Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can anyone explain child centiles to me?

140 replies

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 18:38

AIBU for thinking it's really confusing, or am I being thick?

I've been diagnosed pre diabetic this week and trying to overhaul my diet and tackle my weight as it's got out of control.

Youngest DC is also looking quite chubby. I'm trying to work out their BMI but everything gives me a weight centile, which don't seem to take into account their height? But their height must be a factor?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Violinist64 · 07/11/2022 20:50

@vera16 l was shocked by the weight of an eight-year-old girl compared with that of my ADULT daughter, a woman in her twenties - nothing to do with the tiny child she was. In addition, six stones still sounds very heavy for an eight-year-old, even one who is very tall for her age. I would have thought five stones would be about right for the height she is now. I know from my own experience what it is like to be overweight and would not wish it on anyone, let alone an eight-year-old child. I have nothing but sympathy for this child and the OP obviously loves her daughter very much and only wants the best for her. Unfortunately, sometimes love means having to make difficult decisions and not being blind to problems but doing something about them and following through, which is the hardest thing of all.

@hippoherostandinghere thank you. She is fine these days. This was at the end of her first year at university. She had her appendix removed and they were investigating diseases such as Crohn’s and diverticulitis but could not find anything conclusive.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 20:31

My dd has been over 99th centile since she was 18 months old. We went through HELL with the Hv and Gp ended up having all sorts of tests and being referred to obesity clinic.

I was accused of fabricating her food diary and they tried to push for us to go into hospital for observation I actually posted on here at the time.

Long story short dd is perfectly healthy. Nothing wrong with her at all (except asd but that doesn’t cause weight issues!) But we were treated like liars and bad parents.

vera16 · 07/11/2022 20:19

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 19:25

I agree with @Violinist64, why would we brag about our own underweight children, that too comes with its own problems. Believe me, I take responsibility for my DC weight, and do my best to make sure they are both fit and healthy.

Violinist, I'm sorry to hear about your DD, I can only imagine how worried you were about her at that low weight, I hope she's on the mend.

It's when violinist said she was 'shocked' when comparing OP's daughter's weight to her own petite children. I didn't find that particularly helpful either. Bear in mind that OP's daughter could be be near enough six stone and still classed as 'healthy weight'.

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 19:25

I agree with @Violinist64, why would we brag about our own underweight children, that too comes with its own problems. Believe me, I take responsibility for my DC weight, and do my best to make sure they are both fit and healthy.

Violinist, I'm sorry to hear about your DD, I can only imagine how worried you were about her at that low weight, I hope she's on the mend.

angelikacpickles · 07/11/2022 18:40

olivewreath13 · 07/11/2022 08:50

So basically you can't use the centile charts if their height is into the top centiles? Or you can, but their weight needs to be a lower centile?

I am going to get her a GP appointment. I've realised this morning she can't zip her winter coat up over her belly which was a bit 😳

You keep asking this but the thing is that being in the same centile for both weight and height doesn't mean everything is fine.

Being at the very top of the chart for weight is a concern. The fact that your daughter is also tall doesn't mean that her weight isn't a concern, particularly when you say that she is carrying weight on her belly (rather than being naturally tall and lean). I'm glad you are going to the GP. Hopefully they will be able to help you and her.

Violinist64 · 07/11/2022 17:14

We are not bragging. We are very concerned for your child. She might well be tall but she is also very obese and the more you post the more concerning the picture becomes. You still seem to be in denial about the true extent of the problem. You say that you have only just noticed how tight her clothes are. I said that I was considered a short, chubby child myself by seventies standards yet I was not really overweight, let alone obese. You have said how many other children look similar to your daughter. This is a real cause for concern as they are at risk of serious health problems.
Small children also have problems. A few years ago, my daughter was in hospital for a week (not anorexia) and her weight plummeted to 5 1/2 stones. It was a huge concern.

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 15:46

Seriously OP, that's what you took from my posts? I offered you advice and tried to give you some perspective. An 8 year old should not be 7 stone, it's not healthy. If you want to take your frustrations out on me go ahead by all means if it helps. Or channel it into helping your DD.

olivewreath13 · 07/11/2022 15:43

Bragging about perfect petite children when I've explained mine is tall isn't really helpful is it @hippoherostandinghere 🙄

OP posts:
Violinist64 · 07/11/2022 14:50

@hippoherostandinghere my daughter was a very similar size to your daughter at eleven. As an adult she is around 5’1”, with size 2 feet and probably doesn’t weigh much more than the OP’s eight-year-old daughter, which makes her a petite size 6. I think this is what shocked me about the OP’s daughter’s weight. As a child, I was fairly short and chubby but at eight, I probably weighed about four stones at around 4’1”.

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 13:57

@SpookySally Yes, she is very short, around 130cm. She's also under paediatric review and no immediate concerns. 13 year old DS is only just over 5 stone. I'm just trying to give another perspective to OP.

SpookySally · 07/11/2022 13:52

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 10:03

Firstly OP I'm glad you are doing something about this now for your daughters sake. It doesn't matter how overweight she is, the fact is she is overweight and that's not healthy. But now is a good time to do something about it.
The extra curricular activities are great so keep them up. Portion sizes for children tend to have got very out of hand. A child should be eating of a small plate.

For context, my DD is 11 and she weighs 3 stone 8lb. Everyone passes comment about how little she is but in reality she's perfectly in proportion for a child. Children this age should certainly not have a belly or rolls of fat. The weight trigger for puberty is 45kg which is what your DD is, at 8 years old.

Is she really short? That’s a very low weight for an 11 year old.

vera16 · 07/11/2022 10:52

OP if you play around with the numbers on the NHS calculator you can see she would need to be 1st and 2 lbs lighter to sneak into the 'healthy weight' category. The range is large so already accounts for different builds, muscle mass etc. (in most cases). From everything you have said she is likely carrying an extra stone in weight around her middle which you say have noticed yourself. It is not too late to rectify this and could be very do-able in a reasonable time frame.

Can anyone explain child centiles to me?
vera16 · 07/11/2022 10:33

@MRex anything above 91% on the BMI centiles is overweight. Above 91% on the weight centiles might be OK depending on height. Sorry if that is what you meant but just wanted to clarify.

hippoherostandinghere · 07/11/2022 10:03

Firstly OP I'm glad you are doing something about this now for your daughters sake. It doesn't matter how overweight she is, the fact is she is overweight and that's not healthy. But now is a good time to do something about it.
The extra curricular activities are great so keep them up. Portion sizes for children tend to have got very out of hand. A child should be eating of a small plate.

For context, my DD is 11 and she weighs 3 stone 8lb. Everyone passes comment about how little she is but in reality she's perfectly in proportion for a child. Children this age should certainly not have a belly or rolls of fat. The weight trigger for puberty is 45kg which is what your DD is, at 8 years old.

titchy · 07/11/2022 09:44

Your GP isn't gojng to do any sort of body composition scan on her. All your GP will do is weigh her and say fucking hell 7 stone! My adult dc is taller than her and weighs the same!

Muscle mass doesnt produce flabby bellies. Dancers are lean. Ignore discovereads - she objects to most things people posts for some reason.

3 meals a day, use side plate not normal plate and half full of veg. Breakfast high protein - scrambled eggs in one slice of toast. Keep up the activities for her. Snack on small amount carrot and humous for example.

MRex · 07/11/2022 09:39

olivewreath13 · 07/11/2022 08:50

So basically you can't use the centile charts if their height is into the top centiles? Or you can, but their weight needs to be a lower centile?

I am going to get her a GP appointment. I've realised this morning she can't zip her winter coat up over her belly which was a bit 😳

Anything above 91st centile will be overweight. You can't refine to "how overweight" without switching to a BMI measurement. GP input might help; the main thing will be stopping her weight from going up any more for a few years.

randommusings8 · 07/11/2022 09:32

What size clothes is she in?

As many other previous posters have said, she is very overweight and there should be no belly or rolls of fat on a healthy weight 8 year old.

As others have also said, our perception is skewed due to so many children being overweight, and also if parents themselves are overweight, this skews perception even more.

olivewreath13 · 07/11/2022 08:50

So basically you can't use the centile charts if their height is into the top centiles? Or you can, but their weight needs to be a lower centile?

I am going to get her a GP appointment. I've realised this morning she can't zip her winter coat up over her belly which was a bit 😳

OP posts:
MRex · 07/11/2022 08:33

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 22:36

I can't work out the centile charts at all. She's on the 98th centile for height and the 99th for weight on the chart, but she comes out as 98th centile on the calculator things you put weight and height into. She doesn't have any problems running or climbing on playground equipment.

She has some little rolls on the top of her belly when she sits down but I can see her spine etc. She really doesn't look massively overweight.

The centile doesn't fully match BMI, because there may be a higher percentage who are very overweight than who are tall. If you look at charts for her height and how that matches average age, you can see what a standard weight would be at that height. It doesn't work for under 5s, nor once puberty hits, but at your DD's age it might help you to visualise better. So a 50% 10yo is 141cm and 31kg, which is 4 stone 12. Your DD is more than 2 stone over this weight, 40% over it. Although the centiles match, because that's very high it means she's very overweight.

primeoflife · 07/11/2022 08:10

olivewreath13 · 06/11/2022 23:13

If she's obese then more than half of kids her age must be too. She honestly doesn't look huge, she just has a bit of excess belly. I was expecting her to be slightly overweight.

This is true though.
I've been teaching years and I can see that children are just getting bigger and bigger and the parents just don't see it.

I've currently two children in my class significantly overweight, the mum thinks it's just a bit of puppy fat and hormones. Bollocks is it.

For context my youngest is 5ft4 and weighs under 7 stone. She does not look underweight, your daughter is significantly shorter and weighs more.

I think many are now not sure what a good weight should look like.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 07:59

Hellocatshome · 07/11/2022 07:41

Fair enough I don't know as much about girls as boys despite being one. However I still think this comment from OP in particular points at maybe the problem not being totally solved by ascribing it to muscle mass.

I've just watched some of the videos her dance school post to their fb group and I was quite shocked actually. She has some noticeable belly wobble going on compared to the other girls and she looks much more puffed out 😳

Anyway a load of strangers on the Internet are not going to be able to accurately determine anything so a health professionals opinion is probably worth seeking.

I agree it cannot all be ascribed to muscle mass, but some of it likely is.
Body composition test at a GPs will better inform how much excess weight she is actually carrying.
Generally with children, they don’t do weight loss but adjust diet so their BMI drops as they grow. If the diet ends up being too low calorie & nutrient wise, it can be harmful to an athletic child- ie risk low bone density & then osteoporosis in older age.

So, yes need a medical professional to do an individual assessment.

SkankingWombat · 07/11/2022 07:50

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 07/11/2022 00:50

here's your answer - muscle mass is much denser than fat. So two children of the same height and weight the one with the high proportion of muscle mass will look very different than the one with the high proportion of body fat.

Averaging a couple of hours of exercise a day is way way more than the average kid.

This simply cannot be true for DCs. That amount of bulking out of muscle that puts the super-fit/muscle-y into the 'overweight' category doesn't happen until much later (as witnessed in the youngest apprentices at work who lived at the gym and would try anything to add that level of muscle mass). My 8yo is solid muscle - you can see definition in her arms and legs, she has a six pack (visible until she's had breakfast at least!), and she can do chin ups and 10 or so vertical sit ups without rest. When she was weighed at the doctors a couple of months ago she was 25.5kg. By your logic she should weigh much more than than. She is shorter than OP's DC, but not 45% smaller, and nor would adding a very small layer of 'insulation' make up that difference.

OP my friend's DD is 8yo and a similar height to your DD. My friend recently expressed her concern to me that her DD was overweight and told me she is currently 5 1/2 stone. She is definitely overweight, you can see it to look at her. Your DC is considerably heavier.
I agree with a PP that although she does many hours of exercise, it may not all be that vigorous (certainly if the swimming lesson is a standard AquaEd one rather than a swim club's training session, there will be an awful lot of waiting around for your turn). Equally you can be fit but still very overweight.

Hellocatshome · 07/11/2022 07:41

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 07:23

A bit of belly and high muscle mass does fit for girls.
Females naturally have around 50% more body fat than males without being overweight, even from age 3, so long before puberty.
No you cannot tell by looking.

Fair enough I don't know as much about girls as boys despite being one. However I still think this comment from OP in particular points at maybe the problem not being totally solved by ascribing it to muscle mass.

I've just watched some of the videos her dance school post to their fb group and I was quite shocked actually. She has some noticeable belly wobble going on compared to the other girls and she looks much more puffed out 😳

Anyway a load of strangers on the Internet are not going to be able to accurately determine anything so a health professionals opinion is probably worth seeking.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 07:36

astronewt · 07/11/2022 07:06

It is not a good idea to post a picture. Firstly because this is an 8yo, and secondly because the last thing OP needs is people fluffing her that her DD "looks fine" and "it's probably muscle". An 8yo is not carrying 3 stone of extra muscle from routine extracurriculars.

OP, see a GP.

3 Stone? I think that’s a typo. The DD is only 1.5 stone above an ideal weight for her height by the BMI chart. It’s quite possible she has good muscle mass contributing to that as she is physically active 6x a week. I agree with & have said best to see a GP to discuss and a body composition test is usually more accurate to determine if overweight or obese.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 07:23

Hellocatshome · 07/11/2022 07:10

This is not necessarily the answer muscle mass does not fit right with a bit if a belly. My DS is 12 swims competitively and trains over 13 hours a week despite having big shoulders and the start of some impressive pecs and abs he is skin and bone. If an 8 year olds BMI was down to muscle mass rather than fat you would be able to tell by looking at them and that doesn't seem to fit with OPs description.

A bit of belly and high muscle mass does fit for girls.
Females naturally have around 50% more body fat than males without being overweight, even from age 3, so long before puberty.
No you cannot tell by looking.