Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is absolutely pathetic?

213 replies

VertAmon · 06/11/2022 14:52

Genuinely not sure if I am being unreasonable thinking this.

My family are big on family holidays, we go away often as a large group and also more immediate family too.

DD was born during COVID so hasn’t had a holiday yet at all, as I’ve been cautious about starting to travel again even after things opened up.

There is a resort in Spain that my mum and dad took me and my siblings to most years, we also went as a wider family (so grandparents, cousins etc.) and it’s recently been reopened after a long closure for a 4-5 year refit.

I met up with mum yesterday and mentioned I was interested in maybe going next summer with DH and DD and would her and her husband, his kids and grandkids etc. be interested in joining us, flights are cheap and the resort is reasonable too. Immediately her face lit up and said they’d love to, it will be nice to start new traditions at the same place with DD.

4 hours later I got a call from mum who said she had been thinking about it and would prefer to go somewhere else as she wants to go to another country next year. This was odd so I pushed and it turns out her husband is refusing to go, as he ‘doesn’t want to go anywhere that mum and my dad used to go together’

this isn’t the first time he has been weird like this about something similar, but AIBU in thinking this is absolutely pathetic, and even a little bit controlling?

OP posts:
APollforTuesday · 08/11/2022 13:18

MummyJ36 · 08/11/2022 13:13

He wants to go somewhere else because it was somewhere she went on holiday with her ex husband and family. I’d say that’s a big red flag of insecurity from a man who I’m imagining must be at least 50+ if not 60+. It’s not like her mum is going to start reminiscing about all the sex she had with her ex husband whilst they’re there? And if they reminisce about previous family holidays then I think that goes with the territory of being with a woman who has children and has lived a life before knowing you. By not visiting this destination it’s not going to change the fact that she was married to someone else and had a life before she knew him. Why not make new memories with him in this clearly much loved destination? Surely that’s better than shrouding it in negative emotions.

I'd say you have little experience of second marriages. It's NEVER about sex (you keep mentioning sex in your posts) and a lot more about a million other reasons why you wouldn't want to go to a holiday destination that your spouse shared with their former spouse.

RealBecca · 08/11/2022 13:15

They broke up 15 years ago so he is being silly. But I'd look at the bigger picture. Clearly mum wont go so she doesnt rock the boat which is isolating for her. And she wont feel able to speak up to you again if she has been put in a hard place.

I dont know what the answer is but I'd look at whether it is better to be seen to "give in" to him or keep mum in the family circle.

You said he is an arse in other ways. How did that play out? Is she generally more withdrawn since meeting him?

MummyJ36 · 08/11/2022 13:13

APollforTuesday · 08/11/2022 13:08

But he's not denying her a holiday, he's just saying he wants to go somewhere else.

He wants to go somewhere else because it was somewhere she went on holiday with her ex husband and family. I’d say that’s a big red flag of insecurity from a man who I’m imagining must be at least 50+ if not 60+. It’s not like her mum is going to start reminiscing about all the sex she had with her ex husband whilst they’re there? And if they reminisce about previous family holidays then I think that goes with the territory of being with a woman who has children and has lived a life before knowing you. By not visiting this destination it’s not going to change the fact that she was married to someone else and had a life before she knew him. Why not make new memories with him in this clearly much loved destination? Surely that’s better than shrouding it in negative emotions.

clpsmum · 08/11/2022 13:10

I can see his point tbh. He doesn't have to go and tbh your mum can still join you or you can go alone or you can go where they want to go.

APollforTuesday · 08/11/2022 13:08

MummyJ36 · 08/11/2022 13:07

For everyone defending him….your parents are divorced. It’s totally unreasonable and childish to deny your wife a family holiday because she went there with her ex husband (who is also the father of her children!). I’ve known someone like this and believe me, it won’t just be this that he’s being childish over. If a woman has children with another man, shock horror, she will have lived a life with him and had sex with him and gone on holiday with him! You’d think a grown man, who no doubt had previous relationships of his own, would be a bit more adult about all of this.

But he's not denying her a holiday, he's just saying he wants to go somewhere else.

MummyJ36 · 08/11/2022 13:07

For everyone defending him….your parents are divorced. It’s totally unreasonable and childish to deny your wife a family holiday because she went there with her ex husband (who is also the father of her children!). I’ve known someone like this and believe me, it won’t just be this that he’s being childish over. If a woman has children with another man, shock horror, she will have lived a life with him and had sex with him and gone on holiday with him! You’d think a grown man, who no doubt had previous relationships of his own, would be a bit more adult about all of this.

APollforTuesday · 08/11/2022 12:51

I wouldn't like it either.

Bookworm20 · 08/11/2022 12:45

If it was just a place you'd been to once as a family when you were a kid which you just remembered liking, then thats one thing.

But I compltely understand how a new partner would not want to holiday at a resort where frequent previous family holidays took place. It is absolutely a trip down memory lane for you and your mother and siblings OP. Thats why you have chosen it. Because you have such fond memories of it as a child. And you've even mentioned looking forward to visit the restaurant you 'always ate at'.
Thats fine for you, and lovely you have those memories and want your dd to have the same.

His saying he isn't comfortable with it though and your mum realising this and asking if you can go to another resort is not in the least bit unreasonable. You don't have to change your plans, just go without them. But I think its a bit rubbish of you not even trying to consider and understand their view on this, and calling your dms partner pathetic, when its been blatently pointed out to you the reason why.

If this holiday resort means so much to you, that you won't consider looking elsewhere to go as a group, then simply go there without them.

The fact is IS so important, kind of proves the guys point.

Glera · 08/11/2022 12:34

ShinyMe · 06/11/2022 14:58

I think if I was a second spouse, I wouldn't want to go on holiday to somewhere that my spouse and family used to go to regularly with my predecessor.

I second this. Perhaps the new husband doesn't want to be seen as overwriting previous memories and instead wants to create new ones.

AryaStarkWolf · 08/11/2022 12:26

Meh, maybe a little but it's something he's uncomfortable so your mother is respecting that 💁is it that big of a deal to pick another resort? There's so many to choose from?

Tessabelle74 · 08/11/2022 12:20

Personally I wouldn't want to revisit all the haunts my husband and his ex went to either. Please don't make your Mum piggy in the middle, you go with your husband to the old resort and try somewhere new with your Mum

Knanks · 08/11/2022 11:57

I agree with these that it sounds like you don't like the guy anyway and are looking for further reasons to vilify him. It clearly looks like you're just posting to confirm your beliefs about the bloke and not get genuine perspective on what's going on.

As a second wife, I understand where he's coming from. I wouldn't want to go somewhere my husband had likely shagged his ex many, many times. Just because you were there as a family doesn't mean they didn't have "romantic" times there. The thought of that sounds a bit eww to me.

Have your holiday where you want, but you may want to keep in mind that your mum clearly cares about him and his feelings, so by acting this way towards him you may be pushing her away as well. I know if I was in her situation I'd definitely not want to go on holiday somewhere once I found out it would potentially cause emotional anguish to my husband. You would come off as a bit callous to me.

SwingByLater · 08/11/2022 11:53

I’m actually in your stepdad’s position here - my DP and his ex wife have a place where they’d visit every year for their holidays and even considered relocating to at one point.

I absolutely do not want to trip down memory lane with him, have no desire to hear about how ‘we went here, did this, did that’ and see no value in trying to recreate or ‘compete’ against memories of their times there together - so I wouldn’t go.

Wouldn’t stop him from going without me, of course, but would rather not have the ghost of relationship past on our precious holidays together 🤷🏼‍♀️

Youdoyoutoday · 08/11/2022 11:46

To be fair, I can see his point. The new spouse doesnt fancy a trip down memory lane with all 'do you remember that time before when......' constantly bringing memories of your mum and dad.

Turn this thread in to 'DH wants to take me to the same holiday resort that he went to every year for 10 years with his ex-wife but I don't like the idea' everyone would say you're not being unreasonable.

Stoptheworld1000 · 08/11/2022 11:39

I can see his point. I wouldn't want to go on holiday with my partner and hear them talk about old times with their ex. I don't think he's being unreasonable. He's not saying no he's saying not there. I think you need to decide if it's the place that's more important or who you are with.

Algor1thm · 08/11/2022 11:16

AnneElliott · 07/11/2022 20:54

I get it if it's the same resort/ hotel. I know someone who has taken both wives and at least 3 partners to the same hotel in Spain. I always wonder what the hotel owners think when he turns up with the latest one!

Could you not do a different resort in the same area?

Ugh my dad has done this with at least two wives. I find it so bizarre. I wonder if the second even knows the first went there with him too. Either way it's so odd.

I find it bizarre that the OP and others can't see how bloody awful this holiday would be for the new husband. Also for her actual dad! I'd be mortified to think of my children as adults going back to reminisce at places that we made memories as a family, with my husband and a new wife and the wife's kids and grandkids, while I sat at home.

SeasonFinale · 08/11/2022 07:38

I also think your mum got caught up in the excitement of a family holiday and didn't really think it through when saying it sounded great.

If you really want a family holiday go elsewhere. If you really want that location go there as a smaller unit.

SeasonFinale · 08/11/2022 07:36

I don't understand how "his" whole family were coming and outnumbering yours when he has said no from the outset. Are his kids and families coming?

If the original plan was you and your DH and Dd were going why does it matter if noone else is now?

DooLallyy · 08/11/2022 07:26

I can see his point, I wouldn't want to go on holiday to somewhere DH had been with his exW, maybe to the same resort but not the same hotel, it's just weird. Luckily they didn't go on many holidays together.
Holidays are expensive so why would he want to spend thousands of £'s going somewhere he doesn't want to go to? His feelings are valid, even if you don't agree with them.

If you want to go then but it for you, DH & DC. If you want to go away as a group then you decide on a destination you all want to go to.

TikNeres · 07/11/2022 21:56

It's not really that he doesn't fancy it - that part is understandable I guess.

The problem is that he's told his wife that she can't go, because he doesn't want to, and it wouldn't be fair on him.

That's the petulant whiny arse bit, and the bit that matters.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 07/11/2022 21:56

Hollypups · 07/11/2022 20:53

The way she talks about him I think she may well of chose a place she knew he would kick up about, just to make him look bad and petty. Its pretty obvious she isn’t keen on him.

Well yeah she's more or less said that she isn't keen on him. Still doesn't mean she needs to plan her holidays around where he'd like to go

Fudgemonkeys · 07/11/2022 21:49

As a step parent I can see it grom his point of view. The family would spend a lot of time mentioning the things they did with your dad so I can understand why your mum would rather not. Yes she could go without him but she may not want to or indeed be able to afford it.

NoDatingForOldMen · 07/11/2022 21:07

RFPO77 · 07/11/2022 20:50

I understand where he's coming from Tbh. You might want to make new memories but if it's a special family holiday location from your childhood you're likely to spend a lot of time reminiscing about old times. Great for you and your mum but tedious for everyone else. Either go there just your immediate family or go with the wider family somewhere else.

Absolutely this ^ will be terrible for him to be to be in company with others who have all the same memory set, I can completely get his point.

AnneElliott · 07/11/2022 20:54

I get it if it's the same resort/ hotel. I know someone who has taken both wives and at least 3 partners to the same hotel in Spain. I always wonder what the hotel owners think when he turns up with the latest one!

Could you not do a different resort in the same area?

Hollypups · 07/11/2022 20:53

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 07/11/2022 20:40

For those who haven't read the thread or just don't understand:

  1. OP, her DH and their DC are going on holiday to a place OP has been many times in the past with her parents
  2. OP mentioned this to her mum and asked if they would like to come.
  3. Mum liked the idea but later said she can't come because her husband won't go AND won't let her

Now, why should OP change her holiday plans? It's like saying "oh, me and DH are going to this restaurant on Friday, want to come?" "No, let's go here instead".

So OP YANBU to want to go. He is NBU to not want to go. YABU if you specifically chose this place to try and make him uncomfortable (which I don't think you have) and HIBU if he is preventing your mum from going.

The way she talks about him I think she may well of chose a place she knew he would kick up about, just to make him look bad and petty. Its pretty obvious she isn’t keen on him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread