Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain child centiles to me?

140 replies

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 18:38

AIBU for thinking it's really confusing, or am I being thick?

I've been diagnosed pre diabetic this week and trying to overhaul my diet and tackle my weight as it's got out of control.

Youngest DC is also looking quite chubby. I'm trying to work out their BMI but everything gives me a weight centile, which don't seem to take into account their height? But their height must be a factor?

OP posts:
Tinner01 · 06/11/2022 22:53

@astronewt
1- sorry didn’t see the parents heights. Yes that doesn’t really sound like she’s going to have much of a growth “spurt” but she still has a fair amount to do and is around puberty age.
2- I didn’t phrase that correctly, sorry. What I meant is that children who are overweight as children, if helped correctly to manage their weight, are often more successful in staying a healthy weight as adults compared to peers who struggle when their metabolism slows down. OP needs to ensure her DD gets the support she needs to lose weight whilst avoiding provoking any sort of Ed/poor relationship with food/body. If so it will be a valuable lesson for the rest of her life.

astronewt · 06/11/2022 22:48

Tinner01 · 06/11/2022 22:43

Yes she is quite overweight but I wouldn’t encourage weight loss to her unless she specifically talks to you about it. Instead, you should give her smaller portions, watch out for liquid/empty calories, and promote a balanced diet focusing on all the food groups with occasional treats not zero. Also encourage exercise which it sounds like she’s keen on already.

has she always been quite chubby looking? She could be going through a slightly overweight phase before a growth spurt at that age. What about you and her DF? Are you genetically prone to putting on weight?

unless she is very overweight for a considerable period of time I would not worry. Just provide her with all the resources to keep healthy now and particularly in the future.

it can be sometimes good for children to be overweight as children and then lose it as they learn how to manage weight as adults in comparison to kids with high metabolisms who put on weight when they slow down as adults.

The child is already 98th centile on height, much higher than her parents' height suggest her adult centile is going to be; what kind of growth spurt do you think she's going to have?

And no, it's not "good" for a child of 8 to be obese. Ever. Your post is just more denial.

NewNovember · 06/11/2022 22:46

You should be able able to see a young child's ribs. If you can't they are overweight op.

prettylittlethingss · 06/11/2022 22:45

OP you sound in denial. Your daughter is overweight and instead of messing around working out percentiles you should figure out how to tackle this- or call your GP.

Coffeeandcrocs · 06/11/2022 22:44

OP, there should be no rolls of any kind on an 8 year old really.

8 year old DD is very tall (95th centile ) and is 25kg eg 3.9stone for context

Tinner01 · 06/11/2022 22:43

Yes she is quite overweight but I wouldn’t encourage weight loss to her unless she specifically talks to you about it. Instead, you should give her smaller portions, watch out for liquid/empty calories, and promote a balanced diet focusing on all the food groups with occasional treats not zero. Also encourage exercise which it sounds like she’s keen on already.

has she always been quite chubby looking? She could be going through a slightly overweight phase before a growth spurt at that age. What about you and her DF? Are you genetically prone to putting on weight?

unless she is very overweight for a considerable period of time I would not worry. Just provide her with all the resources to keep healthy now and particularly in the future.

it can be sometimes good for children to be overweight as children and then lose it as they learn how to manage weight as adults in comparison to kids with high metabolisms who put on weight when they slow down as adults.

astronewt · 06/11/2022 22:43

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:36

I can't work out the centile charts at all. She's on the 98th centile for height and the 99th for weight on the chart, but she comes out as 98th centile on the calculator things you put weight and height into. She doesn't have any problems running or climbing on playground equipment.

She has some little rolls on the top of her belly when she sits down but I can see her spine etc. She really doesn't look massively overweight.

With all due respect: you are going to need to accept that your view on how a child looks is not reliable and not going to change the situation here.

Your child is very overweight.

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:43

@Violinist64 She already eats 3 meals a day and doesn't drink squash or soda.

OP posts:
macaronip1e · 06/11/2022 22:43

As a comparison, my DD is 139cm (so nearly same height as your DD), and weighs 5stone 2. She’s 10 and for her age these are both equivalent to just under 50th percentile (ie, in good proportion), and 48th percentile according to NHS BMI calculator.

I realise that it seems illogical that high percentile height AND weight don’t mean normal BMI. Aside from children growing “over tall”, you can’t assume the underlying data for the height and weight percentiles are in “normal BMI” proportion. As a result the highest percentiles are skewed by overweight children; the lowest are skewed by underweight children.

angelikacpickles · 06/11/2022 22:43

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:36

I can't work out the centile charts at all. She's on the 98th centile for height and the 99th for weight on the chart, but she comes out as 98th centile on the calculator things you put weight and height into. She doesn't have any problems running or climbing on playground equipment.

She has some little rolls on the top of her belly when she sits down but I can see her spine etc. She really doesn't look massively overweight.

You keep posting the same thing but, honestly, if she is 7 stone at 140cm then she will be much heavier than most of her peers. Several people have explained why being tall doesn't necessarily mean that she isn't overweight. It is probably best if you speak to your GP or someone else about her weight.

vera16 · 06/11/2022 22:42

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:36

I can't work out the centile charts at all. She's on the 98th centile for height and the 99th for weight on the chart, but she comes out as 98th centile on the calculator things you put weight and height into. She doesn't have any problems running or climbing on playground equipment.

She has some little rolls on the top of her belly when she sits down but I can see her spine etc. She really doesn't look massively overweight.

Here you go. 98th for height and 99th for weight gives you a BMI centile of just above 98%.

Can anyone explain child centiles to me?
Violinist64 · 06/11/2022 22:38

An eight year old should not weigh 7 stone 1. She is extremely overweight as this is almost double the normal weight of a child her age. I would imagine that a lot of the problem is portion size and snacks. She should have three meals a day and drinks should be mainly water or milk. Squash and fizzy drinks should be a treat. This way she should maintain her weight and slim down as her height increases. It would be a good idea to seek medical advice, possibly a dietitian.

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:36

I can't work out the centile charts at all. She's on the 98th centile for height and the 99th for weight on the chart, but she comes out as 98th centile on the calculator things you put weight and height into. She doesn't have any problems running or climbing on playground equipment.

She has some little rolls on the top of her belly when she sits down but I can see her spine etc. She really doesn't look massively overweight.

OP posts:
Tinner01 · 06/11/2022 22:35

Nhs bmi calculator can be quite scary- used to say my DS was “very overweight” as well but he was just due a growth spurt! Encourage a healthy balanced diet and exercise, don’t focus too much on numbers as it can be quite dangerous for kids especially girls.

vera16 · 06/11/2022 22:33

Onceinnever · 06/11/2022 22:21

I didn't realise overweight children grow taller than they should until reading this thread. My daughter was born on the 99.6 centile and is now I think on the 91st? She is 98 for height. I just thought because she started on a higher centile that she would remain on it. I don't generally weigh her so I'm not certain on her weight. Oh dear.

This does not include children whose genetics dictate that they will be tall regardless. And in any case your daughter is not overweight going by those numbers.

BogRollBOGOF · 06/11/2022 22:30

Junior school age children should be fairly lean and ribby, with toddler chub long gone. For them to look "overweight" compared to adults with visible surplus fat they are very overweight. Children don't have the testosterone levels to build up BMI busting muscle levels and the charts have enough variation to take into account a range of builds.

A lot of children are now overweight and that distorts our view of normal. I've had people think my "healthy zone" children are thin and underweight while dismissing the letters they've had about their children at the yR and y6 checks. They do look thinner than their peers but their statistics, appetites and energy levels are all healthy. I know 9yo's superficially the same height and mass as me (but not with the muscle density) and too unfit to climb, run or walk briskly which must make life difficult for them as they grow up.

It's also easy to overestimate activity levels. An hour's dance/ swimming/ karate class can often have a large proportion of time hanging around waiting. Incidental movement and short bursts help a lot, walking to school, active games, playing outside all add up along with formal activity.

It's on your radar now and there are ways of tweaking to make healthier lifestyles and help your child grow into her weight healthily and safely.

SNWannabe · 06/11/2022 22:30

Your school should be able to refer you on to a healthy weight team specially equipped to advise on child healthy weights. You don’t aim for kids to lose weight but for their weight to remain constant while they grow… so they outgrow their weight problems.

But @olivewreath13 you really need to, in all kindness, get out of the denial mindset you’re in currently. You are dangerously overweight yourself and you are sending your daughter down that pathway too. It’s not too late for either of you- but you owe it to her to get your head out of the sand, forget about making excuses about her muscles or her dancing or whatever. Being fit does not mean you cannot be fat- and she is fit if doing all that exercise, great, but she is overweight and that impacts her biologically including hormones and is setting her up for a lifetime of medical
issues.

astronewt · 06/11/2022 22:29

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:23

She does 9 hours of dance a week, a swimming lesson and a skating lesson.

I'm just over 5"7, her dad is about 6".

Okay. That indicates strongly that her height, genetically, is not going to be 99.8th centile and that she is currently taking in a significant calorie excess which has led her to be both over-heighr and overweight.

vera16 · 06/11/2022 22:28

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:16

So their weight centile is supposed to be lower than their height, not the same? Because her height is also 98th centile... am I being really thick?

The BMI centile is a different number. If she is exactly 98th for height and weight her BMI centile would be about 91%. You can plot it on a chart here: https://www.rcpch.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Girls2-188yearsgrowthhchart.pdf

SpookySally · 06/11/2022 22:24

That is really very heavy for an 8 year old, my 7 year old is literally half that weight.

Please tread very carefully though OP and be delicate with how you approach her weight. There are many threads here you can refer to on how to deal with an overweight child without destroying their self esteem and relationship with food forever. I wouldn’t mention weight at all, just encourage healthy eating, filling up with protein and fibre, and moving more as a family. Best of luck to you.

watingroom2 · 06/11/2022 22:23

I was constantly told my 25 centile weight daughter 'was underweight' but she was 90th centile for height- if she were not getting enough food she would not have grown!

I think with children you can 'look' and tell if they are overweight- and understand they can 'fatten up' before they grow... but if your child has 'rolls of fat' .. look at increasing fiber - and good bacteria - to enable them to be healthier

I'm really not convinced BMI is a good measure

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:23

She does 9 hours of dance a week, a swimming lesson and a skating lesson.

I'm just over 5"7, her dad is about 6".

OP posts:
Onceinnever · 06/11/2022 22:21

I didn't realise overweight children grow taller than they should until reading this thread. My daughter was born on the 99.6 centile and is now I think on the 91st? She is 98 for height. I just thought because she started on a higher centile that she would remain on it. I don't generally weigh her so I'm not certain on her weight. Oh dear.

astronewt · 06/11/2022 22:20

I'm sorry, but your DC is overweight. An 8yo should not have "a bit of a belly", period. It does sound that your standards of what is "normal" and healthy in a child is distorted.

Bumbletrees · 06/11/2022 22:19

7 stone! My almost 8 year old is 4 stone and 50th centile. Also very overweight children grow taller than they should. I honestly would urgently seek advice to help her

Swipe left for the next trending thread