Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you would do? (Mortgage related)

56 replies

Ofgrace · 06/11/2022 23:11

Sorry posted on money matters but it’s quiet on there and I need to make this decision tomorrow afternoon. I’m still pondering.

I’ve just got an agreement in principle for a 95% mortgage. It’s a broker bad credit mortgage because despite not missing a payment in 4 years, no dependents, no outstanding debt etc, I have a default from when I was a student in 2018 and absolutely broke. It’s from a phone contract and for 65.00, no ccj, no anything else.

Anyways, finally got offered a AIP but it’s for 6.5%. However, the repayments are still cheaper than what I’m paying in rent currently, by 120.00 and it would mean I’d have a nice new built home and some security.

the thing is, mortgage company have offered me either a 2 year fixed or 5 year and I’m still unsure. Broker is convinced I could go high street in 2 years and lower my rate- but with the recession looming and things being bad what if I can’t? And suddenly my rate gets even higher?

ive had days to read, ponder and ask opinion and I’m still unsure of what to do. I’m a single person currently, aged 29 and will be paying everything myself. I could have a partner living with me in two years towards it but that’s a risk and who knows what the future holds.

what would you do? :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MRex · 07/11/2022 12:50

Ofgrace · 07/11/2022 10:47

Thank you all, it’s a tough one isn’t it? Not exactly the best time to be buying a home and most of my friends either still rent or put down larger deposits 20% or more so don’t have this worry of being in negative equity.

I’ll probably go for the five year and muddle through and see where I am then.

As a side note, I really wish they’d teach young people at school about credit. I work for a university and I see our students being offered 2000 overdrafts and credit cards as “free money” and pay off when you graduate. I wish there was a better understand of the impact of missed payments and adverse credit.

You seem to have missed a few of us saying that it seems unlikely that you have to be on an adverse rate from what you've described, but it needs to go am to a human underwriter. Are you going to try talking to a few banks first to see if you can work through this?

lifehappens12 · 07/11/2022 12:46

Fix for 2 years or as close to when the default drops off your credit rating as you should be able to get a better offer once your credit rating improves

Have you tried to get the default removed? I had one on my record but made a complaint to the company that put it on (Barclays) who found in my favour and removed it. My argument was that they hadn't done enough to support or contact me

Bigslippers · 07/11/2022 11:40

I would go for the 5 years

You will be used to paying X amount for 5 years and you will have learned how to budget.

After the 5 years your default will have probably fallen off and if you are comfortable with paying the same amount you can overpay to match your payments now

2 years is only 24 payments to get you into the swing of getting used to it. Does Martin Lewis have anything on his website about it or can you ask in his forum?

Its such a big deal and I’m sure you need better advice

Congratulations on your first home too OP

Dragonskin · 07/11/2022 11:40

Truthfully it's always a gamble. You need to decide what your attitude to risk is and what your priority is.

If you fix for 5 years and rates drop you will pay more than you need to, but for that length of time you have certainty in payments and you will be more protected from the risk of coming to the end of your fix and being in negative equity if house prices drop,

In 2 years the default will have dropped off so you will have more options and could potentially save money, but risk being in negative equity

Personally with things as they are and a 95% LTV, I would go for 5 years in your position. The payments are affordable and it gives you time to build equity without worry. Whatever you do, good luck in your new home!

BackOnTheBandWagon · 07/11/2022 11:27

Ofgrace · 07/11/2022 10:47

Thank you all, it’s a tough one isn’t it? Not exactly the best time to be buying a home and most of my friends either still rent or put down larger deposits 20% or more so don’t have this worry of being in negative equity.

I’ll probably go for the five year and muddle through and see where I am then.

As a side note, I really wish they’d teach young people at school about credit. I work for a university and I see our students being offered 2000 overdrafts and credit cards as “free money” and pay off when you graduate. I wish there was a better understand of the impact of missed payments and adverse credit.

Think that's the right choice, it gives you certainty in what is going to be a very uncertain few years for the economy

RincewindsHat · 07/11/2022 11:20

Personally, as you know the payments are affordable on the 6% fix, I would consider fixing for 5 years especially as your LTV is so high. I am very risk averse and like to know that things like mortgage payments are within my control.

What you can do to get some extra clarity is make a table to calculate your potential repayments over the 5 years based on a few scenarios: first, consistent 6% rate, how much those monthly payments add up to over 5 years.

Then look at the 6% rate for 2 years and work out what your repayments would be for every % increase after that in subsequent years, eg if your mortgage rate went went up to 7% after 2 years and you then had a 3 year fix at 7%, what would repayments look like and how much more would you be paying in interest?

Do the same for everything up to 10% and get a feel for what your potential situation could be if you don't fix for 5 years and that will help you decide. There are online calculators to help you do it, so it's a ten minute task.

Ofgrace · 07/11/2022 10:47

Thank you all, it’s a tough one isn’t it? Not exactly the best time to be buying a home and most of my friends either still rent or put down larger deposits 20% or more so don’t have this worry of being in negative equity.

I’ll probably go for the five year and muddle through and see where I am then.

As a side note, I really wish they’d teach young people at school about credit. I work for a university and I see our students being offered 2000 overdrafts and credit cards as “free money” and pay off when you graduate. I wish there was a better understand of the impact of missed payments and adverse credit.

OP posts:
ping78 · 07/11/2022 10:36

But negative equity just means the OP goes into the SVR which may well not be as high as 6,5% in 2 years, I don't think it's as cut and dry as 5 years being the answer. 6.5% is a high rate to be locked into for 5 years. It's a shame they don't have a 3 year option like Nationwide do.

linelgreen · 07/11/2022 08:26

Broker should have told you to clear default and then once it shows satisfied most high Street lenders would ignore as its less than £200.

SuperstarDJsherewego · 07/11/2022 08:25

Personally I’m risk adverse so I would fix for 5. Then I’d over pay that £120 difference from your current rent to build up equity. On 95% and in a recession/falling market there is a risk of negative equity.

Jmaho · 07/11/2022 08:08

You shouldn't need a "bad credit" mortgage
I work in mortgages and work for a high Street lender and even we would overlook a default from 2018 with a mobile phone company
I would find a new broker

LeftTheWashingOut · 07/11/2022 08:02

I'd go 5 years- the 2 yrs goes so quick and you'll be looking at securing your new rate in 18months time. I don't see that rates will have recovered that soon. If you can afford the repayments, then at least 5yrs saves you the stress of worrying for the next few years

jevoudrais · 07/11/2022 08:00

This is the gamble you make, but it's worth paying more for peace of mind I think.

We fixed for five years at 3.73% in 2015 and I know plenty who got lower rates in the next couple of years. But it did what we needed, and we are now on 1.6% for the best part of another five years when most we know are at the mercy of current rates. Most of it comes down to chance.

GunsNShips · 07/11/2022 08:00

I’d go 5 years personally. You can afford it and it’s less than rent and it’s gives you a lot of security while you’re getting to grips with homeownership and all the hidden expense that can bring. Yes you might end up paying more and the front end of your mortgage but you’ll still have the house and mortgage in 5 years time.

Elsanore · 07/11/2022 07:59

Either is ok. Probably personally I would go 2 years and hope to get a better rate at the end but more cautious people might say 5 and that's sensible too.

You've done really well to get a mortgage by yourself, on a nice house for less than your current rent! That's fab either way! Congrats

jevoudrais · 07/11/2022 07:58

I'd go five years. My worry is at 95%, you might be in negative equity in two years.

Singlebutmarried · 07/11/2022 07:57

A default and not arrears?

A lot of high street lenders will take this into consideration. Are you sure your broker is getting you the best deal (the adverse lenders give much higher kick backs).

Phone defaults are usually easily set aside and if the underwriter has any common sense they won’t lost the business of a £65 missed payment. Halifax, NatWest and HSBC would consider you. And that just off the top of my head without my morning coffee.

mansviewpoint · 07/11/2022 07:55

lljkk · 07/11/2022 07:52

this makes most sense to me, too

Except you don't know where the house is, what it is worth and what it will be worth. Just because the news says that house pries are going down, it doesn't mean they are in the area where this house is.

Alexalee · 07/11/2022 07:53

I'd go for the 5 year due to probable negative equity in the short term. 6.5 isn't much higher than standard rates atm

mansviewpoint · 07/11/2022 07:53

to be able to give an answer more than gut feel you'd need to provide the martgage amount, the early repayment fees and your salary and non guaranteed overtime. But as a very rough, gut feel, it's all about risk, the risk of not knowing what deal you'll get in 2 years vs 5 years. Personally i'd go for the 5 years, but completely dependant on early termination and if I can overpay at all.

SmokedHaddockChowder · 07/11/2022 07:52

Fix for 2, but be prepared to get a lodger in future if needs be.

lljkk · 07/11/2022 07:52

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 07/11/2022 07:23

For a 95% LTV I would fix for 5 years. After 2 years, I think you’d be in negative equity the way the market is going.

this makes most sense to me, too

babbi · 07/11/2022 07:50

Sorry - go for 5 years 🤦‍♀️

babbi · 07/11/2022 07:49

Definitely 5% … lets you settle into your home with security for a longer time .
Current situation is not likely to improve in 2 years … you really don’t want to be at the mercy of a SVR as a FTB.
as a previous poster says you could be in negative equity then and remortgaging then will be an issue ..

Those who say 6% is high and can only see it going down are probably way younger than me and don’t remember the rate going to 15 % .
Its been done before - could again though of course wecall
hope not .

Go for 5 % … overpay any month that you can and then try for a great rate after the 5 years is up .

Congratulations 👏 on your house and enjoy it !
I love a new build - so little to be done !

PicaK · 07/11/2022 07:48

I'd go for 5. With full awareness of what your redemption rate is. You'll have certainty. Its a very volatile world out there.