Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think flying with a 18month old will be that bad?

138 replies

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 08:52

Am needing some guidance from parents who have experienced an 18 month old!

I am turning 30 next year and the plan has always been to go to the Bahamas for a couple of weeks to celebrate.

DD is our first and is currently a very well behaved baby, but as I don’t have a crystal ball I’m wondering if DH and I are crazy to think flying for 10 hours with her will be fine.

She has flown a few times already (one trip being more than 10 hours), but she slept for most of those flights so not a fair comparison.

AIBU to think an 18 month old won’t be a total nightmare to fly long distance with?

We can’t wait much longer to book as the hotel is already holding a room and has given a deadline to book of next week (they sell out quite far in advance so are lucky to have a hold!)

YABU - 18 month olds are usually awful flyers. Don’t do it

YANBU - should be fine

OP posts:
TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 09:53

Have you thought through how DD will fit into your actual holiday when you get there? At 18 months there is a load of faff feeding them solids so meals are not relaxing, and you'll have to be in bed all three of you by 7pm every evening. 18 month olds won't sleep soundly in a park in the corner in the same way a baby will.

Then there is the sun cream, the daytime napping, the faff with car seats in taxis if you go for a day out, the fact that the two adults can't be in the pool or the sea together at the same time. They don't get anything out of being abroad. You will have no sex even if you have a suite because she probably won't tolerate not being in the same room as you at night in a strange place. Honestly I found holidays abroad with a child that age really frustrating as it was a constant parade of "lovely things we could do if our child wasn't here".

The flight is the least of your problems.

YellowTreeHouse · 07/11/2022 09:52

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 07/11/2022 09:08

Fine for you or for every other poor sod trapped on the plane with you?

So parents should never take their kids away to experience new places simply because there’s a a possibility they’ll be upset?

If you can’t handle crying kids, you shouldn’t be on the plane, because that is a you problem.

Honeyroar · 07/11/2022 09:52

i don’t remember it being that long a flight to the Bahamas, more like 8 hours? There probably won’t be enough flights to be a night flight both ways, usually it’s on the return. If you can upgrade and get a bed that’s one sector sorted! 18 months is a difficult age as they want to toddle constantly. Be aware of where trolleys and galleys are, they’re very heavy and a loose toddler could easily hurt themselves. I’m not sure that the suggestion of bubbles and toys with bright flashes will be any better for other passengers than a crying toddler.

Glitterbaby17 · 07/11/2022 09:50

I’ve done this a few time as we have family in Australia. Going to be honest 15 months - 2.5ish is the worst - they are mobile, give no sh*ts about rules or not upsetting other people and get hyper out of routine. Saying that I’ve done it multiple times and survived but it’s very stressful - but 2 adults and 1 18month old for 10 hours won’t be that bad - you can take turns to walk up and down/entertain her and rest. Lots of snacks, surprise toys, Peppa pig etc. I found pull ups a bit easier than nappies to manage on planes - good luck!

TinaYouFatLard · 07/11/2022 09:49

We flew long haul with 19 month old twins. It was hard work but we had a wonderful time away with them and I would take the shit 10 hours for the reward of 2 lovely weeks away.

In terms of other passengers, I think it’s really important to visibly show that you are doing your best to minimise impact on them. I’ve only ever seen passengers get annoyed when the parents aren’t doing enough to placate their kids. Remember their tolerance level will be lower than yours.

Scottishskifun · 07/11/2022 09:47

We have flown with a toddler honestly it's fine!
We got a amazon kids fire and downloaded multiple things, had a bag of new toys, sticker book, colouring book and only gave one or 2 new items an hour.
Also depends on the time of the flight we found evening flights much easier as they had already burnt beans off during the day.

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 09:46

Faciadipasta · 07/11/2022 09:43

Do a night flight and get bulkhead seats and you should be fine. We flew with 17 month old twins on a 10 hour flight and it really wasn't that bad at all. They both slept for quite a lot of it.

17 month old twins! I am bowing through my screen - this gives me hope!

OP posts:
Faciadipasta · 07/11/2022 09:43

Blimey with her own seat it will be fine!! Do it.

Faciadipasta · 07/11/2022 09:43

Do a night flight and get bulkhead seats and you should be fine. We flew with 17 month old twins on a 10 hour flight and it really wasn't that bad at all. They both slept for quite a lot of it.

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 09:42

picklemewalnuts · 07/11/2022 09:25

I had to do long haul with a toddler. It's hard work. A night flight is helpful, if they are good sleepers, because they are tired and ready to sleep. Think about whether you can pay for a seat for them, or will they be on your lap the whole time (tight fit if the seat in front reclines).

Whatever you do, pack lots of food and drink- things that take a lot of time to eat, so sweetcorn she can pick up one piece at a time etc.

Activities- bubbles, wheeled toys, new toys that will catch her interest. Maybe a flashing light spinner toy?

Mine had a Lego tractor that he drove all round the plane.

Oh she will definitely have her own seat, am contemplating an upgrade to ensure she can lie down properly.

Thank you for the tips! Sweetcorn is a genius idea, she loves it already so that’s helpful!

OP posts:
TheBirdintheCave · 07/11/2022 09:40

I've done four three hour flights with our toddler (at 18 months and 22 months). The first set of journeys was ok though he was on our laps for that one. We kept him distracted with food and books and on the return leg he fell asleep half way through. It wasn't a massively pleasant experience but didn't scream or cry.

The second set of journeys was an absolute dream as he had his own seat both ways. He was very happy to watch downloaded shows on the iPad and eat his lunch. Our boy is quite tall so it made a huge difference for him to have his own space.

AlwaysLatte · 07/11/2022 09:40

We always travelled at night for long haul flights with toddlers. So much easier!

MistyFrequencies · 07/11/2022 09:36

It will be fine. Ive been going back & forth to New Zealand (avg 24hrs flight time) for years with little ones and only once was it a nightmare and that was teething, so make sure you take paracetamol/neurofen travel size. If they want to toddle its usually fine, those big planes have plenty of room. And despite the unnecessary comments up thread my experience is people have always been kind and helpful.

pjparty · 07/11/2022 09:33

Totally fine! Kids have to fly, it's only 10 hours out of a fantastic two week holiday! Go for it! We lived abroad (18 hours flying in total and three connecting flights) and my mum used to fly solo with me and my brother from 18m and 4 years. It was probably difficult but doable and worth it.

ChristmasCakeAndStilton · 07/11/2022 09:33

There is a chance it will be fine, and she will be an angel.
There is a chance it will be hell on earth, and your previously docile child will spend the whole time wanting to jump on the seat (DS1) or scream (DS2).
Only you can decide if you are prepared the risk the second possibility.

Anything between babes in arms and about 4 years old (which is when personally screens became possible for mine) is hard work.

FlounderingFruitcake · 07/11/2022 09:32

18MO if they’ll watch an ipad (download stuff before you go) with headphones is actually pretty easy. Stupid as it sounds you actually have to practice this so get them hooked on paw patrol or peppa pig or whatever and use the headphones at home a lot in the weeks before you go to get them used to it. I know it’s tempting to save money but under no circumstances book them as a lap infant in economy. You can comfortably share a business or first class seat as they’re bigger but otherwise they need their own. Take all the snacks, a few toys, colouring and stickers, sippy cup, dummy if they have one. Suspend any rules you might usually have about screens and snacks, forget the routine and remember anything that isn’t crying or shouting is a win! Genuinely I’ve never had a bad flight with mine and back when we were expats we used to do a lot of travel.

5foot5 · 07/11/2022 09:31

When DD was 11 months I flew with her to Sydney dingle handed. She was absolutely ticket boo.

At 22 months we took her on a very short haul flight, flight time only one hour. I cannot begin to tell you how terrible that was. For us and everyone else on the plane.

So clearly there is a transition from easy peasy to nightmarish at some point between 11 and 22 months. I guess the change from baby to toddler. Whether 18 months will be that point for you is hard to predict.

Appleblum · 07/11/2022 09:31

It'll be fine but I suggest you get her a seat.

MinkyWinky · 07/11/2022 09:30

We did it and it was fine but:

  • she had her own seat. You don't want a 18mth climbing all over you on a 10hr flight
  • we had various 'surprises for her' that we brought out over the flight. Small new toys, food etc. (We froze some yoghurt pouches which we used to keep things cool then she ate later in the flight).
  • New games/stories on the iPad. She vaguely watched the inflight enterntainment
  • Definitely take your own food, the only bit she was interested food wise on the flight was the ice cream (Virgin Atlantic)
  • We sat at the back of the plane where 4 seats went to three, so had some additional space to the side of the seats - helped with all the bits we were carrying

She didn't sleep at all on the way out - it was day time and there was far too much interesting stuff going on. She fell asleep in her car seat on the way to the hotel. We had a night flight on the way back and she fell asleep after she'd eaten.

Enjoy!

Sidge · 07/11/2022 09:29

We flew London to Perth when DD3 was 13 months.

It was hideous. She was a placid, happy child usually, but metamorphosed into a hyperactive non sleeping demon as soon as we boarded. Hardly slept and hardly ate.

Everyone thought it was cute as we toddled up and down the aisle. I smiled back at them through gritted teeth.

I’ve blocked the return journey from my memory.

Beees · 07/11/2022 09:26

This was our worry, as it sounds like the time most are actively not wanting to stay still, but again that’s all I’ve got from books no actual real life experience with a child that age to use as a guide!

Definitely prime wandering figety bottom age and you'll likely spend 90% of the flight walking her up and down the aisle.

I would definitely leave her if you have the option. Yes she might be fine and enjoy it but the odds are just as if not more likely that she won't and you will feel like the whole experience was a huge waste of time, money and energy.

picklemewalnuts · 07/11/2022 09:25

I had to do long haul with a toddler. It's hard work. A night flight is helpful, if they are good sleepers, because they are tired and ready to sleep. Think about whether you can pay for a seat for them, or will they be on your lap the whole time (tight fit if the seat in front reclines).

Whatever you do, pack lots of food and drink- things that take a lot of time to eat, so sweetcorn she can pick up one piece at a time etc.

Activities- bubbles, wheeled toys, new toys that will catch her interest. Maybe a flashing light spinner toy?

Mine had a Lego tractor that he drove all round the plane.

lilyfire · 07/11/2022 09:23

18 months is probably one of worst ages to fly at - they are toddling and just want to be on the move and they’re too young to want to sit and watch screens for very long. I guess maybe if it’s a night flight and they sleep through most of it might be ok - but then you’ve still got the horrendous disruption to sleep pattern thing to get through. I did long haul with 2 and half year old and it was ok though as they watched stuff and slept. Maybe put it off a bit?

Beees · 07/11/2022 09:23

I started getting my DD to watch films from around 15 months so by the time we flew she would sit through a 90min kids film!

That's a very rare anomaly for a child so young! Even my nearly 3 year old doesn't have the concentration skills to watch a 90 minute film.

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 09:23

Beees · 07/11/2022 09:18

18 months is prime toddling age and she's likely to not want to stay still for more than 5 minutes it sounds like a terribly stressful idea and not at all enjoyable for your birthday.

Is there any way you could leave her at home with grandparents? It would be much less stressful for everyone involved.

This was our worry, as it sounds like the time most are actively not wanting to stay still, but again that’s all I’ve got from books no actual real life experience with a child that age to use as a guide!

We were planning to leave her, but as it’s 2 weeks I’m 50:50 whether it will be a bit too long. I’m not that precious about leaving her and if it’s a case of leave her or don’t go I’ll be going, but taking her is the top option.

OP posts: