Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the bank should refund us

89 replies

broccolibush · 06/11/2022 17:42

I noticed a transaction on my bank account that wasn’t authorised by either DH or me - for nearly £1,000 to a taxi company in South America - so called the bank to report it as a fraudulent transaction and ask for the money to be returned. It was a debit card payment.

We don’t spend using debit cards on the account (do day to day spending on credit cards and clear the balance every month) and we’re in the UK not in South America. The bank have said that the payment was made using chip and pin and have refused to accept it was fraudulent as the card is still in our possession, albeit many thousands of miles from where the transaction was made.

AIBU to think that there is no way a debit card in the UK could have been legitimately used for a chip and pin transaction in South America and that as a result refusing to accept this as fraud because the card is in our possession is insane? Has anyone else been in a similar situation and found a way to get their money back? I don’t fancy being £1k down to a criminal aided by the bank.

OP posts:
GoldenCupidon · 25/11/2022 16:50

I think it's worth you getting in touch with finance journalist Paul Lewis twitter.com/paullewismoney?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor - you can message him on Twitter, who is usually shit hot at getting results out of finance organisations who do a bad job. He's the presenter of R4 Money Box.

PriamFarrl · 25/11/2022 16:37

broccolibush · 25/11/2022 13:24

Well the bank have said it’s not fraud as it’s “not the spend pattern we would expect from an opportunistic fraudster” so off to the ombudsman I go…

Does anyone bank with anyone nice?

How is someone using your card fraudulently not fraud?

I’m with Nationwide and Amex from my credit card. I can give you recommended a friend offers on both if you like.

JLQ1020 · 25/11/2022 16:37

Ex bank staff here.
You can't raise a direct debit as it was a DD payment, however you should absolutely log a complaint and if they do not resolve it satisfactorily then you can take it to the ombudsman.. You need to log the complaint with the bank first though.

Redead · 25/11/2022 16:32

This happened to us and we are in canada! It was a charge from Tokyo using Amazon.ja. Our backs absolutely REFUSED to refund it and told us we needed to contact amazon to fix it but all the reps spoke japanese and refused to help us. We managed to get someone who spoke broken english and they told us they wouldn’t help. We kicked up a fuss with the bank and they insisted it was us and they would not help. WE DON’T SPEAK JAPANESE AND WE ARE NOT FROM JAPAN. NO RECEIPTS OF VISITING JAPANESE WHY WOULD WE MAKE A PURCHASE ON AMAZON.JA???

We were out $300 and the bank would not help. We were forced to switch banks over it as we had to get food from the food bank to feed our family as we were out of grocery money because of it. This was right after I gave birth too so we felt so vulnerable. 😔

We felt betrayed. We made sure the next bank had decent fraud policies but we now have trust issues with banks because of it. They didn’t protect us. We tried to fight it for three months but nothing came of it. At one point someone actually accused us of lying. All of the evidence was clear we did not make this purchase. How could they do this to us?

Whiskyvodka · 25/11/2022 16:23

God help you if its Lloyd's. Eels must envy their slipperiness.
My friend's dh greatest wish is to bring them down.
Whenever Ic watch Mary Poppins and they go in that old bank I always think of Lloyd's.

ChilomenaPunk · 25/11/2022 16:13

And who spends £1000 on a taxi anyway? Surely this should flag something up. Sounds like a failure of their security system to me.

ChilomenaPunk · 25/11/2022 16:10

Clearly you haven't given anyone your details so they must refund you. Yes, please say which bank it is.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/11/2022 16:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Quackpot · 25/11/2022 16:03

I bank with Halifax and they always check with me before they allow an unusual transaction to be made, even once between my own accounts with them (withdrawing savings, I never do that 🤣). DH banks with tsb and their fraud team even phoned him to tell him about attempted fraud before he knew about it, he'd bought something online from what turned out to be a fake version of a well known sports shops website, and they had cloned his card. So if you want a new bank there's 2 good ones 🙂

Really hope you get sorted, and hopefully some compensation on top for the stress.

RuperttheBearHug · 25/11/2022 16:01

TSB have a fraud refund guarantee OP (this is where you say that’s who you’re with 😮‍💨) and I would personally recommend First Direct and Monzo to bank with also.

BritWifeInUSA · 25/11/2022 15:56

I don’t know if this is available in the UK but it’s what we have here with our bank (Bank of America) and it stopped a similar thing happening:

We have the online banking app on our phones. The app constantly tracks the location of your phone when the phone is on. If the debit card is used in a different location to where your phone is, it’s rejected. One morning at 3 am someone tried to use a clone of my husband’s debit card to buy gas around 50 miles from where we live. We were asleep in our home at the time. The person tried three times and each time it was rejected because the phone was located 50 miles away.

It can be a mess if you go out and forget your phone and want to use your debit card. But I’d rather have that inconvenience for the security that we have.

MrsPnut · 25/11/2022 15:50

There was a section on Watchdog about bank fraud and refunds this week. It was on a Wednesday’s One Show.
I bank with First Direct though and have never had any problems.

broccolibush · 25/11/2022 15:50

MoirasSaggyBundles · 25/11/2022 15:07

All calls are recorded. Do a subject access request and tell the bank you want a copy of the voice recording of all the calls you have made about this fraudulent transaction. This will be good evidence to show the Ombudsman that the bank is not dealing with your complaints properly.

Oh good idea. I'll add that to my list of things to do come Monday as frankly nobody is going to deal with it today are they.

Honestly I don't know how they think refusing this is going to fly. It clearly wasn't us. We were in the UK and they know it due to card use, we don't use our debit cards (DH only did on this occasion because his credit card was declined - seemingly due to some kind of fraud device on the point of sale machine), there are police reports of the same thing happening at the same station in the same week and all manner of other reasons. Besides its for them to prove we authorised it not the other way round.

Have now cried at 2 people from the bank today. And my anxiety medication is out of stock due to a manufacturing issue. Will go and have a pity party somewhere.

OP posts:
fancyacuppatea · 25/11/2022 15:49

@broccolibush the response from your bank is awful.
I had a text about my "apple pay" not working with a link to a website...thing is I have an "olde worlde" brick phone that doesn't do t'interweb Grin and I don't have any apples except the odd couple left in the fruit bowl.
Stick to your guns. Maybe write them a letter - they probably won't know what to do with it. Wink
Put everything else on your credit card and open a bank account with someone else (we have more than 1) then get your salary and DDs transfered. Nationwide are ok.

StrawberryPot · 25/11/2022 15:46

First Direct alerted us to some fraudulent activity on our account years ago. DH and I both had our cards in our possession but FD suggested either they'd been cloned (petrol stations were high on the list of culprits) or one of us had bought something online from a site with poor security controls. There was no question that they wouldn't reimburse us.

We've been with FD for 30 years and wouldn't bank elsewhere.

JackandVera · 25/11/2022 15:44

What bank is this? I had this with HSBC and it was dealt with immediately. My card was used in New York.

NImumconfused · 25/11/2022 15:42

I had an odd one with HSBC, where they blocked two transactions to buy designer clothing online (obviously knew I was too much of a middle aged frump for that!) but when we checked other recent transactions they hadn't queried one for £1400 worth of ice-cream!!! I got the mobile banking app after that.

GelatoQueen · 25/11/2022 15:38

That's shocking OP. I've had fraudulent transactions on my card more than once and on some occasions the bank has rung me suspecting fraud before i knew an attempt had been made. On all occasions the card was in my possession - once someone tried to buy a sofa in John Lewis in London for £1K and it was blocked because I don't live anywhere near london and have no spending pattern there.

Dorisbonson · 25/11/2022 15:36

Get a mobile banking app and turn on payment notifications. Every transaction gets notified on my phone. I know when my son has bought a movie on Amazon or bought something on Google play or anything else. It's very reassuring.

Suffrajitsu · 25/11/2022 15:29

I once had a similar issue back in the days when credit card slips were those things with carbon paper. When I queried the payment they sent me a copy of the counterfoil with an incredibly snotty letter saying if I still contended this was a fraud I would have to explain how come someone else had got hold of my card. But when I looked at the counterfoil, it was immediately obvious that it was neither my name nor my signature, and the number was one digit out. I sent them a snotty letter explaining that and borrowed their phraseology to say I needed their explanation as to how come they refused to acknowledge the error when it was so obvious. I never did get a reply, though they refunded the money.

SnaccidentsHappen · 25/11/2022 15:26

Amybelle88 · 25/11/2022 13:26

File a direct debit indemnity claim.

If they don't comply, escalate to the FOS.

You can only file a dd indemnity if it is a dd. In this case it is not, it is a debit card txn.

MoirasSaggyBundles · 25/11/2022 15:07

All calls are recorded. Do a subject access request and tell the bank you want a copy of the voice recording of all the calls you have made about this fraudulent transaction. This will be good evidence to show the Ombudsman that the bank is not dealing with your complaints properly.

Gastonia · 25/11/2022 14:59

Yes, that is very galling! Hope you get a refund.

bewarethetides · 25/11/2022 14:55

I hope the bank reverses course quickly, as they are completely in the wrong under your described scenario.

Shockingly poor customer service.

Elderflower14 · 25/11/2022 14:52

My Mum bought me a Bruce Springsteen ticket for my birthday/Christmas present... She gave me her card to pay... There were ten thousand in front of me... When I eventually got to pay Mum's card was refused three times and I lost my ticket... Cue floods of tears from me... I then had to go through the whole process again with my card and got my ticket.
Clearly my Mum's bank didn't think an 86 year old woman should be going to see The Boss in concert!!!