Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD has a very possessive unhealthy friendship with girl at school

62 replies

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:06

DD6 has in recent months made friends with another girl in her class who has unfortunately become extremely possessive of her - she initially would cry and make a fuss if DD played with another child, and would pressure DD to make promises to play with her instead. This has now progressed to forbidding DD to play with others and physically taking her by the arm and pulling her away from other children. DD has said how she is upset at not being allowed to play with other friends, and how she tries to tell this girl she would like to play with others but the girl basically harasses her into submission by literally following her around the playground and whining until she gives in. DD has suggested they all play together and the girl refuses and says she only wants DD to play with her (sounds reasonable!)
I have broached this with DD’s teachers who haven’t taken it seriously at all. Do i approach this girls parents? I have never actually met them but I have their contact details from the class WhatsApp group. Meanwhile how do I support DD? I have reiterated over and over again how she is allowed to play with whoever she wants and I have had a couple of other friends from her class round to our house to play during half term. Would really appreciate advice from anyone who has been in a similar position with their child! Thanks!

OP posts:
DWMoosmum · 06/11/2022 19:49

This child might only be young but this is narcissistic behaviour and will not improve. Yes, girls fall out and remake friends all the time but this sounds a bit full on.

Encourage your DD to make other friends and encourage those friendships as much as you can.

daffodilandtulip · 06/11/2022 19:48

I've had this recently with a high school child. The home link person spoke to the child and his parents for me.

SimplyTheBus · 06/11/2022 19:40

I've had this with DD (who is now 10) who was refusing to go to school over it. We had success with explaining to DD (yours might be too young?) that a real friend wouldn't make you so unhappy etc.
Used the example of the friend who she want to play with not kicking up a stink because possessive child (PC) demanded DD play with her.

Gave her a few lines to say, "No, I'm playing with A today. We're playing this if you want to join in" so it's PC's choice not to join in and DD couldn't be accused of excluding her. Explaining she couldn't say "I don't want to play with you" or "you're not allowed to play with us" etc. Assuring DD that if PC went crying to the teacher, I'd have her back.

Definitely agree with inviting some other girls over one by one for a few weeks so she can cement some other friendships.

I also spoke to DD's friends mum and explained what was happening in case friend was upset DD was always playing with PC.

redflowerbluethorns · 06/11/2022 19:28

Push harder with school, don't go to her parents. The school should be involving her parents.

If you've got nowhere with teachers, go to the head.

Hunkyd0ry · 06/11/2022 19:25

I’m currently going through the exact same thing with my DD who is 6 too.

it’s hard as she loves playing with the friend and they have fun together but it’s not working in a group situation. The friend gets my DD alone or tells her that other people aren’t fun to play with.

the teacher told us they are aware of it and they are encouraging other friendships.

we’ve told DD that if friend does something she doesn’t like, then she just needs to say no and walk off. If friend follows then tell an adult.

its so hard though as they are so young and don’t have the social skills developed yet

id say in your situation the teacher needs to do more!

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/11/2022 18:59

You have to be a very squeaky wheel to make the message get through. This is probably happening at break or lunchtime when the playground is either being supervised by a couple of teachers/TAs from other classes who have their minds on other things they could be doing, or lunchtime supervisors. They may have no idea that there is a problem. I’d email the head and the teacher if you can, outline the issues clearly and insist that it is brought to the attention of all the playground staff because your daughter needs their support.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/11/2022 18:49

Will the school in your experience inform this girls parents of her behaviour?

They might do, but not in the sense you possibly mean, where they characterise the other girl as domineering and aggressive and "wrong", by contrast with your daughter, the victim, whose behaviour does not contribute to the dynamic.

They might suggest to the other parents that their daughter lacks confidence to play with a range of children, and this is making her cling to preferred friends, and exclude others, and let the parents know the staff are encouraging her to widen her friendship group.

I think you need to remember this other little girl is six too - she is not some skilled manipulator. She is struggling with social interactions, just as your six year old daughter is.

NightFright · 06/11/2022 17:14

and a huge NO to approaching the other parents.

If you do, you will forever look back and wince!

NightFright · 06/11/2022 17:01

Also, please don’t forget, your DD is 6.

At this age I’m really surprised at the amount of detail your DD remembers about this friend, and that you’re taking everything she tells you as gospel.

Agree with pp, the teacher will most probably see an entirely different picture than what you imagine.

Endwalker · 06/11/2022 16:54

ThingsIhavelearnt · 06/11/2022 16:30

Safeguarding issue

emotional peer on peer abuse report it for what it is

How to make sure you're a joke in the staff room....

They're six years old. It's a social-emotional issue not abuse FFS.

I agree with what @Barbie222 has posted and this matches my own experiences at school, we really do see a different side to DC than the one their parents see.

Raise it again with the teacher but from the POV of supporting your DD to be more confident/assertive in saying no. Ask if whoever is on playground duty and the lunchtime staff can be made aware so that they can check in with both girls and redirected as needed.

NightFright · 06/11/2022 16:48

Emotional peer on peer abuse!? Really? They’re 6, not 16 ffs!

Rhondaa · 06/11/2022 16:42

ThingsIhavelearnt · 06/11/2022 16:30

Safeguarding issue

emotional peer on peer abuse report it for what it is

I wouldn’t say it was a safeguarding issue by any stretch of the imagination, nor would I call it emotional abuse. It is 6yr olds learning how to play and develop their social skills. The op has told the staff about it, I'm sure they'll be keeping an eye.

Swonderful · 06/11/2022 16:35

We had similar with my daughter, although she was slightly older. I encouraged her to break off the friendship. It was really tough for a few months but she was a lot happier when she managed to break away and play with a new group.

ThingsIhavelearnt · 06/11/2022 16:30

liveforsummer · 06/11/2022 14:26

Speak to the head teacher then. Explain you've told dd to approach the teacher but she's too shy. Let her know you've approached the teacher twice and nothing has changed

Safeguarding issue

emotional peer on peer abuse report it for what it is

sittinghere · 06/11/2022 16:26

I think I was the Mum of the other girl in this situation, although I didn't realise it at the time as it was never raised by teachers or TAs. I think that it some cases, it does make sense to talk to the parent of the other child, maybe via the school.

My daughter was extremely shy through primary school (she's 15 now) and struggled with friendship dynamics. I think she sometimes ended up seeming possessive over children who did play with her, and she worried that another child was no longer her friend if they played with other people.

I only realised when she was about to go to secondary. While still in year 6, she and her best friend found out they would be in the same class, and both girls seemed really happy and enjoyed the transition day together. A few days later, the other girl told my daughter that her parents had moved her to a different class as they felt my daughter was too possessive. In this case, I wish I could have had a heads up from the other parent rather than hearing that there was a problem from my very distressed daughter. I do understand why they moved their daughter to a different class, but wish it had been done in way that didn't hurt my daughter quite as much.

soupmaker · 06/11/2022 16:25

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 15:23

Thankyou for your replies, yes I have arranged for DD to have friends over to our house during half term and we role play on a daily basis how to say no to this girl/remind her she must tell a teacher if she’s unhappy with something - nothing has improved things. I am so worried about DD having such a compliant nature, and furious at this girl’s behaviour and that the school don’t appear to have done anything to help.

I've been there, so I get you're upset. But being furious with the girl in question isn't going to help. They're 6 for goodness sake. Nor is being angry at the school - they may be doing things you're not aware of - you need to have another measured discussion with them.

The bit of this you have some control of is supporting your own DD in being more resilient and able to navigate friendships. It's hard at 6, they are all just learning.

Take a deep breath. You're doing all the right things by arranging play dates and supporting your DD.

Rhondaa · 06/11/2022 16:25

'I am so worried about DD having such a compliant nature, and furious at this girl’s behaviour and that the school don’t appear to have done anything to help.'

It may be because they see it every single day and know it isn't anything to worry about. 6yr olds are notorious for this, possessiveness one day then a different bff the next. The staff will be experienced enough to intervene if boundaries are crossed and any unpleasant behaviour starts. Just carry on encouraging your dd and supporting her.

I know how you feel, we had similar when one of ours was that age. I too wanted it sorting but honestly it'll blow over and as I say the staff will intervene if they see issues in the playground.

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 15:55

DD is a friendly girl who has historically made friends easily. She is too eager to please and uncomfortable asserting herself which we are aware of and trying our best to help her with. This obviously makes her an easy target for a domineering child. I think she initially played with the other girl happily as she would with any child, not because they share any particular special friendship, but the other girl quickly became possessive and has been allowed to become more and more aggressive in her dominating of DD. I am really upset, as well as angry. Will the school in your experience inform this girls parents of her behaviour? I’m hoping if aware they would encourage alternative friendships for her and tell her to leave DD alone

OP posts:
Barbie222 · 06/11/2022 15:46

Just to give another perspective on this. I saw a lot of this scenario as a Y1 teacher:

50% of the time the girls appear to be playing happily together.

25% of the time A doesn't want to play with B.

25% of the time B doesn't want to play with A.

Parents hear about one or other of the 25%s and assume this is 100% of the story, because children don't report on the good.

Teachers are confused as they are hearing the same story from both parents yet the children appear to be happy together so much of the time.

The situation usually arises because one child is ready to move on developmentally and play more complex group games, and the other isn't. This happens gradually, so at first the more mature child still enjoys the old games and so you see the happy 50% of the time. This becomes harder to keep up with though and inevitable the gap widens and becomes frustrating for both.

I'm not saying at all this is what's happening here but a lot of Y1 is shot through with some children maturing out of their friendships faster than others, and this can be upsetting and hard to handle for the child who can't understand why their old friend is rejecting them.

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 15:23

Thankyou for your replies, yes I have arranged for DD to have friends over to our house during half term and we role play on a daily basis how to say no to this girl/remind her she must tell a teacher if she’s unhappy with something - nothing has improved things. I am so worried about DD having such a compliant nature, and furious at this girl’s behaviour and that the school don’t appear to have done anything to help.

OP posts:
Rhondaa · 06/11/2022 15:18

This is typical primary behaviour as they all learn social skills etc.
Never approach the parents, they of course will have heard their dd's version of events anyway.
All you can do is carry on reassuring your dd to ask TAs to help if she's struggling. Maybe have a friend or 2 over to play at your house and have tea to help her develop other friendships.

liveforsummer · 06/11/2022 15:18

The problem is that if your dd appears to be happily playing with the other girl, then asking them to keep her away from your child is a bit much.

Yes we frequently get this too where a parent will say this then the dc chooses to actually play with the child that the parent wants kept away from them. Just needs some close supervision and for staff to timed the dc to come and say if there is a problem

soupmaker · 06/11/2022 15:12

We had this with DD1 when she was 6. Teachers helped by moving the kids about in class and ensuring TAs kept an eye in the playground. I also had to coach DD into saying No and asking the girl to play in a group. The inevitable happened, girl complained DD wouldn't play with her but thankfully TAs dealt with it really well. I also did play dates with other friends as well as the girl in question a couple of times. DD1 actually really liked her, but didn't want to play with her on her own.

Anyway, they are all teenagers now, have done primary school and go to different secondary schools. I often bump into the mum of the girl and she complains about her being anti-social and never wanting to do things with friends. So sad.

MrJi · 06/11/2022 14:51

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:44

i have informed her teacher, and quoted the school bullying policy but yet to hear back (this was last week). If they continue to be ineffective and things don’t improve, what is my next step? Complain to the board of governors? Also realistically what will the teachers actually do in this situation - is it unrealistic to say I want this girl kept away from DD? (It is a small school). This is my first experience of anything like this and guidance would be appreciated! Thanks

The problem is that if your dd appears to be happily playing with the other girl, then asking them to keep her away from your child is a bit much.
Better to ask them to encourage more communal play, and for whoever supervises at playtime to ensure that your dd isn’t being monopolised.
Your dd needs to say a firm and loud NO, so practise this at home, and tell her to walk away and go to a teacher if she feels harassed. Her going along with what the other girl wants will just perpetuate the behaviour.

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 06/11/2022 14:50

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:44

i have informed her teacher, and quoted the school bullying policy but yet to hear back (this was last week). If they continue to be ineffective and things don’t improve, what is my next step? Complain to the board of governors? Also realistically what will the teachers actually do in this situation - is it unrealistic to say I want this girl kept away from DD? (It is a small school). This is my first experience of anything like this and guidance would be appreciated! Thanks

You need to call school office and say it’s important you speak to the headteacher. Then tell the HT exactly what’s happened. Tell her you want communication about what is happening at lunch and break. Explain to them that DD doesn’t want to play with X but is too shy/timid to say no. And explain X doesn’t allow DD to play with others.

Once HT speaks to Teacher then hopefully action will be taken. Say you want update in a couple of days.

I know in my school - TAs have to physically keep an eye on kids involved and log everything so it’s shown to parents. We even ask children how they are feeling every break/lunch to monitor situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread