Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

stuck into giving lift to close friend

295 replies

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 09:03

Live in small town and have 2 mates. We meet every friday and saturday night at Jane's flat and chill out. Problem is that Susan now,who doesn't drive, has moved about 2 miles away and needs a lift home every time. It's 2 miles out of my way-adding about 10 minutes on to my journey home.

Starting to feel resentful over this but don't have it in me to say no. I'm thinking of just not joining them anymore.

OP posts:
gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 13:36

At the next meeting park your car a short distance away out of sight from Janes. When you leave and Susan automatically leaves with you just start walking in the opposite direction to the direction Susan needs to go. When she questions where the car is just say you had no money left for petrol so you've walked

I might do this.

OP posts:
strupel · 07/11/2022 13:32

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 07/11/2022 13:29

At the next meeting park your car a short distance away out of sight from Janes. When you leave and Susan automatically leaves with you just start walking in the opposite direction to the direction Susan needs to go. When she questions where the car is just say you had no money left for petrol so you've walked.

Only if you don't care about potentially losing the frienship of both of them though?!

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 07/11/2022 13:29

At the next meeting park your car a short distance away out of sight from Janes. When you leave and Susan automatically leaves with you just start walking in the opposite direction to the direction Susan needs to go. When she questions where the car is just say you had no money left for petrol so you've walked.

strupel · 07/11/2022 13:22

I'll have a go...

"Hi Susan, I've been struggling a bit with my health and finances recently! Would you be able to get to mine under your own steam for our socials, to save me the extra driving on the way there? And would you be able to give me £X a week for the added petrol? Thanks"

If she doesn't reply with sympathy and questions about what you've said, then I'll be inclined to agree she's a CF @gloriamoi

Whoopy · 07/11/2022 13:17

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 10:24

OP you haven't said how long your journey home would be without the detour. If you live in the same place as Jane, couldn't you start cycling/ walking to these soirees? Then Susan would need to make her own arrangements

I live over a mile away in the other direction. It's rural and dark roads so not safe to be out walking/cycling at night really and we are up far north of Scotland so it's freezing.

Could one of your parents give you a lift occasionally, so you could say that you can’t ask them to go further out of the way, meaning that she can’t rely on you for a lift.

Or, living rurally in the North in Scotland, will give you the perfect opportunity to stop these lifts pretty soon. When the roads start to get icy, say that you don’t feel happy to drive her home! She may say that you are already out, but say if you get stuck on the way home, you could manage to walk the rest of the way, but couldn’t if you got stuck further away!

Testina · 07/11/2022 13:16

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 12:02

To all the people saying I should not mind as it's a friend you wouldn't say the same if it was a man I was dating and felt he was taking advantage of me in some way. I'd be told to dump him.

Yeah, and we wouldn’t say the same if your local zookeeper was asking you to take giraffes for a ride cos you have a sunroof. It’s a totally different situation!

Susan is supposedly a good enough friend for you to spend 1.5 hours watching TV with every Fri and Sat.

Yet, not a good enough friend that you want to spend any extra time with her in the car:

“I just want to go home, not drape 2 miles up back roads to her house and back down at the end of the night.”

When I drop friends home, we carry on the chat, often end up parked up outside their house still chatting!

This is hardly any extra time at all, so I think that if you originally offered / agreed to collect her, she just fairly assumed that was a permanent offer. For such a small amount of time, half of which is spent with a supposed friend, I think it’s fine if she didn’t realise it was going to become a big deal for you. If my friend was constantly re-thanking me, I’d get annoyed and tell her to hush!

If your illness means it’s too tiring to extend the evening to include her, reduce the time at Jane’s.

If you can’t afford the extra petrol money - tell her. Or speak to Jane as well and say you need to do the fuel cost instead of bringing Jane chocolate 2x a week! Jane isn’t really hosting anything, is she? In fact, Jane has it easiest so definitely doesn’t need to be brought chocolate twice a week if you can’t afford it!

Or just stop going and meet another way with Jane, because it doesn’t seem as if you actually like Susan 🤷🏻‍♀️

diddl · 07/11/2022 13:13

I think that most people would be happy to do this for a friend-if the friend didn't seem to expect it & they could easily afford it!

Do they think that you are rolling in money because of the job you used to do?

Pixiedust1234 · 07/11/2022 13:09

I'm confused OP, and I know this isn't what you are asking, however the whole scenario seems messed up.

You are going to Jane's house twice a week to watch TV for an hour.
Why only an hour, thats not a lot of time to watch anything! Do you chatter about anything or just tv?

Are you bringing Jane snacks but none of you eat them? You are just handing it over because?

How does the other one get there?

I think you are being taken for a mug by both actually. I do understand why you go but everything about it seems joyless. Would it be better to go once a week but for longer? Have plans to watch a specific film and everyone bring their own drink and popcorn? Perhaps even order a pizza in to share? I think you need to look at all of it and decide if anything can be changed so you can look forward to it.

I think the lift problem is a symbol of you wanting to break from the monotony of it all. If not, then I do apologise.

strupel · 07/11/2022 13:07

AbsolutelyNebulous · 07/11/2022 13:05

OP if you’re not prepared to say Susan, money is really tight for me right now so I’m afraid I can’t give lifts anymore unless you’re contributing then you need to decide whether the company and friendship twice a week is worth the cost and inconvenience.

Realistically you’re living in the back end of nowhere with very money and coping with illness so your options regarding making new friends right now don’t sound great. You’re free to just stop going or to refuse lifts of course but what you decide will obviously have consequences for you in terms of your already very limited social life. Whether any of us think giving regular lifts is fine or a pain in the arse doesn’t really matter but you need to consider whether you’d be cutting off your nose to spite your face if you stop going.

This is it.

@gloriamoi you've got a couple of options, what do you think you want to do?

AbsolutelyNebulous · 07/11/2022 13:05

OP if you’re not prepared to say Susan, money is really tight for me right now so I’m afraid I can’t give lifts anymore unless you’re contributing then you need to decide whether the company and friendship twice a week is worth the cost and inconvenience.

Realistically you’re living in the back end of nowhere with very money and coping with illness so your options regarding making new friends right now don’t sound great. You’re free to just stop going or to refuse lifts of course but what you decide will obviously have consequences for you in terms of your already very limited social life. Whether any of us think giving regular lifts is fine or a pain in the arse doesn’t really matter but you need to consider whether you’d be cutting off your nose to spite your face if you stop going.

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/11/2022 13:03

Does Susan have her own money? Does her partner drive? I couldn’t imagine just expecting a lift twice a week even for a short journey without offering anything.

PollyAmour · 07/11/2022 13:01

This Friday, turn up at Jane's house without your car, and get a taxi home, or the bus, if there is one. Break the pattern. Susan will either have to walk or use public transport to get home. You could be canny with the truth and say you've got car problems, or you can't afford to run a car any longer.

rookiemere · 07/11/2022 12:56

Bunnyfuller · 07/11/2022 12:50

So, to summarise:

  1. You’re all close friends but your only contact is this twice a week 90 mins watching tv together.
  2. You’re close friends but Susan hasn’t ever said in passing ‘BIL brought me’ or anything else
  3. You’ve not asked, casually when you get there ‘oh, you’re here already, how did you get here?’
  4. Jane never picks up on it
  5. You’re close friends but don’t know what to buy for each other food wise.
  6. You’ve assumed Susan won’t pay if you just say casually, I’m going to have to cut back on these, really struggling to afford the fuel - prices are eye-watering’ in front of them both.

You’re not friends. How old are you all out of interest?

OP has asked Susan for petrol money before on previous occasions.
Susan therefore doesn't need to be a genius to figure out that offering petrol money would be appropriate.

ashitghost · 07/11/2022 12:55

Resentment like this will eat away at you. Most people would be happy to do this for a close friend.

Bunnyfuller · 07/11/2022 12:50

So, to summarise:

  1. You’re all close friends but your only contact is this twice a week 90 mins watching tv together.
  2. You’re close friends but Susan hasn’t ever said in passing ‘BIL brought me’ or anything else
  3. You’ve not asked, casually when you get there ‘oh, you’re here already, how did you get here?’
  4. Jane never picks up on it
  5. You’re close friends but don’t know what to buy for each other food wise.
  6. You’ve assumed Susan won’t pay if you just say casually, I’m going to have to cut back on these, really struggling to afford the fuel - prices are eye-watering’ in front of them both.

You’re not friends. How old are you all out of interest?

MadelineUsher · 07/11/2022 12:48

Geez, you're recovering from a brain tumour - you don't need the extra stress of driving out of your way on unfamiliar little roads at night when you just want to go home and chill afterwards. If you weren't there, how would Susan get home? How does she even get there? It's all very odd, and a bit unfair.

BagOfBollocks · 07/11/2022 12:47

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 12:02

To all the people saying I should not mind as it's a friend you wouldn't say the same if it was a man I was dating and felt he was taking advantage of me in some way. I'd be told to dump him.

That's a massive stretch.

If the man was part of the friendship group and all other details were the same, I'm sure most would say what they've already said.

CatJumperTwat · 07/11/2022 12:45

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 12:02

To all the people saying I should not mind as it's a friend you wouldn't say the same if it was a man I was dating and felt he was taking advantage of me in some way. I'd be told to dump him.

Why did you ask if YABU if you're going to get sulky and then make up your own answers?

ancientgran · 07/11/2022 12:40

gloriamoi · 07/11/2022 12:02

To all the people saying I should not mind as it's a friend you wouldn't say the same if it was a man I was dating and felt he was taking advantage of me in some way. I'd be told to dump him.

Like I said you have choices, if you aren't that bothered about seeing them then don't. If you want to see them then either give her the lift, ask her for petrol money or tell her you aren't giving lifts. It is your decision.

Pushmepullu · 07/11/2022 12:38

For those saying it’s only 2 miles/10 minutes out of your way. I have this with an ex work friend. Every time we make plans to meet up in a group she texts to ask for a lift as her husband has the car. It’s 10 minutes out of my way but there are loads of diversions where she lives and I don’t know the area or the huge estate she lives on that well so very frequently end up getting lost and arriving home late. I get resentful because she has the expectation that I will pick her up and drop her off. So OP I understand.

Fingerscrossed2015 · 07/11/2022 12:35

Here's the problem.

Realistically, I am guessing that Susan is unlikely to organise a taxi twice a week, as it would be expensive for anyone but certainly for someone who already has a tight budget. It also doesn't look like she has many other options to get there and back. You are entirely within your rights to refuse her the lift (and I understand your reasons for wanting to do this), but that action will have consequences.

Consequence 1: Not having a lift that may mean Susan is no longer able to attend the gatherings on the weekends or, at least, no longer able to attend so frequently. She may also be upset and/or angry. You will definitely lose her company, and you may also lose her as a friend.

Making friends is hard as an adult, particularly if you don't have much money for socialising and live in a small area. Are you ok with losing her as a friend entirely?

Consequence 2: Once Jane finds out that you've 'dumped' giving Susan lifts, she will also have her own reaction. From the replies you've received on the post so far, you can probably already tell that some people think you are right to refuse to drive Susan home but others think it is unreasonable. If Jane sides with Susan and is angry with you, you may also lose Jane as a friend too.

Would you also be ok with that? You would then be left with no friends at all, and nothing to do on a weekend.

To reiterate, you absolutely could refuse to give her the lift. You would save yourself some petrol money and some time. But would it really be worth it?

PuppyMonkey · 07/11/2022 12:30

I’d be giving the visits a miss for a few a few weeks …or tell friend you can’t do the extra driving to give her the lifts in pitch black due to it making you feel anxious .. or even that with your condition it’s not advised.

NewNameWhoDis2 · 07/11/2022 12:27

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 07/11/2022 10:35

Funny old way to treat your friends.

Yep. Can't imagine being this cheeky that I'd expect a friend to ferry me around for 20m twice per week every week without offering petrol money or checking they're absolutely fine doing it. Susan sounds like a right cheeky mare.

strupel · 07/11/2022 12:26

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 07/11/2022 12:22

Starting to feel resentful over this but don't have it in me to say no

Well, we can't help you with that. Either you tell her you can't do it anymore or you put up with it... what do you want us to do?

You've ignored any practical suggestions or excuses...

This is it - OP I feel you just want a thread of people bitching about Susan?

You know if she's a good friend or not. Clearly she hasn't realised, and so you need to talk to her if you want things to change.

If you don't address this, you risk losing the frienship of both of them, and your friday & saturday night, if it's just going to drag on with them not picking up hints.

MeridasMum · 07/11/2022 12:26

I think you're getting too much of a hard time from some posters OP.

I do think, however, that you need to take matters into your own hands. It's bothering you and it's within your gift to fix it.

Say, 'hey friend, I'm not sure how you're coping but the cost of living rises are really impacting me. Petrol, in particular, is so much more expensive than it used to be. I'm going to need you to start contributing for the lifts I give you. 8 miles a week costs me £?? per month. You can give me cash on the last Friday of the month of transfer it online, it's up to you.'

If she says no, you tell her that you're having to miss out on 'something' (of an equivalent amount) every month to give her freebies and it's not working for you.

If she's your friend she'll understand

Swipe left for the next trending thread