some people are more accepting of that and more able to adapt to it than others.

I work on a voluntary basis with older people and as a sweeping generalisation the ones who can accept ageing and adapt their activities seem happier. There are others who constantly look back to things the used to be able to do but can't now. I hope I age like the first group, with a good attitude, but you just never know how things will turn out. So much shapes your attitudes and abilities, you can't always just 'give yourself a shake' or 'look on the bright side'. It's not always that easy.

It is frustrating to listen to someone always 'moan' about how their life has changed and feel you can't do anything for them.

I think all you can do, like others have suggested, is make sure your gps have as much support as they can have to take the physical burden off your gran. Then maybe she'll feel a bit lighter. So a carer's assessment through social services, buying in private care or companionship if possible.

Then just keep in touch. Of course she wants to hear your news. It will brighten her day. Send her something in the post, a book if she still reads or a magazine? Do your kids chat to her? Do they share an interest in nature programmes or history documentaries or Strictly?

And yes, listen to her moan. It gets you down, I know, but it will be doing her some good getting it off her chest.

totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 12:30

LookingForTipsNotPuns · 07/11/2022 12:26

Says the person sick of her "moaning"

Please, show me where I used the word "moaning"

OP posts:
Feysriana · 07/11/2022 12:27

I know she has a husband but she needs more company, preferably female. She needs a befriending service but doesn’t have the energy to work that out, google befriending in her area and see if there’s any charities you can out her in touch with. Also get in touch with Age Uk etc.

YABVU if you think she should sit in silence waiting to die. If she’s healthy (and wealthy) she coukd have another 10-15 yrs left.

YABU if you aren’t happy to just listen to her moan sometimes. Think of all the times you cried at her as a toddler. This is the other end of that journey and you owe it to her to listen, even if you can’t ‘fix’ the problem. Maybe schedule a 1 hr phone call at a regular time, twice weekly, so she can look forward to it?

LookingForTipsNotPuns · 07/11/2022 12:26

Says the person sick of her "moaning"

pastabakeonaplate · 07/11/2022 12:26

totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 12:24

@MotherOfFireBreathers yes, I can accept that I worded it clumsily. But she's not going to read it!! I would never say anything like this to her. We are very close and I will be devastated when they both go

Ok so you worded it clumsily, can you think how you might rephrase it? I'm genuinely trying to understand your view. Do you mean you don't like that she focuses on that and you want to try and make her life exciting?

totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 12:26

@whatsup00 sadly not, he is in much worse health and I don't think he has long left. He is old and tired and can't breathe and has no interest in doing anything. So i do understand why she won't leave him, maybe she will want to get out more when it's just her 😢

OP posts:
totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 12:24

@MotherOfFireBreathers yes, I can accept that I worded it clumsily. But she's not going to read it!! I would never say anything like this to her. We are very close and I will be devastated when they both go

OP posts:
totallybonafido · 07/11/2022 12:22

@LookingForTipsNotPuns what a horrible comment. I don't need or want her money and would much rather have my grandparents

OP posts:
LookingForTipsNotPuns · 07/11/2022 12:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

russetmellow · 07/11/2022 12:13

AIBU to think that she needs to accept that her time is nearly up and be grateful for what she does have

Seeing as this was your original question, then yes YABU for being so brutal in your attitude. Your poor grandma, she's clearly having a really difficult time and is reaching out for help. She might be elderly but she's also still a human being with a life who is trying to exert some agency and needs help in continuing to find meaning. Can you not specifically address it with the family that live closer?

MotherOfFireBreathers · 07/11/2022 12:12

I wish I could do something to help, but AIBU to think that she needs to accept that her time is nearly up and be grateful for what she does have?

Yep, it's this as to why you're getting a hard time and rightly so tbh. You then point out all the ways that you are caring but it's just such a crass and horrible thing that you have written, perhaps you've expressed yourself very clumsily and I'm being generous to you there, but the way you've written that makes it sound like you're not particularly upset that she won't be around much longer as well!

I say that as someone who is very pragmatic about very elderly people dying, I've had too many younger relatives die and someone dying in their 80s/90s is not tragic, it's just life. But on a personal level I miss my grandparents so much, I wish so much that they were still here. My last grandparent recently died and its brought back all the sadness at losing the others too. And how I wish I had spent more time with them.

whatsup00 · 07/11/2022 12:04

also - maybe focus on what your grandad likes doing. are there any hobbies he enjoys that a friend can come and do with him? then she would have to 'get out of the way' maybe reframed like that it would be easier for her to go out!

pastabakeonaplate · 07/11/2022 12:03

AIBU to think that she needs to accept that her time is nearly up and be grateful for what she does have? it's this bit that's making people think badly of you I think. She might not be able to accept it and she might be struggling with the aging process.

whatsup00 · 07/11/2022 12:02

it's her choice.
if she literally won't leave her husband and he's housebound the options are very limited.
the online tours thing was a good idea.
new hobbies that can be done inside - jigsaws, puzzles, crafts, making simple things.
encourage her to go out with a friend or to something but ultimately it's her decision. a bit sad bc she might really enjoy it once she is there. if i was housebound i would not want my partner to stay in with me 100% of the time at all. i'd want them to be able to go out and enjoy themselves, why should two people be confined when only one has to?

GerbilsForever24 · 07/11/2022 11:58

I wish I could do something to help, but AIBU to think that she needs to accept that her time is nearly up and be grateful for what she does have?

This IS a crass and unkind sentiment and why you're getting some negative responses. Reading your subsequent posts with an open mind, I think it sounds like this was expressed badly and mostly you're frustrated that she is so unhappy and can't be happy with what she has. Which is still a little unfair, but understandable.

It does sound like she COULD do stuff, but chooses not to. is she struggling because she is basically a carer for your granddad now? In which case perhaps you need to be encouraging her to look into more support - such as someone who comes to be with him a few times a week so she can perhaps get out a bit more. My gran has a more active social life than I do frankly - she's at the gardening club or her book club or getting her little chores done. She's 94 and gets tired easily so has cut back on what she does , but she keeps herself active both physically and mentally. But importantly, she doesn't have someone else she's responsible for ....

Beautiful3 · 07/11/2022 11:58

I know how you feel. My father is in the same boat. I used to go over all the time, but I was neglecting my family and house. Now I see him once a week and he calls me once a week too. That's enough for me. He can't believe how his life's changed too. I understand that. I find any suggestions I make e.g. downsize and move closer to me, join a club, get a hobby, reconnect with old living pals all gets dismissed. Sometimes they just like to have a good moan.

Georgeskitchen · 07/11/2022 11:48

If she won't leave grandad, how does she go to the shops and the hairdresseres every week? She must be mobile if she can do that. Most areas have lunch clubs etc for elderly folk, does she go to church?
There's lots of stuff elderly but mobile folk can do, but nobody can force them.
She could get a sitting service in for a couple of hours a week to get out and mingle with people. If she's not willing to do that then unfortunately there's not much more you can do.
Just let her get on with it

1POTUS · 07/11/2022 11:33

MavisChunch29 · 07/11/2022 11:33

Also if you are five hours away, there is really only so much you can do. Your young family comes first.

This. YANBU op

MavisChunch29 · 07/11/2022 11:33

Also if you are five hours away, there is really only so much you can do. Your young family comes first.

MavisChunch29 · 07/11/2022 11:31

it’s your offering to listen, and express sympathy with murmuring noises

Exactly. You can't change them, or their attitude. When DM moved in with us I took her to different activities with me hoping that she'd make friends and get involved with village life, but she didn't want to and her world is very small - all about us really. Which can be frustrating as it can be rather suffocating, but it's her choice and we can't change that. I still go out and do different things with her but she has no interest in doing things independently.

melj1213 · 07/11/2022 11:29

YABU

It is hard, especially for the "fitter" member of an elderly couple when one has health issues and they are so used to doing everything together. They often feel obliged to stay with their partner but it means they don't go out with other people and if they do go out together it requires a lot more planning/effort due to the less able partners limitations so they stop making the effort and then end up stuck at home.

What I would be doing is encouraging your grandmother to go out without your grandfather even if it's just for short periods - either have someone spend the afternoon with him while she goes out to do an activity with friends or a social group so she doesn't feel like she's "leaving him behind" or find out if there is an Age UK or similar centre nearby where they have a day centre where your grandmother could leave your grandfather so she can go out and do things, knowing he's safe and looked after.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/11/2022 11:29

I feel like she’s very much entitled to her feelings and it must suck for her. I don’t think she has to just accept it.

However Im not sure you are the most appropriate person to do anything about it, or sounding board, as you live a long way away, have young children and work full time. There must be someone more appropriately placed?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/11/2022 11:20

I get you, OP.

I’m old now myself, but when I had the responsibility for elderly relatives, one of the hardest things to cope with was the moaning. Nothing was right, the world was worse and getting worse ( more right now than a few years ago!) , it was really depressing.

I never found an answer. I just had to accept that was how they were, and let them bang on. Sometimes with one, I would just put the phone down for a minute, and put the washing on or something. They didn’t notice.

it’s your offering to listen, and express sympathy with murmuring noises. Treasure in Heaven, and all that.