Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the bank should refund us

89 replies

broccolibush · 06/11/2022 17:42

I noticed a transaction on my bank account that wasn’t authorised by either DH or me - for nearly £1,000 to a taxi company in South America - so called the bank to report it as a fraudulent transaction and ask for the money to be returned. It was a debit card payment.

We don’t spend using debit cards on the account (do day to day spending on credit cards and clear the balance every month) and we’re in the UK not in South America. The bank have said that the payment was made using chip and pin and have refused to accept it was fraudulent as the card is still in our possession, albeit many thousands of miles from where the transaction was made.

AIBU to think that there is no way a debit card in the UK could have been legitimately used for a chip and pin transaction in South America and that as a result refusing to accept this as fraud because the card is in our possession is insane? Has anyone else been in a similar situation and found a way to get their money back? I don’t fancy being £1k down to a criminal aided by the bank.

OP posts:
broccolibush · 25/11/2022 14:52

The galling/funny thing @Gastonia is my credit card company did just that with me this week because I made an unusual purchase. It's what we expect and normally what happens!

OP posts:
TrixJax · 25/11/2022 14:50

Oops @Gastonia GrinGrinGrinGrin

broccolibush · 25/11/2022 14:50

The not typical fraud pattern is in the formal response to our complaint so it's not someone who doesn't know better fobbing me off. I've told them the payment wasn't made by us, offered proof of us being in the UK (including a contactless payment made by the same card in the UK just minutes after this big overseas transaction) but they're not interested. I can't even get past the initial call handlers in the fraud team - and was only given the fraud team number today!

The bank is one mostly taxpayer owned since 2008.

OP posts:
Gastonia · 25/11/2022 14:48

many banks would contact the customer if a spend like that comes up to check it's genuine
This happened to us. Our joint credit card was used to try to book a flight to the US. The fraud department rang and I said it certainly wasn't us, and they stopped the transaction.
(A short time later, DH came in from our home office, and ranted about how he'd not been able to book a flight to the US for his dad, as the transaction was stopped... 😳)

Wordsoup · 25/11/2022 14:47

As someone who works for a bank, when you called and someone said it’s not the typical fraud pattern that will just be an agent on the phone, they could be wrong, ie just said some random crap to shut you up
call fraud services again and explain that your card has clearly been cloned, you’re in the UK and it’s that simple. You need to file a complaint before you take it to FOS. They have an 8 week time to investigate complaints.

ivykaty44 · 25/11/2022 14:42

Does anyone bank with anyone nice

first direct have an excellent reputation and Atom bank has opened with their previous CEO at the helm - offering good rates of interest on their bonds to boot

ivykaty44 · 25/11/2022 14:39

Which bank is this?

port in spain?

TrixJax · 25/11/2022 14:35

@broccolibush many banks would contact the customer if a spend like that comes up to check it's genuine.
I'm with Halifax/Bank of Scotland and they would send a text before authorising payment. As you say, it's abroad and not your spending pattern. Your bank's algorithm failed here

minou123 · 25/11/2022 14:35

Sorry @broccolibush . I'm peacemaking as this thread has useful information.

I'm helping a family member who has had the exact same problem with HSBC. They are claiming my family member has acted with gross negligence because the card is still in thier possession.

BashfulClam · 25/11/2022 14:34

Go to the ombudsman or at least tell the bank you will be ad they get charged for each complaint even if you’ve in their favour.

If you are switching banks check out Narrin Lewis’ site and see which ones give cashback, DH just got £200 for switching to Nationwide. I am with Natiobwide already and really rate them. They have a good east to use app and never had an issue (our mortgage is with them and I quite r hit seeing the balance decrease). Quidco might also have cashback deals for switching. I got an extra £70 from them in top of the normal switching fee. Nationwide switching was so easy.

1001Daffodils · 25/11/2022 14:25

When I had my card cloned (best guess as to how they got my details) the bank were satisfied that the spending didn't fit with my spending profile so accepted the transaction as fraud and sorted it. This was Lloyds bank who I think are otherwise inept...but they way they handled this made me stay as a customer.

Hope you get some traction with the ombudsman. £1k isn't an amount most people can just wave goodbye to (even if you could, you shouldn't have to!).

DomingoinLittleOakley · 25/11/2022 14:11

Ah sorry, I have just seen that your original post was 6 November.
Good luck!

broccolibush · 25/11/2022 14:07

Thanks for the link @SerenaTee - that's pretty much what I'd read from other sources. They have to refund me unless they can prove it's not fraud. They are banking on me not knowing this, which makes them horrible, horrible people.

I've spent hours going round in circles this week to get answers, being told something different every time, finally getting the response today that was written on 10 November! Which makes me even more annoyed with them.

Anyway, I have sent it to the ombudsman now so hopefully they will start their slow wheels turning, or maybe the bank will have a change of heart when they realise I'm not going away.

The abroad thing really bugs me - we don't use our cards abroad as we have a currency card with another provider. Neither of us has ever made a debit card payment outside the UK and we haven't even put our debit cards in a cashpoint abroad since 2012ish. So whilst it's not the spending pattern of a fraudster (allegedly) it's not my spending pattern either - and they have 30 years of history to check for me!!

OP posts:
DomingoinLittleOakley · 25/11/2022 14:07

Have they recorded it as a formal complaint OP? They need to provide you with a formal response within 15 days, rejecting the complaint and explaining their reasons for doing so, along with Ombudsman details. The Ombudsman route will take ages though - they have a massive backlog. If you do have to go that route, and the Ombudsman finds in your favour, they will award 8% interest for the time that money was not in your account.

However, the FCA have said that banks can't just say that use of your card or PIN means you authorised the payment. If they haven't formally rejected your complaint yet, I would escalate it - they have to pay the Ombudsman for every case so maybe someone else will see sense.

UrsulaPandress · 25/11/2022 13:55

If I don’t inform my bank I’m going abroad then they refuse transactions.

I’m with RBS and First Direct.

girlmom21 · 25/11/2022 13:52

This is shocking. It doesn't matter what pattern they expect. It's either a fraudster or a glitch in their system!

Malbecfan · 25/11/2022 13:50

Nationwide has been really good when I had some direct debits set up fraudulently on my account. I was able to speak to a real person pretty quickly and the money was refunded within an hour. All the DDs were to 2 different insurance companies and in the end, I got the info from the DDs and rang the insurance companies who were also really helpful. I now check which DDs I have on that account every week or so.

I think Nationwide is also paying money into your account to switch, according to MSE.

FelizNavicrab · 25/11/2022 13:47

They also pay £10 an hour for your time so log every time you call, including wait times.

That's really good!

2bazookas · 25/11/2022 13:45

Obtain name of the bank employee who declined to compensate, and use it when escalating your complaint.

CheeseAndNutellaSandwich · 25/11/2022 13:44

Just realised my suggestion about the tenner an hour only really makes sense if you’re already with NatWest or if your bank does the same but you can always ask…

CheeseAndNutellaSandwich · 25/11/2022 13:43

*NatWest

CheeseAndNutellaSandwich · 25/11/2022 13:43

We’ve never had any problems with Nawest. They also pay £10 an hour for your time so log every time you call, including wait times. I didn’t even ask for it. The complaints guys said ‘how long do you think you’ve spent dealing with the complaint?’ I said ‘about 6 I guess’ and that’s when he said they pay £10 an hour in compensation. That’s after DH and I got £200 due to the actions of a staff member in branch, threatening to close our account after we enquired how long the wait was going to be 😆

SerenaTee · 25/11/2022 13:36

Have a read of this www.fca.org.uk/consumers/unauthorised-payments-account

Good luck with FOS but be prepared to wait as they’re very busy. If you win, ask them to include compensation for the time you’ve spent without the money in your account.

Amybelle88 · 25/11/2022 13:26

File a direct debit indemnity claim.

If they don't comply, escalate to the FOS.

broccolibush · 25/11/2022 13:24

Well the bank have said it’s not fraud as it’s “not the spend pattern we would expect from an opportunistic fraudster” so off to the ombudsman I go…

Does anyone bank with anyone nice?

OP posts: