Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD has a very possessive unhealthy friendship with girl at school

62 replies

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:06

DD6 has in recent months made friends with another girl in her class who has unfortunately become extremely possessive of her - she initially would cry and make a fuss if DD played with another child, and would pressure DD to make promises to play with her instead. This has now progressed to forbidding DD to play with others and physically taking her by the arm and pulling her away from other children. DD has said how she is upset at not being allowed to play with other friends, and how she tries to tell this girl she would like to play with others but the girl basically harasses her into submission by literally following her around the playground and whining until she gives in. DD has suggested they all play together and the girl refuses and says she only wants DD to play with her (sounds reasonable!)
I have broached this with DD’s teachers who haven’t taken it seriously at all. Do i approach this girls parents? I have never actually met them but I have their contact details from the class WhatsApp group. Meanwhile how do I support DD? I have reiterated over and over again how she is allowed to play with whoever she wants and I have had a couple of other friends from her class round to our house to play during half term. Would really appreciate advice from anyone who has been in a similar position with their child! Thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FannyPhart · 28/03/2023 09:56

This thread was last November so it probably isn't very relevant anymore as OP hasn't returned.

waterrat · 28/03/2023 09:54

Op my daughter can be quite like the posessive child in this situation.

She has now been diagnoses as autistic and I recognise that as an autistic trait - she can't do group play because of sensory issues etc so tended to try and find a child who would be happy to just be with her but it could seem bossy.

As several teachers have come on here to say - this is really normal child behaviour.

The reason we send 6 year olds off to play together in groups at school/ park etc is so they can learn this stuff! Part of this is for your child to learn herself - with some support from adults of course.

Being furious with another six year old is just odd OP you need to remember that is also someones precious child who is learning how to be a normal human through play and socialising.

Go back to school and say you are feeling you aren't being listened to and see what the lunchtime TAs can tell you - it may be more two sided than you are hearing.

My 8 year old tells me all sorts of stuff from the playground that is very one sided.

Cinnamon23 · 28/03/2023 09:50

Your DD sounds very kind to want to take this girl’s feelings into consideration, but learning to say NO and accepting that sometimes that may upset someone else is a valuable lesson. She is entitled to her boundaries and this girl is trampling all over them!

I’d also make a complaint about the teacher doing sweet FA.

Nanny0gg · 27/03/2023 22:51

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:06

DD6 has in recent months made friends with another girl in her class who has unfortunately become extremely possessive of her - she initially would cry and make a fuss if DD played with another child, and would pressure DD to make promises to play with her instead. This has now progressed to forbidding DD to play with others and physically taking her by the arm and pulling her away from other children. DD has said how she is upset at not being allowed to play with other friends, and how she tries to tell this girl she would like to play with others but the girl basically harasses her into submission by literally following her around the playground and whining until she gives in. DD has suggested they all play together and the girl refuses and says she only wants DD to play with her (sounds reasonable!)
I have broached this with DD’s teachers who haven’t taken it seriously at all. Do i approach this girls parents? I have never actually met them but I have their contact details from the class WhatsApp group. Meanwhile how do I support DD? I have reiterated over and over again how she is allowed to play with whoever she wants and I have had a couple of other friends from her class round to our house to play during half term. Would really appreciate advice from anyone who has been in a similar position with their child! Thanks!

If the teachers aren't taking it seriously talk to the HT

No, don't talk to the parents. They're not in the playground

neilyoungismyhero · 27/03/2023 22:51

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 14:45

As in how do I “MAKE them listen”???

Personally I would be going into the school and making a fuss until something was done.

SchoolTripDrama · 27/03/2023 22:48

ButterfliesnWaterfalls · 06/11/2022 14:09

We have this on the playground a lot. As I’m on duty every day, I always ask the child who is being forced what they want to do - and they go off and play with whoever they want. Then I ask the child who is doing the forcing to try playing with different children or play on the monkey bars etc.

To be honest, the TAs are the ones who will probably be the ones who see them most at play times. Tell the teacher you’re concerned and if they can give you feedback regarding their child at playtime/lunch time. Speak to Headteacher if teacher isn’t taking it seriously.

Well that’s not the way to handle it! Bloody hell. At no point in that example did you explain to the child doing the forcing that this behaviour is not kind/not acceptable……!
Wow

Hankunamatata · 06/11/2022 21:30

I find some online resources about what makes a good friend and how they should make you feel? Id also start role playing situations with dd to give her the confidence not to be pulled away from the group. Self-empowerment is a big thing here - teach dd to be her own person and that she is worthy of people who treat her with respect and respect her wishes when she says no or wants to change domineering girls plans.

Nevermind91 · 06/11/2022 20:50

A very similar thing is going on with our DD, age 12. Her friend of a few years has become increasingly dependent on our daughter.
She asked to move classes at the start of the year, just to get some respite. She immediately became so much happier and enthused about school...until a few weeks later the friend was moved to her new class! It is now an ongoing battle between us, our DD, the other girl and her parents and the school.
It's such an important age with physical and emotional changes to contend with, and this just makes it so much harder.
I hope your DD's situation is resolved quickly. It sounds like you are doing all the right things- I just hope those you have spoken to actually sit up and take notice.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 20:50

Op I had an extremely similar situation, in my case on one level they got on but it was definitely toxic and I don't know why they couldn't get this.

They couldn't understand that toxic, control element.

It was awful to the point where we nearly left the school.

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 06/11/2022 20:41

I had a friend like this at school and it was horrific. It gave me such a warped idea about what friendship is and it has affected me my whole life. No-one cared then because it was the early 90s. However, please seek some help from school - they may not be fully aware of this dynamic but would want to help for both girls' sakes. Good luck, I hope it's sorted too.

Oblomov22 · 06/11/2022 20:35

"Speak to the head teacher then. Explain you've told dd to approach the teacher but she's too shy. Let her know you've approached the teacher twice and nothing has changed."

Email Head. Then Your'll have it in writing, thus a paper trail.

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 20:32

I did actually say a few weeks ago to DD if she feels unable to say to this girl “no” then to blame it on me, say my mum says we’re not allowed to play because you don’t listen to me when I say no Thankyou to things. The girls response was that’s ok we won’t tell your mum.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/11/2022 20:26

Tell her to say her mom said she is not allowed to play with Dfriend anymore.

It'll take the pressure off her.

If the little girl is hurt, she'll learn how she cannot control friends.

Speak to the teacher.

My DS had to be taught that he cannot control other DC.

It was tough but necessary.

He isn't perfect yet but understands personal space a bit better.

Barbie222 · 06/11/2022 20:22

If there's physical pulling away from children going on that's probably the best place for the teacher to start, as the message 'no pulling' is easier for immature children to understand than 'don't talk to X or interrupt X if she is already playing with Y and Z. Also easier to spot / report on and unambiguous. If the other friend did not touch your DD presumably the whole group would be able to move away and play?

I hope it gets sorted and do understand how this can be difficult on both sides. Just trying to say that it's not always easy to have a full sense of what the playtimes look like, and how children will readily absorb an adults interpretation of the situation.

Oriunda · 06/11/2022 20:18

I had this when my child was little. A friend started at their primary school and became very possessive. In the end, I spoke to the teacher and asked that they be kept apart in class, and an eye kept on them at lunchtimes. I also stressed to my child that they could play with anyone they wanted.

I also instigated a series of play dates with other children after school. While it might feel a bit mean for the possessive child to see your DD going off after school with others, it will help reinforce the point that she has other friends. It will also highlight to the other child’s parent that the child needs help broadening her social circle.

In our case, it worked. The possessive child found another friend, remained friends with my child but not as close.

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 20:11

@Barbie222 The girls were talking about a game they have always played together and literally unprompted said “but we don’t get to play 123 any more because Child 123 doesn’t let you play with anyone but her!” They then said “you shouldn’t let her pull you away if you talk to other people, that’s not kind”
there isn’t a narrative being imposed, it’s actually happening

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/11/2022 20:10

If there wasn't already a narrative among the girls that the other girl is wholly to blame in this situation and needs to be avoided, there certainly will be now.

I agree. I wouldn't have been encouraging this at all.

Barbie222 · 06/11/2022 20:06

That sounds like an odd conversation the children had during the play date. How did you manage that conversation about a child who wasn't present tactfully OP? If there wasn't already a narrative among the girls that the other girl is wholly to blame in this situation and needs to be avoided, there certainly will be now.

Boofay · 06/11/2022 20:05

As others have mentioned, this is possibly a social skills thing. My daughter was the other girl in this situation. She had a best friend she didn't want to share. It got to a head and the friend broke away from my daughter, utterly breaking her heart. I wish that someone had spoken to me about the situation before it got too much for the other girl so I could have coached my daughter through the situation. She loved her friend to bits and only wanted to spend time with her but the other girl was a sociable and lovely girl who wanted to play with lots of people. It got so much for her that she just didn't want to be my daughter's friend anymore.
Years later and we're exploring an ASD diagnosis for my daughter. She's an amazing young lady (nearly 18) but definitely struggles with social skills, amongst other things.
If I was the other girl's parents I think I'd want to know about it but maybe it's best that it's dealt with through the school.

Mischance · 06/11/2022 20:04

There will be a complaints policy on the school website - follow that.

TakeAShowerTakeAShower · 06/11/2022 20:01

Hi, thanks for your replies. When DD had friends from school come to our house during half term the other girls openly spoke about this girl stopping them playing with her. They described how she follows DD around the playground and won’t give up until DD stops what she’s doing and plays with her and how she has literally frogmarched DD off away from them.
DD needs to get much better at making a fuss. She is very much one for masking her feelings publicly (out of fear of embarrassment I think) but will say at home how she is unhappy at so and so’s behaviour.

OP posts:
donttellmehesalive · 06/11/2022 19:57

Are you certain events unfold exactly as your dd reports?

I only ask because I teach and have had this happen several times over the years.

Often, the child complaining about being forced to play with someone appears to be quite happy when on the playground even when asked. It is hard to separate them when they are both saying that they want to play with each other.

Another thing that has happened in the past is the child says they 'spent the whole playtime' with the unwanted child when actually it was 2-3 minutes before others joined them or one of them drifted away.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 06/11/2022 19:56

Ah we have this exact situation at the moment. A girl who is no longer at school with our oldest but tells her when they speak that she cries all the time now they aren’t together and that she would sooner die than have another best friend, they should be together all the time and that we the parents can’t keep them apart.

I find it quite troubling and whilst I like the parents I too find them possessive of us. Tbh i also don’t approve of some of the business dealings of the dad. He is one of those who is always after a quick buck and will try to embroil you in his schemes (some of which aren’t always entirely kosher).

I don’t know what to do because I don’t want to sit on our DD too much but she becomes bolshy, manic and much harder to get focused (especially with her mild SEN) when they have been in contact.

cansu · 06/11/2022 19:54

Ignore ThingsIhavelearnt.

Children need to learn the art of friendships. It is very common for kids to struggle with this. I have year 6 girls who find this difficult!

cansu · 06/11/2022 19:52

Go back to the teacher and ask her / him to speak to the other child about this. You also need to teach your dd some things to say. It is very common for children to try and keep a friend to themselves. However, it isn't healthy and needs to be dealt with kindly but firmly.