Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For asking my Ukrainian guest to get a job so they can move out?

404 replies

Erith1985 · 06/11/2022 15:58

Wondering if anyone else is going through the same thing.

I’ve been hosting a Ukrainian guest at my house for six months. I’m appalled by the war and I have a big spare room with its own bathroom and so although I normally live alone by choice, I offered up my room. The first few months were ok, they are clean and tidy and were out and about a fair amount so we didn’t get in each other’s way. We didn’t discuss length of stay when they first arrived because I didn’t want them to feel unwelcome. I figured I would bring it up when they got a job.

That hasn’t happened. They say they have been sending off their CV and getting some interviews, but they haven’t secured anything. It seems they have only been looking at jobs in their previous sector, and that they have pretty high salary expectations since they’re complaining about the 45% tax rate. In the meantime, they’ve now settled into a routine that means they are at home nearly all the time - coming down to cook three times a day and only seeming to leave the house to go to the gym or the job centre, and spend most of the time in between instagramming. It feels like the heating and / or the oven is constantly on and they aren’t very communicative so when we’re in the shared space at the same time it feels awkward.

We finally had the conversation a month or so ago to say that I would like my hosting to end at the end of November, which they accepted on the basis that they were sure they would have secured one of the jobs they were going for by then, but there’s no sign of that being the case. When I ventured that they might need to look at work that wasn’t their first choice sector, they looked at me like I was mad and said that they’d rather start her own business (!) They’ve also mentioned several times how expensive flats in our area are and how they needs the big salary they want to be able to afford it.

I’m really just at a loss for how to handle this situation - I obviously won’t be turfing them out on the streets but how do I make them see that they might have to accept work that is not their ideal and work towards it? And / or rent a room that is outside of London to be able to afford it? They have great language skills, and there’s no reason they couldn’t find work other than they aren’t willing to consider something which isn’t their “dream job” and furthering their career; I totally get wanting that, but not at the expense of being able to support yourself. I’m worried that I am now just stuck hosting as long as they want me to, and the Council have been no help (basically got a letter saying “no other hosts available and we hope you’ll help them as long as they need you”.)

Am I being unreasonable for wanting them to work harder at getting a job (any job) so that I can have my house back?

OP posts:
problemouno · 07/11/2022 12:26

Freddosforall · 07/11/2022 11:40

It's fascinating isn't it how people can be encouraged to turn against whole groups by using one or two extreme anecdotes. Not saying this one is untrue at all, but it is the way nearly all extremists operate - tell a story people can relate too, make them feel outraged and that their way of life may be under threat. Make it human and relatable - don't deal in statistics, deal in stories.

It's interesting how some people will take someone's perfectly understandable and reasonable experience and try to gag any dialogue by calling it extreme and hate baiting.
MN deals in unique, personal stories, not statistics, we're not in completely totalitarian society just yet.

Iknowforsure1 · 07/11/2022 12:22

It’s not always possible to get the same job you had in your home country. That’s why I had to give up my amazing career after I moved to the UK due to circumstances. It took me ten years to get into another field. So it is for many many people with difficult situations, so I don’t get why a person can’t temporarily do some other jobs. So do millions of people around the world to bring food to the table.

BigglyBee · 07/11/2022 12:20

I despise British exceptionalism and this attitude that foreigners should just be bloody grateful for anything. I am 100% certain that if most of you were in the same position as these refugees, you'd consider yourselves 'expats' and expect a similar lifestyle to what you had back home. That's if you could even cope at all without imploding.

I have lived abroad, and seen how many British people thought it beneath them to learn the local language, but also seen how many did(I did, but none of my family really bothered). I do menial, manual, dangerous work now, so would have no problem doing it elsewhere. I don't believe you can generalize about British people any more than about Ukrainians.

It is difficult, but I think there are two separate issues here. First, the guest has almost certainly experienced some trauma and the circumstances which brought the OP her here are awful. Secondly, her behaviour is not acceptable to the OP. She isn't rude or violent or filthy, but she is putting pressure on the OPs finances, and it has probably been much more difficult to share a house than OP expected.

I always start from the position that a lot of unreasonable behaviour stems from fear. If this woman has left everything behind, then her profession is the last part of her old life, and it's understandable, if misguided, that she is clinging to it. She is probably also afraid of moving out on her own, away from the secure place to live that OP has kindly provided.

OP, could you have one more try to talk to her and maybe offer help with finding somewhere to live (a reference from you might well help, even if she also needs financial support from elsewhere). She doesn't sound like a terrible person, and I suspect that if she can be encouraged to let go of her expectations, she will find a job which is better than she fears, and can work up from that. Realistically, this was never going to be a case of simply housing someone for a few months and then waving them off as they made their own way in a totally new country.

pixie5121 · 07/11/2022 12:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

LaGioconda · 07/11/2022 12:18

Inmyhandbag · 07/11/2022 12:16

In our small town they've been housed in two local luxury hotels.

They aren't luxury hotels, are they?

Inmyhandbag · 07/11/2022 12:16

Whaeva · 07/11/2022 11:27

Qq- why doesn't the government and people won't host the other refugees arriving from other war torn countries from Africa and middle East at homes of general UK public like for Ukraine?
Anything to do with skin colour at all!

In our small town they've been housed in two local luxury hotels.

pixie5121 · 07/11/2022 12:14

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

x2boys · 07/11/2022 12:10

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

I think your the one who lacks self awareness ,everyone would like a nice lifestyle of course they would but people need to live and feed their families ,how do you expect people to do that on zero income ?
My dh works in a ware house ,a lot of his collegyes are from eastern europe ,many are highly educated ,but they take minimum wage jobs as a means to supporting themselves untill they can find employment more suitable too their education levels

FixundFoxi · 07/11/2022 12:06

We have a ukrainian guest too. Working in an almost NMW job despite having a degree and post graduate qualifications. She's managed to save £500 pm and hopefully moving out tomorrow into a shared house. Saying that we live in the NW where rent is relatively reasonable. Back when the scheme first started I was always sceptical about how the hosts in expensive rural areas or London would cope post 6 months. I just think emotion got the better of people....
I'm a member of a facebook hosts support group. Some of the tales are shocking, others heart warming. Over the last few months some of the posters have sounded like UKIP supporters tbh and I have pretty much distanced myself from the group.
I suspect that some of the hosts saw the experience as an opportunity to 'save' someone, others to make 'lifelong friends', one talked about it being 'an adventure' so was sorely disappointed when reality turned out differently. I think people have had unrealistic expectations about the whole thing. We've kept things business like. She doesn't want to be best friends or one of the family. Certainly didn't want to come on days out with us. She made it pretty clear we were a means to an end (a refuge) and that was it.

Whaeva · 07/11/2022 11:59

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Well you can't have everything for free either! When lots of British people do lots of these "MENIAL" jobs (as you think), a job is just a way to put food on table. Everyone needs to get to grips with reality of real world where you have to work to earn money to be able to put food on the table and not expect everything will come for free irrespective of if you are a refugee or a British citizen.

Kanaloa · 07/11/2022 11:54

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

My job now involves cleaning toilets - and I’ve done worse jobs too. So yes I bloody would. Plenty of British people work ‘menial’ jobs. Would I rather work in a much better job and have a much bigger and nicer house? Well yeah! But unfortunately I need to work to eat.

My point was, a program of ‘help’ which included asking people to open their home to basically unvetted strangers from a totally different culture (who may or may not be easy to live with) was always going to be massively problematic. It wasn’t a good idea.

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/11/2022 11:53

Ladyof2022 · 07/11/2022 11:22

Why do you keep calling her "they"?

It's a Mumsnet thing. People do it even after revealing the sex of the person/child the thread is about (e.g. 'My DD won't go to school...they stay in their bedroom all day, etc').

I find it bizarre in those circumstances.

pixie5121 · 07/11/2022 11:51

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

ilukp · 07/11/2022 11:47

Give her notice again. And this time do not make it conditional on whether she has a job or not.
Unfortunately you won't be hosting her anymore after x date and she needs to move out before then.
Where she goes is not your problem.

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 07/11/2022 11:46

Set a firm date for leaving and stick to it. You've been more than fair and they are being completely ridiculous if they can't see things from your perspective. They're now taking the p out of your generosity and should be trying to help themselves with realistic ambitions

ganachee · 07/11/2022 11:41

Freddosforall · 07/11/2022 11:40

It's fascinating isn't it how people can be encouraged to turn against whole groups by using one or two extreme anecdotes. Not saying this one is untrue at all, but it is the way nearly all extremists operate - tell a story people can relate too, make them feel outraged and that their way of life may be under threat. Make it human and relatable - don't deal in statistics, deal in stories.

Indeed.

ganachee · 07/11/2022 11:40

ProFannyTea · 06/11/2022 18:07

This does seem a recurring theme. Either work shy or completely unrealistic.

Or those who are having problems share it whilst we don’t know the number where the placement has gone well. It could be many more.

Freddosforall · 07/11/2022 11:40

Tukmgru · 06/11/2022 17:37

These replies have been really helpful, now we know which ways we can gently nudge the brits into hating Ukrainians without sounding like complete dicks. Everyone is so earnest and caring except that they aren’t - we enjoy the repeated use of ‘beggars can’t be choosers throughout’ by largely well off people in the Uk (I.e Mumsnet) when referring to people who are fleeing invasion - we‘ll start using that.

Love, the Kremlin

It's fascinating isn't it how people can be encouraged to turn against whole groups by using one or two extreme anecdotes. Not saying this one is untrue at all, but it is the way nearly all extremists operate - tell a story people can relate too, make them feel outraged and that their way of life may be under threat. Make it human and relatable - don't deal in statistics, deal in stories.

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 07/11/2022 11:29

Whaeva · 07/11/2022 11:27

Qq- why doesn't the government and people won't host the other refugees arriving from other war torn countries from Africa and middle East at homes of general UK public like for Ukraine?
Anything to do with skin colour at all!

🙄

Whaeva · 07/11/2022 11:27

Qq- why doesn't the government and people won't host the other refugees arriving from other war torn countries from Africa and middle East at homes of general UK public like for Ukraine?
Anything to do with skin colour at all!

Ladyof2022 · 07/11/2022 11:22

Why do you keep calling her "they"?

problemouno · 07/11/2022 11:19

Catslovepies · 07/11/2022 11:07

I have been hosting successfully since May - a mum who started working almost immediately and her two well behaved animal-loving children, ages 7 and 12. All is going great and they're no trouble.I just wanted to mention this as I get annoyed by the "I told you so" posters who claim incredible psychic powers that things were never going to work out based on a few isolated incidences that people post about on here.

OP in your position I'd give a move-out date and stick with it, informing the council who have a duty to take it from there.

It's lovely @Catslovepies it sounds like yours is the situation that most hosts were envisaging and hoping for.

pewtypie · 07/11/2022 11:18

You need to make clear that the November deadline is still in place. She needs to move out.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 07/11/2022 11:16

Erith1985 · 07/11/2022 11:13

Just to be clear I didn’t say my guest was “dirty, lazy, noisy” - quite the opposite! My guest is quiet, clean, courteous, and never leaves mess or fails to clean up after themselves.

A guest can be quiet, clean and courteous.

They can also take the piss especially once they've stayed for a while, with using heating etc and thinking the property is more theirs than the owners.

This woman needs to get a job ASAP, you are not her gravy train OP.

Kanaloa · 07/11/2022 11:14

Catslovepies · 07/11/2022 11:07

I have been hosting successfully since May - a mum who started working almost immediately and her two well behaved animal-loving children, ages 7 and 12. All is going great and they're no trouble.I just wanted to mention this as I get annoyed by the "I told you so" posters who claim incredible psychic powers that things were never going to work out based on a few isolated incidences that people post about on here.

OP in your position I'd give a move-out date and stick with it, informing the council who have a duty to take it from there.

I think this is the thing though - imagine sending a random selection of British people over to another country. You’d get some people like this, and some advantage taking arseholes. Just because you’re fleeing war doesn’t mean you can’t be selfish and taking advantage. If you were a dick before you’ll be a dick afterwards too.

And that’s where the ‘I told you so’ came from. Nobody was saying ‘Ukrainians are bad, don’t help them!’ They were saying ‘a program encouraging people to open their homes indefinitely to random people, some of whom will likely not be very nice to live with, with no real financial or practical support, isn’t a great idea and will result in problems for many.’

Swipe left for the next trending thread