Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think flying with a 18month old will be that bad?

138 replies

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 08:52

Am needing some guidance from parents who have experienced an 18 month old!

I am turning 30 next year and the plan has always been to go to the Bahamas for a couple of weeks to celebrate.

DD is our first and is currently a very well behaved baby, but as I don’t have a crystal ball I’m wondering if DH and I are crazy to think flying for 10 hours with her will be fine.

She has flown a few times already (one trip being more than 10 hours), but she slept for most of those flights so not a fair comparison.

AIBU to think an 18 month old won’t be a total nightmare to fly long distance with?

We can’t wait much longer to book as the hotel is already holding a room and has given a deadline to book of next week (they sell out quite far in advance so are lucky to have a hold!)

YABU - 18 month olds are usually awful flyers. Don’t do it

YANBU - should be fine

OP posts:
justabigdisco · 07/11/2022 10:47

I’ve done plenty of long haul with my 2 at all different ages. Not gonna lie, 1-2 is the worst age for flying although at least you don’t need to pay full price! It will be hard work but it will be fine, and the holiday sounds amazing so I’m sure it will be worth it.

WoolyMammoth55 · 07/11/2022 10:46

We took our 18 month old on a 15 hour flight this summer.

Booked a night flight but due to Heathrow disruption they rescheduled it for the morning!

Not going to lie, it was HARD. My toddler won't watch screens for hours, isn't all that snack orientated, and loves to run.

We did end up letting him run laps of the plane at a few points when nothing else was keeping him happy - down one aisle, through the cabin crew section at the back, up the other aisle, scoop him up before he bursts into business class and then let him reverse the route...

It wasn't ideal but the whole plane heard his meltdown when we tried to stop him, and I think everyone appreciated that he at least wasn't screaming...

On the way back we got our night flight (thank god!) so got the chance to use a £20 inflatable foot rest cube we'd bought from amazon, which blows up like a beachball to fill the gap between the edge of the seat and the seat in front - makes a toddler-sized flat bed from any standard seat. Worked well and he slept well on it.

Wish you best of luck OP x

BatshitBanshee · 07/11/2022 10:45

Night flights are your friend here. We did a flight with our 1 year old and it was hell, she's 18 months old now and won't sit in her chair for longer than a mealtime so a 10hr flight where she's awake would be my personal nightmare (she's amazing and I love her but she doesn't sit still, going through a leap and the meltdowns trapped on a plane would be... An experience 😅)

Heronwatcher · 07/11/2022 10:45

It will be fine as long as you and your partner are prepared to spend all of your time, probably both of you, amusing her. The issue is that at that age she’ll be too old to sleep in the bassinet and too young to just enjoy being allowed unlimited screen time. She’ll also want to be out of her seat and moving. So you’ll need to buy some new toys and be prepared to amuse her with games etc, and walk up and down the plane endlessly. If even one of you is expecting to chill out drinking a g&t then don’t do it. You’ll also need to be prepared for the jet lag once you get there- my 18 month old woke up, unfailingly, at 3am and would not properly go back to sleep for 6 days! Then he was ready for bed by about 5pm. So don’t expect lazy lie ins and civilised dinners, especially if you’re all sharing the same room.

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 10:44

@Hadriansfall how was I being patronising? I think you read a confrontational tone into what I intended to be a general chatty and helpful response about the whole holiday experience. I did not mean to suggest that you might have literally given no thought to how the rest of the holiday might pan out. It was just a figure of speech. If I had thought you hadn't thought it through I'd have said "you haven't thought this through, have you?"

I think that there can be a huge difference between theory and practice with life with small children so was just offering a of experience.

However looks like I touched a nerve?

I'm so sorry that planning your exotic holiday so stressing you out so much that you feel the need to be rude to strangers on the Internet who are just trying to be helpful.

oceanbleu · 07/11/2022 10:44

I struggle massively with a 2 hour flight to be honest, it's awful. However depends on her temperament and a night flight would be better.

Pigsears · 07/11/2022 10:44

My daughter was a fabulous on planes. I flew with her (without an extra seat) right up to 23 months- longhaul (asia, Australia etc). She remains tall- so her last flights at 23 months without a seat was a bit of a stretch but totally doable. I was flying without another set of hands. All was good.

I do think it depends on your child though.

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 10:43

Should add I lived overseas so I was travelling home to my parents rather than a normal holiday - also never had a shortage of circa 65-70 year old ladies offering to help read stories etc too. The route was mostly business travel but with a good number of older people travelling to see family who like us were living overseas. No such thing as tablets then but they had just introduced the screens on the back of seats which were helpful, dd1 particularly enjoyed watching the map, mesmerised by the little plane

byvirtue · 07/11/2022 10:43

Go for it we did, daughter was fine!

Does it have to be the Bahamas? Mauritius is virtually the same time zone and you can do night flights there and back? We went to the Caribbean though and it was great although I was still breast feeding and it helped with her ears.

Also Pack twice the amount of food you think you will need under 2s don’t get any food on the plane.

Kinsters · 07/11/2022 10:42

I've done 14 hours (daytime flight) with my toddler when she was 18 months. It was fine - we brought loads of stuff for her to do and eat, made sure she had her own seat plus took it in turns dealing with her.

14 hours (night flight) with 3mo DS and 2yo DD - easy. DH looked after DD and I looked after DS and they both slept most of the flight.

14 hours (night flight) with 10mo DS and almost 3yo DD. I was alone and it was awful but we managed! Wouldn't do it for a holiday though...

Wheredoallthepensgo · 07/11/2022 10:41

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 09:53

Have you thought through how DD will fit into your actual holiday when you get there? At 18 months there is a load of faff feeding them solids so meals are not relaxing, and you'll have to be in bed all three of you by 7pm every evening. 18 month olds won't sleep soundly in a park in the corner in the same way a baby will.

Then there is the sun cream, the daytime napping, the faff with car seats in taxis if you go for a day out, the fact that the two adults can't be in the pool or the sea together at the same time. They don't get anything out of being abroad. You will have no sex even if you have a suite because she probably won't tolerate not being in the same room as you at night in a strange place. Honestly I found holidays abroad with a child that age really frustrating as it was a constant parade of "lovely things we could do if our child wasn't here".

The flight is the least of your problems.

I was thinking the same ... could be lovely but relaxing it will not!

Beees · 07/11/2022 10:41

MrsWarboysHandGrenade

I'm beginning to wonder if we have the same child. I'm trying desperately to suppress the lovley fun trips we did when he was between 15 months and 2 years. Everyone of them including his birthday day out ended up with someone in tears.

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 10:39

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 10:33

No, we are planning a trip with no consideration on how DD will fit in when we get there.

There is no need to be snarky @Hadriansfall. You said that you were first time parents and had little idea of the reality vs the theory of the flight. I was asking if you had extended that thought to the holiday overall as it might help tip the balance between taking her or leaving her. I was speaking from actual experience, which you do not have and which, if I'm not mistaken, you asked us to share?

I asked about flight experiences

You decided to be patronising, not sure why you’d jump to no thought being placed on what the actual holiday would be like.

I am wondering about the flight as she will be in peak toddle mode, and not sure how viable that is in terms of a long flight, whether it’s just not worth the drama. The holiday itself we are content with, hence why I didn’t ask ‘AIBU to think a holiday with a 18month old won’t be that bad’

But thank you for your comment.

OP posts:
MrsWarboysHandGrenade · 07/11/2022 10:38

Mine would both have been a total nightmare at that age, both always wanting to just run off - too heavy to be held comfortably and would squirm, but didn’t want to hold hands and walk about in a calm way. We once did a 2 hour train journey to spend a nice afternoon in another city with the then-15-mo DS, and ended up sat, exhausted, trying to book train tickets home early as he was such a handful on the journey and when we got there - he broke a plate in a cafe, ran off (thank god for reins) wouldn’t sit in the pushchair, wouldn’t be carried, lay on the floor a lot……

But if your DD is an experienced flyer it might be fine, sounds like you’re well prepared!

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 10:37

shivawn · 07/11/2022 10:01

@TerraNostra Important to remember that all kids are different. 😉 No doubt OP will be well aware of her own child's bedtime and feeding routine. We're just back from a holiday with ours and there is no faff feeding him, he sits in his highchair and feeds himself. He slept in his own room at 10pm every night and we had plenty sex. It was so good that we came home and immediately booked the next holiday for 4 months time!

She will have no idea now about what her child's bedtime and feeding routine at 18 months will be.

What were you doing with your child up to when you all went to bed at 10pm?

superking · 07/11/2022 10:36

Personally I found 18 months pretty much the worst age for flying - past the tiny baby sleeping stage, old enough to be unhappy about being confined in a small space, and too young to reason with/ occupy with an iPad. That's not to say you shouldn't do it but be prepared for it to be very hard work.

JustFrustrated · 07/11/2022 10:35

I did 10 hours with a baby about that age and a toddler.

Fine for us, them and the other passengers.

Greenqueen40 · 07/11/2022 10:34

Sounds hellish but if you do go book her a seat, an 18 month on your lap for that long would be absolutely awful.

BecauseICan22 · 07/11/2022 10:34

Impervious to the sneers and judgment of others**

gogohmm · 07/11/2022 10:33

I flew with mine 10 hours long haul 2-3 times a year, often on my own and it was fine. Not restful for the parent as you need to entertain them unless they are sleeping but certainly not a problem.

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 10:33

No, we are planning a trip with no consideration on how DD will fit in when we get there.

There is no need to be snarky @Hadriansfall. You said that you were first time parents and had little idea of the reality vs the theory of the flight. I was asking if you had extended that thought to the holiday overall as it might help tip the balance between taking her or leaving her. I was speaking from actual experience, which you do not have and which, if I'm not mistaken, you asked us to share?

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 10:33

Dogtooth · 07/11/2022 10:06

Honestly, I had some really shit holidays in the early days with DC - same shit as home but extra challenges in terms of avoiding sun burn, lack of sleep, hazards everywhere, not eating the food, worrying about dehydration and overheating and mosquitoes etc. Not much lying by the pool. Even the beach was hard without enough shade, sand in eyes etc. I think you could risk spending a lot of money to have a stressful time. Kids don't always enjoy the change in scenery, it can be unsettling for them. I wouldn't fancy a ten hour flight either.

Is it possible that your dream just isn't compatible with parenthood of a toddler? You could go somewhere nice in Europe for now and put this off for a few years if you have someone you could leave her with.

I realise that sounds very grouchy but it's based in experience!

I already have someone I can leave her with (well multiple people) and if the choice is leave her or not go, we will be leaving her with nanny!

But I wanted to see if I am blowing how bad it might be out of proportion (half hoping I am Grin)

OP posts:
BecauseICan22 · 07/11/2022 10:32

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 10:28

No, we are planning a trip with no consideration on how DD will fit in when we get there.

This made me laugh!!!!

Just leave her in Reception at the hotel, she'll entertain herself.

BecauseICan22 · 07/11/2022 10:31

Hey OP, you could do all the prep, disaster management, distraction techniques and contingencies in the world but you won't know how she is or how she copes until the day.

There are only 2 aspects you can control here.

  1. You and your DH need to be in a zen like state, totally aligned and in tune to one another for what will be a somewhat naturally stressful event. If you know you can essentially not react to any of that stress, go for it.
  1. You will have to take that zen like state with you on that flight. TRUST me there will be people flying on the same flight who will have ZERO tolerance for a toddler and that's a hard atmosphere to be stuck in. (See the need for point number 1 here).

I flew a 5 hour flight last week. There was a family on the flight back, they had a 20 month old little girl who was just not settling at all. Both parents were trying everything with her. The massive over the top sighs from some of the other passengers and the tutting was horrible to witness and the parents felt it too. They were in the seats behind me. I felt immensely for them. Those 2 parents were so, so stressed, inevitably their child was distressed and it wasn't a nice experience.

Point 1 and 2 are all you can prep for. If it was me, I'd take my toddler, you turn 30 once. But you've got to be imperious to the sneers and judgement of others. Do your best if you take her but ultimately she's not a robot and you're not holding her remote.

Have a wonderful 30th 😊

Hadriansfall · 07/11/2022 10:31

Jimmini · 07/11/2022 10:10

Sounds horrendous. I’d try a short break first to Barcelona or somewhere so you can see what’s she’s like, but plan to push back the big holiday until she’s a bit older

I have stated in my first post she has flown multiple times already.

We are also planning a mini break a few months before which will be a 4hr flight so can see what she is like - but at that point it would be too late to change our minds Blush

OP posts: